Current Events > Do you believe in the "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" mentality?

Topic List
Page List: 1, 2
darkmaian23
10/29/23 2:14:59 AM
#1:


Do you think that you are a self-made person?
Do you think that your mistakes are your fault? Do you own up to them?
Are you satisfied with your life? Do you think your path to satisfaction is somehow universal, and that other people will prosper if they do what you did?

The amount of smug people on Reddit dispensing useless advice to people struggling with life is staggering. By all means, people should do whatever they can for a better life if they're not comfortable with the one they have. Genuine advice is always cool to see, but so many people just want to post about how successful they are, or how they survived X, Y, and Z hardships and how it is no big deal and you just need to "get tough" or some variant of that. The existence of suicides and homeless camps and various other states of "failure" indicate that, no, not everybody makes it, and I'd just dare somebody to say such people didn't try hard enough.

I wonder how many people, for example, who claim to be making six figures online are actually just doing the minimum wage work they so look down on in their posts in reality.

---
Cuteness is justice! It's the law.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Torgo
10/29/23 2:18:14 AM
#2:


The irony is that "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" was an expression meant to ridicule this mentality, because it's technically impossible to actually perform such a feat.

But conservatives and libertarians are not good at nuance or very clever, they are good at pretending privilege is merit and exploiting others into believing their difficulty is due to government existing or because marginalized people are holding them back.

---
Moderated for telling people not to commit illegal acts of assault and murder.09/2/23
Also moderated for not responding to obvious bait. - 10/03/23
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kai_Laguna
10/29/23 2:18:39 AM
#3:


Hell no, most people that spout that shit are the people that have their own boot firmly planted on your back, preventing you from getting up.
... Copied to Clipboard!
ai123
10/29/23 2:21:12 AM
#4:


I am very satisfied with life, but I recognize that this is in large part due to fortunate circumstances and the support I have received.

I wouldn't dream of using the bootstraps line on anyone.

---
You'll see motivational pictures about working hundred hour weeks/Well, it only applies to those who are operating at a really basic level
... Copied to Clipboard!
mercurydude
10/29/23 2:23:36 AM
#5:


Considering that I always hear it from people who DIDN'T make it to where they are by their own effort, the answer is no.

---
God forbid you ever had to walk a mile in her shoes, 'cause then you really might know what it's like to have to choose. - Everlast
... Copied to Clipboard!
Glob
10/29/23 2:24:47 AM
#6:


darkmaian23 posted...
Do you think that you are a self-made person?
Do you think that your mistakes are your fault? Do you own up to them?
Are you satisfied with your life? Do you think your path to satisfaction is somehow universal, and that other people will prosper if they do what you did?


I feel that Im about as self-made as it is possible to be, in that Ive come up from nothing and am very successful, but Im not going to pretend that this didnt require some lucky breaks alongside the hard work. I know that not all people will get that same luck.

Its all too easy for people who have worked hard to convince themselves that their hard work is the only reason that they are successful, which then leads them to believe that anybody who is less successful just doesnt try as hard, but thats not reality. Nobody has ever gotten anywhere without some significant measure of luck.

... Copied to Clipboard!
Torgo
10/29/23 2:27:10 AM
#7:


Glob posted...
I feel that Im about as self-made as it is possible to be, in that Ive come up from nothing and am very successful, but Im not going to pretend that this didnt require some lucky breaks alongside the hard work. I know that not all people will get that same luck.

Its all too easy for people who have worked hard to convince themselves that their hard work is the only reason that they are successful, which then leads them to believe that anybody who is less successful just doesnt try as hard, but thats not reality. Nobody has ever gotten anywhere without some significant measure of luck.

The thing is, many people work their asses off and never get the breaks, other people have opportunities thrown at them, screw up royally over and over, and because of who they are and who they know... end up doing just fine anyway.

