Board 8 > Illuminati Mafia Topic 1: It begins.

(+) Yeah! (+)

PunishedBen posted...

Upon re-read i have discovered that Sultan and Aeicoo are scum buddies

Why do you say that?

---

These are the first two posts Aecioo made.

Aecioo posted...

I've honestly been out of the game so long people think I'm a chris alt

=(

Aecioo posted...

Defending yourself already?

##vote:bossman

lets get this game going

Gravy votes Aecioo. Sultan then makes this post. Keep in mind the only two posts Aecioo made were the two above.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

With majority of society world wide being at home i thought id come in being way behind. Looking at day so far aecioo does looks a bit odd. Now that you exsplained yourself im a little less weary on you at the moment

Sultan, you're gonna have to explain what it is about Aecioo that made you think he looked odd.

---

PunishedBen posted...

Sultan, you're gonna have to explain what it is about Aecioo that made you think he looked odd.

Already exsplained this read the game Ben.

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Just off in general not being strong in anything he did really

I saw this. It's not good enough considering you specifically said "odd" in the post I quoted (Not off). Why did you think he looked odd?

---

Aecioo posted...

Defending yourself already?

##vote:bossman

lets get this game going

In this vote he says gravy was already defending himself like it wasnt how he came into the game Gravy started the game in defense mode so i thought this was an odd way to phrase the vote and then he was being stand offish after that as well

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

then he was being stand offish after that as well

But that was after you made the "odd" post, right?
---

Ben is friend. Vote Sultan with me :)

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

In this vote he says gravy was already defending himself like it wasnt how he came into the game Gravy started the game in defense mode so i thought this was an odd way to phrase the vote and then he was being stand offish after that as well

He didnt make any posts between the one you quoted and your remark though.

Sultan, unfortunately your're just way too towny when you're town so when you are not it's sticking out. ;0;


---

Well im not scum and i have a way to prove it

---

Hbthebattle posted...

But that was after you made the "odd" post, right?

And yes. I thought his reaction to Gravy was a little odd maybe i didnt use the ebst wording but whatever

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Well im not scum and i have a way to prove it

Okay. Consider me abated for now.

---

Where is half of the game. Majority of the people plauing haven't played or posted less then 3 times

---

I posted 4 times I think.

---

Corrik7 posted...

I posted 4 times I think.

hi corrik

now that youre here, what are your thoughts on what happened with Gravy?

---

Tange if you had to kill someone who would you kill

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Tange if you had to kill someone who would you kill

Im still not sold on neighbors both being town, so probably one of them

---

DoubleTangicide posted...

hi corrik

now that youre here, what are your thoughts on what happened with Gravy?

Dumb and makes these games unfun with this stuff happening every game day 1 basically.

---

Okay between the 2 gravy/ben looks bad because gravy and the replace

But

Sbell not using the chat is also suspicious to me

---

Gravy pretty much is town unfortunately

---

Does that make sbell scum or di we have the odd both town neighbors

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Okay between the 2 gravy/ben looks bad because gravy and the replace

Do you think it's impossible for gravy to get this annoyed as town?
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Do you think it's impossible for gravy to get this annoyed as town?

I mean id be pretty pissed if i came into the game excited have a cool role like neighbor and my neighbor not wantint to talk to me

And it he was scum neighbor idk if id be as mad id been like my neighbor isnt interacting with me i can probably put suspicion on them right?

---

But honestly the 2nd part could go either way

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Does that make sbell scum or di we have the odd both town neighbors

Reason to believe they are both town, but as of now, if one is scum it is Sbell.

---

Wow why is day still up

---

Fastbreak posted...

Wow why is day still up

##vote:Scare


---

Corrik7 posted...

Reason to believe they are both town, but as of now, if one is scum it is Sbell.

Thats a fancy approach to the situation. Wrong, but fancy in a Corrik kind of way.

---

?

---

Fastbreak posted...

Wow why is day still up

Hate to follow Sultan but...

##vote: scare

That post scare, what's up?

---

Obellisk posted...

Thats a fancy approach to the situation. Wrong, but fancy in a Corrik kind of way.

What?
Are you questioning Corriks assumption that you and Ben are both town? Do you think Ben is scum?

---

5tarscream posted...

What?
Are you questioning Corriks assumption that you and Ben are both town? Do you think Ben is scum?

No the, if one is scum its sbell part of it.

That would be the wrong part.

---

Obellisk posted...

Hate to follow Sultan but...

Wow im offended by this sbell

---

I also was leaning both town. Gravy because his blow up makes zero sense as scum when he could just throw shade at SBell instead.
SBell for being cautious and ignoring gravy when it would be easy to just play along and immediately try and pocket heavy for free.
Thats also why SBell looks scummier of the two if I had to pick one because its easier to make a case that SBell didnt want to give anything away.

