Board 8 > YGO Master Duel Mafia Topic 5 - What does Pot of Greed do again?

(+) Yeah! (+)

I'm not voting or anything because i am out and about and want to reread things before committing.
But Ben is almost certainly scum, and i don't know why he lied about something so silly.

Lopen, this doesn't make sense. If a scum was gonna lie about being the bus driver in the mass, why wouldn't they do that in this "bus driver only" situation?

Only person we have yet to hear back from is Sultan, yeah? We could have this whole massclaim business sorted out tonight once we hear back from him

I am sick and tired of people saying that lopen does not make sense.

Peace___Frog posted...

I am sick and tired of people saying that lopen does not make sense.

well he doesn't to me lol

Lopen posted...

Also the why of swapping Kirby and Han

For clarity, my results PM just says I watched Kirby, with reassurance that it's not a typo. Which then prompted me to recheck my PM and make sure I said Han, lol. I also could have been targeted directly and driven to Kirby if scum thought I was power and wanted to interfere with me.

Hbthebattle posted...

on what planet are you or sultan more valuable kills for scum than Han or me. That's silly.

Not in this game for sure.

Also should I say it or nah?

no claiming until we can decide on a sametime-time

I'm very open to a mass claim anytime if we want to use today to get all our ducks in order. Because Ben is already the scummiest player, he's got a guilty scan on him, and his claim looks rushed and full of holes. Just say the word and my vote is cast. i just don't want to end the day until we've had a chance to discuss everything we need to.

I'm not claiming. Also if Lopen is confirmed scum. The. That's the and I will mention again Lopen BCT some team makes alot of sense on how Lopen was about protecting BCT early.

Peace___Frog posted...

I am sick and tired of people saying that lopen does not make sense.

Lopen was 100% convinced Ben was town because everyone seemed to be dogpiling him
Lo and behold, Hb scanned Ben guilty, and Lopen still immediately considered that Hb was scum. Somehow.

And now he's about to found out just how wrong he was about Ben.

I stand by my argument that Lopen makes no sense. Mans is jumping through so many logical hoops just to make a completely wrong conclusion.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Also should I say it or nah?

Say what, Sultan?

Poppy has protected bct more than almost anyone else this game.

yeah ofc we're not ending day early, or at least not right now

Kirby321 posted...

Say what, Sultan

Already said it.

Ben who is the bus btw. You'd see it with your watch

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Already said it.

Yeah my bad I didn't refresh the page before posting.

Kirby321 posted...

If there was another Cop, why the hell wouldn't they counter Hb? Lopen, please.

If there's a counter-claim, it has to be today. The ONLY reason somebody wouldn't counter-claim right away D2 is to get another scan off, so they could then call out HB AND somebody else. That's a ballsy play, but if they're hidden enough they can get away with it. Especially if they think there are other, smarter targets for scum.

I'm okay with claiming too. Lemme know when I should be here.

Hbthebattle posted...

Also let's look at Ben's claim. He claims that he watched Han but got swapped to Kirby. Wouldn't that mean scum had to have shot at Kirby?

That... yeah, that would be the case. Why on earth would they target Kirby here? Could someone on the scum team please explain?

...gosh, I wish it worked like that, xD. I don't buy Ben's claim, nor do I know if there's actually a bus driver. Sounds like Ben's now claiming there's a scum bus driver...? That makes no sense. Why would scum choose to redirect him specifically from Han to Kirby? That sounds a little TOO perfect... like they knew he was Watcher. That also sounds like a redirect power, not a driver power. A driver power would imply that scum targeted Kirby. My head hurts from trying to understand this claim. Which is why I don't buy it at all.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

I'm not claiming.

...that's not a good look for someone who's blatantly scum.

Lopen posted...

Ben who is the bus btw. You'd see it with your watch

LOL
Ben fakeclaiming a power role and completely botching all of the logic is totally in his wheelhouse

Kinda sucks that the rest of the day will probably stagnate because we've got definitive scum on our hands

Wait save it for the mass

Lopen posted...

Ben who is the bus btw. You'd see it with your watch

No one visited Kirby, which makes me think I was visited and redirected

actually, if everyone's set on it being Ben, perhaps the mass should wait til tomorrow?

PunishedBen posted...

No one visited Kirby, which makes me think I was visited and redirected

that's not how bus driver works dude

Hbthebattle posted...

actually, if everyone's set on it being Ben, perhaps the mass should wait til tomorrow?

Not a bad idea tbh

Yep. Ben is out.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

that's not a good look for someone who's blatantly scum.

Youre litterally the only one saying I am...

Kirby321 posted...

Kinda sucks that the rest of the day will probably stagnate because we've got definitive scum on our hands

Yeah, it's pretty blatant that Ben, Lopen, and Sultan are all scum. Why don't we just kill the three of them in that order? Why take 48 hours each of those days when we have three obvious scum here? We can push the mass claim until after we've nailed them all.

