Current Events > Tom Holland vs Andrew Garfield vs Tobey Maguire

Topic List	Page List: 1, 2
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 3:46:11 AM #1:	Who is YOUR live action Spider-Man? Tom of course Andrew obviously Tobey duh Who is YOUR live action Spider-Man? - Results (208 votes) Tom of course 41.35% (86 votes) 86 Andrew obviously 7.69% (16 votes) 16 Tobey duh 50.96% (106 votes) 106 ? --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953393384] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote> Who is YOUR live action Spider-Man? Tom of course Andrew obviously Tobey duh Vote View Results Who is YOUR live action Spider-Man? - Results (208 votes) Tom of course 41.35% (86 votes) 86 Andrew obviously 7.69% (16 votes) 16 Tobey duh 50.96% (106 votes) 106 Show Voting Form ? </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MrMallard 04/30/21 3:47:40 AM #2:	Can't strobe the tobe. Andrew Heathcliff and Tom Nederlands got nothing on that shit. --- It's like one of those Chinese kites flying in the wind, and then some kid with a shotgun sends a bullet through it Now Playing: Minecraft <cite>MrMallard posted [p:953393398] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Can't strobe the tobe. Andrew Heathcliff and Tom Nederlands got nothing on that shit. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
#3	Post #3 was unavailable or deleted.
SolidShadow3 04/30/21 3:49:17 AM #4:	Tom looks like peter, acts like peter, and has the best suit. So.... him. Andrew has the second best suit, but was bad as Peter, but good as Spiderman. Tobey was a bad Spider-Man, but a perfect Peter. Tom hits both sides well. --- By Odin's beard! TheDogFather, you will be missed. <cite>SolidShadow3 posted [p:953393422] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Tom looks like peter, acts like peter, and has the best suit. So.... him. Andrew has the second best suit, but was bad as Peter, but good as Spiderman. Tobey was a bad Spider-Man, but a perfect Peter. Tom hits both sides well. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 3:50:03 AM #5:	MrMallard posted... Can't strobe the tobe. Andrew Heathcliff and Tom Nederlands got nothing on that shit. hahaha tobeys fan base is too real lol [LFAQs-redacted-quote] ROTFL now thats funny! Good times --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953393427] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>MrMallard posted... </cite> <quote>Can't strobe the tobe. Andrew Heathcliff and Tom Nederlands got nothing on that shit.</quote> hahaha tobeys fan base is too real lol <cite>[LFAQs-redacted-quote]</cite> ROTFL now thats funny! Good times </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 3:51:01 AM #6:	SolidShadow3 posted... Tom looks like peter, acts like peter, and has the best suit. So.... him. Andrew has the second best suit, but was bad as Peter, but good as Spiderman. Tobey was a bad Spider-Man, but a perfect Peter. Tom hits both sides well. i see what youre saying thats a good point --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953393449] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>SolidShadow3 posted... </cite> <quote>Tom looks like peter, acts like peter, and has the best suit. So.... him. Andrew has the second best suit, but was bad as Peter, but good as Spiderman. Tobey was a bad Spider-Man, but a perfect Peter. Tom hits both sides well.</quote> i see what youre saying thats a good point </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Machete 04/30/21 3:53:23 AM #7:	80s cartoon spiderman --- I do not receive notifications, so using the @ feature will not do anything. I might see your post and respond though if I have already been in the topic. <cite>Machete posted [p:953393489] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>80s cartoon spiderman</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ShyOx 04/30/21 3:54:09 AM #8:	I mean none of this would exist without Tobey doing it first. Batman movies were important but the last few were so bad people stopped making them. Superman movies got weird real fast and never really captured what the comics were about. Spiderman hit the mark waaaaay closer and had waaaaay larger profit margins. Movies didn't start making the CRAZY money until Spiderman, Lord of the Rings, and Titanic, and the latter two were super in depth expensive projects developing technology no one had ever seen. I suppose the star wars prequels go into that too THEN Disney started making insane, holy hell shit your pants money with their stuff. And now we're watching the film industry cannibalize itself tl;dr Tobey did it first and so should rightfully get credit for that, he's also a better actor by miles than the other two based on his other performances. --- http://img836.imageshack.us/img836/6938/vyqp.jpg DIPLOMACY <cite>ShyOx posted [p:953393497] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>I mean none of this would exist without Tobey doing it first. Batman movies were important but the last few were so bad people stopped making them. Superman movies got weird real fast and never really captured what the comics were about. Spiderman hit the mark waaaaay closer and had waaaaay larger profit margins. Movies didn't start making the CRAZY money until Spiderman, Lord of the Rings, and Titanic, and the latter two were super in depth expensive projects developing technology no one had ever seen. I suppose the star wars prequels go into that too THEN Disney started making insane, holy hell shit your pants money with their stuff. And now we're watching the film industry cannibalize itself tl;dr Tobey did it first and so should rightfully get credit for that, he's also a better actor by miles than the other two based on his other performances. