Board 8 > Mercenaries 4 Mafia Topic 1: Stockholm Syndrome Simulator 2017

(+) Yeah! (+)

Lopen posted...

I don't see any legitimate suspicion here. I also don't really know what I could do 20 minutes into the game to assuage any legitimate suspicions even if I did, so I might as well just talk about meta anyway.

##vote: Lopen.

lol
---

Yess the topic posted. Exciting! Looks like not too much up for discussion just yet, but to put my 2 cents in:


UltimaterializerX posted...

It's plenty legitimate. Town never talks about what they would do "if they were town". They just do it. anything else is unnatural for a reason.

Not convinced by this argument yet; I think Lopen was legitimately just talking about the game from IGCD's perspective there.

I do however, disagree with Lopen's idea of treating day 1 like a 28 hour day. True, I don't really know how Day 1's are supposed to work (all I have had for reference is Board 8 lol) but I figure we can't start getting insight without stuff to read so...yeah! I think we should discuss away!
---

Is there a reason you bolded the second legitimate and not the first one there, Chris?
---

Lopen posted...

Is there a reason you bolded the second legitimate and not the first one there, Chris?

Obvious scum slip sad to see how Chris has fallen.
---

Also, Jaded, points for the Dresden Files quote.
---

Lopen posted...

Is there a reason you bolded the second legitimate and not the first one there, Chris?

Bolding things is hard on mobile.
---

*rolls past topic*
---

Why, thank you. I thought it suited. :)
---

Oh okay I thought you were pointing out that saying "I don't believe that was a legitimate suspicion" was a contradiction to "I don't know what I'd do if there was a legitimate suspicion 20 minutes into the game"

Cause it kinda was! I would've given you more points for that!
---

man mzero looks bad. I'm really feeling a vote on him. Flimsy defending while protesting he's not defending... yah...

##Unvote
##Vote: mzero
---

is menuwars playing? If so, give some thoughts
---

greengravy294 posted...

1. Ben
2. VI
3. Ulti
4. IfGodCouldDie
5. JohnBobb
6. Death (replaced JC)
7. Kanz
8. Oddity
9. Tony
10. Eaed
11. Corrik
12. Scare
13. Jaded_Eye
14. Mzero
15. Chris
16. Shad
17. Lopen
18. Leo

---

Unsure if Chris is town. He did say he would be less active and I know he was pretty ragey back in the day, but it's been a long time.
---

He is not

Hunt begins when I get back from WaWa
---

well, maybe ragey isn't the right word... he had conviction.
---

Why ask if menuwars is playing when there's a players list in the 4th post?
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

Shaduln posted...

UltimaterializerX posted...

Oddity posted...

Checking in. Just FYI I have no idea about the flavor... so Chris... where are you, friend? Ulti I have a for serious real question for you. Are you scum?

Not this time around. You'll notice a night and day difference in my play, too. I'm the easiest guy on B8 to read.

This is true.

Also, aloha from hawaii. I'm waiting on my pizza.

Gordon Ramsey says if you put pineapple on a pizza you suck, bro.

And Gordon Ramsey is a whiny little bitch.
---

It's Ramsay you uncouth swine.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Well I'm Pjbasis and I'm Miller

I cant even vote that because of course gravy would do that

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I uh, honestly expected 'Sir Chris' to be scum so I am a bit confused by Ulti's claim.

pretty sure its admins as scum, I'm Dante, miller
---

my activity may be spotty tonight, going to a bbq later but well see whats up
---

Oddity is probably town so my revenge for Dark Tower mafia will have to wait.
---

Lopen posted...

It's Ramsay you uncouth swine.

Motherfucker can't even spell his own name right.
---

1. Ben - dont really know you, I know i killed you night 1 in that other game and you apparently know enough to host
\
4. IfGodCouldDie - corrik lite to the extreme. should be fun to watch him play with chris

7. Kanz - I dont rememer if I played a game with kanz or not but I know I have spectated his games and he is a pretty easy read

8. Oddity - I think we played before but its been ages?

13. Jaded_Eye - you are the newbie, right? Have you played at all before? Whats your experience.
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Lopen posted...

