Board 8 > Dog Mafia Topic 2: Puppy Power!

(+) Yeah! (+)

The Doggies
1. RED
2. Wallz
3. Ulti
4. Lopen
5. Black Hydras
6. IGCD
7. death
8. Abacus
9. JC
10. Sbell
11. Dumey
12. Peaf
13. Corrik

(D1 Votals to be posted if/when this topic is needed - Day 2 will start in this topic regardless!)

Should still be accurate votals

BlueCrystalTear posted...

WOOF WOOF BARK BARK Votals
(4) Ulti- Red, (Sbell), Death, Wallz, Lopen
(3) Death- (Peaf), (JC), SBell, JC, IGCD
(1) IGCD- (Ulti), (Lopen), Hydras
(1) Dumey- (Sbell), Peaf
(1) Hydras- Corrik
(1) JC- Dumey
(0) Corrik- (Hydras)
(0) Red- (Ulti), (lopen)
(0) wallz- (Lopen)
(0) Sbell- (Dumey)

Round ends at 9 pm EST (a bit over an hour from now) or when a majority (7) is reached.

A new topic will be posted shortly, just in case.

Scrappy doo aw hell naw

I'm looking at this and finding myself agreeing.

wallmasterz posted...

Man I overall like the people on ulti way more than the people on death.

But something tells me one of JC and SBell is scum and not the other. But fuck if I can figure it out.

Lopen posted...

Well if it's too apathetic we can do IGCD

I'm here

Then switch and see if JC follows through? That just changes the tiebreak situation but I think is a move in the right direction.

##unvote: Death
##vote: IGCD

i don't think death is happening so may as well

Not everyone disinterested in an ulti lynch can be scum but there has been a lot of movement. the death countertrain popped up quickly and so forth. And people still are looking for alternatives. But I cant imagine looking at anything ulti has done and going oh god no please dont lynch him

the only thing in his favor is not being here.

Jc why do you see Ulti as a bad lynch?

wallmasterz posted...

Jc why do you see Ulti as a bad lynch?

It's not so much that he's a bad lynch it's that I'd just rather lynch the other two before him.

also honestly i thought his opening post was a town scanner breadcrumb. less likely if corrik is telling the truth but that has sat with me

Chaeix posted...

It's not so much that he's a bad lynch it's that I'd just rather lynch the other two before him.

also honestly i thought his opening post was a town scanner breadcrumb. less likely if corrik is telling the truth but that has sat with me

If corrik was telling the truth I'd be scum so why vote with me.

Black_Hydras posted...

If corrik was telling the truth I'd be scum so why vote with me.

good god stop being so hyperfocused on corrik calling you roleblocker

he hasn't fkn dayscanned you, he can be telling the truth about being cop and talking out his ass about you in the same post

Fair enough.

I could put Ulti back in the lead over IGCD, but I don't want either lynch and kind of want to see what happens if I don't break the balance.

He called himself a resource guarder. I agree bloodhound sounds more like some form of scanning. But regardless of alignment he was probably just talking out of his arse.

I think IGCD is a solid lynch for his back and forth. He never really showed that he was trying to gauge reactions or anything and Lopen had a recent post where I feel he laid out a good case for the scum equity in IGCDs actions where I didnt really connect those potential dots on my own.

death I dont really get. I am neutral on him.

I am here though if anyone wants to make a last minute appeal.

wallmasterz posted...

But regardless of alignment he was probably just talking out of his arse.

yeah it falls into my 'who the fuck knows' analysis

i'm really not good at reading ulti

Vote igcd please

VO ITS THE MAILMAN! TALS
(3) Ulti- Red, (Sbell), Death, Wallz, (Lopen)
(3) IGCD- (Ulti), (Lopen), Hydras, IGCD, lopen
(2) Death- (Peaf), (JC), SBell, (jc), IGCD
(1) Dumey- (Sbell), Peaf
(1) Hydras- Corrik
(1) JC- Dumey
(0) Corrik- (Hydras)
(0) Red- (Ulti), (lopen)
(0) wallz- (Lopen)
(0) Sbell- (Dumey)

We have a Tie if any discrepancy let it be known.