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SolidShadow3 04/30/21 3:56:32 AM #9:	ShyOx posted... I mean none of this would exist without Tobey doing it first. Batman movies were important but the last few were so bad people stopped making them. Superman movies got weird real fast and never really captured what the comics were about. Spiderman hit the mark waaaaay closer and had waaaaay larger profit margins. Movies didn't start making the CRAZY money until Spiderman, Lord of the Rings, and Titanic, and the latter two were super in depth expensive projects developing technology no one had ever seen. I suppose the star wars prequels go into that too THEN Disney started making insane, holy hell shit your pants money with their stuff. And now we're watching the film industry cannibalize itself tl;dr Tobey did it first and so should rightfully get credit for that, he's also a better actor by miles than the other two based on his other performances. He can get all the credit in the world for doing it first, but that doesnt mean hes the best Peter Parker/Spider-Man. Although like I said, he was a perfect Peter, just missed the mark when it comes to Spider-Man. --- By Odin's beard! TheDogFather, you will be missed. <cite>SolidShadow3 posted [p:953393536] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>ShyOx posted... </cite> <quote>I mean none of this would exist without Tobey doing it first. Batman movies were important but the last few were so bad people stopped making them. Superman movies got weird real fast and never really captured what the comics were about. Spiderman hit the mark waaaaay closer and had waaaaay larger profit margins. Movies didn't start making the CRAZY money until Spiderman, Lord of the Rings, and Titanic, and the latter two were super in depth expensive projects developing technology no one had ever seen. I suppose the star wars prequels go into that too THEN Disney started making insane, holy hell shit your pants money with their stuff. And now we're watching the film industry cannibalize itself tl;dr Tobey did it first and so should rightfully get credit for that, he's also a better actor by miles than the other two based on his other performances.</quote>He can get all the credit in the world for doing it first, but that doesnt mean hes the best Peter Parker/Spider-Man. Although like I said, he was a perfect Peter, just missed the mark when it comes to Spider-Man. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MhkaCHemistry 04/30/21 3:58:30 AM #10:	Man, I must be fucking tired because I only just realized in Far From Home that Tom Holland wakes up in Holland after the first big Mysterio fight. --- https://imgur.com/iB1sU http://i13.photobucket.com/albums/a290/juliaxx/Picture56.jpg Free stuff! <cite>MhkaCHemistry posted [p:953393564] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Man, I must be fucking tired because I only just realized in Far From Home that Tom Holland wakes up in Holland after the first big Mysterio fight. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
#11	Post #11 was unavailable or deleted.
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 4:00:56 AM #12:	Machete posted... 80s cartoon spiderman i didnt get to see that one but I heard great things about it actually so Im sure youre right ShyOx posted... I mean none of this would exist without Tobey doing it first. Batman movies were important but the last few were so bad people stopped making them. Superman movies got weird real fast and never really captured what the comics were about. Spiderman hit the mark waaaaay closer and had waaaaay larger profit margins. Movies didn't start making the CRAZY money until Spiderman, Lord of the Rings, and Titanic, and the latter two were super in depth expensive projects developing technology no one had ever seen. I suppose the star wars prequels go into that too THEN Disney started making insane, holy hell shit your pants money with their stuff. And now we're watching the film industry cannibalize itself tl;dr Tobey did it first and so should rightfully get credit for that, he's also a better actor by miles than the other two based on his other performances. hahaha I feel that SolidShadow3 posted... He can get all the credit in the world for doing it first, but that doesnt mean hes the best Peter Parker/Spider-Man. Although like I said, he was a perfect Peter, just missed the mark when it comes to Spider-Man. lol what about him as spider man didnt you like? --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953393598] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Machete posted... </cite> <quote>80s cartoon spiderman</quote> i didnt get to see that one but I heard great things about it actually so Im sure youre right ShyOx posted... </cite> <quote>I mean none of this would exist without Tobey doing it first. Batman movies were important but the last few were so bad people stopped making them. Superman movies got weird real fast and never really captured what the comics were about. Spiderman hit the mark waaaaay closer and had waaaaay larger profit margins. Movies didn't start making the CRAZY money until Spiderman, Lord of the Rings, and Titanic, and the latter two were super in depth expensive projects developing technology no one had ever seen. I suppose the star wars prequels go into that too THEN Disney started making insane, holy hell shit your pants money with their stuff. And now we're watching the film industry cannibalize itself tl;dr Tobey did it first and so should rightfully get credit for that, he's also a better actor by miles than the other two based on his other performances.</quote> hahaha I feel that SolidShadow3 posted... </cite> <quote>He can get all the credit in the world for doing it first, but that doesnt mean hes the best Peter Parker/Spider-Man. Although like I said, he was a perfect Peter, just missed the mark when it comes to Spider-Man.</quote> lol what about him as spider man didnt you like? </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
