Board 8 > Simple Mafia Topic 1: My intro to hosting Mafia

(+) Yeah! (+)

Peace___Frog posted...

Ben, sbell, and ctes don't have votes down. Sbell hasn't even placed one at all during the day, despite his attempt.

but that's not indicative of alignment.

and I'd be voting no lynch right now if it wouldn't hammer

Hey frog why do I feel like you've said alot but also said nothing all at the same time?
Give me 3 highlights of what you have seen

Maybe I just need to read your thought more accurately

Peace___Frog posted...

You disagree with it... so you vote for it. Yeah totally makes sense.

Its not like it really matters at this point. The NL is happening whether I agree with it or not so I thought I was ending day just to get it over with.

Lol that is 100% what I've been saying about corrik and Kirby.

I provided a very detailed post about every player in the game this morning and have given a breadth of impressions for you to read. Have I been tunnel visioned on isquen and Kirby? Yeah, probably, but the only other notable things that have happened since then have been the continuation of the fake math analysis, and ctes/ben.

I mentioned that I wanted to look into things more closely when I can get to my pc after work, but given the rate this is going I'll have to do it after night starts :)

But I'll flip it back on you, friend.
You joined the nl crew early on. You have had some incredibly funny and entertaining posts, I'll give you that. I always appreciated that as an outsider.
But what are your impressions? Surely you have thoughts to share with the class.

Lets sleuth this out now so that I can say I never had to rely on cop scans to figure out this game.

Sbell is part of Team Sben and is therefore town. He came into the game very strong, and I don't think he would be as willing to work with me and declare as hard I am town if he was scum. He dropped off a bit (AND NEVER DID NARROW DOWN HIS LIST) but I think he is just legitimately busy irl.

I dont think Kirby would play the "you KNOW me" cards as scum. If he is bravo. But that would mean he'd have to be on another level of confident that I will know he's town. So that sounds like town to me.

IGCD is town probably. I cant really think of a bullshit reason to explain why I think this, so sorry!

For Sultan I liked his post where he said 'Scum better kill me because I have been on a roll'. Dont think he would feel he is on a roll anymore right after rolling scum. That's a streak ender right there.

Isquen I feel kind of bad because the only thing stopping me from calling him scum is that last game I thought the same thing. I think the vote for IGCD that Ulti called him town for is pretty null. The best thing he has going for him is that he thought there are 3 scum. I guess if there are 3 scum then this means nothing, but I think 3 is too much.

There's some posts that make me think Ulti and Corrik are not scum together. I lean towards Ulti being town much more than Corrik. There's a post from Ulti later where he says Corrik and him would have been bussing each other more if a scum team...which makes me think that spat between them was not planned, otherwise Ulti would remember it.

Personally I think 3 scum is too much and 2 mislynches is too few. But its probably between Ctes, Corrik, and one of Peaf or Isquen. Peaf was trying to push Isquen throughout the day and seemed disappointed that more people weren't going for it. I dont think he does this to a scum buddy.

I do really like Ulti trying to town clear people too. I just dont feel like scum ever does this as much day 1. Especially in a small game. Sbell I like for similar reasons

Alright you can end it unless Sbell has more to say

Peace___Frog posted...

But I'll flip it back on you, friend.
You joined the nl crew early on. You have had some incredibly funny and entertaining posts, I'll give you that. I always appreciated that as an outsider.
But what are your impressions? Surely you have thoughts to share with the class.

Early impressions is i actually like Ben this game. Usually Ben does not grow to a top read for me. The confirming Kirby and IGCD early I dont nessisarily like.

IGCD I think has not turned it on yet or is scum. Chris has called us the best town players recently and so far im still craving some good insite, IGCD when town makes good reads even if he can't explain them i am I that boat too I think

Kirby I think this is similar to his 3rd party game so idk what that means lol

Sbell I had thought on early but have kind of let them slide abit and might be interested in reading into more.

The math for the NL in a game this size is the only time I'd legit consider it.

Ulti I have a scum lean on but its a feeling more than anything else

But you know day 1

Obellisk posted...

You can tell Ulti and I aren't scummates because I haven't bussed him yet. :D

I was thinking of this post which for some reason I had memory of Ulti saying. Welp, me and Ulti can't be scum together!

clocked out early and took the kids to target. Man do I love that place.

Anyway. in no order of feels.

good feels:
Ben
Corrik
Ulti
Igcd
peaf
Sbell

Other feels
Kirby
Ctes
isquen
sultan

PunishedBen posted...

I was thinking of this post which for some reason I had memory of Ulti saying. Welp, me and Ulti can't be scum together!

I like it for its double entendre-ness

Who wants to lynch someone. Choo choo

feels a bit early for a train. don't we have another hour?

Well, change of plans. I'll probably be here for the end of the day, but seeing how we don't have many posts left in this topic, I'll just state that I'm adamant on No Lynch and am not open to specialing anybody.

Obellisk posted...

feels a bit early for a train. don't we have another hour?

Idk. I just woke up and saw no one posting.

Corrik7 posted...

Who wants to lynch someone. Choo choo

I'm down. Who you wanna kill?

PunishedBen posted...

I'm down. Who you wanna kill?

No Lynch is the right play. And we see who was willing to do the right play. Who had to be forced kicking and screaming to it. But the question is. Do we wanna do the right play... or do we wanna have fun.

Whatever you guys decide to do, do it here:
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80133498