Board 8 > Rate That Pokemon: Day 41 - Legendaries Revolution

(+) Yeah! (+)

we're rating every pokemon

maybe

who knows

stats and stuff as we go on. Megas/alternate forms on second sheet.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xckmWbxFYEPFwQbEtudIRoTbuyvr0zqZYtSMt725VaI

Stuff:
- Ratings 1-10, no decimals. If you include a decimal, I will round down.
- You are free to rate any Pokemon from past days or change your rating. The Pokemon that have already been covered will be listed first in the spreadsheet by number order. If you want to change the username you are listed by in the spreadsheet, you can tell me that as well.
- Nominations for future ratings are accepted. This does not guarantee your noms will be up for rating the next day but they will be moved up the queue for sooner rather than later.
- You obviously do not have to rate everything, just the ones you want.

YA KNOW (659 rated):
1. Arcanine 8.567
2. Decidueye 8.308
3. Scyther 8.154
4. Gengar 7.968
5. Zapdos 7.963
6. Articuno 7.963
7. Milotic 7.958
8. Jolteon 7.939
9. Excadrill 7.897
10. Scizor 7.885
11. Tyranitar 7.839
12. Squirtle 7.825
13. Umbreon 7.818
14. Chandelure 7.815
15. Nidoking 7.800
16. Metagross 7.800
17. Mimikyu 7.793
18. Aggron 7.786
19. Totodile 7.739
20. Galvantula 7.750
21. Dragonair 7.710
22. Ninetales 7.704
23. Flygon 7.692
24. Joltik 7.679
25. Growlithe 7.667
26. Houndoom 7.667
27. Hawlucha 7.667
28. Bulbasaur 7.610
29. Corviknight 7.609
30. Breloom 7.552
31. Haunter 7.548
32. Dragapult 7.536
33. Garchomp 7.533
34. Honchkrow 7.483
35. Volcarona 7.480
36. Charmander 7.475
37. Tyrantrum 7.444
38. Vulpix 7.444
39. Luxray 7.438
40. Hydreigon 7.433

42. Empoleon 7.400
114. Piplup 6.760

612. Feebas 3.000
612. Happiny 3.000
612. Scatterbug 3.000
612. Blipbug 3.000
617. Igglybuff 2.848
618. Vullaby 2.800
619. Binacle 2.793
620. Lickilicky 2.600
621. Cascoon 2.536
622. Silcoon 2.393
623. Smoochum 1.862

Megas/Forms (92 rated):
1. Alolan Marowak 8.174
2. Alolan Ninetales 8.130
3. Alolan Vulpix 7.652
4. Alolan Sandslash 7.440
5. Mega Ampharos 7.476
6. Mega Kangaskhan 7.304
7. Mega Beedrill 7.304
8. Mega Charizard X 7.242
9. Mega Pidgeot 7.182
10. Alolan Raichu 7.067
11. Mega Blaziken 6.875
12. Mega Aggron 6.870
13. Alolan Exeggutor 6.750
14. Mega Absol 6.692
15. Shaymin-Sky 6.692
16. Mega Metagross 6.640
17. Mega Banette 6.625
18. Galarian Zigzagoon 6.591
19. Mega Scizor 6.524
20. Alolan Sandshrew 6.520


Past Days (Copy/Paste Forms):
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Vv1mo82m5NMRUagOQuEIBFZlCz4wv6S_xGuATrjIBa0

