Current Events > Tom Holland vs Andrew Garfield vs Tobey Maguire

Topic List
Page List: 1, 2
SwayM
05/02/21 11:58:47 AM
#51:


Nostalgia goggles sure has people believing all kinds of bullshit.

Tobey is absolute trash. He couldnt act then and its especially bad when you go back and watch them today.

Tom is the quintessential Spider-Man and is so unbelievably good at being both Peter and Spider-Man. Tom has shown such range and depth to the character. His movies are better. And hes in an established universe and fits right in along side dudes with metal arms and dudes than can grow 20 stories tall.

Tom is easily the best Spider-Man and its not even close.

---
Like 90% of CE topics are the same way lol. CE is edgy/contrarian as f*** and will do anything to troll the TC/OP. -Touch
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/02/21 9:17:33 PM
#52:


slmcknett posted...
This is all I can really say.

Tom Holland is just...eh to me. Mainly cuz they spend too much time on him worshiping Tony's existence and making him just generically awkward. He doesn't really feel like Peter or Spidey outside of a couple scenes. And in Far From Home, he basically didn't even have a character arc -- he was just dicking around, being told to do stuff by Fury.

I really want to see how Sony will handle his Spidey in their non-MCU movies, and hopefully this third MCU movie will step away from the Stark stuff and just let him be his own character.

great post actually thats pretty true if he steps into his own more that would be really good in my opinion as well

pfh1001 posted...
Yeah, pretty much this.

True!

Sir Cyrus posted...
Thing is, IMO Tom's Spider-Man is only good because of the script. I prefer Tobey when he's Peter by far. Give Tobey Tom's script and it'll be perfect.

I see

BeyondWalls posted...
Andrew was the most like the Spider-man I grew up with in the 80s. Tobey was terrible and Im not that invested in Spider-Kid.

Haha true I feel that then. I can see how Andrew Garfields Spider-Man would hit on point for a specific audience that might have preferred that comic era Spider-Man honestly

cuttin_in_farm posted...
Just coming in to say this is the most positive and supportive TC Ive ever seen tbh.

Thank you! Much appreciated!

BeyondWalls posted...
I dont understand why people expect Peter to be Clark Kent. Peter in the 80s was just a normal guy. Not some bumbling social outcast.

That does makes sense, I could see modern era Peter Parker being a hip Pete like Garfields Spider-Man portrayed


---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
KiwiTerraRizing
05/02/21 9:18:35 PM
#53:


Bully Maguire

---
Trucking Legend Don Schneider!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/02/21 9:19:38 PM
#54:


SwayM posted...
Nostalgia goggles sure has people believing all kinds of bullshit.

Tobey is absolute trash. He couldnt act then and its especially bad when you go back and watch them today.

Tom is the quintessential Spider-Man and is so unbelievably good at being both Peter and Spider-Man. Tom has shown such range and depth to the character. His movies are better. And hes in an established universe and fits right in along side dudes with metal arms and dudes than can grow 20 stories tall.

Tom is easily the best Spider-Man and its not even close.

dang you dont think Tobey can act at all?

KiwiTerraRizing posted...
Bully Maguire

Haha good one lol!

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
SwayM
05/02/21 9:25:15 PM
#55:


greatmonkeybaby posted...
dang you dont think Tobey can act at all?

Not in the Spider-Man movies.

---
Like 90% of CE topics are the same way lol. CE is edgy/contrarian as f*** and will do anything to troll the TC/OP. -Touch
... Copied to Clipboard!
twitterfriends
05/02/21 9:25:55 PM
#56:


Damn CE pull through this time, Tobey ftw

---
#BidenHarris #JusticeDemocrats #Hive #WolfPAC #Dogecoin
#WeAre12 #12thMan #Seahawks #Belieber #DENT #UBI #PokemonGo #twitterfriends #MMA #PopularHashtags
... Copied to Clipboard!
#57
Post #57 was unavailable or deleted.
greatmonkeybaby
05/04/21 3:23:28 AM
#58:


SwayM posted...
Not in the Spider-Man movies.