JC is on IGCD, IGCD didn't vote himself.

with the correction we still have a tie!
(3) Ulti- Red, (Sbell), Death, Wallz, (Lopen)
(3) IGCD- (Ulti), (Lopen), Hydras,lopen, JC
(2) Death- (Peaf), (JC), SBell, (jc), IGCD
(1) JC- Dumey
(1) Dumey- (Sbell), Peaf
(1) Hydras- Corrik
(0) Corrik- (Hydras)
(0) Red- (Ulti), (lopen)
(0) wallz- (Lopen)
(0) Sbell- (Dumey)

I messed the person up.

@Leafeon13N
@wallmasterz
@Lopen
@UltimaterializerX
@Black_Hydras
@IfGodCouldDie
@htaeD
@Xirsca

i guess it's not unlimited time

Whelp, I gave it a moment to see if anyone would take the opportunity.

I do this because I'm unconfident in my own reads. Let's go Lopen.

##Unvote:
##Vote: IGCD

Reiterating that IGCD's claim doesn't make much sense from a scum perspective.

Choice between the two I still very much kill Ulti.

(It's not over until 9:30 btw)

EDumey posted...

Whelp, I gave it a moment to see if anyone would take the opportunity.

I do this because I'm unconfident in my own reads. Let's go Lopen.

##Unvote:
##Vote: IGCD

You have seemed pretty confident so far this game to me. I have been getting town vibes from you but I wish you would own your decision a bit more here. And I wouldnt like this much if it turns out not lynching ulti is good for scum. I do agree Lopen seems like a good choice if youre going to sheep someone though.

I didn't realize this would stay open even after my vote. >_> So I kinda walked away. I'm gonna stick with my decision to follow Lopen. I agree Wallz that I should be more confident in myself. But I think it's my best play.

Final Votals
(4) IGCD- (Ulti), (Lopen), Hydras,lopen, JC, dumey
(3) Ulti- Red, (Sbell), Death, Wallz, (Lopen)
(2) Death- (Peaf), (JC), SBell, (jc), IGCD
(0) JC- (Dumey)
(1) Dumey- (Sbell), Peaf
(1) Hydras- Corrik
(0) Corrik- (Hydras)
(0) Red- (Ulti), (lopen)
(0) wallz- (Lopen)
(0) Sbell- (Dumey)

IGCD Has been Lynched he was :

Bichon Fris town Vanilla

Little tiny white curly haired fluff ball is the Bichon Fris. I honestly picked this one beacuse it is fun to say. They are very small and just a big furry ball of hair. They are know for being energetic loving Dogs. I give them no powers so youre just a vanilla fluff ball.

You win when all threats to town are eliminated.

The Doggies

1. RED

2. Wallz

3. Ulti

4. Lopen

5. Black Hydra

6. death

7. Abacus

8. JC

9. Sbell

10. Dumey

11. Peaf

12. Corrik

D1:IGCD town Vanilla

Dumey had Died he was:

schipperke town Vanilla

Small black dog with Point ears, curly tail(if not cut offf) and a Fluffy Coat.
Fun fact this is the Type of Dog I had growing up and my parents favorite dog breed. schipperke are known as Belgian Ship dogs who would basically hunt Mice on the ships. The name means little Captain. The are know for being loyal. I however give them no powers. This is a cute little loyal Vanilla Doggie.

You win when all threats to town are eliminated.

The Doggies

1. RED
2. Wallz
3. Ulti
4. Lopen
5. Black Hydra
6. death
7. Abacus
8. JC
9. Sbell
10 Peaf
11. Corrik

D1:IGCD town Vanilla
N1:Dumey town vanilla

WOOF!!

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/0/0a2b493d.jpg

That's directed at those of you that lynched the obvious town vanilla igcd.

I see you all didn't kill the person I said. Surprising.