PiOverlord 04/30/21 4:01:18 AM #13:	Tobey feels like an actual, awkward nerdy guy Tom feels like a guy trying to act like a awkward nerdy guy --- Number of legendary 500 post topics: 33, 500th posts: 30; PiO ATTN: 5 RotM wins 1, LETTEN MY ARROW FLYEN TRUE <cite>PiOverlord posted [p:953393608] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Tobey feels like an actual, awkward nerdy guy Tom feels like a guy trying to act like a awkward nerdy guy </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 4:02:53 AM #14:	MhkaCHemistry posted... Man, I must be fucking tired because I only just realized in Far From Home that Tom Holland wakes up in Holland after the first big Mysterio fight. lol true that true that! [LFAQs-redacted-quote] https://youtu.be/gT2ys2QvJOY tobey on his ray j mode --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953393623] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>MhkaCHemistry posted... </cite> <quote>Man, I must be fucking tired because I only just realized in Far From Home that Tom Holland wakes up in Holland after the first big Mysterio fight.</quote> lol true that true that! <cite>[LFAQs-redacted-quote]</cite> https://youtu.be/gT2ys2QvJOY tobey on his ray j mode </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 4:04:42 AM #15:	PiOverlord posted... Tobey feels like an actual, awkward nerdy guy Tom feels like a guy trying to act like a awkward nerdy guy LOL cool how you worded that ! I can kind of see that actually Tobey did have the nerd by day hero thing down pretty good --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953393640] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>PiOverlord posted... </cite> <quote>Tobey feels like an actual, awkward nerdy guy Tom feels like a guy trying to act like a awkward nerdy guy</quote> LOL cool how you worded that ! I can kind of see that actually Tobey did have the nerd by day hero thing down pretty good </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SolidShadow3 04/30/21 4:05:22 AM #16:	greatmonkeybaby posted... i didnt get to see that one but I heard great things about it actually so Im sure youre right hahaha I feel that lol what about him as spider man didnt you like? Spider-Man makes quips constantly in combat to hide how afraid he is, he doesnt pause in the face of danger, he is actually capable. He lacks quips. He freezes all the time By the end of 3 hes still fighting like he did in #1. Never seemed to learn. And mostly: The largest part of the WHOLE character is his scientific knowledge; something Tobeys character NEVER showcased. Spider-Man works on new webbing, suits, tech to help him fight, Tobeys got organic webs and... that was the end of that aside from mentioning his college classes and his conversations with Ock. --- By Odin's beard! TheDogFather, you will be missed. <cite>SolidShadow3 posted [p:953393651] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>greatmonkeybaby posted... </cite> <quote>i didnt get to see that one but I heard great things about it actually so Im sure youre right hahaha I feel that lol what about him as spider man didnt you like?</quote>Spider-Man makes quips constantly in combat to hide how afraid he is, he doesnt pause in the face of danger, he is actually capable. He lacks quips. He freezes all the time By the end of 3 hes still fighting like he did in #1. Never seemed to learn. And mostly: The largest part of the WHOLE character is his scientific knowledge; something Tobeys character NEVER showcased. Spider-Man works on new webbing, suits, tech to help him fight, Tobeys got organic webs and... that was the end of that aside from mentioning his college classes and his conversations with Ock. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Kami_no_Kami 04/30/21 4:05:43 AM #17:	Tobey - Perfect Peter Parker. Meh Spider-Man Andy - Good Spider-Man. Terrible Peter Parker. Tom - Awkward teen #482,636 in both roles. Gonna go with Tobey. <cite>Kami_no_Kami posted [p:953393657] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Tobey - Perfect Peter Parker. Meh Spider-Man Andy - Good Spider-Man. Terrible Peter Parker. Tom - Awkward teen #482,636 in both roles. Gonna go with Tobey. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SolidShadow3 04/30/21 4:08:24 AM #18:	Kami_no_Kami posted... Tobey - Perfect Peter Parker. Meh Spider-Man Andy - Good Spider-Man. Terrible Peter Parker. Tom - Awkward teen #482,636 in both roles. Gonna go with Tobey. Question was best Spider-Man, not Peter! /s --- By Odin's beard! TheDogFather, you will be missed. <cite>SolidShadow3 posted [p:953393689] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Kami_no_Kami posted... </cite> <quote>Tobey - Perfect Peter Parker. Meh Spider-Man Andy - Good Spider-Man. Terrible Peter Parker. Tom - Awkward teen #482,636 in both roles. Gonna go with Tobey.</quote>Question was best Spider-Man, not Peter! /s </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 4:16:36 AM #19:	SolidShadow3 posted... Spider-Man makes quips constantly in combat to hide how afraid he is, he doesnt pause in the face of danger, he is actually capable. He lacks quips. He freezes all the time By the end of 3 hes still fighting like he did in #1. Never seemed to learn. And mostly: The largest part of the WHOLE character is his scientific knowledge; something Tobeys character NEVER showcased. Spider-Man works on new webbing, suits, tech to help him fight, Tobeys got organic webs and... that was the end of that aside from mentioning his college classes and his conversations with Ock. youre actually right i enjoyed tobeys trilogy but he isnt as comic accurate when directly compared Kami_no_Kami posted... Tobey - Perfect Peter Parker. Meh Spider-Man Andy - Good Spider-Man. Terrible Peter Parker. Tom - Awkward teen #482,636 in both roles. Gonna go with Tobey. what made Garfields Pete terrible? --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953393795] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>SolidShadow3 posted... </cite> <quote>Spider-Man makes quips constantly in combat to hide how afraid he is, he doesnt pause in the face of danger, he is actually capable. He lacks quips. He freezes all the time By the end of 3 hes still fighting like he did in #1. Never seemed to learn. And mostly: The largest part of the WHOLE character is his scientific knowledge; something Tobeys character NEVER showcased. Spider-Man works on new webbing, suits, tech to help him fight, Tobeys got organic webs and... that was the end of that aside from mentioning his college classes and his conversations with Ock.