---

I dunno why I switched from talking to you to about you there but that was directed at you SBell. Even with bias you surely can see why its not fancy but logical to assume of the two you look worse if one of you is scum. Which for now I dont think you are fwiw.

---

5tarscream posted...

I also was leaning both town. Gravy because his blow up makes zero sense as scum when he could just throw shade at SBell instead.
SBell for being cautious and ignoring gravy when it would be easy to just play along and immediately try and pocket heavy for free.
Thats also why SBell looks scummier of the two if I had to pick one because its easier to make a case that SBell didnt want to give anything away.

I guess that's fair. I can't really argue it and it's just your personal view of the situation.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Wow im offended by this sbell

Don't be, you tend to be a little all over the place most of the time. ;)

---

Sultan. Can you explain what it is specifically that makes you think Scare is scum with that post and not just being an idiot.


---

Corrik7 posted...

Gravy pretty much is town unfortunately

Unfortunately?

5tarscream posted...

Sultan. Can you explain what it is specifically that makes you think Scare is scum with that post and not just being an idiot.

Well for 1 he only posted like 5 times with no content then comes in says why isnt day over its not a good look and i exspect more from scare when he jumps in when he is town

---

I was exaderating a bit scare has posted a bit but doesnt make it look better none the less

---

5tarscream posted...

Aecioo (not Chris) seems nervous to me. That could just be rust but I have a gut feeling thats its rust combined with rolling scum on a first game back.
@Aecioo can you fill me in on your mafia experience real quick when you get a chance.

Uh, I played in countless games but haven't played in a few years? If that mafia archive is still around go pick pretty much any game from pre-2018, maybe a bit earlier.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

And it he was scum neighbor idk if id be as mad id been like my neighbor isnt interacting with me i can probably put suspicion on them right?

This is kind of my mindset as well. It has no bearing on Sbell leaning either way, but I would imagine it's much more frustrating to play as a town neighbor where your partner is not talking to you. Scum neighbor can throw tons of shade at the other player later on for not talking to them, leading people to think they must be scum because they refuse to talk. Don't think that argument holds much weight when it was only hours into the first day

---

To clarify, the "don't think that argument holds much weight etc" is in regards to Sbell leaning a certain way, not to Gravy looking more town.

---

Ok cool I thought as much but I didnt play then.
Aecioo whats your best catch as town in your opinion and your best scum game.

---

Aecioo posted...

To clarify, the "don't think that argument holds much weight etc" is in regards to Sbell leaning a certain way, not to Gravy looking more town.

Honestly I think Gravy gave up to soon if he would have kept fighting it out we would have probably got more outta the situation no offense to ben but ben doesnt give us that interaction here beacuse well he wasnt the one yelling at or about his neighbor. Ben is wilson (Home improvement) or flanders (the simpsons) in the esk of neighbor right now. As in Ben has been friendly (so it seems)

Id leave the neighbors alone for now and look else where that should sort it self out i think.

---

5tarscream posted...

Ok cool I thought as much but I didnt play then.
Aecioo whats your best catch as town in your opinion and your best scum game.

Oh god that's literally impossible for me to remember. I hosted Bond Mafia though! That was a fun one if you want to reread some old games at some point. I remember screaming about the mafia team during the awful Harry Potter game (sorry chris), but I only figured out the entire team by lynch or lose. I know I won some scum games too but I legit don't remember which ones except for one where I was godfather and won as the last scum alive. I will say I used to try and brute force my way to lynches in an almost chris like way when I had a lot of conviction, but that was years ago and I'm definitely not the same person now, plus it wasn't always so successful.

---

##unvote
##Vote: Corrik

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Honestly I think Gravy gave up to soon if he would have kept fighting it out we would have probably got more outta the situation no offense to ben but ben doesnt give us that interaction here beacuse well he wasnt the one yelling at or about his neighbor. Ben is wilson (Home improvement) or flanders (the simpsons) in the esk of neighbor right now. As in Ben has been friendly (so it seems)

Id leave the neighbors alone for now and look else where that should sort it self out i think.

There's nothing to gain from poking at it more except to have more people weigh in and create more discussion so scum might slip up, and given the level of activity right now I'm not opposed to that. Just want more posting. I'm here for awhile.


---

red13n posted...

##unvote
##Vote: Corrik

Why? I have my own ideas as to why you voted but don't want to put words in your mouth first

---

Well im here too work has been crickets so far so whats sup aeicoo

---

The short of it, he seems a little salty and eager to call people town.

---

And starscream, I'd like to know what you plan on gleaning from asking me these questions. I'm enjoying the trip down memory lane but are you going to evaluate my play in this game from a blurb about how I played years ago?

---