---
Moderated for telling people not to commit illegal acts of assault and murder.09/2/23
Also moderated for not responding to obvious bait. - 10/03/23
... Copied to Clipboard!
Glob
10/29/23 2:32:32 AM
#8:


Torgo posted...
The thing is, many people work their asses off and never get the breaks, other people have opportunities thrown at them, screw up royally over and over, and because of who they are and who they know... end up doing just fine anyway.

I quite agree. Im not claiming that society is meritocratic.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Joelypoely
10/29/23 2:50:41 AM
#9:


Generally I can't really relate to that kind of mentality. Happiness/life satisfaction is such a variable thing dependent on so many factors, and while it can be tied to some objective measures of success, I don't think those measures necessarily define it.

However, I'm a fan of the Sci-fi story By His Bootstraps by Robert Heinlein

---
https://philoetryblog.wordpress.com/
... Copied to Clipboard!
pnut027
10/29/23 2:53:51 AM
#10:


No one got to where they are solely on their own. Everything we do is from the culmination of human knowledge and experience passed down for hundreds of thousands of years.

---
If you're not getting promoted, it's not because you're not good at your job. It's because you're good at ONLY your job.
... Copied to Clipboard!
GrandConjuraton
10/29/23 2:56:42 AM
#11:


No, it's ridiculous.

---
Heavy weight, one more stone...
https://imgur.com/o21DN7r
... Copied to Clipboard!
Naysaspace
10/29/23 3:04:22 AM
#12:


in effect, yes. however i dont agree with what the phrase has come to represent.
basically, i believe in hard work. whatever you do
... Copied to Clipboard!
Notti
10/29/23 3:07:50 AM
#13:


No man is an island.

---
http://m.youtube.com/TheYoungTurks/videos Bernie>Biden>poo>Trump http://RightWingWatch.org http://reddit.com/r/BreadTube http://fb.me/OccupyDemocrats
... Copied to Clipboard!
MistyKnight
10/29/23 12:04:22 PM
#14:


It's survivor bias and it's disgusting

---
friend find, look behind
... Copied to Clipboard!
tankboy
10/29/23 12:08:06 PM
#15:


The term was originally (back in Horatio Alger times) intended to mock was what considered the obvious fantasy of being self-made. Over time, the rich started using it seriously and the origins were forgotten.
... Copied to Clipboard!
faizan_faizan
10/29/23 12:09:58 PM
#16:


I don't follow that specifically but I believe in not worrying about things out of my control or inevitable things that there's literally nothing I can do about. You do what you can to improve your circumstances in every situation but at some point you will have to accept that it's useless to spend any amount of brain energy on things out of your control.

---
Allergic to bull****.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Lil_Bit83
10/29/23 12:30:13 PM
#17:


It's not a bad mentality to have at all. Some people may have better chances for opportunities afforded to them. Or they're so stubborn and practical they won't give up on their dreams no matter what, and will work all the way to the top.

Unfortunately due to a wide variety of circumstances, not everyone can do it. And some people are eventually crushed by bad events and/or constant failures so they stop believing in themselves and their dreams.

---
I'm just a girl who loves games
... Copied to Clipboard!
supercrono
10/29/23 12:38:49 PM
#18:


I have a "make good smart as possible decisions" mentality which often leads to bootstraps, but not exclusively.

---
Kids in the back seat cause accidents, accidents in the back seat cause kids.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Glob
10/29/23 6:36:37 PM
#19:


Lil_Bit83 posted...
It's not a bad mentality to have at all. Some people may have better chances for opportunities afforded to them. Or they're so stubborn and practical they won't give up on their dreams no matter what, and will work all the way to the top.

Unfortunately due to a wide variety of circumstances, not everyone can do it. And some people are eventually crushed by bad events and/or constant failures so they stop believing in themselves and their dreams.