</quote> youre actually right i enjoyed tobeys trilogy but he isnt as comic accurate when directly compared Kami_no_Kami posted... </cite> <quote>Tobey - Perfect Peter Parker. Meh Spider-Man Andy - Good Spider-Man. Terrible Peter Parker. Tom - Awkward teen #482,636 in both roles. Gonna go with Tobey.</quote> what made Garfields Pete terrible? </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Nukazie 04/30/21 4:21:27 AM #20:	tobey and if someone's gonna beat tobey, it would be the supaidaman --- Life is just a journey from the maternity ward to the crematorium. <cite>Nukazie posted [p:953393869] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>tobey and if someone's gonna beat tobey, it would be the supaidaman </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SolidShadow3 04/30/21 4:21:46 AM #21:	greatmonkeybaby posted... what made Garfields Pete terrible? He was already confident as a person before the powers, and then just got more confident. Peter as Peter is supposed to remain akward; because he is at heart an akward individual. --- By Odin's beard! TheDogFather, you will be missed. <cite>SolidShadow3 posted [p:953393874] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>greatmonkeybaby posted... </cite> <quote>what made Garfields Pete terrible?</quote>He was already confident as a person before the powers, and then just got more confident. Peter as Peter is supposed to remain akward; because he is at heart an akward individual. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 4:26:08 AM #22:	Nukazie posted... tobey and if someone's gonna beat tobey, it would be the supaidaman lmfao SolidShadow3 posted... He was already confident as a person before the powers, and then just got more confident. Peter as Peter is supposed to remain akward; because he is at heart an akward individual. yeah I noticed that too actually he had spidermans ego early on --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953393922] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Nukazie posted... </cite> <quote>tobey and if someone's gonna beat tobey, it would be the supaidaman</quote> lmfao SolidShadow3 posted... </cite> <quote>He was already confident as a person before the powers, and then just got more confident. Peter as Peter is supposed to remain akward; because he is at heart an akward individual.</quote> yeah I noticed that too actually he had spidermans ego early on </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SolidShadow3 04/30/21 4:29:26 AM #23:	Honestly, I like them all, but Tobey and Garfield both played really hard into one aspect of the character, and not enough in the other side. Tom got the chance to see both and do it right. Without them, Tom could quite possibly suck at the role, but he had the advantage of previous iterations to learn from, and he did. --- By Odin's beard! TheDogFather, you will be missed. <cite>SolidShadow3 posted [p:953393967] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Honestly, I like them all, but Tobey and Garfield both played really hard into one aspect of the character, and not enough in the other side. Tom got the chance to see both and do it right. Without them, Tom could quite possibly suck at the role, but he had the advantage of previous iterations to learn from, and he did. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 4:36:47 AM #24:	SolidShadow3 posted... Honestly, I like them all, but Tobey and Garfield both played really hard into one aspect of the character, and not enough in the other side. Tom got the chance to see both and do it right. Without them, Tom could quite possibly suck at the role, but he had the advantage of previous iterations to learn from, and he did. dang you have a good point studying what they did right and their flaws to give people the Spider-Man they wanted Kind of reminds me of the way naruto is extremely successful but pulls inspiration from the DBZ spectrum of influences its cool that the poll is that close of a call for Tom and Tobey though --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953394064] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>SolidShadow3 posted... </cite> <quote>Honestly, I like them all, but Tobey and Garfield both played really hard into one aspect of the character, and not enough in the other side. Tom got the chance to see both and do it right. Without them, Tom could quite possibly suck at the role, but he had the advantage of previous iterations to learn from, and he did.