Day 41: Legendaries Revolutions
Jirachi
Deoxys
Dialga
Palkia
Darkrai
Arceus
Victini <cite>kateee posted [p:940734985] in Rate That ... [t:78775154]...</cite> <quote> pics? no only for gen 8 only for gen 7 & 8 only for gen 5-8 only for gen 4-8 only for gen 3-8 only for gen 2-8 yes for all ...whatever wut Vote View Results pics? - Results (1 vote) no 0% (0 votes) 0 only for gen 8 100% (1 vote) 1 only for gen 7 & 8 0% (0 votes) 0 only for gen 5-8 0% (0 votes) 0 only for gen 4-8 0% (0 votes) 0 only for gen 3-8 0% (0 votes) 0 only for gen 2-8 0% (0 votes) 0 yes for all 0% (0 votes) 0 ...whatever 0% (0 votes) 0 wut 0% (0 votes) 0 Show Voting Form we're rating every pokemon maybe who knows stats and stuff as we go on. Megas/alternate forms on second sheet. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xckmWbxFYEPFwQbEtudIRoTbuyvr0zqZYtSMt725VaI Stuff: - Ratings 1-10, no decimals. If you include a decimal, I will round down. - You are free to rate any Pokemon from past days or change your rating. The Pokemon that have already been covered will be listed first in the spreadsheet by number order. If you want to change the username you are listed by in the spreadsheet, you can tell me that as well. - Nominations for future ratings are accepted. This does not guarantee your noms will be up for rating the next day but they will be moved up the queue for sooner rather than later. - You obviously do not have to rate everything, just the ones you want. YA KNOW (659 rated): 1. Arcanine 8.567 2. Decidueye 8.308 3. Scyther 8.154 4. Gengar 7.968 5. Zapdos 7.963 6. Articuno 7.963 7. Milotic 7.958 8. Jolteon 7.939 9. Excadrill 7.897 10. Scizor 7.885 11. Tyranitar 7.839 12. Squirtle 7.825 13. Umbreon 7.818 14. Chandelure 7.815 15. Nidoking 7.800 16. Metagross 7.800 17. Mimikyu 7.793 18. Aggron 7.786 19. Totodile 7.739 20. Galvantula 7.750 21. Dragonair 7.710 22. Ninetales 7.704 23. Flygon 7.692 24. Joltik 7.679 25. Growlithe 7.667 26. Houndoom 7.667 27. Hawlucha 7.667 28. Bulbasaur 7.610 29. Corviknight 7.609 30. Breloom 7.552 31. Haunter 7.548 32. Dragapult 7.536 33. Garchomp 7.533 34. Honchkrow 7.483 35. Volcarona 7.480 36. Charmander 7.475 37. Tyrantrum 7.444 38. Vulpix 7.444 39. Luxray 7.438 40. Hydreigon 7.433 42. Empoleon 7.400 114. Piplup 6.760 612. Feebas 3.000 612. Happiny 3.000 612. Scatterbug 3.000 612. Blipbug 3.000 617. Igglybuff 2.848 618. Vullaby 2.800 619. Binacle 2.793 620. Lickilicky 2.600 621. Cascoon 2.536 622. Silcoon 2.393 623. Smoochum 1.862 Megas/Forms (92 rated): 1. Alolan Marowak 8.174 2. Alolan Ninetales 8.130 3. Alolan Vulpix 7.652 4. Alolan Sandslash 7.440 5. Mega Ampharos 7.476 6. Mega Kangaskhan 7.304 7. Mega Beedrill 7.304 8. Mega Charizard X 7.242 9. Mega Pidgeot 7.182 10. Alolan Raichu 7.067 11. Mega Blaziken 6.875 12. Mega Aggron 6.870 13. Alolan Exeggutor 6.750 14. Mega Absol 6.692 15. Shaymin-Sky 6.692 16. Mega Metagross 6.640 17. Mega Banette 6.625 18. Galarian Zigzagoon 6.591 19. Mega Scizor 6.524 20. Alolan Sandshrew 6.520 Past Days (Copy/Paste Forms): https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Vv1mo82m5NMRUagOQuEIBFZlCz4wv6S_xGuATrjIBa0 Day 41: Legendaries Revolutions Jirachi Deoxys Dialga Palkia Darkrai Arceus Victini </quote>

... Copied to Clipboard!

more evidence for legendary design becoming better recently!

Jirachi 5
Deoxys 5
Dialga 7
Palkia 5
Darkrai 6
Arceus 4
Victini 4
Keldeo 5
Genesect 7
Tapu Koko 7
Tapu Lele 6
Tapu Bulu 6
Tapu Fini 7
Magearna 6
Marshadow 8
Zeraora 6
Eternatus 7

Deoxys Attack 5
Deoxys Defense 4
Deoxys Speed 5
Keldeo Resolute 6

---

Jirachi 9
Deoxys 10
Dialga 8
Palkia 6
Darkrai 7
Arceus 6.5
Victini 4
Keldeo 3
Genesect 7
Magearna 4
Marshadow 4.5
Zeraora 2
Eternatus 4

Deoxys Attack 10
Deoxys Defense 7
Deoxys Speed 10

---

Jirachi 8
Deoxys 6
Dialga 3
Palkia 5
Darkrai 5
Arceus 4
Victini 6
Keldeo 8
Genesect 2
Tapu Koko 1
Tapu Lele 3
Tapu Bulu 2
Tapu Fini 7
Magearna 1
Marshadow 8
Zeraora 9
Eternatus 2

