Board 8 > 90s nickelodeon mafia topic 2 Slime everywhere

(+) Yeah! (+)

Sheep007 posted...

Second, are less active players entirely off the table for you? Is this a consistent thing for your D1s, or is there something particular about this game? I'm curious, because I don't think there's many great options besides the less active players, especially if Plum is off the table.

For today, at least. What's consistent for me on D1s is focusing on the less-active players and getting them to talk, but Plum took the spotlight for most of the day that I couldn't help but talk about him for the most part.

Even if one or both of them might be scum, it's no fun to be a newcomer and then get insta-lynched. I was in that position not too long ago, though I was lucky Lopen was beefing with Crescent my first game, so I had absolutely no worries of being lynched. Honestly, I felt bad when you got nightkilled that very night when you replaced Rana.

Sheep007 posted...

Third... I like your walls, generally, but this one feels lacking. I know you're a very analytical person, and it's missing that streak which I would expect after two games of watching you as town. I know this is a difficult situation, but this is wishy-washy stuff and lacking for this point in the day. I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt with a busy weekend for now, but I am concerned and we may be having words tomorrow. If I die tonight (which I think is fairly likely), I would ask that y'all take a look at Kirby. Ben shall be my messenger from beyond the grave.

I don't blame you. Even I think my posts have been lacking this game so far, tbh. I recognize that I don't have any strong scum reads, contrasted with last game when I was very aggressive toward you. Perhaps it's the fact that this game is only a fourth of the way into its second topic on Day 1, contrasted with the boatload of posts from Sir Chris Mafia and Star Wars/Pokmon Mafia. But that's a lame excuse to make.

Tbh, I'd like more questions and engagement, really. I don't think much else besides Plum's antics and Lea's behavior have been noteworthy this day!

PunishedBen posted...

Alright fair enough. I was wondering when Ulti became so much scummier than Red that you'd sooner suspect the people defending him are scum than you'd vote for Red. So it sounds like you are pretty confident his dodging is a town sign?

No, I'm not. Red is firmly in my ???? camp but I don't feel like his attitude makes as much sense with him being Scum, though I could see it.

Ulti is Scummier because he has made more posts, such as going after Tidus here, which looks again like reaching for low-hanging fruit.

masterplum posted...

Tidus currently. He is the best mixture of never getting shot and hasn't immediately made himself obvious as scum.

Now I need to reconsider though

I wanted to be confirmed town :(

UltimaterializerX posted...

Hider will self resolve. Off.

His scum list is the three players that tied themselves to each other the hardest.

You got me bro. Lea/Ben/me all called each other confirmed town as a grand scum gambit. Amazing. Where is the scum equity in three people all doing that?

Ulti, I think you're Town, but we are not killing Tidus today. You have played with him before. He cannot resist slipping as either alignment, and an abysmal reads list will not make me want to lynch someone who will probably confirm themselves within another two days, especially with fifteen minutes to go.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

I legitimately don't know because my experience is so limited.

I'll be honest, playing the experience card this much is why I feel fine lynching you. It feels like theatre at this point.

I dont think Red is being obstinate, I think he legitimately cannot be here

UltimaterializerX posted...

Yes, the contradiction that MZero pointed out, of which I cited.

I get youre just doing the thing where you vote me and see how I react, but usually you dont outright lie and ignore points Ive made. Plums attack on Sheep was bad and had nothing to do with you.

The contradiction MZero pointed out that I pointed out first????

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I'll be honest, playing the experience card this much is why I feel fine lynching you. It feels like theatre at this point.

It wasn't theatre four years ago. It's not theatre this time. I'm just overwhelmed by all this since I haven't played any ORGs in ages. It's a rough readjustment!

Sounds like we've decided Red and Plum are scum but we just have to get them another day lol
okay
##Unvote
##Vote: BCT

Red has been obstinate the entire game up to this point, though.

I feel Red tends to be more sly and less stubborn as scum, but it's probably been about half a decade since I saw scum Red so I'm hesitant to go all-in on that one

UltimaterializerX posted...

An abysmal read list is a pretty good reason to lynch someone.

Let me put it this way: do you think Town Tidus has a better reads list?

Not a valid reason, Ben.

##Vote:Ben

Testing you

##Unvote
##Vote: Red

PunishedBen posted...