It's Ramsay you uncouth swine.

Motherfucker can't even spell his own name right.

This is amazing coming from 'Merle'

no hate God, I just saw the post and couldn't help but laugh

ScareChan posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Well I'm Pjbasis and I'm Miller

I cant even vote that because of course gravy would do that

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I uh, honestly expected 'Sir Chris' to be scum so I am a bit confused by Ulti's claim.

pretty sure its admins as scum, I'm Dante, miller

scare are you secretly pjbasis

has anyone seen them both in a game together?
---

oh we have played a lot of times, I lynch him like every game. doesnt matter what our alignments are he ends up late game lynch candidate
---

ScareChan posted...

oh we have played a lot of times, I lynch him like every game. doesnt matter what our alignments are he ends up late game lynch candidate

I respect this, I can never get a solid read on pj

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Oddity is probably town so my revenge for Dark Tower mafia will have to wait.

I think that game was part of the fettbox archives that died, what happened there?
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Oddity is probably town so my revenge for Dark Tower mafia will have to wait.

Why is this? Does he have a town tell of some sort that he's displaying that I'm not familiar with or do you just think he generally feels like a town player at the moment?
---

Oddity is a rather coy scum player (old info granted) but I don't think he has the awareness to be like "hey is Mzero even playing?" Scum tend to be a bit more considerate and measured in their knowledge, ie I'd expect scum to never ever have to wonder who is on a roster.
---

Dark Tower is probably one of the finer 1 on 1 games ever played between me and Oddity. I was BP town who got the SK who could lynch me killed day 2 and then when town was in the brink of a loss I murdered all of Oddity's team and it came down to me, oddity, colegreen and someone else and Oddity had an innocent scan on him as godfather... and I still almost lynched him, but I couldn't quite pull the trigger. It was a brilliant game by both sides, and Oddity escaped with the win.
---

That's strange because I got the reverse feel from him from that exact same post which is why I was asking.

I feel like a scum player would be more likely to post "is Mzero playing" in an attempt to appear active/concerned/etc while a town player would just you know, look at the player list. Just felt like a kinda fake question to me.
---

I was investigating Mzero's posts after Oddity's vote:

MZero11 posted...

well there isn't a whole lot to talk about atm, might as well try to get some discussion going. Better than talking about wrestling

BTW, it's not defending to say that you don't see something the same was someone else does. I was just offering another interpretation!

I will say this, MZero, this comes off as kind of wishy washy. You offered a case against the "if I'm town" being a scum slip, so I would consider your previous post to be a defense. Just saying.

But I agree with Mzero's argument that Lopen should not be lynched just based off of the "if I'm town" post. Is Lopen really bad as scum? Because with the other "slip" involving the contradictory "legitimate suspicions" sentences...I dunno, I'm not buying the Lopen lynch just yet. I feel like a good scum player would be more scrutinizing for slips like that, yeah?
---

Lopen posted...

That's strange because I got the reverse feel from him from that exact same post which is why I was asking.

I feel like a scum player would be more likely to post "is Mzero playing" in an attempt to appear active/concerned/etc while a town player would just you know, look at the player list. Just felt like a kinda fake question to me.

Hmm... interesting. Not the slant I tend to take but I can see where the thought could come from, sure.
---

Lopen posted...

That's strange because I got the reverse feel from him from that exact same post which is why I was asking.

I feel like a scum player would be more likely to post "is Mzero playing" in an attempt to appear active/concerned/etc while a town player would just you know, look at the player list. Just felt like a kinda fake question to me.

