Board 8 > Paper Mario Mafia Topic 6 - PS Time to Recycle Paper Mario Jokes

(+) Yeah! (+)

I think Sultan left.

Cody11533 posted...

Also I think I may have been the first person to float the idea of activate star powers being a thing, I know I definitely suggested it.

You were. I didnt even think about it at all until you theorized that maybe Eldstar could have healed the poison. So that's another thing Kirby made up that i started this

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Got to leave in like 5 minutes not a great time to be the lynch candidate. I can claim now if you guys want

This was almost 30 minutes ago I think he is gone past the deadline.

PunishedBen posted...

so then I'll go to my follow-up question, of why not JC?

Because Ctes is a better target, I guess? Idk, this wasn't the original argument I was trying to make.

My point was that it was convenient that the person you scanned was also the person you were pitted against. You have to realize that looks uncanny to me. It could be a complete coincidence, but to me, it looked like you were faking it since it was so convenient.

Kirby321 posted...

My point was that it was convenient that the person you scanned was also the person you were pitted against. You have to realize that looks uncanny to me. It could be a complete coincidence, but to me, it looked like you were faking it since it was so convenient.

Were JC and Ben against each other on Day 1?

Well I refuse to lynch Sultan without his claim.

Do you guys want me to claim instead?

We are missing the people I want to talk to at deadline and I don't like it.

Kirby321 posted...

Well I refuse to lynch Sultan without his claim.

Do you guys want me to claim instead?

This is a weird juxtaposition

Cody11533 posted...

Were JC and Ben against each other on Day 1?

From what I quickly skimmed, they had a few interactions. It was mostly Ben being inquisitive toward JC rather than the other way around. But don't quote me on that since I'm going completely off of memory.

Kirby321 posted...

Because Ctes is a better target, I guess? Idk, this wasn't the original argument I was trying to make.

My point was that it was convenient that the person you scanned was also the person you were pitted against. You have to realize that looks uncanny to me. It could be a complete coincidence, but to me, it looked like you were faking it since it was so convenient.

It was coincidence, but if my goal was to get JC lynched I'd need more than "JC is not a Star Spirit"

I said I need to see more of Ben D1 and we sure got more

PunishedBen posted...

It was coincidence, but if my goal was to get JC lynched I'd need more than "JC is not a Star Spirit"

No, that's completely beside the point.

It looks fishy because it's an easy clear for yourself. If JC claimed first, you could just adjust your scan based on whatever he claimed his flavor to be.

I dont see the case on Plum

I didn't really remember anything JC did day 1, which is why I scanned him.

This is certainly one of the worst Day 2's in a while...

Ulti do you feel Plum is a better option than anyone else currently with a vote?

UltimaterializerX posted...

##Unvote
##Vote: Plum

This feels right. Sorry man but whenever youre being lazy it trips all my red flags on you. And trying to lynch Sultan after tunneling him all day is pretty lazy. Not to mention everything else I pulled up earlier in the day.

Not sure what you are wanting from me. Sultan was solidly off D1. This isn't town Sultan. Town Sultan has been on fire and this Sultan has basically said he has no reads

Unofficial Votals:

Kirby [3] - Dumey, Ben, Sultan
Sultan [3] (Plum), (Ulti), (Ulti), Plum, Hb, Peaf
Han [1] - JC, (Ulti)
JC [1] (Han), (Peaf), ctes
Hb [1] - Death, (Sultan)
Plum [1] - Ulti
Ben [0] - (Sultan), (Kirby), (Plum), (Ulti), (Dumey)
Ulti [0] - (Sultan)
Dumey [1] - (Ulti), Han
Death [0] - (Peaf), (Dumey)

UltimaterializerX posted...

Specifically, I dont think the unvote yesterday cleared you at all and I would expect a lot more in true effort department after deciding a lynch. Its like you did that, saw you werent a huge suspect today, then didnt bother doing much.

I really do think youre scum and knew that was town/town on day 1.

Why the hell would I save potential town power and confirm town as scum. That makes no sense.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Im having the same problem this game as last one. I think most people in the game look town. No one else has the balls to lynch Han (he did flip doctor last time we killed him without a scan, I get it), so Im happy with Plum instead. Thats at least a better option than Kirby or Sultan, I mean come on here.

