Board 8 > Rate the Character Day 5: Tyrion Lannister

(+) Yeah! (+)

9/10

Best Hobbit.
---

bump
---

Never watched GoT... or read. So skipping today, sorry to post about skipping today but felt like it.
---

8/10

4/10

one liners do not a character make
---

Fuck it

9
---

3/10

Unforgivable.
---

Tyrion: 9

Donkey Kong: 4.5
Snape: 8
Darth Vader: 7.5
---

9
---

Scarecrow - 7
Tyrion - 10
---

Scarecrow - 10
Tyrion - 7
---

8.5
---

Eddv posted...

4/10

one liners do not a character make

you're an idiot


10/10
---

Like it cannot be stated enough how stupid Eddv's post in this topic is.

It's the dumbest thing I've ever seen suggested that Tyrion is only one liners. He should be slapped across the face extremely hard for posting it.
---

6/10

a fairly entertaining character at times, but with some huge flaws that make it hard for me to like him
---

7

Dragged down almost entirely by book Tyrion becoming insufferable.

I'm gonna go with a 9.5. Would be a ten, but I feel like he's been pushed a LITTLE too hard at times when he could've been kept on the backburner.
---

ExThaNemesis posted...

Like it cannot be stated enough how stupid Eddv's post in this topic is.

It's the dumbest thing I've ever seen suggested that Tyrion is only one liners. He should be slapped across the face extremely hard for posting it.

Oh no hes a bad character who only really has a witty writer going for him.

Sorry.
---

what is bad about him

i know as a john cena fan you get to be like "I like this so he's good" but when discussing literature you are held a bit more accountable for your opinions
---

A fictional character is only good because of the writer? Wanna think that one through?
---

Donkey Kong 7
Snape 9
Darth Vader 8
Scarecrow 2
Tyrion 2.5
---

No comment on Tyrion, but you can be a bad character while still having good dialogue.
---

9
---

Read eddv's post as "the only good part about him is his witty one liners" and not "there is nothing to him but his witty one liners," as I'm pretty sure that's what he was saying there.
---

its objectively false that there is nothing to him but witty one liners, he is one of the most fleshed out characters in the entire series with a great deal of the book devoted to him and his family and their lives, personalities, and backstory

if you wanna argue "i don't like tyrion except his one liners" but thats different than "bad character who is just one liners", which is what he is arguing.

Is he, though? That's not how I read it.
---

with Eddv you can never be too sure
---

4

Would've been a 10 if the series stopped after Storm
---

Also hi scarlet
---

9.5/10

Sure he kinda sucks in Dance, but it's pretty understandable why he sucks. I'd be a bit put off if he were completely fine after Storm. I think people are a bit too harsh on him for it, though I understand the reaction when we only get book material for him once a decade these days.
---

Hi MI
---

Yeah the deleted post is me calling out eddv for that before deciding I couldn't be bothered explaining how garbage that post is in a potentially protracted argument

Glad others decided to do it for me >_>
---

9
---