Board 8 > Xenoblade Chronicles 3 Mafia: 1-2 Something A Bit Meatier

(+) Yeah! (+)

Peace___Frog posted...

You're right, i forgot about those.

I'm leaving my vote on you though because that's a nice catch up post and all... but I don't get any sense that you're doing much with the information that you provided. You gave town reads, "iffy" reads, and then named han and dumey as people you want to see more from? Where's a single scum read? Are you scared to list a teammate and bring attention to them, or are you scared to start a train on someone that you know is town? There's people with multiple votes on them, such as myself. You think the two people on me are town! But you don't want to call me anything?

I feel like dumey has given a lot to work off of. You say you feel good about him but are treading carefully because it's your first game with him...? I was honestly feeling that he was town after the lopen exchange, but this feels like a bad attempt at giving a non-read on your partner.

Chang is my top priority now.

the part where he goads doesn't make sense to me? two town can be on someone and that can mean nothing for the person they're on.

and if someone hasn't fully formed opinions on who's scum, i would rather they were upfront about it than spouting crap for the sake of appearances.

peaf scum, chang town imo

Obellisk posted...

You did praise JC. You said he's doing a great job at playing his role. You bought what JC was selling and told him he's doing a great job playing it as it should be done. Where is the falsehood?

No, I specifically was dissecting his claim.

And finish catching up in this topic - he was correct in the way he hinted things. He was not playing correct in the way he actually claimed.

If it was unclear, sorry, I'll take the hit. But no, I don't think JC "played his role the right way". Don't pretend I do. Context matters.

I'll admit, seeing JC return and gun for Peaf is not what I expected.

Honestly plum being convinced by hb flavor meta to stop pressuring JCshould make him autolynch today

He's shriveled up and died since I pointed it out too

Just lynch plum

Yeah no I wasn't missing any of that thanks for confirming.

Genuine frustration, stupid amount of (should be banned in the future) effort.

Plum NEVER takes flavor meta seriously. I'm fairly certain he has active disdain for it.

Particularly when he wasn't even voting him based on flavor!

Peace___Frog posted...

changmas posted...

This was in response to lopen arguing that it would be silly for ben to put chang into the game for balance reasons if he had a role that would self destruct after 3 days. I thought that too, but i think there are mechanics in the game that would make it more of a maybe than a definite. Look at the first bullet of the game! Ben tells us that there are hidden mechanics against scum, and perhaps jc's role is connected to them somehow under certain conditions?

I think jc is town at this point, but this post from chang really feels like he's letting on that he knows more than i do (ie scum).

I agree with chang's logic, but that's because i began seeing jc as town at some point. I think it was actually when he voted for me, it felt like he had real suspicion there. But then look at chang's catch up post!

changmas posted...

This is all he has to say about jc. He only speaks to the claim. Nothing about how jc has acted or anything. Chang believes the claim in a vacuum, nothing more or less. I think that can only come from a scum pov.
He's repeating what i said (if jc is alive at that time then he should die) but he doesn't give any other thoughts about jc. Only claim evaluation. Nothing else.
Chang is scum.

what

Lopen posted...

Honestly plum being convinced by hb flavor meta to stop pressuring JCshould make him autolynch today

He's shriveled up and died since I pointed it out too

Just lynch plum

Lopen posted...

Plum NEVER takes flavor meta seriously. I'm fairly certain he has active disdain for it.

Lopen posted...

Particularly when he wasn't even voting him based on flavor!

These 3 post by Lopen give me pause

New topic

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80324232