</quote> dang you have a good point studying what they did right and their flaws to give people the Spider-Man they wanted Kind of reminds me of the way naruto is extremely successful but pulls inspiration from the DBZ spectrum of influences its cool that the poll is that close of a call for Tom and Tobey though </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SolidShadow3 04/30/21 5:29:11 AM #25:	greatmonkeybaby posted... dang you have a good point studying what they did right and their flaws to give people the Spider-Man they wanted Kind of reminds me of the way naruto is extremely successful but pulls inspiration from the DBZ spectrum of influences its cool that the poll is that close of a call for Tom and Tobey though perfectly even as of now. I think they all deserve their own credit, and I wont bash the others in favor of mine. I don't have any genuine insults for their portrayal of the character, I just think Tom had the biggest advantages, and used them well to make a pretty accurate depiction of the character, even if it isn't a 1/1; but it's closer to a 1/1 than the others. Just to say; I'm a HUGE comic nerd, so I may be opinionated; I'm not trying to pass my opinions as fact. --- By Odin's beard! TheDogFather, you will be missed. <cite>SolidShadow3 posted [p:953394662] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>greatmonkeybaby posted... </cite> <quote>dang you have a good point studying what they did right and their flaws to give people the Spider-Man they wanted Kind of reminds me of the way naruto is extremely successful but pulls inspiration from the DBZ spectrum of influences its cool that the poll is that close of a call for Tom and Tobey though</quote>perfectly even as of now. I think they all deserve their own credit, and I wont bash the others in favor of mine. I don't have any genuine insults for their portrayal of the character, I just think Tom had the biggest advantages, and used them well to make a pretty accurate depiction of the character, even if it isn't a 1/1; but it's closer to a 1/1 than the others. Just to say; I'm a HUGE comic nerd, so I may be opinionated; I'm not trying to pass my opinions as fact. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 9:56:38 PM #26:	SolidShadow3 posted... perfectly even as of now. I think they all deserve their own credit, and I wont bash the others in favor of mine. I don't have any genuine insults for their portrayal of the character, I just think Tom had the biggest advantages, and used them well to make a pretty accurate depiction of the character, even if it isn't a 1/1; but it's closer to a 1/1 than the others. Just to say; I'm a HUGE comic nerd, so I may be opinionated; I'm not trying to pass my opinions as fact. I agree in the sense that while my personal favorite is Tobeys Spider-Man I think that Toms is closer to accuracy too its all good no worries lol, my step dad has a personal shop sized collection Im not as much of a fan but I understand the passion. Who are some of your favorite comic book characters? --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953423016] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>SolidShadow3 posted... </cite> <quote>perfectly even as of now. I think they all deserve their own credit, and I wont bash the others in favor of mine. I don't have any genuine insults for their portrayal of the character, I just think Tom had the biggest advantages, and used them well to make a pretty accurate depiction of the character, even if it isn't a 1/1; but it's closer to a 1/1 than the others. Just to say; I'm a HUGE comic nerd, so I may be opinionated; I'm not trying to pass my opinions as fact.</quote> I agree in the sense that while my personal favorite is Tobeys Spider-Man I think that Toms is closer to accuracy too its all good no worries lol, my step dad has a personal shop sized collection Im not as much of a fan but I understand the passion. Who are some of your favorite comic book characters? </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MedeaLysistrata 04/30/21 9:59:40 PM #27:	SolidShadow3 posted... Although like I said, he was a perfect Peter, just missed the mark when it comes to Spider-Man. I think you missed the part where that's not his problem --- "Why is ontology so expensive?" - JH [Is this live?][Joyless planet...] <cite>MedeaLysistrata posted [p:953423115] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>SolidShadow3 posted... </cite> <quote>Although like I said, he was a perfect Peter, just missed the mark when it comes to Spider-Man.</quote>I think you missed the part where that's not his problem </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Tired-Insomniac 04/30/21 10:01:06 PM #28:	SolidShadow3 posted... Tom looks like peter, acts like peter, and has the best suit. So.... him. Andrew has the second best suit, but was bad as Peter, but good as Spiderman. Tobey was a bad Spider-Man, but a perfect Peter. Tom hits both sides well. --- "I like turtles" <cite>Tired-Insomniac posted [p:953423159] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>SolidShadow3 posted... </cite> <quote>Tom looks like peter, acts like peter, and has the best suit. So.... him. Andrew has the second best suit, but was bad as Peter, but good as Spiderman. Tobey was a bad Spider-Man, but a perfect Peter. Tom hits both sides well.</quote> </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 04/30/21 10:06:01 PM #29:	MedeaLysistrata posted... I think you missed the part where that's not his problem haha --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953423306] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>MedeaLysistrata posted... </cite> <quote>I think you missed the part where that's not his problem</quote> haha </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Vicious_Dios 04/30/21 10:07:03 PM #30:	MrMallard posted... Can't strobe the tobe. Andrew Heathcliff and Tom Nederlands got nothing on that shit. --- S / K / Y / N / E Twitch/YouTube/GT: *Adzeta* <cite>Vicious_Dios posted [p:953423338] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>MrMallard posted... </cite> <quote>Can't strobe the tobe. Andrew Heathcliff and Tom Nederlands got nothing on that shit.</quote> </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