It may not be a bad mentality to apply to yourself if it motivates you to do well, but its a pretty poor mentality to use to judge others.
... Copied to Clipboard!
BloodMoon7
10/29/23 6:39:57 PM
#20:


1. No
2. Yes. Yes.
3. No. No.

---
My maid will hear about this.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Southernfatman
10/29/23 6:43:02 PM
#21:


I'm not a horrible person brainwashed by propaganda from the rich, so no. It's just stupid justification of the rotten status quo from conservatives. They think if someone is struggling, it's not because of income inequality, price gouging by the rich, the lack of a good social safety net, and other things that keep the non-rich down, but it's only because those struggling are just lazy.

Also, a lot of people with that mentality come from privilege or defend those with privilege like Musk, Trump, Gates, Bezos, etc.

---
http://i.imgur.com/hslUvRN.jpg
When I sin I sin real good.
... Copied to Clipboard!
KnightofShikari
10/29/23 6:46:27 PM
#22:


"have you tried just not being poor?"

---
The Earth is round. Two plus two equals four. Joe Biden and Kamala Harris won the 2020 election for President and Vice President of the United States
... Copied to Clipboard!
Prismsblade
10/29/23 6:51:48 PM
#23:


Yes, yes, and yes.

Though while I get much of the advice can rub people the wrong way many still came from the same place they did and have genuinely good advice to give.

What I hate more than anything though are users who ask for help only to dismiss it all and make up excuses why it wont help. Idk why they even asked if their such experts on the matter.

---
3DS FC:3368-5403-9633 Name: Kaizer
PSN: Blackkaizer
... Copied to Clipboard!
#24
Post #24 was unavailable or deleted.
Notti
11/01/23 3:13:54 AM
#25:


Prismsblade posted...
What I hate more than anything though are users who ask for help only to dismiss it all and make up excuses why it wont help. Idk why they even asked if their such experts on the matter.


What makes you think your advice is so good that people just have to do what you say?

Yes. People can ask for advice, consider it, and dismiss it. Often because your advice was already tried or has obvious flaws.

---
http://m.youtube.com/TheYoungTurks/videos Bernie>Biden>poo>Trump http://RightWingWatch.org http://reddit.com/r/BreadTube http://fb.me/OccupyDemocrats
... Copied to Clipboard!
Guide
11/01/23 3:23:16 AM
#26:


Schwarzenegger has gone on the record against the very concept of the self-made man.

The closest I'll come to this is that you should always be trying, even if it's trying just to try. But that's never any sort of guarantee, not even close.

---
evening main 2.4356848e+91
https://youtu.be/Acn5IptKWQU
... Copied to Clipboard!
MICHALECOLE
11/01/23 3:43:28 AM
#27:


Notti posted...
No man is an island.
Except island reinhold
... Copied to Clipboard!
Glob
11/01/23 3:44:58 AM
#28:


Notti posted...
Prismsblade posted...

What makes you think your advice is so good that people just have to do what you say?

Yes. People can ask for advice, consider it, and dismiss it. Often because your advice was already tried or has obvious flaws.

This is sometimes true. Its also true that some people dont actually want help and just want people to validate their failures for them and tell them that nothing is their fault, regardless of the truth of it. Im honestly not sure which is more common.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Patchwork
11/01/23 6:04:04 AM
#29:


I believe that betting on yourself is the only real solution to success, but I dont believe you can just miraculously overcome certain overwhelming circumstances because you want it badly enough.

So, no, I guess?

---
The mind is its own place, and in itself
Can make a heav'n of hell, a hell of heav'n.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zwijn
11/01/23 6:16:34 AM
#30:


ai123 posted...
I am very satisfied with life, but I recognize that this is in large part due to fortunate circumstances and the support I have received.

I wouldn't dream of using the bootstraps line on anyone.

... Copied to Clipboard!
GuerrillaSoldier
11/01/23 6:21:19 AM
#31:


i don't believe in wearing boots


---
Disclaimer: There's a good chance the above post could be sarcasm.
Die-hard Oakland A's fan --- Keep the A's in Oakland!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Jiek_Fafn
11/01/23 7:30:19 AM
#32:


My life makes absolutely no sense in the amount of lucky breaks ive gotten. It's to the point where many other people have accused me of being the main character. While I've earned a lot on my own merit, a ton of shit has been literally handed to me by happenstance. That doesn't happen for most people.

