Lurker > Ashethan

It takes a lot for me to rate a character under 3.

Only characters I've rated under 4:

Vaan (Pointless and annoying.)
Quina (Serves no story purpose, which is criminal for a playable character)

"Son... I'm honestly surprised Barnes & Noble lasted eleven more years. You know?"

Lopen posted...

All I remember her for is the slap fight which is something that I thought was really stupid. And that's saying something because...

Are you confusing Elena for Scarlet?

And probably the last!

(Well maybe Seahawks/Cowboys)

Top 20:

1. Vivi Orniter - 8.83
2. Emet-Selch - 8.78
3. Auron - 8.75
4. Cidolfus Telamon - 8.72
5. Aerith Gainsborough - 8.54
6. Dagger - 8.41
7. Cloud Strife - 8.25
8. Clive Rosfield - 8.25
9. Rydia - 8.17
10. Yuna - 8.16
11. Rikku - 8.15
12. Squall Leonhart - 8.12
13. Tifa Lockhart - 8.08
14. Kefka - 8.01
15. Torgal - 7.86
16. Tidus - 7.85
17. Beatrix - 7.76
18. Barret Wallace - 7.74
19. Celes Chere - 7.69
20. Rinoa Heartilly - 7.68

Recent Results:

Garland (FFIX) - 5.83
Galenth Dysley - 3.42
Genesis - 5.65
G'raha Tia - 6.39
Doctor Cid - 6.50
Regent Cid - 6.25
Cid Kramer - 4.86
Judge Cid - 5.06

Garland does better than the OG Garland, and fairly well for a minor villain.

Galenth Dysley does third worst of all characters

Genesis does decently

G'raha Tia rates pretty well

Doctor Cid rates higher than Fran!

Regent Cid rates a little below Freya

Cid Kramer is the lowest rated FF8 character currently

And Judge Cid almost does as well as Marche, but much better than his son.

Haven't tabulated the recent results, but I'll get to it after my kids get home from school.

I think there's maybe 84 characters left worth doing if that. So about 3 more weeks.

Couple of years? For me it's weeks dammit.

Baltimore
Pittsburgh
Houston
LA Chargers
WASHINGTON
Jacksonville
Detroit
Miami
Dallas
San Francisco
Seattle
Buffalo
Minnesota
Kansas City

Isquen posted...

Didn't stop me from running DBD!

Hey, I was interested in DBD!

I just want to do a flavor people can get excited about or at least know. I think it helps.

Oh, I don't disagree with that. Just the whole "It had to be a scum role!" thing, and not just because it was a town role. If I were town, I'd have totally lynched him thinking he was scum too. But because of the way he was like "Welp, I'm killing FD" immediately after FD was like "I'm going to grab the box."

changmas posted...

i just wish people would stop insisting that such and such role couldnt possibly be town because 99% of the time you are wrong in those evaluations

I wanted to argue against this, but I was scum and my team wanted to get the lynch. I didn't join it though, cause I felt bad for JC and figured if I voted him he'd have voted me anyway. I'd have totally jumped on the Brohan lynch of yours though.

Reminds of the reverse where people couldn't see certain roles as scum, until they were. Prosty and DayVig come to mind.

I'd like to consider hosting again some time in the future. I was thinking Good Omens Mafia, but I'm not sure if anyone's interested in the flavor or not and would rather do a flavor people are interested in if I do one.

Pretty sure Trump's actual IQ is around 116-134. He's above average intelligence, but not above that.

Obama's IQ is actually 155.

My flavor knowledge was about the only value I brought my team, unfortunately. I can't play scum for the life of me. It's hard for me to suspect someone on 'gut' or 'vibes' in the early days, and then everything I see later just leads me back to my team, and I didn't want to draw attention to them.

Hopefully my terrible claim, and my seeming to escape every day somehow (largely thanks to Corrik) was at least entertaining. I thought I was getting lynched for sure day 2, and I was confused by my survivor role, which I thought meant I had to guess if someone was a survivor or killer, and was like "Well what's the point of that?"

I think Death's role was fair, but mostly because our team was small. And it was a fun idea tied to Sadako. Town probably should have had a bit more of a hint to its existence though. There was the opening post, but I don't know how many people read that.

It was a fun game, though. Thanks again for hosting Isquen. Great job with the flavor and everything.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Who was the one who kept saying Ethan claimed scum? Me.