Deoxys Attack 5
Deoxys Defense 6
Deoxys Speed 6
Keldeo Resolute 9

---

Jirachi 7
Deoxys 7
Dialga 5
Palkia 1
Darkrai 3
Arceus 4
Victini 5
Keldeo 1
Genesect 3
Tapu Koko 3
Tapu Lele 2
Tapu Bulu 2
Tapu Fini 5
Magearna 1
Marshadow 2
Zeraora 6
Eternatus 7

Deoxys Attack 5
Deoxys Defense 2
Deoxys Speed 5
Keldeo Resolute 1

---

Day 41: Legendaries Revolutions
Jirachi 8
Deoxys 4
Dialga 6
Palkia 5
Darkrai 7
Arceus 9
Victini 8
Keldeo 7
Genesect 5
Tapu Koko 8
Tapu Lele 8
Tapu Bulu 10
Tapu Fini 7
Magearna 6
Marshadow 8
Zeraora 4
Eternatus 2

Deoxys Attack 4
Deoxys Defense 4
Deoxys Speed 5
Keldeo Resolute 7

Tapu Bulu

---

Wow, with all that voting data you could create compatibility stats.

Hopefully I'll have time to vote tomorrow.

---

Jirachi 7
Deoxys 8
Dialga 6
Palkia 6
Darkrai 8
Arceus I mean, 9
Victini 6
Keldeo 5
Genesect 9
Tapu Koko 6
Tapu Lele 6
Tapu Bulu 6
Tapu Fini 7
Magearna 10
Marshadow 9
Zeraora 4
Eternatus 4

Deoxys Attack 8
Deoxys Defense 7
Deoxys Speed 8
Keldeo Resolute 4

---

Haste_2 posted...

Wow, with all that voting data you could create compatibility stats.

not easily, no. naive compatibility comparisons don't well work for data with many degrees of freedom

---

Jirachi 7
Deoxys 6
Dialga 6
Palkia 6
Darkrai 8
Arceus 6
Victini 6
Keldeo 3
Genesect 5
Tapu Koko 6
Tapu Lele 6
Tapu Bulu 6
Tapu Fini 6
Magearna 4
Marshadow 5
Zeraora 1
Eternatus 1

Deoxys Attack 6
Deoxys Defense 6
Deoxys Speed 6
Keldeo Resolute 3

---

pretty bad set today

Jirachi 8
Deoxys 3
Dialga 2
Palkia 2
Darkrai 5
Arceus 4
Victini 3
Keldeo 5
Genesect 7
Tapu Koko 3
Tapu Lele 7
Tapu Bulu 2
Tapu Fini 3
Magearna 4
Marshadow 6
Zeraora 9
Eternatus 6

Deoxys Attack 3
Deoxys Defense 2
Deoxys Speed 2
Keldeo Resolute 5
---

also I think compatibility stats would be cool although I have no idea how difficult they are to do
---

Jirachi 6
Deoxys 5
Dialga 8
Palkia 5
Darkrai 9
Arceus 1
Victini 3
Keldeo 8
Genesect 7
Tapu Koko 9
Tapu Lele 8
Tapu Bulu 5
Tapu Fini 7
Magearna 3
Marshadow 6
Zeraora 5
Eternatus 6

Deoxys Attack 7
Deoxys Defense 6
Deoxys Speed 7
Keldeo Resolute 8

Day 41: Legendaries Revolutions
Jirachi 1
Deoxys 1
Dialga 5
Palkia 4
Darkrai 3
Arceus 2
Victini 1
Keldeo 2
Genesect 5
Tapu Koko 9
Tapu Lele 1
Tapu Bulu 1
Tapu Fini 1
Magearna 1
Marshadow 10
Zeraora 10
Eternatus 2

Deoxys Attack 1
Deoxys Defense 1
Deoxys Speed 1
Keldeo Resolute 2

---

Drakeryn posted...

also I think compatibility stats would be cool although I have no idea how difficult they are to do

This is a problem I've thought about in another context. The issue is that people score on different scales so that you can't look at the difference between scores for a given pokemon between people and expect it to give useful information.

Consider there people--Dire, who scales based around a bellcurve centered at 7, Ermine, who has one centered at 4, and NFUN, whose is centered also at 7. We rank Bulbasaur and Charmander. Ermine and Dire think Bulbasaur is fine, so they give him a 4 and 7, respectively. I don't like him, so I give him a 4. Charmander is ok, so he gets a 7 from me. Dire and Ermine like him, so Dire gives out a 9 and Ermine a 7. From this, it looks like me and Ermine have great compat despite us not sharing any opinions at all, while he and Dire agreed entirely and didn't have a great score.