Sounds like we've decided Red and Plum are scum but we just have to get them another day lol
okay
##Unvote
##Vote: BCT

???

What a random vote.

I don't think I see any issues with BCT. This is just Han grilling newbies like he did back in Sir Chris Mafia with me. I don't think BCT is the right answer here, especially so last-minute.

mildly related but holy shit Tidus just appearing ten minutes before deadline with that makes me want to brush my teeth with chainmail you are not helping my generous outlook on you buddy

UltimaterializerX posted...

BCT should not be lynched for the same reason DYL should not be lynched. Give the poor dude a day or two to get his feet under him.

Yup. If you know me, coming back after all this time only to be lynched Day 1 would get me to never even read another Mafia game again.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Not a valid reason, Ben.

##Vote:Ben

Also wow that seems opportunistic unless you really think I';m the scummiest between Red and Plum

I think votals are pertinent at this stage!

[3] Plum - (Han), (Ulti), (Lea), (Death), Chang, Sheep, Kirby
[3] Ben - IGCD, (Red) Tidus, BCT
[2] Red- Lea, DYL, (Ben)
[1] DYL - (Ulti), MZero, (Sheep),( Kirby)
[1] Sheep - Plum
[1] Kirby- Red
[1] Ulti - Han
[1] Tidus - Ulti
[1] BCT - Ben
[0] MZero - (Ulti), (Ben), (plum)
[0] Lea - (IGCD)

okay I fuckin love BCT's response to Ben. Town points to him.

PunishedBen posted...

Testing you

And my vote was simply to see where you stood.

##Unvote

The problem is that there are people blocking a number of the angles I am pushing, except for what, Red?

I'm going to die tonight and one of these guys saying not to lynch the alternative trains I am pushing is likely Scum for it. Keep that in mind y'all.

PunishedBen posted...

Testing you

##Unvote
##Vote: Red

Well, for what it's worth, these crazy stunts are exactly what I should've been expecting from Ben lol

Oh damnit Ben

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Yup. If you know me, coming back after all this time only to be lynched Day 1 would get me to never even read another Mafia game again.

Question, when you made that vote were you aware that your lynch isnt in contention with the current votals but mine is?

I prefer Ben to red

##Unvote
##Vote:Ben

I just dont think Ulti contradicted himself in that one instance.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

And my vote was simply to see where you stood.

##Unvote

... Okay well this brushes me wrong.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

##Unvote: Ulti
##Vote: Ben

And this just seems opportunistic. I've got my eye on you, Han...

lol those two votes

Ben, why are you reaching for the lowest-hanging fruit? Who are you protecting? Yourself?

Whoa whoa whoa

Why Ben?

There's seven minutes left and our top lynch has three fucking votes. This is a mess of an EoD. I do not want to overthink this Plum vote but I am fucking paranoid

Holy shit what the fuck do not lynch Ben are y'all insane

Okay Han answered that

I will say I didnt expect Plum to vote Ben over Red

*sigh* We are seriously not lynching Ben. What is wrong with you guys.

##Unvote
##Vote: Red

I'd prefer Plum, but there's no way we're killing Ben today wtf

Han just leaving his vote on Ulti I do not like with how close the red/Plum lynch is.

If you have been following along with me this game you knew where my vote was going to end up today. I have to represent with the boys. Oh wait Ulti moved to Tidus lol. Well at least I have can still sheep Sheep.

##Unvote:
##Vote: Plum

Oh wait why am I voting Red if Plum has more votes. Fuck me

##Unvote
##Vote: Plum

And he voted me. We'll talk about that tomorrow maybe if we're both alive

Yeah, this is good vote switching at end of day.

Can we lynch Kirby? Scum says no

PunishedBen posted...

Question, when you made that vote were you aware that your lynch isnt in contention with the current votals but mine is?

I knew that was my first vote but wasn't sure how many votes you had. I was hoping to get votals and Death complied (though he didn't get Ben revoting Red in). Also this is getting hectic.

UltimaterializerX posted...

BCT is flagrantly and obviously newbie town. I have serious doubts he could fool me here. The guy is honest to a fault

I mean, you've seen me regret missing my save trades and feeling bad that I didn't hold up my end of the deal lol