Sell me on Han. I asked earlier about his opening post and nobody responded

I think

Votals:

Sultan [3] (Plum), (Ulti), (Ulti), Plum, Hb, Peaf
Kirby [3] - Dumey, Ben, Sultan
Han [1] - JC, (Ulti)
JC [1] (Han), (Peaf), ctes
Hb [1] - Death, (Sultan)
Plum [1] - Ulti
Dumey [1] - (Ulti), Han
Ben [0] - (Sultan), (Kirby), (Plum), (Ulti), (Dumey)
Ulti [0] - (Sultan)
Death [0] - (Peaf), (Dumey)

I mean, I don't like the Sultan lynch, either. I also don't like my vote being wasted.

##Vote: Dumey

##vote: Sultan

Unless people want to special ctes.

Kirby321 posted...

I mean, I don't like the Sultan lynch, either. I also don't like my vote being wasted.

##Vote: Dumey

Yeah I like this vote coming from a town Kirby. Not a fan of this kirby lynch either

In the Ben/Kirby debate, I lean towards Ben, but still don't feel comfortable lynching Kirby here myself.

Hmmm I dont like this Sultan train at all

I have good reads on most everyone voting for Sultan, but I don't have a strong feeling about Sultan myself otherwise I would have voted him already.

Chaeix posted...

Hmmm I dont like this Sultan train at all

The list of people on it makes it way preferable to kirby.

Chaeix posted...

Hmmm I dont like this Sultan train at all

Who on it do you not like?

I'm honestly uncomfortable here. I think Sultan may be town, but the way he floundered there at the end makes me doubt my Kirby lynch. I'm honestly considering the special route.

Yeah the Kirby train is the one I am raising eyebrows about

I think this is a town Kirby too. I'm not interested in a ctes special even though Sultan is unclaimed.

Hbthebattle posted...

Who on it do you not like?

I am increasingly iffy on you and plum in part because I think he is obvtown

Votals:

Sultan [4] (Plum), (Ulti), (Ulti), Plum, Hb, Peaf, red
Kirby [3] - Dumey, Ben, Sultan
Dumey [2] - (Ulti), Han, Kirby
Han [1] - JC, (Ulti)
JC [1] (Han), (Peaf), ctes
Hb [1] - Death, (Sultan)
Plum [1] - Ulti
Ben [0] - (Sultan), (Kirby), (Plum), (Ulti), (Dumey)
Ulti [0] - (Sultan)
Death [0] - (Peaf), (Dumey)

Did Han state he wouldn't be around?

Did Han announce he would be missing deadline? Or just 'got busy'?

UltimaterializerX posted...

Inconsistent arguments and making excuses not to be here.

Started the day calling Justin scum. Now Justin is town. Accused me of ignoring him and not listening to him and said its weird I trust him, then I vote him and he insults me before going afk. He was all over both Peaf and Isquen yesterday. His vote is currently on Dumey because enough people think Dumey is scum, which does not line up with Hans town game.

Han is arguably the best town player other than Chris or My Immortal weve ever had. That logic to vote for someone is weak, because Han doesnt need the approval of others to vote for people. He does detective work, leads, and finds scum by himself.

Most importantly, he was 1 off the lynch lead and no one voted for him. Today reeks of please town just hang yourself.

hmm hmm hmm

I am torn here. I think you are right but I got screwed over not being confidant enough being right last game

Tie Han with someone else? Idk

Gah, fuck me. This may be a useless vote for Ctes, but I think it comfortably takes Kirby out of contention.

##Unvote:
##Vote: Ctes

Plum, I explained the opening post thing

Also, don't really trust Ulti when last time he did this
, I was Doctor. It's very not town Ulti

And yes I'm busy. At dinner.with gf

UltimaterializerX posted...

That man could be in the Ohio train wreckage with no internet and still not miss the lynch as town.

This is explicitly false. Dont lie to try to lynch .me

We are not doing any crazy tying shenanigans with only two minutes left on the clock.