He didn't say 'MZero'. He said 'Menuwars'. Kind of an important difference IMO. Makes it a nulltell re: Oddity.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Dark Tower is probably one of the finer 1 on 1 games ever played between me and Oddity. I was BP town who got the SK who could lynch me killed day 2 and then when town was in the brink of a loss I murdered all of Oddity's team and it came down to me, oddity, colegreen and someone else and Oddity had an innocent scan on him as godfather... and I still almost lynched him, but I couldn't quite pull the trigger. It was a brilliant game by both sides, and Oddity escaped with the win.

Gotcha, much appreciated Chris, thanks! Here's to hoping we can close the deal this time.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Lopen posted...

That's strange because I got the reverse feel from him from that exact same post which is why I was asking.

I feel like a scum player would be more likely to post "is Mzero playing" in an attempt to appear active/concerned/etc while a town player would just you know, look at the player list. Just felt like a kinda fake question to me.

Hmm... interesting. Not the slant I tend to take but I can see where the thought could come from, sure.

yeah, I'm kind of leaning with Lopen here
---

I meant Menuwars I'm just mentally confusing the names.
---

ScareChan posted...

1. Ben - dont really know you, I know i killed you night 1 in that other game and you apparently know enough to host
\
4. IfGodCouldDie - corrik lite to the extreme. should be fun to watch him play with chris

7. Kanz - I dont rememer if I played a game with kanz or not but I know I have spectated his games and he is a pretty easy read

8. Oddity - I think we played before but its been ages?

13. Jaded_Eye - you are the newbie, right? Have you played at all before? Whats your experience.

Haven't played at all before, Scare, only watched over Oddity's shoulder when he was playing back in the day (you have indeed played with him b4), and most recently lurked the CT mafia topics. A lot. So...yeah, know the basics but this is my first actual game.
---

Jaded_Eye posted...

But I agree with Mzero's argument that Lopen should not be lynched just based off of the "if I'm town" post. Is Lopen really bad as scum? Because with the other "slip" involving the contradictory "legitimate suspicions" sentences...I dunno, I'm not buying the Lopen lynch just yet. I feel like a good scum player would be more scrutinizing for slips like that, yeah?

Extra credit: Explain why it's a contradiction other than I said it was one.
---

Guys I'm not going to be playing until after my Linear Algebra Exam tomorrow morning. When I am done with that, I will start replying to things i'm noticing. Have a few posts I want to get back to later
---

ScareChan posted...

4. IfGodCouldDie - corrik lite to the extreme. should be fun to watch him play with chris

OK, I quit. Greengravy please find me a replace. I never ever want to be considered anything so vile again. /jk

This actually made me laugh out loud to the point I snorted.
---

I don't even know what corrik lite to the extreme could even mean.
---

where did you go mzero? Also, is it just me or did IGCD mysteriously disappear too? Gonna have to go back and look methinx. I'll be honest, I expected Chris to come out the gate swinging at me, because he wanted to burn me after Dark Tower. Also, the other player was Boko Chris. It was boko and he's the one who won me the game (you couldn't get past your read of him, also he got replaced out late). Oops, dinner time. BRB
---

But i want to say that I like scarechan and Ulti

Scarechan because I doubt he'd claim Miller after I did if he's lying. Sure it was a pretty obvious joke, but i feel like scum would be more cautious.

So i think Scare is definitely Miller

VI seems a little off, but I'll have to get back to that later

With Lopen I have little comment, but i didnt like the post where he said "It's impossible for me to be this suspect in the 1st 20 minutes". Because nothing is impossible
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I don't even know what corrik lite to the extreme could even mean.

It means I am all of the good with none of the trash but the obnoxiousness is ten fold.
---

Hm.... You know, I expected to have some thoughts on what was going on when I got back. But... I honestly don't!

Let's just poke Leo that always seems like a good idea to me.

##vote: Leo
---

Ah I missed IGCD's response to me, which is what I was looking for, so he didn't disappear. But ever since I voted Mzero he's been gone. I'll admit that he could just have something going on, but it makes me suspicious.
---

Also, VI what is Leo's skill as a player. I feel like I played with him long ago but don't remember him being remarkable or anything.
---