And Dumey, and Sultan, and....

I want to see what he flips. We need the info to solve the game. And we can't split on a tie.

##Vote: Brohan

BlueCrystalTear posted...

It's also possible that not all of scum was coordinated at the end of the last day. What if Death is scum and his vote on Brohan was already set? That limited scum options for sure.

If Brohan is town, why wouldn't Deaths teammates just vote Brohan?

Can someone tell me what we get from lynching Corrik over Brohan? Both are probably scum at this point. At least Corrik will show up.

htaeD posted...

Either way Ashe and BCT should show up and say what they want.

I'm not sure. At the moment I'm leaning Brohan, though. He's certainly scum, and I think we get more information from his lynch. And we also get more town input on what his flip means than if we wait for tomorrow.

We're running out of characters almost.

Wanted to do an all turtle day, but alas there's only two turtles.

She doesn't have as many haters as Tifa and Yuna.

Corrik7 posted...

Can we talk about how Ashe said he was blocked? I definitely didn't block him and why would scum block Ashe tonight?

I mean who else would they have blocked? I'd assume maybe you if you were town, but I don't think you are.

I was roleblocked again last night. Tried to scan BCT. I felt it'd solve the game whether I scanned him or death. And I thought his vote on Corrik at end of day was really weird.

Brohan is definitely scum. If he were town, scum could have jumped on him and won the game after I did. The only way they couldn't is if one of them wasn't there. Except the only other person not there was Death, who already had his vote on Brohan.

After that, Corrik is almost certainly scum. He made it very clear that he intended to vote wall yesterday. If he's town, that means scum knew one town would vote another town (wall), and didn't just pile on with him.

Less sure between Death and BCT.

Just waiting for the Roger Rabbit remake where he is not only Roger Rabbit, but also Bugs Bunny and Mickey Mouse.

Kuuko posted...

I doubt he'll be VP. Maybe some random cabinet spot. I think the Trump campaign will pick someone who's ostensibly "moderate" to balance the ticket rather than double-down with two people both trying to outrage. Kind of redundant.

No way does he pick a moderate. He'll pick an election denier 100%

Socialists. They won't want to have sex with and marry my kids.

Top 20:

1. Emet-Selch - 9.13
2. Vivi Orniter - 8.83
3. Auron - 8.75
4. Cidolfus Telamon - 8.72
5. Aerith Gainsborough - 8.54
6. Dagger - 8.41
7. Cloud Strife - 8.34
8. Clive Rosfield - 8.25
9. Rydia - 8.17
10. Yuna - 8.16
11. Rikku - 8.15
12. Squall Leonhart - 8.12
13. Tifa Lockhart - 8.08
14. Kefka - 8.01
15. Torgal - 7.86
16. Tidus - 7.85
17. Barret Wallace - 7.74
18. Beatrix - 7.83
19. Celes Chere - 7.69
20. Rinoa Heartilly - 7.68

Yesterday's Results:
Beatrix - 7.83
Yunalesca - 5.39
Scarlet - 5.21
Anabella Rosfield - 6.07

Beatrix rates in the Top 20 and finishes higher than Zidane.

Yunalesca is the currently lowest rated FFX character, a little below Kimahri.

Scarlet is the currently lowest rated FFVII character, slightly below Hojo.

And Anabella Rosfield gets a pretty mixed reception, with many people absolutely despising her while others love how terrible she is. But is also the lowest rated FFXVI character, though that's not saying much at the moment.

It all

I'll follow death, and just hope we're not... dead by daylight. (Quit groaning)

##Vote: Brohan

I'm here.

I can't see Brohan and wall being scum together. Maybe if he was annoyed his teammate wasn't showing up and thought it'd make him look good by voting him out.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

I didn't wanna vote for Sultan or Brohan. Which is why I didn't. Sultan I knew had to be 3P, but I wanted to, y'know, lynch scum. I thought that was a more imminent problem and that we could worry about the 3P later.

Didn't you say earlier in the day though that you thought Brohan had to be scum?

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Brohan is most likely scum since he's not cared to show himself. I still don't trust Wall, either. Sultan being a third party can wait for now but I think there's more to his role than he's saying.

I still think Chang was killed because he was onto something. I also expect to die tonight if I don't roleblock the scum killer FWIW.

Oliver Queen

Corrik7 posted...

Wallz tried to save brohan at the end oddly enough.