FortuneCookie 04/30/21 10:27:29 PM #31:	Andrew > Tom > Tobey The Sam Raimi films had high production values, but Tobey Maguire was miscast. He was alright as Peter Parker, but he didn't feel like Spider-Man. He didn't have the cockiness down pat. It was like making a Muhammad Ali movie and not letting him trash talk. Maybe Spider-Man was more humble in the 1960s when Sam Raimi was a kid, but that's ignoring several decades of development. I would say you might as well put Batman in blue but Hollywood did that too. <cite>FortuneCookie posted [p:953423971] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Andrew > Tom > Tobey The Sam Raimi films had high production values, but Tobey Maguire was miscast. He was alright as Peter Parker, but he didn't feel like Spider-Man. He didn't have the cockiness down pat. It was like making a Muhammad Ali movie and not letting him trash talk. Maybe Spider-Man was more humble in the 1960s when Sam Raimi was a kid, but that's ignoring several decades of development. I would say you might as well put Batman in blue but Hollywood did that too. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Proto_Spark 04/30/21 10:37:36 PM #32:	FortuneCookie posted... Maybe Spider-Man was more humble in the 1960s when Sam Raimi was a kid, but that's ignoring several decades of development. I would say you might as well put Batman in blue but Hollywood did that too. He wasn't, in fact he was more of an ass in the earlier stuff IIRC. Well not exactly, but Spider Man 100% learns he needs to actually be a good person to be a superhero. I think Garfield is underrated as Spider Man. The first one was great, and while Garfield could be "too cool" he still rocked the whole awkward outcast thing Peter Parker has. Though I think Tom Holland has all the potential of being the best Peter Parker and Spider Man if only he was given an actual Spider Man story. Holland's Parker is way too cool and way too MCU focused. Peter Parker should never have the whole "king of the Nerds" thing he has in the MCU. <cite>Proto_Spark posted [p:953424239] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>FortuneCookie posted... </cite> <quote>Maybe Spider-Man was more humble in the 1960s when Sam Raimi was a kid, but that's ignoring several decades of development. I would say you might as well put Batman in blue but Hollywood did that too.</quote> He wasn't, in fact he was more of an ass in the earlier stuff IIRC. Well not exactly, but Spider Man 100% learns he needs to actually be a good person to be a superhero. I think Garfield is underrated as Spider Man. The first one was great, and while Garfield could be "too cool" he still rocked the whole awkward outcast thing Peter Parker has. Though I think Tom Holland has all the potential of being the best Peter Parker and Spider Man if only he was given an actual Spider Man story. Holland's Parker is way too cool and way too MCU focused. Peter Parker should never have the whole "king of the Nerds" thing he has in the MCU. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Dakimakura 04/30/21 10:39:29 PM #33:	Tobey Maguire is the only spider-man. --- https://imgur.com/ca2qBa1 <cite>Dakimakura posted [p:953424290] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Tobey Maguire is the only spider-man. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
FortuneCookie 04/30/21 10:43:52 PM #34:	Proto_Spark posted... He wasn't, in fact he was more of an ass in the earlier stuff IIRC. Well not exactly, but Spider Man 100% learns he needs to actually be a good person to be a superhero. I think Garfield is underrated as Spider Man. The first one was great, and while Garfield could be "too cool" he still rocked the whole awkward outcast thing Peter Parker has. Though I think Tom Holland has all the potential of being the best Peter Parker and Spider Man if only he was given an actual Spider Man story. Holland's Parker is way too cool and way too MCU focused. Peter Parker should never have the whole "king of the Nerds" thing he has in the MCU. Holland's Spider-Man is just business. Disney doesn't own the movie rights lock, stock, and barrel, so they're trying to utilize Spider-Man's popularity while still positioning their own heroes to be cooler. <cite>FortuneCookie posted [p:953424427] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Proto_Spark posted... </cite> <quote>He wasn't, in fact he was more of an ass in the earlier stuff IIRC. Well not exactly, but Spider Man 100% learns he needs to actually be a good person to be a superhero. I think Garfield is underrated as Spider Man. The first one was great, and while Garfield could be "too cool" he still rocked the whole awkward outcast thing Peter Parker has. Though I think Tom Holland has all the potential of being the best Peter Parker and Spider Man if only he was given an actual Spider Man story. Holland's Parker is way too cool and way too MCU focused. Peter Parker should never have the whole "king of the Nerds" thing he has in the MCU.</quote> Holland's Spider-Man is just business. Disney doesn't own the movie rights lock, stock, and barrel, so they're trying to utilize Spider-Man's popularity while still positioning their own heroes to be cooler. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MabusIncarnate 04/30/21 10:46:19 PM #35:	Sorry, but Holland is the best. I've been a Marvel fan as long as I can remember, he matches the character the best. --- Above us lay the burdens, Below us lay the truths. We're somewhere in the middle, and we're all discontent too. Slayer_22 picked waifu - https://ibb.co/WD8p1Kz <cite>MabusIncarnate posted [p:953424511] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Sorry, but Holland is the best. I've been a Marvel fan as long as I can remember, he matches the character the best. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Zikten 04/30/21 10:51:06 PM #36:	Tom is my least favorite Andrew was a great Spider-man Tobey was a really good Peter Parker <cite>Zikten posted [p:953424639] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Tom is my least favorite Andrew was a great Spider-man Tobey was a really good Peter Parker</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