Of course, this is a very simple example. This assumes normal score distributions which isn't a great assumption. For this, you could simply find the average scores people gave and do a little manipulation to change the average to 5 or 7 or whatever. Generally, I don't think you can normalize people's scores in a way to easily compare them between people. If anybody can think of a good way I'd love to hear it

---

honestly i've thought about compatibility stats before but had no idea how to do it.

so if anyone wants to give it a try, the data's all in the spreadsheet

Jirachi 2
Deoxys 5
Dialga 8
Palkia 5
Darkrai 8
Arceus 5
Victini 2
Keldeo 3
Genesect 5
Tapu Koko 8
Tapu Lele 7
Tapu Bulu 4
Tapu Fini 3
Magearna 6
Marshadow 10
Zeraora 8
Eternatus 7

Deoxys Attack 6
Deoxys Defense 3
Deoxys Speed 5
Keldeo Resolute 3

marshadow might be top 5 for me. curious to see all my 10s when this is all over.

---

Jirachi 8
Deoxys 3
Dialga 4
Palkia 2
Darkrai 1
Arceus 1
Victini 8
Keldeo 5
Genesect 2
Tapu Koko 6
Tapu Lele 8
Tapu Bulu 5
Tapu Fini 8
Magearna 3
Marshadow 2
Zeraora 5
Eternatus 2

Deoxys Attack 3
Deoxys Defense 3
Deoxys Speed 3
Keldeo Resolute 4

Eh, I'll just rate the only one I care about in this bunch.

Genesect 9

---

Jirachi 6
Deoxys 5
Dialga 6
Palkia 3
Darkrai 10
Arceus 4
Victini 4
Keldeo 2
Genesect 6
Tapu Koko 7
Tapu Lele 6
Tapu Bulu 5
Tapu Fini 6
Magearna 3
Marshadow 9
Zeraora 6
Eternatus 5

Deoxys Attack 5
Deoxys Defense 3
Deoxys Speed 4
Keldeo Resolute 4

---

Day 41: Legendaries Revolutions
Jirachi 9
Deoxys 5
Dialga 5
Palkia 3
Darkrai 4
Arceus 1
Victini 5
Keldeo 4
Genesect 7
Tapu Koko 9
Tapu Lele 10
Tapu Bulu 8
Tapu Fini 7
Magearna 1
Marshadow 2
Zeraora 4
Eternatus 5

Deoxys Attack 5
Deoxys Defense 6
Deoxys Speed 4
Keldeo Resolute 5

---

Jirachi 7
Deoxys 2
Dialga 1
Palkia 1
Darkrai 1
Arceus 1
Victini 5
Keldeo 8
Genesect 2
Tapu Koko 6
Tapu Lele 9
Tapu Bulu 7
Tapu Fini 4
Magearna 2
Marshadow 2
Zeraora 1
Eternatus 1

Deoxys Attack 1
Deoxys Defense 1
Deoxys Speed 1
Keldeo Resolute 7

---

The mythicals are great. Despite how much I hate their exclusivity, they've got some of the coolest lore in the game.

Jirachi 7
Deoxys 9
Dialga 7
Palkia 6
Darkrai 10
Arceus 9
Victini 7
Keldeo 5
Genesect 6
Tapu Koko 8
Tapu Lele 4
Tapu Bulu 3
Tapu Fini 3
Magearna 7
Marshadow 8
Zeraora 6
Eternatus 1

Deoxys Attack 5
Deoxys Defense 1
Deoxys Speed 7
Keldeo Resolute 1


---

Jirachi 10
Deoxys 6
Dialga 9
Palkia 7
Darkrai 9
Arceus 8
Victini 10
Keldeo 9
Genesect 6
Tapu Koko 8
Tapu Lele 10
Tapu Bulu 7
Tapu Fini 10
Magearna 10
Marshadow 8
Zeraora 7
Eternatus 6

Deoxys Attack 6
Deoxys Defense 5
Deoxys Speed 6
Keldeo Resolute 9

Ratings for yesterday's stuff:

Nidoran F 5
Nidorina 3
Nidoqueen 8
Nidoran M 5
Nidorino 3
Nidoking 8
Slowpoke 5
Slowbro 6
Slowking 8
Kangaskhan 7
Horsea 6
Seadra 4
Kingdra 8
Slakoth 4
Vigoroth 3
Slaking 4
Piplup 9
Prinplup 5
Empoleon 9

Mega Kangaskhan 8
Galarian Slowpoke 5
Galarian Slowbro 5
Mega Slowbro 5
---

Day 41: Legendaries Revolutions
Jirachi 3
Deoxys 6
Dialga 4
Palkia 4
Darkrai 7
Arceus 5
Victini 8
Keldeo 7
Genesect 7

Magearna 7
Marshadow 8
Zeraora 8
Eternatusoh my...