How did he try to save brohan? He voted for him.

Beatrix - 9
Yunalesca - 7.5
Scarlet - 6.5
Anabella - 8

Beatrix should have been playable. Change my mind.

Yunalesca is a solid villain. Her motivations are pretty good.

Scarlet is okay. That slap fight is entertaining at least. Can't wait to see it in the remake.

Anabella is so hateable, which is why I think she's a good character. Do I feel warm and fuzzy about her? No. Do I think her story is intriguing? Yes! And her ending is, while not quite enough for all that damage she did, pretty damn satisfying still. Perhaps more so because it's not what she really deserves. Because sometimes the bad guys don't get what's coming to them.

Top 20:

1. Emet-Selch - 9.27
2. Vivi Orniter - 8.82
3. Auron - 8.74
4. Cidolfus Telamon - 8.72
5. Aerith Gainsborough - 8.50
6. Dagger - 8.39
7. Cloud Strife - 8.30
8. Clive Rosfield - 8.25
9. Rikku - 8.13
10. Yuna - 8.12
11. Rydia - 8.12
12. Squall Leonhart - 8.08
13. Kefka - 8.04
14. Tifa Lockhart - 8.03
15. Torgal - 7.86
16. Tidus - 7.85
17. Barret Wallace - 7.74
18. Celes Chere - 7.66
19. Rinoa Heartilly - 7.61
20. Dion Lesage - 7.59

Yesterday's Results:

Vayne - 4.60
Emet-Selch - 9.27
Dion Lesage - 7.59
Mewt Randall - 3.13

Vayne rates just ahead of Penelo.

Emet-Selch soars above literally everyone, with our first 9 rating! Universally loved by those who played him, his lowest vote was a 7!

Dion is very well liked, and lands in the top 20. Not surprising considering he's The Dominant for Bahamut

And Vaan gets a huge reprieve as Mewt is rated as the current worst Final Fantasy character, well below Vaan. Nobody rated him above a 5.5

An incel is a man who hates women, and wonders why they won't date him.

KamikazePotato posted...

Based on my quick math, after last round there's a new #1 (by a lot)

Yes there is. But not only that -- we have a new worst character. So congrats to Vaan. I'll have a new day up tomorrow.

More Mr. nice guy

They should have flexed the Jets/Raiders out for Jaguars/49ers

Carolina
Indianapolis
Baltimore
Cincinnati
San Francisco
New Orleans
Pittsburgh
Tampa Bay
Atlanta
Detroit
Dallas
Seattle
Las Vegas
Buffalo

I thought SBell's plan was good, until I realized Sultan is probably just lying. Why didn't he tell us this yesterday, when he softclaimed indy?

Also, is red usually this averse to claiming? I mean he claimed miller on day 1, but he hasn't told us much about his even days.

Another question for Wallz, what is the passive ability of your ability mystic? Is it the same as mine? Which is kind of a Ninja-like role?

Corrik7 posted...

When he initially claimed?

Yes. I mentioned both Mystic and Quiet, and said what they did when I claimed. You were the one who asked me to claim, so I'm surprised you don't remember. you told me 'claim or die'.

wallmasterz posted...

Ashethan Im sure youve played far more mafia than me and probably know the full b8 crew in mafia context but recapping to be safe, Corrik has a reputation for being one of the communitys best players and capable of solving a game singlehandedly as town. I only started playing this year and at least twice now including last game he was the n1 kill because hes a threat to scum as town. Last time I recall him rolling scum, he also got through the game with minimal suspicion and town got their butts kicked similarly to how this game is going. Corrik also seems hard to lynch barring a few exceptions so despite the cries of wifom! I already hear from the back, I would not pick on town Corrik as scum wallz. This is ? Corrik and town wallz. Some people may think its scum/scum, so be it, but if I wanted to work towards a mislynch as scum I wouldnt end day and start another focused on one of the playgrounds bigger bullies. But whatever.

I probably haven't tbh. I've only played sporadically, and even then I took a break a couple years ago. I'm only really familiar with a couple of players in this game. But yes, I know Corrik's reputation.

But in your actions claim you said:

wallmasterz posted...

I thought about saving Corrik but figured the scum team would likely have folks who played last game and since Corrik was just the n1 kill, I thought they might go a different direction.

For night 1. Then you saved him night 2. So I wanted to see if your logic followed or not.