TerrifyingRei 04/30/21 10:52:15 PM #37:	"Oh no, small knives! My one weakness!" --- 'I saw my future today. It said I'm going away, but I still haven't sung my last line.' - Demon Hunter 'Where did I go wrong? Who was I supposed to be?' - FFDP <cite>TerrifyingRei posted [p:953424687] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>"Oh no, small knives! My one weakness!" </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Cobra1010 04/30/21 11:18:01 PM #38:	I don't mind if tobeys spiderman is different to cartoon spiderman. I like that more serious version. How mcu spiderman is constantly a comic relief gets annoying after a while for me. --- Now is the hour! Riders of Rohan! Oaths you have taken, now fulfill them all, to lord and land! <cite>Cobra1010 posted [p:953425398] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>I don't mind if tobeys spiderman is different to cartoon spiderman. I like that more serious version. How mcu spiderman is constantly a comic relief gets annoying after a while for me. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 05/01/21 3:36:26 PM #39:	FortuneCookie posted... Andrew > Tom > Tobey The Sam Raimi films had high production values, but Tobey Maguire was miscast. He was alright as Peter Parker, but he didn't feel like Spider-Man. He didn't have the cockiness down pat. It was like making a Muhammad Ali movie and not letting him trash talk. Maybe Spider-Man was more humble in the 1960s when Sam Raimi was a kid, but that's ignoring several decades of development. I would say you might as well put Batman in blue but Hollywood did that too. thats true I did enjoy Garfleids spidey humor and quotes a lot Proto_Spark posted... I think Garfield is underrated as Spider Man. The first one was great, and while Garfield could be "too cool" he still rocked the whole awkward outcast thing Peter Parker has. Indeed very true!!! Dakimakura posted... Tobey Maguire is the only spider-man. feelz FortuneCookie posted... Holland's Spider-Man is just business. Disney doesn't own the movie rights lock, stock, and barrel, so they're trying to utilize Spider-Man's popularity while still positioning their own heroes to be cooler. makes sense MabusIncarnate posted... he matches the character the best. yeah thats true --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953444939] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>FortuneCookie posted... </cite> <quote>Andrew > Tom > Tobey The Sam Raimi films had high production values, but Tobey Maguire was miscast. He was alright as Peter Parker, but he didn't feel like Spider-Man. He didn't have the cockiness down pat. It was like making a Muhammad Ali movie and not letting him trash talk. Maybe Spider-Man was more humble in the 1960s when Sam Raimi was a kid, but that's ignoring several decades of development. I would say you might as well put Batman in blue but Hollywood did that too.</quote> thats true I did enjoy Garfleids spidey humor and quotes a lot Proto_Spark posted... </cite> I think Garfield is underrated as Spider Man. The first one was great, and while Garfield could be "too cool" he still rocked the whole awkward outcast thing Peter Parker has. Indeed very true!!! Dakimakura posted... </cite> <quote>Tobey Maguire is the only spider-man.</quote> feelz FortuneCookie posted... </cite> <quote>Holland's Spider-Man is just business. Disney doesn't own the movie rights lock, stock, and barrel, so they're trying to utilize Spider-Man's popularity while still positioning their own heroes to be cooler.</quote> makes sense MabusIncarnate posted... </cite> <quote>he matches the character the best.</quote> yeah thats true </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 05/01/21 3:38:39 PM #40:	Zikten posted... Tom is my least favorite Andrew was a great Spider-man Tobey was a really good Peter Parker your least favorite? Dang lol, but yeah they really were TerrifyingRei posted... "Oh no, small knives! My one weakness!" rotfl good times right there! Cobra1010 posted... I don't mind if tobeys spiderman is different to cartoon spiderman. I like that more serious version. How mcu spiderman is constantly a comic relief gets annoying after a while for me. I see where youre coming from thats understandable too --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953445016] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Zikten posted... </cite> <quote>Tom is my least favorite Andrew was a great Spider-man Tobey was a really good Peter Parker</quote> your least favorite? Dang lol, but yeah they really were TerrifyingRei posted... </cite> <quote>"Oh no, small knives! My one weakness!"</quote> rotfl good times right there! Cobra1010 posted... </cite> <quote>I don't mind if tobeys spiderman is different to cartoon spiderman. I like that more serious version. How mcu spiderman is constantly a comic relief gets annoying after a while for me.</quote> I see where youre coming from thats understandable too </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