---
I don't believe in belts. There should be no ranking system for toughness.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Avirosb
11/01/23 7:34:47 AM
#33:


Only psychologically.

Materialistically one is always dependent on others finding value in one's time, skill or product.

---
Really attractive in 144p
... Copied to Clipboard!
ExtremeLuchador
11/01/23 8:16:47 AM
#34:


Reddit is supposedly full of undersea skyscraper electric plumber welders who make over $100,000. Yet they still have time to farm 500,000 comment karma making posts that lack empathy and trash you for asking for advice. My oldest account there is from 2011 and doesn't even have 2,000 comments.

---
"It was horrible," guard Jeff McInnis said.
"I took 100 naps and we were still in the air."
... Copied to Clipboard!
VeggetaX
11/01/23 8:21:12 AM
#35:


ExtremeLuchador posted...
Reddit is supposedly full of undersea skyscraper electric plumber welders who make over $100,000. Yet they still have time to farm 500,000 comment karma making posts that lack empathy and trash you for asking for advice. My oldest account there is from 2011 and doesn't even have 2,000 comments.
Reddit is full of larpers. Escapism to the extreme.

---
Don't like it? Don't watch it. It's that simple
Dictator of Nice Guys
... Copied to Clipboard!
Avirosb
11/01/23 8:22:23 AM
#36:


"Influencer" only getting 500.000 impressions or whatever it's called:
"What thee fakk is with this woke algorithm?!"

Me getting a notification on GF:
"Oh crap what did I do this time"

---
Really attractive in 144p
... Copied to Clipboard!
UnsteadyOwl
11/01/23 8:29:17 AM
#37:


Your own personal choices matter, and nobody succeeds completely on their own. I have a good career. I would have never gotten there if I didn't work my ass off to do it. I also would have never gotten there if it wasn't for the support of others - individuals in my life and resources that society made available to me. Both of those things can be and are true.

So, yes, you need to be willing to do the work to succeed. But that isn't a reason not to recognize that achieving success is much, much harder for some people than it is for others due to circumstances that are completely out of their control. And that we can and should be doing much better as a society to give everyone a good shot a making a decent life for themselves.

---
"It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose. That is not a weakness. That is life."
... Copied to Clipboard!
Glob
11/01/23 8:30:22 AM
#38:


UnsteadyOwl posted...
Your own personal choices matter, and nobody succeeds completely on their own. I have a good career. I would have never gotten there if I didn't work my ass off to do it. I also would have never gotten there if it wasn't for the support of others - individuals in my life and resources that society made available to me. Both of those things can be and are true.

So, yes, you need to be willing to do the work to succeed. But that isn't a reason not to recognize that achieving success is much, much harder for some people than it is for others due to circumstances that are completely out of their control. And that we can and should be doing much better as a society to give everyone a good shot a making a decent life for themselves.

Well said.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Intro2Logic
11/01/23 8:30:47 AM
#39:


No I'm normal

---
Have you tried thinking rationally?
... Copied to Clipboard!
Cemith
11/01/23 8:30:48 AM
#40:


While I think there's a very staunch difference in success that is proportional to how much effort you put in, the amount of success you can ultimately glean comes down to a number of factors.

A not insignificant factor being luck.

---
https://i.ibb.co/2vRbyC0/Rosa-6.png
"Friends don't let friends watch The Big Bang Theory" - mogar002
... Copied to Clipboard!
God_of_6strings
11/01/23 8:42:51 AM
#41:


I DON'T believe in the victim mentality, I'll tell you that much.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Prismsblade
11/01/23 9:28:08 AM
#42:


Notti posted...
Prismsblade posted...

What makes you think your advice is so good that people just have to do what you say?

Yes. People can ask for advice, consider it, and dismiss it. Often because your advice was already tried or has obvious flaws.
I personally dont believe thats the case often.

