Board 8 > Final Fantasy 14 Mafia - Day 2: Thrill of the Hunt

(+) Yeah! (+)

In the night...

Death has died. He was...Quin69! TOWN Vanilla
"WHERE ARE THE EELS?"
You have no special abilities outside of your ability to avoid the eels.

Mzero has died. ........?

THE LIVING
1.Ulti
2.Red
3.Sir Chris
4.Crescent
5.Banana
6.Isquen
7.Tidus
8.Scare
9.MikeTavish
10.Plum

THE DEAD
1. [LD1]Shonen - Haurchefant, TOWN Bodygaurd
2. [KN1]Death - Quin69, TOWN Vanilla
3. [KN1]Mzero - ????, ????? ??????

WITH 11 ALIVE, IT TAKES 6 VOTES TO LYNCH. DAY ENDS THURSDAY AT 8PM EST.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hvTwFl6OIAk

Required watching for:
Scare, Tidus, Banana, Plum, Mike

anyway I think there isn't a huge amount of scum on this list, one at most I THINK without looking (hi plum)

Maybe scare, didn't even look his way day one, but banana was okay and so was mike. Given Death's town flip my radar is probably doing OK this game so I will operate with that and hope we can lynch scum today.

Also I am guessing (guessing) there are 3 scum and one of them is a double voter or some weird thing and that's why our count is off. 3/13 with some voodoo power messing with the lynch makes a lot of sense with a lot of villains in FFXIV so I am going to just go with that for now.

Well that was incredibly disappointing.

Hello Mr. Tavish. Now that you know that was a town flip what are your thoughts on day one?

PunishedBen posted...

Mzero has died. ........?

Uh wtf. Why?
also darn, I was almost sure bat was scum

Mzero likely got janitored, it is a mafia role which obscure the flip of the target

Still at work for another half hour, but I'll make presumptions.

1.) I very likely called out at least one scum with one of my votes between Plum and Mike.
2.) There was a mayor-type voting as the six that lynched Haurchefant, since 7 was supposed to be the cutoff. Either that or our invisible 14th is pulling strings.

Also, anyone else noticing Crescent has not been italicized at least twice now? Formatting error, or SUSPICION?

(Probably a formatting error.)
(But yeah they're probably going to go off on me for "being obtuse" and a cute, but I know I'm... right.)

Isquen posted...

Still at work for another half hour, but I'll make presumptions.

1.) I very likely called out at least one scum with one of my votes between Plum and Mike.
2.) There was a mayor-type voting as the six that lynched Haurchefant, since 7 was supposed to be the cutoff. Either that or our invisible 14th is pulling strings.

End of day caused lynch, didn't it?

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Hello Mr. Tavish. Now that you know that was a town flip what are your thoughts on day one?

I'm a lot more suspicious of anyone who was against the Shonen lynch because I really think a lot of what he did was scummy as hell between the slip, his reaction to the slip, and his responses afterwards. I feel like the only way someone would consider him town was if they knew something the rest of us don't. Yes, that includes you.

Will say more later, gotta get ready and head out to work.

I feel like I explained majority and plurality yesterday

MikeTavish posted...

I'm a lot more suspicious of anyone who was against the Shonen lynch because I really think a lot of what he did was scummy as hell between the slip, his reaction to the slip, and his responses afterwards. I feel like the only way someone would consider him town was if they knew something the rest of us don't. Yes, that includes you.

Will say more later, gotta get ready and head out to work.

Ah yes, the whole 'I was so right even though I was totally wrong so the fact you were right means you are suspicious.'

A terrible way to play mafia to be sure, but a town one nonetheless.

Miz and Death are odd kills

Death is a perfectly fine kill in worlds where you dont have a way to be sure you kill me night one.

Mzero... I am not sure about.

Red and Chris both alive makes me feel okay with them

red keeps me alive fairly often. Maybe that would change since I think the last time I was town and he was scum I murdered his entire team but even so.

My eyes today are on plum and crescent

DoomTheGyarados posted...

End of day caused lynch, didn't it?

Unsure. I have to go reread.

anyway pretty sure plum was saying the opposite of normal plum things and crescent is smart but while I was napping nothing good happened. I expect good things to happen when smart people are typing the words and yet all that happened is my point on bat was ignored. Tut tut

Okay let's see I need 6 town friends today.

Plum and Crescent are not town friends atm

Mike, Scare, Banana, and Tidus you can be town friends

Ulti, Isquen, and red are in my "I guess by my logic one of you is scum and two of you are town, but not sure what yet" list

Mike you are not allowed to suspect me because it would annoy me

anyway I feel like scum plum votes where he did because he feels iffy about not having a vote on. There was no other viable lynch. I think town plum just kind of goes 'whatever' and doesnt take a stance there but I feel as if he felt pressured to do so.

