Board 8 > Dead by Daylight Mafia Topic 1: Happy Halloween!

(+) Yeah! (+)

move here

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80607067

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Far to early reads list beacuse I'm bored

Ashethan- very meh null but on the scum end
Chaeix / jc- town i think JC has probably been the most genuine player so far this game.
Corrik7 / Corrik- Corrik is being day 1 corrik so null
Crescent-Moon- if she is scum shes very good at it. This resembles the Town Crescent that i remember
EDumey / Dumey- meh? I think i get where Dumey is coming from with the questions but i also see where Creasent is coming from when it comes to be a little bit of fishing
Forceful_Dragon / FD- has he posted yet?
htaeD / Death- so far so good
IfGodCouldDie / IGCD- so far i think these jabs he has thrown look pretty town like.
Lea- odd for her to be so inactive but it is probablyNI
Obellisk / Sbell- town sbell alot of the things he is doing doesnt seem like something scum sbell woul do
PeaceFrog- another Meh? Just feels flat so far.
PunishedBen / Ben- dont like ben only pop ins have been very underwhelming and wrong
red13n / Leafeon13n- red is always a hard read but I'm thinking Null but on the town end

UltimateBrohan / Brohan- I got nothing
UltimaterializerX / Ulti- ulti clearing half the game for a bad reason Is something I can see both Ultis doing but I'm leaning town here
wallmasterz / Wallz- I'm disappointed so far in wallz it could just be his scum game and not being comfortable

Sultan JC Brohan look good so far.

Ashethan posted...

Don't like the wall vote on dumey at all. When he gave his thoughts the first time he said:

The only players he mentions at this point are Sbell and Peaf. Fair enough, if that's all he has a read on. It's still early on day 1.

But... by this point Dumey had already talked about the miller claim. If the way he went about it felt scummy, shouldn't he have felt that before?

Shouldn't this have been part of his initial read? It's like he saw an opportunity, and went for it, rather than legitimately trying to figure dumey out.

##Vote: Wall

Don't like this post since it immediately follows someone say they could see him as timid and shy as scum for the first time in forever.

PunishedBen posted...

Alright was busy raiding last night and just now actually reading beyond the first two sentences of these posts.

Look at these two angels. First of all, The words "SOLO QUEUE" being the first thing you saw heavily implied third party. If you were there, you'd understand this. if you were scum, then Solo Queue was not the first thing you saw and thus you had the context that allowed you to never make this assumption. I can now find so many scum just based off of who did not understand this concept at all. And I will.

In fact, one was already very obvious to me last night. More on that later~

Going back to Sbell and IGCD though, as if you needed anything more to prove that Sbell is town, look at the bolded statement. Scum rarely does that. First they have to have the right role that puts them in the position to say that. But secondly, scum dont like admitting things that they dont need to. Town just want to be honest, especially if their role sucks. Sbell is so town it hurts and all it took was a first post.

IGCD I feel the same about and his posts on page 1 support my initial read of him.

Honestly this is probably solid. And it's hard to not think all 3 named here are town. I'm getting too many town reads now. *scratches head*

EDumey posted...

Ben, the only thing I'm specifically asking of you at the moment is if the fact that the opening posts say that ALL PLAYERS were notified that town was called solo queue, does that change your impression at all?

Is there any world where a scum player goes, "Town is solo queue? That's cute, I would have thought that was third party or something!" and made a similar first post of the game as they did?

Possibly a good point but could be scum response trying to discount a solid reason to town clear a good portion of the game.

Hey man, we're in the next topic.

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]

I have a BA in History and a BS in Secondary Education in Social Studies.

Shameless late topic tag from me. Carry on in current topic.

One bump

Two bump