Board 8 > Illuminati Mafia Topic 1: It begins.

(+) Yeah! (+)

you know i was so excited to play a role i never had played by before, and you're just an asshat to me for 16 hours by ignoring me.

sbell is the other neighbor

im out of mafia, this community is garbage.

---

umm...what?

---

Lmfao *shakes head*

---

@PunishedBen replaces greengravy294

---

Yo Sbell now we get to be neighbors for real. Let's roll this game.

Neighbor chat is kind of depressing. Gravy came into this game really excited.

---

I've got patience though. I'm gonna say Sbell is town. The kind of harsh betrayal he displayed only comes from the cold heart of a man who has nothing to lose (I'm exaggerating but you get my point)


---

so why should we trust you in particular then.

---

Sbell why not answer?

---

Oh. I dunno. But I at least get a clean slate right? Also no bias before I replaced I was reading and thought gravy was super town *shrug*

---

You get gravy's slate, not a clean slate.

---

aren't one of the neighbors usually scum??

So if you think Sbell is town........

---

did we seriously peg scumgravy right out of the gate to the point he ragequit?

---

red13n posted...

You get gravy's slate, not a clean slate.

And how did you feel about gravy? His final post kinda cements him town

---

DoubleTangicide posted...

aren't one of the neighbors usually scum??

So if you think Sbell is town........

Chances couldn't be more 50/50. That's kinda the point of neighbors

---

DoubleTangicide posted...

did we seriously peg scumgravy right out of the gate to the point he ragequit?

He quit because his neighbor didn't talk to him. His neighbor can confirm that

---

PunishedBen posted...

Chances couldn't be more 50/50. That's kinda the point of neighbors

That's what I'm saying though.

If it's 50/50 and we have two neighbors, aren't one of them TYPICALLY scum?

Yes, I would like SBell to confirm this.....if/when he decides to show up.....

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Sbell why not answer?

To be fair to Sbell, he probably just didn't find the time yet lol. The game has only been going for an evening

---

my point is, is that if SBell/Gravy were MASONS, I would understand and sympathize.

Personally, I wouldn't trust my neighbor, so I don't understand why Gravy would leave less than 12 hours into the day because his non-confirmed-town partner didn't talk to him

---

DoubleTangicide posted...

That's what I'm saying though.

If it's 50/50 and we have two neighbors, aren't one of them TYPICALLY scum?

Yes, I would like SBell to confirm this.....if/when he decides to show up.....

By 50/50, I mean 50/50 chance of either town/town or town/scum.

Im not calling Sbell confirmed town or anything, but at the moment I want to hope he's town so we can put our chat to good use

---

Ohhh I gotcha

in that case, yeah, Id like Sbell to join us and offer up some info

---

Well

gravy went nuts but I thought he was townie before that

so Ben gets wiggle room from me for now

aeicoo is okay

##Vote: Battle

Using my Day1HanGut here

---

So I mean, what is your take on sbell saying absolutely nothing then?

---

Sbell not taklking to Gravy tells me nothing, I feel like he refuses to talk to him regardless of alignment

---

Ok I'm back
MZero11 posted...

##Vote: gravy

Taking pot shots at Crescent who's not even in the game, that's low

This vote is really, really garbage and just feels opportunistic. Actually, the whole gravy train (ha ha) feels more on him being belligerent rather than actually scummy.
---

we arent even sure if he was refusing to talk to him

its been like 4 hours since day started. Yeah, they could have talked before, but Im not sure it would have even been that productive with no info and no posts to go off of

---

ScareChan posted...

Sbell not taklking to Gravy tells me nothing, I feel like he refuses to talk to him regardless of alignment

oh is that a thing?

---

red13n posted...

oh is that a thing?

I mean

I feel it's a thing?

I don't see any alignment reasoning for sbell to dictate how much he would talk to gravy

---

red13n posted...

So I mean, what is your take on sbell saying absolutely nothing then?

I figure it's either he didn't check in on the chat at all, or he ignored it out of....spite? I'm sure there's an explanation and I doubt the motivation is a scummy one. I am of the mind that scum would interact with their town partner even if they had to force themselves so as to not look scummy by ignoring them. Whereas town Sbell can hold onto the possibility that his partner is scum and is okay to ignore.