Ulti could be scum though based on his post today. Anyone who guesses why gets town points

UltimaterializerX posted...

This post is putrid WIFOM nonsense btw.

No, its not. It is you saying I was rolefishing and me explaining why it was not.

That is not what WIFOM is. If that is WIFOM you cant say anything in this game without it being WIFOM.

ScareChan posted...

Red and Chris both alive makes me feel okay with them

You didn't say much outside of Shonen's "slip". So I am curious, why should we feel ok with you?

red13n posted...

You didn't say much outside of Shonen's "slip". So I am curious, why should we feel ok with you?

Kind of obvious based on his post you know

UltimaterializerX posted...

I'm actually just going to up and claim. Warrior of Light, Town Bulletproof.

BP + BG in a game of 13 is a decent amount of "things scum has to shoot through at night while also worrying about scanners", which is why I ended up believing Bat yesterday. It's a perfectly clean role pairing in a small game. It's also why I have major questions about Mike noticing this yesterday without pursuing it.

I claimed "my role works with BG" before he did, but Mike did not vote for me or really suspect me at all. That's a red flag, because he should have seen my posts and thought of me as scummy. He did not, which means one of two things: he is scum and perspective slipped because he knows I'm town long before he actually should, or he is simply telling the truth and he's a town power role. I lean toward the former, but the latter is definitely possible in a world where the dude is just rusty and disguised his role badly or whatever.

Doubt

but not in a 'you are scum' way

Anyway thoughts on Crescent everyone?

Umm...That is a complete flavor mismatch with Haurchefant being BG.

okay we all know ulti is lying everyone, but like bat ulti lying in mafia is like him breathing, it isn't alignment based

I'm glad my internal reasoning made sense to SOMEONE, even if it's Ulti.

##Vote: Mike

And I've got my eye on another few of you.

Ulti do you even read my posts? So rude

Isquen posted...

Also, anyone else noticing Crescent has not been italicized at least twice now? Formatting error, or SUSPICION?

(Probably a formatting error.)
(But yeah they're probably going to go off on me for "being obtuse" and a cute, but I know I'm... right.)

I think this just denotes replacement btw.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Anyway thoughts on Crescent everyone?

Overthinking Townie or scum looking for a newbie patsy, honestly.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Red, I haven't played FF14. By all means explain this flavor problem.

I've already actually explained the problem in this game.

Isquen posted...

Overthinking Townie or scum looking for a newbie patsy, honestly.

This is...a non-thought?

red13n posted...

This is...a non-thought?

Correct

Isquen please try again.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Trash scum player that gets rattled and emotional very easily, and needs teammates to do the heavy lifting. I've been on teams with her and she's made of glass. One bit of pressure from the game's heavy hitters and she'll make a mistake in-game, cry to her teammates about how she wants to replace out, and/or go inactive.

Legitimately a very good town player. If we give her some time, her alignment will become obvious soon enough.

Sure

death to plum ##vote: Plum

No. If you read further into it, I'm the newbie patsy. And, frankly, I don't care whether or not I'm lynched, providing there's a great reason for it, but "voting for someone because they voted for someone voting for the first lynch" strikes me as the latter option, rather than the former.

I am not spite-voting Crescent, though. I have my own reasons, but feel free to kill them if I die in the night.

Okay so that Ulti claim blows my mind, not because he claimed Warrior of Light (in fact, I was fairly confident that would be his claim from almost his first post when he was hinting big power), but because he claimed Bulletproof which is the power I kind of assumed I could GIVE to Ulti.

I'm not sure if I should just outright claim what I am right now, but I'm coming pretty close to that point because I'm really not positive when a better point to do so would be and now I'm not even 100% sure what the point of my role is.

I know I'm being frustratingly vague and I'm probably going to claim today regardless but I'd like to get a little more discussion going before I inevitably make this day all about me.

On that note...Chris, I want to be your town buddy but I distinctly remember being told that you were the night 1 target of choice for any mafia team that wants to win. Why do you think they let you live?

MikeTavish posted...

Okay so that Ulti claim blows my mind, not because he claimed Warrior of Light (in fact, I was fairly confident that would be his claim from almost his first post when he was hinting big power), but because he claimed Bulletproof which is the power I kind of assumed I could GIVE to Ulti.

I'm not sure if I should just outright claim what I am right now, but I'm coming pretty close to that point because I'm really not positive when a better point to do so would be and now I'm not even 100% sure what the point of my role is.

I know I'm being frustratingly vague and I'm probably going to claim today regardless but I'd like to get a little more discussion going before I inevitably make this day all about me.

On that note...Chris, I want to be your town buddy but I distinctly remember being told that you were the night 1 target of choice for any mafia team that wants to win. Why do you think they let you live?

because ben gave them a janitor instead of a strongman

Also, I'm at work now so I apologize if my responses are slow and sporadic, but I should be around for the next 8 hours or so.