Board 8 > Dead by Daylight Mafia Topic 1: Happy Halloween!

(+) Yeah! (+)

I was I had your confidence, Ben.
For one thing I feel like Sbell is pessimistic and putting himself down all the time.
On the other hand I havent seen him post anything as fake as he did last game, so thats a plus for him.

IGCD does sound like his previous townself as well, I will give you that.

htaeD posted...

I was I had your confidence, Ben.
For one thing I feel like Sbell is pessimistic and putting himself down all the time.
On the other hand I havent seen him post anything as fake as he did last game, so thats a plus for him.

IGCD does sound like his previous townself as well, I will give you that.

It's easy to be confident when he knows they're not scum~

And yes I virtually townlock both of them on a Ben scumflip.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Oh cute look at Ben pre-emptively inventing an excuse to call me scum.

Its not you. My read of your reaction to the SOLO QUEUE incident is that you just like to be different

PunishedBen posted...

Its not you. My read of your reaction to the SOLO QUEUE incident is that you just like to be different

You just said you're planning to find and scumread anyone who said they didn't immediately think they were Indy upon receiving their role.

wallmasterz posted...

I was curious to see a follow up post or two from Dumey. And I was in skimming and shit posting mode last night. I only commented on sbell and peaf after crescent asked to put some thoughts on there, but by no means did I feel the need to exhaust every possible observation I had in the first two hours of the game. I still dont.

When was your initial reaction to it being scummy? Last night, or this morning?

Also um.. How is just "liking to be different" even remotely relevant to this situation?

That doesn't sound like me death

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

It's sitting like a tmi or trying to hard to clear someone kind of a thing. Trying to put more weight on what is a NI post. Like sure the team names are weird but like it's so easy to be fakes to be like oh my role PM confused me I thought I was scum or town.

It's not shit post beacuse it seems like a genuine game play comment not like ohh JC loves his mom he must be town.

##Vote: Sultan

Sultan, you have used this phrasing "TMI" as a reason to go after me on more than one recent occasion. I know for certain you said this in Star Trek mafia...where i was town, and you were Scum. The other time you did this, you may have been town. I genuinely dont remember. If you can find me a game where you suspected me of TMI when you were town, then I will unvote you.

But if you are town then this is not the first time you have used that phrasing about me and been wrong, so consider that.

Obellisk posted...

That doesn't sound like me death

Oh I didnt mean it too harshly, I have just seen you get glum in a lot of games.

Ashethan posted...

When was your initial reaction to it being scummy? Last night, or this morning?

Last night I thought it seemed questionable, leaned a bit scummy but I wanted to see how Dumey followed it up. Then I fully read the thread this morning and had basically the same feeling about it, just thought it came across a bit worse with me fully paying attention.

Crescent-Moon posted...

You just said you're planning to find and scumread anyone who said they didn't immediately think they were Indy upon receiving their role.

Not necessarily. I said I believe I CAN find scum doing this, not that everyone who did this is scum. I found your explanation for your PM reaction to be believable enough.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Like I agree I had to read my pm like 4 times to understand it but like it such a NI comment don't auto clear for it

So you are saying, that if you were scum, you would have had the idea to say in your first post that you thought you rolled 3rd party? And you would have thought that was something that makes you look towny?

PunishedBen posted...

##Vote: Sultan

Sultan, you have used this phrasing "TMI" as a reason to go after me on more than one recent occasion. I know for certain you said this in Star Trek mafia...where i was town, and you were Scum. The other time you did this, you may have been town. I genuinely dont remember. If you can find me a game where you suspected me of TMI when you were town, then I will unvote you.

But if you are town then this is not the first time you have used that phrasing about me and been wrong, so consider that.

Right or wrong or scum, best post by you so far Ben. I have been curious about Sultan because the only time he suspected me as town previously he was scum. It was also Star Trek where you replaced in and were the only person advocating for Hans lynch over mine.

However, Ive had a bad track record reading Sultan and someone being wrong about you doesnt make them scum (contrary to the opinion of last games town mvp, bct lol) so none of my thoughts on sultan are graduating to insights quite yet.

Ulti is posting cat pics your new scum tell?

PunishedBen posted...

So you are saying, that if you were scum, you would have had the idea to say in your first post that you thought you rolled 3rd party? And you would have thought that was something that makes you look towny?

In what world is, "lol look at this genuine reaction I had to receiving my town role dm" not something that sounds beneficial to post? Especially when it is host confirmed that every town is in the same bucket as you?

UltimaterializerX posted...

Oh, and important note for everyone on town.

Isquen writes way too much for his own good and pretty much every role can be safely ignored since that insane psychic shit. This game needs to be solved on vibes and scum hunting, not power roles. Thank me later.

This post makes me feel good about Ulti. Trying to be helpful and make sure town wins. Not a comment he has to make as scum. Easy vibe check :)

EDumey posted...

In what world is, "lol look at this genuine reaction I had to receiving my town role dm" not something that sounds beneficial to post? Especially when it is host confirmed that every town is in the same bucket as you?

Sultan is who I asked because I'm trying to understand why HE thinks IGCD and Sbell arent town cleared

PunishedBen posted...

So you are saying, that if you were scum, you would have had the idea to say in your first post that you thought you rolled 3rd party? And you would have thought that was something that makes you look towny?

It's a possibility. Sbell and IGCD are not dumb I could see one of them potentially trying this.

UltimaterializerX posted...

