Board 8 > Xenoblade Chronicles 3 Mafia: 1-2 Something A Bit Meatier

(+) Yeah! (+)

Can someone not Ulti tell me how I went from number 1 scum on his list to town?

Counterclaim miller

Also of note my role can't be blocked by night actions despite not having a night action.

##Vote: Plum

He is most likely scum

If you're scum and you've cast a wide net on multiple town targets, then it becomes hard to lynch anyone else by day's end.

Hey now, I've been patient with other people not responding immediately, give me a little time. I'm doing other things too. I haven't been hard on IGCD running away after making a BS accusation at me, have I?

I feel like this only works if lopen is good at bringing people to his side (not evident so far) or other players already agree with him (again not really a thing except for me!)

Are you saying Lopen is too bad of a player to lead a lynch?

It's not manufacturing attacks! It's things to want to know! Why is "miller" the only interesting thing there! I mean Sultan got a bunch of flak for "why didn't he claim his flavor??" but that seems more honest a reaction than "w...w... the MILLER... I mean..."

A thought that i just had is what if jc is telling the truth about everything except his alignment.
It's a weird role, but would that give scum any benefit? One extra vote for three days? Or would it be more of a detriment because then there's guaranteed evidence? But if they know it's going to happen then they can try to play around it...

Really????

Ah question for you ED! If you had to vig shot Lopen to save yourself and to win the game how confident are you in that read.

I think if I were on board with your Ulti suspicion, and/or you hadn't claimed Miller, I would be fully on the Lopen train.

You can call me Dume or Dumey. This is an odd hypothetical. If I had to shoot to "save myself" then yes, because I know I am confirmed town. If I had a vig right now, I would not shoot Lopen, no.

To be clear, I have not outright claimed I think Lopen is scum. I've just said we should display caution with the lynches he's leading. The ideal situation right now would be for some other people like SBell, Chang, HB, Red, or 5starscream to pop in and give some opinions so we can have a talk outside the Lopen-sphere.

I don't think that's an honest interpretation at all. I'm asking you to clarify why you thought Ulti was a good vote target, because I wasn't convinced before

Hey igcd.
I don't care how you feel about me. Could you walk me through your evaluation of death? I accused you of being extremely flippy floppy about him, and you started going in harder on me. What's up with that?
I think that having your thoughts there could help with my reread when i get to that part.

IGCD, JC, why Peaf? What made you think he's Scummy or that pressure is worthwhile on him?

##Unvote:

##Vote: Ulti

Sultans logic on Death was sound and I was getting the same vibes reading his posts.

Your reaction didn't seem right. I actually have other reasons too. The big thing for me is you immediately launched into "THIS IS WHY B8 TOWN IS BAD AT THE GAME" but saying the general vibe just seemed weird seems like the kinda thing a town Sultan would latch onto imo

So why am I voting Ulti and not you? Because it's not necessarily you being scum. However Ulti if honestly trying to find a vote target probably doesn't vote Sultan.

I will special right back onto Ulti

I am with you on Ulti. Very lazy scummish play.

That's not it. It's more you're being very lazy, and I have too much respect for your town play (legitimately usually very good!) to let that slide.

Hey now, I've been patient with other people not responding immediately, give me a little time. I'm doing other things too. I haven't been hard on IGCD running away after making a BS accusation at me, have I?