Board 8 > Illuminati Mafia Topic 1: It begins.

(+) Yeah! (+)

MZero11 posted...

Opportunistic of what exactly

I just voted him for being a butt

It just felt like an insincere vote- referring to Crescent rudely, but its not necessarily scummy, and you're a good enough town player to know that.
---

er, referring to Crescent rudely is mean
---

There is no death and thus no one to talk to at weird hours.

---

red13n posted...

There is no death and thus no one to talk to at weird hours.

Gimme a few minutes to catch up and then I can be!

---

##unvote:gravy/bossman/ben

Him exploding made him seem more town in my eyes, honestly. It seemed like he just legitimately felt like he wasn't playing the game because of Sbell not responding. Definitely a huge overreaction but a... sincere one? I don't think there's really much to glean from Sbell not talking to him, but he should still let us know why if there's a specific reason.

I don't have much else to add but please fire away if you're around

---

We could speed lynh lolo before he shows up for fun

He would hate it

---

Why did sbell ghost gravy:

I've been burned by neighborhood before. I didn't want to come into this game with any information because it makes it harder to form opinions based on actual mafia and not meta. (for reference, in adventure time mafia I was still convinced puns could be scum up until the point he died night 1). I was going to eventually talk to him, I didn't mean to break him.

@Bossman_Coolguy / @greengravy294 : I did not mean to upset you so.

##unvote

With that said, I don't see scum neighbor bailing like that. So hooray for double town neighborhood!

---

What do you mean no information?

I mean, Im pretty confused as to why you would ghost your neighbor while actively attacking them in the topic.

I didn't want to have potential scum in my ear. I didn't want to lead myself to believe he was town (if he isn't). I wanted to judge him based on his mafia play.

And based on a page and a half of content, I felt he was definitely scum and I made a good decision.

---

So why the sudden turn to thinking him to be town when recent history says he replaces as scum?

Leafeon13N posted...

So why the sudden turn to thinking him to be town when recent history says he replaces as scum?

That is an excellent question red, thank you for asking.

I'm not going to meta past game replaces and allow it to poison my thoughts towards this game. I will take each action in this game and analyze it. I think the way he replaced out points more to town than it does scum. He was excited to be my neighbor and then I ignored him and he took his ball and went home. Scum doesn't do that, 5 hours into a mafia game.

Now I'm neighbors who with Ben and while I will start with a town feel, I'll need to start the whole process over again.

---

Hbthebattle posted...

It just felt like an insincere vote- referring to Crescent rudely, but its not necessarily scummy, and you're a good enough town player to know that.

I mean when have I ever placed a serious vote on page 1 of a game >_>

---

Obellisk posted...

With that said, I don't see scum neighbor bailing like that. So hooray for double town neighborhood!

Replace meta is bad

---

MZero11 posted...

Replace meta is bad

Exactly. I'd say this isn't necessarily replace meta and more looking at gravy and what he's said and I guess I have more insight since I can see his string of posts attempting to engage me in the neighborhood

---

Obellisk posted...

I guess I have more insight since I can see his string of posts attempting to engage me in the neighborhood

Fair

---

Leafeon13N posted...

So why the sudden turn to thinking him to be town when recent history says he replaces as scum?

This replace meta is bad

Obellisk posted...

With that said, I don't see scum neighbor bailing like that. So hooray for double town neighborhood!

This isnt. You can judge someone's motivations for doing what they do, and in this case the circumstances surrounding Gravy replacing are entirely different.


---

##unvote:Ben

for now. The neighbors still seem like one of them could be scum but that can be worked out later. Also idk who said it but yeah Mzeros Vote is very very weak

---

I do think Mzero is town this game. You heard it here first.


---

Scum Mzero knows the vote looks bad and probably doesn't do it or engage with the people hounding him for it. Town Mzero has an honest answer for believing it to be totally justified.

---

PunishedBen posted...

Scum Mzero knows the vote looks bad and probably doesn't do it or engage with the people hounding him for it. Town Mzero has an honest answer for believing it to be totally justified.