---

oh I liked tange so far too

---

ScareChan posted...

I mean

I feel it's a thing?

I don't see any alignment reasoning for sbell to dictate how much he would talk to gravy

I mean, I don't pay close enough attention to these things. I thought maybe they had a feud and hate each other or something.

---

I can build a meta world both ways regarding sbell contact

I'd rather chalk it to there not being communication means nothing

---

red13n posted...

I mean, I don't pay close enough attention to these things. I thought maybe they had a feud and hate each other or something.

I don't think so?

Gravy has been off lately. He did take pot shots at a non player to start the game. Sbell did state in the sign up topic he couldnt wait to lynch gravy

there's enough to just say whatever about it

---

I mean, it means nothing or scum hatched an insidious plan to stir up paranoia in gravy by making his neighbor give him the silent treatment.

---

I don't think its super alignment indicative for either of them, to be honest. Gravy gets mad as both alignments fairly easily, and as been stated there's plenty of reasons as to why Sbell would ghost from either alignments.
---

btw in the interest of covering bases, pretty sure gravy replaced out early in a recent game. I don't recall which and I don't recall his alignment. If someone with more willpower than me at the moment wants to track that down.

---

Oh shit do I inherit the modkill warning too?

---

red13n posted...

I mean, it means nothing or scum hatched an insidious plan to stir up paranoia in gravy by making his neighbor give him the silent treatment.

yeah and then the counter to that is

as scum do you plot to get gravy removed or do you let him run his head into the wall

I can see the world view both ways which is why I would rather just not touch it

I think gravy going hyper active to start was an okay enough look. I know I can read ben so I'd rather just see how that goes personally

Im sure others will have ben in a hole to dig out of but you know

---

PunishedBen posted...

Oh shit do I inherit the modkill warning too?

you son of a snitch

---

Hbthebattle posted...

Ok I'm back

This vote is really, really garbage and just feels opportunistic. Actually, the whole gravy train (ha ha) feels more on him being belligerent rather than actually scummy.

Opportunistic of what exactly

I just voted him for being a butt

---

I can't remember the last time scum actually plotted anything pre-game. Unless it was me. But I'm gravy!

---

red13n posted...

btw in the interest of covering bases, pretty sure gravy replaced out early in a recent game. I don't recall which and I don't recall his alignment. If someone with more willpower than me at the moment wants to track that down.

he replaced out of that game where he was scum buddies with pun and han recently, scum got swept

he did a lot o f ambien posting then too

---

Also funny that HB gets voted and quickly shows up to vote the notoriously inactive guy

And talks about opportunistic

---

PunishedBen posted...

I can't remember the last time scum actually plotted anything pre-game. Unless it was me. But I'm gravy!

May I interest you in the TABLET of TOWN? it's like a, you know, BOOK, but more modern

---

MZero11 posted...

Also funny that HB gets voted and quickly shows up to vote the notoriously inactive guy

And talks about opportunistic

it was noted

---

PunishedBen posted...

I can't remember the last time scum actually plotted anything pre-game. Unless it was me. But I'm gravy!

I feel like scum neighbor is a role that would absolutely make scum more apt to plot.

---

Actually he didn't vote me, just made a little jab. My bad

Although that might be worse!

---

ScareChan posted...

May I interest you in the TABLET of TOWN? it's like a, you know, BOOK, but more modern

If you sign up for Audible you can get access to thousands of ***OFFICIAL AUDIOBOOKS OF CONFIRMED TOWN*** narrated by yours truly

---

red13n posted...

I feel like scum neighbor is a role that would absolutely make scum more apt to plot.

I mean not necessarily. The last game had a scum neighbor and there wasn't a huge amount of plotting coming from them pre-game.
---

....This is 500 hours of you saying "Sir Chris" over and over

I'll take all you have

---

MZero11 posted...

Also funny that HB gets voted and quickly shows up to vote the notoriously inactive guy

And talks about opportunistic

Well, luckily for you, you have a very obvious towntell- when you actually show up to play consistently, you're town. So we'll see how that goes.
---