This is where it stood with 1 hour remaining:
(4) Ulti- Red, (Sbell), Death, Wallz, Lopen
(3) Death- (Peaf), (JC), SBell, JC, IGCD
(1) IGCD- (Ulti), (Lopen), Hydras
(1) Dumey- (Sbell), Peaf
(1) Hydras- Corrik
(1) JC- Dumey

Final D1 Votals
(4) IGCD- (Ulti), (Lopen), Hydras, Lopen, JC, dumey
(3) Ulti- Red, (Sbell), Death, Wallz, (Lopen)
(2) Death- (Peaf), (JC), SBell, (jc), IGCD
(0) JC- (Dumey)
(1) Dumey- (Sbell), Peaf
(1) Hydras- Corrik
(0) Corrik- (Hydras)
(0) Red- (Ulti), (lopen)
(0) wallz- (Lopen)
(0) Sbell- (Dumey)

I generally say that trying to find reasoning for the n1 kill is absurd, but Dumey is definitely not someone i expected to see dead. That's very curious.

For now going to
##vote: jc

and here i was feeling better about dumey today because he probably wouldn't tiebreak to kill igcd vs an unclaimed townie based off lopen's logic if he were scum

rip dumey

i also don't think hydras is scum for similar reasons. the only reason he would is if he was scumbuddies with ulti and it would be too obvious a pairing. lopen i still feel good about despite the mislynch.

and of course i know i'm town so i think that it was just an unfortunate mislynch (though i am admittedly glad we no longer have the 'do we lynch igcd' question lingering today) and we should spend our energy looking elsewhere

care to elaborate, peaf?

Oh and Ulti + abacus were the ones without votes down.

abacus has been extremely awol to the point i'm surprised blade hasn't replaced in for him

Chaeix posted...

care to elaborate, peaf?

Haven't reread d1 yet but my impressions were that dumey spent significant time looking into you, and trying to get hydra to provide meaningful participation.

I had you in my "scum??" pile even before then, and like I told dumey thought that his read on you was preemptive distancing.

So all in all feels like a reasonable way to start the day.

Chaeix posted...

do we lynch igcd' question lingering today

was always a bad question.

Chaeix posted...

i also don't think hydras is scum for similar reasons. the only reason he would is if he was scumbuddies with ulti and it would be too obvious a pairing. lopen i still feel good about despite the mislynch.

I also still feel good about lopen but am not following your thoughts on hydra. He seemed like a very introductory player yesterday, his entire thing with corrik came across as someone who didn't really follow the game completely.

Red, Death, and wallz - I'm curious what each of you think regarding the tiebreaker and ulti.

Obellisk posted...

was always a bad question.

Agreed.

PeaceFrog posted...

Haven't reread d1 yet but my impressions were that dumey spent significant time looking into you, and trying to get hydra to provide meaningful participation.

I had you in my "scum??" pile even before then, and like I told dumey thought that his read on you was preemptive distancing.

So all in all feels like a reasonable way to start the day.

i don't think there's much scum equity in killing the only guy gunning for my lynch, would be too obvious tbh

Chaeix posted...

i don't think there's much scum equity in killing the only guy gunning for my lynch, would be too obvious tbh

I once killed sbell n1 because he kept prodding me d1. I was eventually caught for other reasons but I don't think it's that obvious. And isn't the only reason why I'm on you.

PeaceFrog posted...

I also still feel good about lopen but am not following your thoughts on hydra. He seemed like a very introductory player yesterday, his entire thing with corrik came across as someone who didn't really follow the game completely.

Red, Death, and wallz - I'm curious what each of you think regarding the tiebreaker and ulti.

if hydras was scum, why would he actively try to redirect the lynch onto a vanilla instead of an unclaimed townie, unless ulti was his scumbuddy? i would give any newbie the credit to recognize that as a bad scum play

Obellisk posted...

That's directed at those of you that lynched the obvious town vanilla igcd.

you could have been the deciding vote but your vote stayed on death so

PeaceFrog posted...

I also still feel good about lopen but am not following your thoughts on hydra. He seemed like a very introductory player yesterday, his entire thing with corrik came across as someone who didn't really follow the game completely.

Red, Death, and wallz - I'm curious what each of you think regarding the tiebreaker and ulti.

Hydras reaction to Corrik tunneling him felt very natural. I dont know his history with mafia but unless he was a seasoned player years ago, I doubt he stays cool as a cucumber if he is scum.

All the movement in the final hours of day make me confident theres scum in ulti and death.