Thats fair haha even though I like that film trilogy I can see where youre coming from lol

twitterfriends posted...
Damn CE pull through this time, Tobey ftw

lol

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


Thats a good way to put it

And I havent seen Spider-Man 2 in a while it is really good though!


---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/05/21 6:39:36 PM
#59:


Time to rewatch the Spider-Man films

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/06/21 10:36:32 AM
#60:


Harry: What do ya mean incredible?

Harry: I swear on my fathers grave Spider-Man will pay, thank god for you though Peter , *hugs Spider-Man emotionally*

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/06/21 9:05:06 PM
#61:


Going to re watch Spider-Man 2 now

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
BettyWhite
05/06/21 9:11:51 PM
#62:


I like how with Tobey you actually feel like this dude is a straight up nerd who never wins and you get to experience a true nerd power fantasy with him.

I like Tom, but his bully is literally more of a nerd than him. This isn't his fault though, I would enjoy if his origin story wasn't skipped and he wasn't rushed into the MCU.

---
Playing: Dragon Ball Xenoverse 2(Piper Perri LVL 99)
Watching: Dragon Ball(Wedding Plans?)
... Copied to Clipboard!
3PiesAndAFork
05/06/21 9:13:39 PM
#63:


BettyWhite posted...


I like Tom, but his bully is literally more of a nerd than him.
It's like being on CE.

---
@('_')@
... Copied to Clipboard!
BettyWhite
05/06/21 9:14:01 PM
#64:


3PiesAndAFork posted...
It's like being on CE.

Lmao.

---
Playing: Dragon Ball Xenoverse 2(Piper Perri LVL 99)
Watching: Dragon Ball(Wedding Plans?)
... Copied to Clipboard!
Ivany2008
05/06/21 9:18:46 PM
#65:


Best Spiderman is the 94 Spiderman. If I'm forced to pick between the 3 LA Spidermen, I'll go with Tom Holland. He's grown on me.
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 3:27:08 AM
#66:


BettyWhite posted...
I like how with Tobey you actually feel like this dude is a straight up nerd who never wins and you get to experience a true nerd power fantasy with him.

I like Tom, but his bully is literally more of a nerd than him. This isn't his fault though, I would enjoy if his origin story wasn't skipped and he wasn't rushed into the MCU.

I just rewatched 1 and 2 and youre right he does nail the role of nerd to a powerful hero, his transition back to normalcy in the second film was savage lol

And the part about his bully is funny lol

3PiesAndAFork posted...
It's like being on CE.

lmfao!

Ivany2008 posted...
Best Spiderman is the 94 Spiderman. If I'm forced to pick between the 3 LA Spidermen, I'll go with Tom Holland. He's grown on me.

True that thats cool!

Nice though fam

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
PMarth2002
05/07/21 3:29:09 AM
#67:


Tobey > Tom > Andrew.

---
You load sixteen tons, what do you get?
Another day older and deeper in debt
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 3:30:26 AM
#68:


Im 12 minutes into Spider-Man 3 and .....the James Franco meme ftw!



lol

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 3:33:39 AM
#69:


PMarth2002 posted...
Tobey > Tom > Andrew.

True that, I think Id say the same possibly

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 4:08:49 AM
#70:


The Spider-Man 3 Stan Lee cameo

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
HighOnSolar
05/07/21 4:11:35 AM
#71:


if Tobey isnt your spiderman dont even fucking TALK to me bro

---
Surf
... Copied to Clipboard!
MARKINGRAM22
05/07/21 4:41:27 AM
#72:


Only reason people say McGuire over Holland is nostalgia
... Copied to Clipboard!
PiOverlord
05/07/21 10:54:38 AM
#73:


MARKINGRAM22 posted...
Only reason people say McGuire over Holland is nostalgia
I mean, I gave my reason. I have issues with certain elements of Holland's portrayal of Spider-Man, and like Tobey more than nostalgia.