Deoxys Attack 7
Deoxys Defense 5
Deoxys Speed 7
Keldeo Resolute 8

---

Jirachi 7
Deoxys 2
Dialga 2
Palkia 3
Darkrai 4
Arceus 4
Victini 7
Keldeo 8
Genesect 6
Tapu Koko 5
Tapu Lele 7
Tapu Bulu 1
Tapu Fini 6
Magearna 5
Marshadow 7
Zeraora 10
Eternatus 2

Deoxys Attack 2
Deoxys Defense 2
Deoxys Speed 2
Keldeo Resolute 7

---

Jirachi 7
Deoxys 5
Dialga 6
Palkia 5
Darkrai 6
Arceus 5
Victini 6
Keldeo 7
Genesect 5
Tapu Koko 8
Tapu Lele 9
Tapu Bulu 2
Tapu Fini 7
Magearna 1
Marshadow 8
Zeraora 6

Deoxys Attack 7
Deoxys Defense 5
Deoxys Speed 7
Keldeo Resolute 7

---

Jirachi 5
Deoxys 8
Dialga 5
Palkia 6
Darkrai 8
Arceus 7
Victini 5
Keldeo 8
Genesect 8
Tapu Koko 8
Tapu Lele 8
Tapu Bulu 7
Tapu Fini 8
Magearna 8
Marshadow 8
Zeraora 8
Eternatus 8

Deoxys Attack 9
Deoxys Defense 4
Deoxys Speed 5
Keldeo Resolute 6

---

Jirachi 4
Deoxys 4
Dialga 3
Palkia 2
Darkrai 3
Arceus 5
Victini 3
Keldeo 4
Genesect 6
Tapu Koko 4
Tapu Lele 5
Tapu Bulu 5
Tapu Fini 7
Magearna 8
Marshadow 9
Zeraora 8
Eternatus 1

Deoxys Attack 4
Deoxys Defense 6
Deoxys Speed 4
Keldeo Resolute 5

There's lots of really stupid looking legendaries, and I think the three frontrunners are here. Who the hell thought a llama stuck in a fence was the best idea for literally god? Also shoutouts to penis monster as the master of space and whoever came up with Eternatus, for making something so overly complicated and hideous it led to the rest of the design team cutting half the pokemon in despair.

---

Jirachi 6
Deoxys 6
Dialga 3
Palkia 1
Darkrai 5
Arceus 4
Victini 7
Keldeo 5
Genesect 4
Tapu Koko 9
Tapu Lele 7
Tapu Bulu 5
Tapu Fini 8
Magearna 3
Marshadow 4
Zeraora 3
Eternatus 3

Deoxys Attack 4
Deoxys Defense 3
Deoxys Speed 4
Keldeo Resolute 5

---

Jirachi 7
Deoxys 3
Dialga 3
Palkia 7
Darkrai 6
Arceus 3
Victini 6
Keldeo 5
Genesect 3
Tapu Koko 5
Tapu Lele 5
Tapu Bulu 5
Tapu Fini 5
Magearna 4
Marshadow 6
Zeraora 7
Eternatus 3

Jirachi 8
Deoxys 6
Dialga 7
Palkia 6
Darkrai 8
Arceus 7
Victini 7
Keldeo 6
Genesect 7
Tapu Koko 7
Tapu Lele 7
Tapu Bulu 7
Tapu Fini 7
Magearna 7
Marshadow 7
Zeraora 6
Eternatus 5

Deoxys Attack 7
Deoxys Defense 7
Deoxys Speed 7
Keldeo Resolute 8

---

ghi

Sheep007 posted...

Who the hell thought a llama stuck in a fence was the best idea for literally god?

Spitting some truth right there. Gen 4 gave us legendaries for Time, Space, and Literally God. I'm glad they've dialed it back since then to mere powerful things, as opposed to abstract conceptual deities in the form of dong-shaped dragons and a camelid who didn't quite escape his pen


---

Jirachi 5
Deoxys 2
Dialga 3
Palkia 4
Darkrai 8
Arceus 6
Victini 10
Keldeo 10
Genesect 4
Tapu Koko 4
Tapu Lele 5
Tapu Bulu 4
Tapu Fini 5
Magearna 5
Marshadow 6
Zeraora 9
Eternatus 7

---