Did he exsplain i must have missed that

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

for now. The neighbors still seem like one of them could be scum but that can be worked out later. Also idk who said it but yeah Mzeros Vote is very very weak

What was weak about it? In your own words

---

From my understanding the only reason you voted Gravy was for a attack on Creasent who isnt even in the game. Or did i miss something?

---

It seemed more like a "not cool" policy vote than a "this guy is scum" vote.

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

From my understanding the only reason you voted Gravy was for a attack on Creasent who isnt even in the game. Or did i miss something?

So? What's weak about that?

---

That is what is weak about it.. i guess what sbell aaid makes sense but like calling someone out who isnt in the game doesnt make them scum maybe a jerk yes but scum no

---

I think gravy bouncing so soon suggests hes town and was super salty. If hes scum I doubt he quits so soon he was really belligerent and controlling as scum in PW mafia and I doubt he bounces so fast this time over being ignored as neighbour. I will judge Ben on his own play though, I thought his first page was weird but not necessarily scum.

---

I understand zeros vote because gravy was being a jerk and Im not sure its a scum easy vote because of the attention it draws so early. Im not sure any scum vote so early with such a weak reason. Im looking at the later votes especially the ones that jumped off so fast.

---

Aecioo (not Chris) seems nervous to me. That could just be rust but I have a gut feeling thats its rust combined with rolling scum on a first game back.
@Aecioo can you fill me in on your mafia experience real quick when you get a chance.

---

Hey Star.


---

ScareChan posted...

Well

gravy went nuts but I thought he was townie before that

so Ben gets wiggle room from me for now

aeicoo is okay

##Vote: Battle

Using my Day1HanGut here

Please do not invoke Hangut.

DoubleTangicide posted...

hmmm I don't like how sultan came in and immediately parroted the first real opinion he saw (other than himself)

what is it about aecioo you don't like?

Why did you say this and not follow through?

##Vote: Sultan

---

Aecioo is more of a standoffish guy than a nervous guy.

---

Han, did you see what I did? I broke gravy!

---

In

---

Ehh Han voted for me doesnt say much..

That point in the game their was barely any content i already started my thoughts on the only other content of Gravy going after me and aecioo looked off so... eh

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

ter me and aecioo looked off so... eh

Off from... What?

Obellisk posted...

Han, did you see what I did? I broke gravy!

Thats not exactly a thing to celebrate, especially if you believe his replace is town.
---

Leafeon13N posted...

Off from... What?

Just off in general not being strong in anything he did really

---

Hbthebattle posted...

Thats not exactly a thing to celebrate, especially if you believe his replace is town.

I'm not celebrating. Please do not misconstrue it as such.

---

Obellisk posted...

I'm not celebrating. Please do not misconstrue it as such.

If Gravy is going to trash talk the community for being voted then he probably isn't fit to play mafia games anymore. There are people who shouldn't be signing up for games anymore, like him, and Blade.

---

Id like to hear more from ben when he gets back

---

What would you like to hear my dude?

---

PunishedBen posted...

What would you like to hear my dude?

A couple of things.

What is your take on Sbell and has he engaged with you on neighborhood?

And thoughts on aeicoo

---

We haven't really spoken yet.

I observed all of gravys posts and said I wish I could give him a hug.

---

Hmm okay

---

I feel like Sultan's asking questions just to ask.

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I feel like Sultan's asking questions just to ask.

Honestly a little bit i hate day 1 so much.

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

A couple of things.

What is your take on Sbell and has he engaged with you on neighborhood?

And thoughts on aeicoo

He's probably town for how the gravy interactions (or lack therof?) went down. I said hi to Sbell and received the much coveted response.

I skimmed over Aeicoo which is a bad habit I have for people I havent played with before.

---

No reason for skimming we are a balmy 4 pages of goodness. Let's get deep in there Ben.

---

Upon re-read i have discovered that Sultan and Aeicoo are scum buddies

---