---
Number of legendary 500 post topics: 33, 500th posts: 30; PiO ATTN: 5
RotM wins 1, LETTEN MY ARROW FLYEN TRUE
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 3:01:26 PM
#74:


HighOnSolar posted...
if Tobey isnt your spiderman dont even fucking TALK to me bro

Understandable lol

MARKINGRAM22 posted...
Only reason people say McGuire over Holland is nostalgia

Some people for sure yeah

PiOverlord posted...
I mean, I gave my reason. I have issues with certain elements of Holland's portrayal of Spider-Man, and like Tobey more than nostalgia.

Yeah I liked Tobey as Spider-Man for more reasons than nostalgia too but I can see where hed have that perspective as well


---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 3:04:40 PM
#75:


Watching The Amazing Spider-Man 2 rn

lol
Peter : I was cleaning the chimney
Aunt May: we have no chimney
Peter : Whaaa

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 8:42:07 PM
#76:


Now, on to Spider-Man Homecoming

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 8:45:30 PM
#77:


LMAO @ Jason trying to a get a date for Homecoming



---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Relient_K
05/07/21 9:01:40 PM
#78:


Tom really nails the combat banter in a way the others lack. He felt like spider-man from the moment he is introduced in civil war. I loved how both bucky and Sam want him to shut up during their fight. The only part of his Peter that is off is due to the fact that they wanted to step away from his traditional origin story a hit more since it has been done twice in major movies already.

Tobey is my second. He really felt like a relatable Peter, and Peter Parker was always supposed to feel like a pretty normal guy before his powers (minus his genius intellect). Awkward, real life problems that interfere with his role as Spiderman.

Andrew was ok but the he feels worse and worse on rewatches. He's full of himself in a way that feels out of place for Spiderman. Would have been nice to see how he would have done with another movie.

---
We all ate the biscuits, Fighter. We can all see through time. [ER]
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 11:21:01 PM
#79:


Relient_K posted...
Tom really nails the combat banter in a way the others lack. He felt like spider-man from the moment he is introduced in civil war. I loved how both bucky and Sam want him to shut up during their fight. The only part of his Peter that is off is due to the fact that they wanted to step away from his traditional origin story a hit more since it has been done twice in major movies already.

Tobey is my second. He really felt like a relatable Peter, and Peter Parker was always supposed to feel like a pretty normal guy before his powers (minus his genius intellect). Awkward, real life problems that interfere with his role as Spiderman.

Andrew was ok but the he feels worse and worse on rewatches. He's full of himself in a way that feels out of place for Spiderman. Would have been nice to see how he would have done with another movie.

His combat banter is great very true!

and I was just thinking about how Toms Spider-Man skipped the origin details since Tobey and Andrew walked us through it twice

i wanted a third film too, especially after ending the film the way they did

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/07/21 11:27:13 PM
#80:


Watching Far From Home now

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/08/21 3:04:39 AM
#81:


Haha #BlinkBeard ftw!

but dang, now Im even more of a fan of Toms Spider-Man films after rewatching them all one by one for comparison

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
BroodRyu
05/08/21 3:18:32 AM
#82:


I dont have much else to say that hasnt already been said in this topic, but Tobey is by far my favorite. The Raimi Spiderman memes are fantastic.

Also TC, I really appreciate the good vibes youve brought to this topic. We need more people like you.
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/08/21 4:27:46 AM
#83:


BroodRyu posted...
I dont have much else to say that hasnt already been said in this topic, but Tobey is by far my favorite. The Raimi Spiderman memes are fantastic.

Also TC, I really appreciate the good vibes youve brought to this topic. We need more people like you.

Same here haha Toms is more comic accurate, easily relatable and down to earth but at the end of the day Tobey is still my favorite Spider-Man too

And true that, they had some lit memes lol!

Thank you though thats very kind and I appreciate it

---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/09/21 1:48:07 PM
#84:






---
Light Yagami: Dad, Write His Name! Use All The Strength You've Got Left And Write His Name!
... Copied to Clipboard!
greatmonkeybaby
05/11/21 1:40:20 AM
#85:


From another thread to this one ~

I shall binge the Spider-Man animated series next (after I finish Friday the 13th and the Halloween/Michael Myers marathon)

Spider-Man(s) ftw!



---
People that hate on me just want to hurt me like I did but they can't because I don't care. Why does a strangers opinion matter to a stranger that jdgaf lol ily
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2