Some people are just defeatist types whove given up. Which is sad, but whatever. Though I sont appreciate them wasting others times though as if they havent.

fortunately they arent hard to identify and call out usually.

---
3DS FC:3368-5403-9633 Name: Kaizer
PSN: Blackkaizer
... Copied to Clipboard!
ArchNemo
11/01/23 9:35:21 AM
#43:


I believe there's no one size fits all solution to problems like this. There are plenty of people who will get "just suck it up" advice and thrive on it. Many won't and will require help. The problem is thinking your advice fits anyone other than you and giving it out as more than a "Here's what works for me and maybe it'll work for you as well"

---
Down with the Signess.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Avirosb
11/01/23 9:37:21 AM
#44:


Prismsblade posted...
Some people are just defeatist types whove given up. Which is sad, but whatever. Though I sont appreciate them wasting others times though as if they havent.

Wasting how?

---
Really attractive in 144p
... Copied to Clipboard!
Southernfatman
11/01/23 9:39:05 AM
#45:


ExtremeLuchador posted...
Reddit is supposedly full of undersea skyscraper electric plumber welders who make over $100,000. Yet they still have time to farm 500,000 comment karma making posts that lack empathy and trash you for asking for advice. My oldest account there is from 2011 and doesn't even have 2,000 comments.

Same for all the doctors and lawyers who spend tons of time on the internet, especially here on Gamefaqs. Man, I always though folks like that were always busy. Wild.

---
http://i.imgur.com/hslUvRN.jpg
When I sin I sin real good.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Avirosb
11/01/23 9:40:38 AM
#46:


Southernfatman posted...
Same for all the doctors and lawyers who spend tons of time on the internet, especially here on Gamefaqs. Man, I always though folks like that were always busy. Wild.
They should have just become engineers. They seem to know everything.

---
Really attractive in 144p
... Copied to Clipboard!
TyVulpine
11/01/23 9:46:46 AM
#47:


That saying is just an excuse by the Bible-thumping right to avoid actually helping others.

---
Insert some witty line here
... Copied to Clipboard!
UnsteadyOwl
11/01/23 9:47:58 AM
#48:


I'll say that at least for me random people on message boards were not helpful to me in getting my life together. Even advice from friends and family didn't help that much. They meant well and their moral support was great, but in terms of specific actionable advice they really couldn't help.

What helped me was seeking out experts in the fields were I needed help. I went to a therapist to work out my personal issues, to a career coach to figure out a career plan, and talked to people in the field I wanted to go into about what they did. Talking with those people helped me immensely.

edit: I guess what I want to say from this is if you're going to message boards and really want to help people do better in their lives, unless you are a professional in a particular area it's probably better for advice to be less "Here's what you should do" and more "Here's where you can find the resources that will help you".

---
"It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose. That is not a weakness. That is life."
... Copied to Clipboard!
Notti
11/04/23 6:28:10 AM
#49:


Prismsblade posted...
I personally dont believe thats the case often.

Some people are just defeatist types whove given up. Which is sad, but whatever. Though I sont appreciate them wasting others times though as if they havent.

fortunately they arent hard to identify and call out usually.

I dont see the problem really.

People ask for suggestions, not ask for commands.

How is this really even wasting ones time regardless? We can talk about the weather instead. Just as much a waste of time.

I think even if people are just frustrated and want to talk about their life, ask advice, and NOT follow advice as if it's some command, what's the problem?

Seems more it's the advice giver feeling insulted like their genius advice was not immediately acted upon.

---
http://m.youtube.com/TheYoungTurks/videos Bernie>Biden>poo>Trump http://RightWingWatch.org http://reddit.com/r/BreadTube http://fb.me/OccupyDemocrats
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sufferedphoneix
11/05/23 12:40:31 AM
#50:


I believe in actually trying to get ahead in life on your own work I'm merits. But no shame in asking for help when needed.

I work night shift and it makes some things difficult so I've asked for help plenty on that.

---
I put my heart and soul into my work and I fear I have lost my mind in the process
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2