dummy420 05/01/21 3:40:01 PM #41:	Gotta go with Tobey. Would be Tom but his spiderman is far to reliant on iron man. --- Trying is the first step towards failure, so just dont give it a shot and you cant dissapoint. <cite>dummy420 posted [p:953445051] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Gotta go with Tobey. Would be Tom but his spiderman is far to reliant on iron man. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Wedge Antilles 05/01/21 3:42:33 PM #42:	Tom>>>>>>>Andrew>>Tobey --- I used the knife. I saved a child. I won a war. God forgive me. <cite>Wedge Antilles posted [p:953445119] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Tom>>>>>>>Andrew>>Tobey </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ThePrinceFish 05/01/21 3:43:25 PM #43:	Tobey Maguire and it isn't close. The MCU kneecaps Holland's movies and lmao at Garfield. --- Then shall the righteous shine forth as the sun in the kingdom of their Father. Who hath ears to hear, let him hear. <cite>ThePrinceFish posted [p:953445142] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Tobey Maguire and it isn't close. The MCU kneecaps Holland's movies and lmao at Garfield. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby 05/02/21 4:18:49 AM #44:	dummy420 posted... Gotta go with Tobey. Would be Tom but his spiderman is far to reliant on iron man. Thats cool then you prefer Tobeys standalone series Spider-Man Wedge Antilles posted... Tom>>>>>>>Andrew>>Tobey Oh dang lol ThePrinceFish posted... Tobey Maguire and it isn't close. The MCU kneecaps Holland's movies and lmao at Garfield. you hated Garifleds performance lol? --- Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name! <cite>greatmonkeybaby posted [p:953464399] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>dummy420 posted... </cite> <quote>Gotta go with Tobey. Would be Tom but his spiderman is far to reliant on iron man.</quote> Thats cool then you prefer Tobeys standalone series Spider-Man Wedge Antilles posted... </cite> <quote>Tom>>>>>>>Andrew>>Tobey</quote> Oh dang lol ThePrinceFish posted... </cite> <quote>Tobey Maguire and it isn't close. The MCU kneecaps Holland's movies and lmao at Garfield.</quote> you hated Garifleds performance lol? </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
slmcknett 05/02/21 4:38:04 AM #45:	Zikten posted... Andrew was a great Spider-man Tobey was a really good Peter Parker This is all I can really say. Tom Holland is just...eh to me. Mainly cuz they spend too much time on him worshiping Tony's existence and making him just generically awkward. He doesn't really feel like Peter or Spidey outside of a couple scenes. And in Far From Home, he basically didn't even have a character arc -- he was just dicking around, being told to do stuff by Fury. I really want to see how Sony will handle his Spidey in their non-MCU movies, and hopefully this third MCU movie will step away from the Stark stuff and just let him be his own character. --- Watch "Final Fantasy XV Abridged" and "Kingdom Hearts Abridged" right here! https://www.youtube.com/user/mcknett3 <cite>slmcknett posted [p:953464604] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Zikten posted... </cite> <quote>Andrew was a great Spider-man Tobey was a really good Peter Parker</quote>This is all I can really say. Tom Holland is just...eh to me. Mainly cuz they spend too much time on him worshiping Tony's existence and making him just generically awkward. He doesn't really feel like Peter or Spidey outside of a couple scenes. And in Far From Home, he basically didn't even have a character arc -- he was just dicking around, being told to do stuff by Fury. I really want to see how Sony will handle his Spidey in their non-MCU movies, and hopefully this third MCU movie will step away from the Stark stuff and just let him be his own character. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
pfh1001 05/02/21 4:41:52 AM #46:	ThePrinceFish posted... Tobey Maguire and it isn't close. The MCU kneecaps Holland's movies and lmao at Garfield. Yeah, pretty much this. <cite>pfh1001 posted [p:953464635] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>ThePrinceFish posted...</cite> <quote>Tobey Maguire and it isn't close. The MCU kneecaps Holland's movies and lmao at Garfield. </quote> Yeah, pretty much this.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Sir Cyrus 05/02/21 11:31:13 AM #47:	Thing is, IMO Tom's Spider-Man is only good because of the script. I prefer Tobey when he's Peter by far. Give Tobey Tom's script and it'll be perfect. --- Sigless for now. <cite>Sir Cyrus posted [p:953471069] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Thing is, IMO Tom's Spider-Man is only good because of the script. I prefer Tobey when he's Peter by far. Give Tobey Tom's script and it'll be perfect.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
BeyondWalls 05/02/21 11:36:28 AM #48:	Andrew was the most like the Spider-man I grew up with in the 80s. Tobey was terrible and Im not that invested in Spider-Kid. --- END OF LINE <cite>BeyondWalls posted [p:953471200] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Andrew was the most like the Spider-man I grew up with in the 80s. Tobey was terrible and Im not that invested in Spider-Kid. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
cuttin_in_farm 05/02/21 11:36:45 AM #49:	Just coming in to say this is the most positive and supportive TC Ive ever seen tbh. --- A show of kindness may not do much help, but a show of cruelty may do much harm. <cite>cuttin_in_farm posted [p:953471207] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>Just coming in to say this is the most positive and supportive TC Ive ever seen tbh. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
BeyondWalls 05/02/21 11:40:28 AM #50:	greatmonkeybaby posted... while Garfield could be "too cool" I dont understand why people expect Peter to be Clark Kent. Peter in the 80s was just a normal guy. Not some bumbling social outcast. --- END OF LINE <cite>BeyondWalls posted [p:953471293] in Tom Hollan... [t:79433012]...</cite> <quote>greatmonkeybaby posted... </cite> <quote>while Garfield could be "too cool"</quote>I dont understand why people expect Peter to be Clark Kent. Peter in the 80s was just a normal guy. Not some bumbling social outcast. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1, 2

Current Events > Tom Holland vs Andrew Garfield vs Tobey Maguire (+) Yeah! (+)

Current Events > Tom Holland vs Andrew Garfield vs Tobey Maguire