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/3/2/4/AABxG1AAE2Yc.jpg

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/5/8/3/AABxG1AAE_O_.jpg

CAT

wallmasterz posted...

Ulti is posting cat pics your new scum tell?

Catposting is never a crime.
Plus Ulti hasnt done the thing yet that I believe he likes to do as scum. (what that is, I am not telling)

Crescent-Moon posted...

We were sent our roles 24 hours before that post was there. People are discussing their immediate reactions when they got their roles. I think it's a bad meta that goes nowhere since it can be faked.

We've now had several people saying they immediately thought they were survivor or scum when they initially got their role PMs. It's just turning into a distracting rabbit hole.

This is like the juiciest stuff you can get out of day 1 for opening post vibe readers like me :P

But anyway, thats just a disagreement about how we play mafia. I do believe that you think this.

wallmasterz posted...

Right or wrong or scum, best post by you so far Ben. I have been curious about Sultan because the only time he suspected me as town previously he was scum. It was also Star Trek where you replaced in and were the only person advocating for Hans lynch over mine.

However, Ive had a bad track record reading Sultan and someone being wrong about you doesnt make them scum (contrary to the opinion of last games town mvp, bct lol) so none of my thoughts on sultan are graduating to insights quite yet.

Glad you have this 2nd paragraph beacuse that first statement is silly

PunishedBen posted...

This post makes me feel good about Ulti. Trying to be helpful and make sure town wins. Not a comment he has to make as scum. Easy vibe check :)

oh boy. Whatever ultis alignment is this just feels either scummy or bizarrely gullible. That post is fluff comment and/or misleading, intentionally or otherwise. Ulti says ignore roles, town af!

PunishedBen posted...

Sultan, you have used this phrasing "TMI" as a reason to go after me on more than one recent occasion

I feel I've got you on this as well. Maybe you use such a language it makes you sound like you know more info than we do.

Ashethan posted...

Well not that good, apparently. Also, feel like we've done this dance before.

Towny response from Ashe. I likey

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Ashe don't mind Ulti he just loves to have everyone claim super fast for no reason lol.

Now THIS is TMI. Poor Sultan is too nice for his own good and is showing pity for town Ashe who is being pestered by town Ulti. I've literally seen Sultan do this before which is why its so tragic lol

I would like for Ulti to be gentler towards our new host tho..
(Of course I didnt even realize he was hosting for the 1st time)

PunishedBen posted...

Towny response from Ashe. I likey

Now THIS is TMI. Poor Sultan is too nice for his own good and is showing pity for town Ashe who is being pestered by town Ulti. I've literally seen Sultan do this before which is why its so tragic lol

I do not know of Ashe is town I was just pointing out Ulti always does this even if ashe is scum it is still a true statements

wallmasterz posted...

oh boy. Whatever ultis alignment is this just feels either scummy or bizarrely gullible. That post is fluff comment and/or misleading, intentionally or otherwise. Ulti says ignore roles, town af!

Yep :)

its probably one of the wisest things anyone has said all game!

I already know scum has things we've never seen in a mafia game before, because I know Isquen. if Ulti is scum here, he does not want to push the narrative that we shouldnt put our trust in power roles to solve the game. its that simple

It is very curious that sultan and Ben are going back and forth about tmi right now, right after Dumey interpreted my sus of Ben as being because he had tmi

htaeD posted...

I would like for Ulti to be gentler towards our new host tho..
(Of course I didnt even realize he was hosting for the 1st time)

He isn't. He hosted before. Dota, i think.

UltimaterializerX posted...

My scum tell (pocketing friends and backing off of them asap while ignoring all of my teammates) is so hilariously easy and I do it on purpose. Well that and just open wolfing all game without ever dying unless Lea or Crescent are around.

I know I technically lost last game but it was fun getting endgamed as scum. I think it was the first time ever, and Sheeps kind words after were really sweet. Love that guy.

Also we really can murder Dumey. Blatant rolefishing and with how this game clearly works there should be no reason to.

Hey you almost had me going along with you
Granted, I could afford to go either way..
Thats not the tell I was talking about anyway, and I suppose you may not even be consistent enough as scum to make it again.
I will have to see.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Also we really can murder Dumey. Blatant rolefishing and with how this game clearly works there should be no reason to.

Ulti "Guys I have to reread my role because I have no idea how to interpret any of this"

Also Ulti "Guys Dumey is definitely blatant scum because there no reason whatsoever to look for clarification on traits."

Make it make sense.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Second time.

And hes someone I consider a personal friend off site. He can very much handle my extreme extroversion not translating to text properly since he knows how I actually am

Oh okay. Thats good enough for me.

PeaceFrog posted...

It is very curious that sultan and Ben are going back and forth about tmi right now, right after Dumey interpreted my sis of Ben as being because he had tmi

I did notice this, I was just waiting for Ben to catch up, since he seemed to be going in order of posts from start to finish.

But yeah that's why i was snarky to isquen in my first post. He made Lopen an insane psychic last time around and it was a tough time for everyone involved.

I believe there are decent reasons to ask Red for clarifications about his miller claim.
But at the same time I dont think the answer could really say much about Red himself.

PeaceFrog posted...

But yeah that's why i was snarky to isquen in my first post. He made Lopen an insane psychic last time around and it was a tough time for everyone involved.

Must be another thing I blocked out of my memories.
Or I died too soon to care.

Lea are you upset that we didn't play Mafia on your birthday. You said that was last Thursday or something right? Happy belated birthday! Or not if I made that all up in my head and or totally misremembered.