Hbthebattle posted...

that's not how bus driver works dude

He meant to say redirector, I think, but his botching of this claim makes him look even worse than he already does.

We're not rushing into anything BCT, cool your jets.

Hbthebattle posted...

We're not rushing into anything BCT, cool your jets.

...you're right. Sorry if I appeared too eager. I'm just excited - we get to lynch some scum!

Also Han being the night kill is super helpful to me. Takes that could of judgement away

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Yeah, it's pretty blatant that Ben, Lopen, and Sultan are all scum. Why don't we just kill the three of them in that order? Why take 48 hours each of those days when we have three obvious scum here? We can push the mass claim until after we've nailed them all.

Why Ben before confirmed scum Lopen??

Also by "not 48" I mean it could be 2 or 24, or even 40. We can always fish more information, just depends on when it stagnates, and we still gotta figure out who the 4th would be.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Also Han being the night kill is super helpful to me. Takes that could of judgement away

I presume that's why you did it.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Why Ben before confirmed scum Lopen??

I mean, Lopen is scum.
... But Ben is quite literally confirmed scum.

Unless you also don't believe that Hb is Cop. With a guilty scan on Ben.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Why Ben before confirmed scum Lopen??

Lopen is not confirmed scum. He's extremely likely scum, but not confirmed.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Why Ben before confirmed scum Lopen??

Because Ben's confirmed scum also? HB scanned him guilty, went "J'accuse!" and then he had a horribly botched, poorly thought-through claim.

When did Lopen get 100% confirmed? Was it my logic earlier?

You're not doing yourself any favors.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Also by "not 48" I mean it could be 2 or 24, or even 40. We can always fish more information, just depends on when it stagnates, and we still gotta figure out who the 4th would be.

I presume that's why you did it.

that makes zero sense. why would scum sultan kill someone he was pretending to think was scum?

tbh the scum equity in the BCT/Sultan pairing is like 60/40 now imo

It works different for every host. We just had this same discussion last game. And I don't know what happened to me, just guessing.It doesn't matter what bus driver does

PunishedBen posted...

It works different for every host. We just had this same discussion last game. And I don't know what happened to me, just guessing.It doesn't matter what bus driver does

it does though? if you were telling the truth, which you aren't, you would have seen the bus driver visit kirby

BCT. Do yourself a favor if you are truly town ignore that I am here. Youre way off and may be clouding your judgement a bit.

changmas posted...

that makes zero sense. why would scum sultan kill someone he was pretending to think was scum?

Tbf scum Sultan could be coached to do that so people like you would bring that argument up in his defense.

Not saying Sultan is scum, but if he were...

That's diving into WIFOM territory, though. I'm still not sure what to think of the Sultan/BCT thing yet. Absolutely doesn't feel staged, so I doubt they're both scum. And yet both of them say some pretty questionable things at times >_>

But in any case, Ben and Lopen are clearly linked.

changmas posted...

tbh the scum equity in the BCT/Sultan pairing is like 60/40 now imo

Do you WANT to give the game to scum? For fuck's sake, I'm town, and I'm just too green at being town to know what to say.

Sultan if you're day cop please scan me again today

Lopen posted...

Sultan if you're day cop please scan me again today

godfather detected :P

Yeah godfather being pot of greeded makes a lot of sense

Lopen posted...

Yeah godfather being pot of greeded makes a lot of sense

Hmm why would you be chosen for pot of Greed?

I'm a lightning rod for power roles

I'm certain I wasn't today because today I have crossout designator

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

BCT. Do yourself a favor if you are truly town ignore that I am here. Youre way off and may be clouding your judgement a bit.

Says the person who was WAY off base with me, told me to "Claim or die" D1 despite only having you voting for me, and subsequently tried to justify every single one of my posts as a scumpost. YOU are the one whose judgment was clouded, which in turn helped me know for certain that you're scum.

Lopen posted...

Yeah godfather being pot of greeded makes a lot of sense

Didn't Death say that we're not told if we were targeted by a spell unless we blocked it with a Crossout? How would you KNOW that you were Pot of Greeded, then?

I think it'd be best for everyone if BCT and Sultan stopped talking about each other for today and focused their energy on other stuff.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Says the person who was WAY off base with me, told me to "Claim or die" D1 despite only having you voting for me, and subsequently tried to justify every single one of my posts as a scumpost. YOU are the one whose judgment was clouded, which in turn helped me know for certain that you're scum.

Didn't Death say that we're not told if we were targeted by a spell unless we blocked it with a Crossout? How would you KNOW that you were Pot of Greeded, then?

If Sultan targeted me yesterday and got a scum result I obviously was

Hbthebattle posted...

I think it'd be best for everyone if BCT and Sultan stopped talking about each other for today and focused their energy on other stuff.

What im trying to say Bro