Board 8 > Star Wars and Pokemon Mafia Topic 3 - Revenge of the Scum

(+) Yeah! (+)

Sheep007 posted...

There were two millers two games ago!

Oh damn...
Well to be fair one was a Miller Tracker

UltimaterializerX posted...

Hes probably scum anyway.

Don't make me die of a broken heart.

For the record I just think Ben and sheep are scum/scum based on sheep's response to my posts about Ben so I wanted to put the screws to him too.

But fine sure counter claim works too

##unvote: sheep
##vote: ben

I am tired and reversed that

##unvote:Ben
##vote: sheep

I dont even know if scumCorrik would claim a safelist flavor so early

Two trackers.

let's just gladiate them....

are we at risk of a hammer?

consider my vote on sheep. scum doesn't counter and go one for one.

I'm all for sheep considering the dual tracker claim, that got spicy quickly

Two trackers. You don't touch power claims day 1. Especially when so many unclaimed are on the board. 21 people. Two tracker is fine. Scum wouldn't have fake claimed it because counter risk is astronomical.

Both are town. Carry on.

Sheep isn't stupid.

Just think of what silly things we could have made scum Ben do in two hours.

<B>##Vote: Sheep</B>

fairly sure we're nowhere near hammer sbell

Obellisk posted...

Two trackers.

let's just gladiate them....

Sadly, I can't do that. Lopen was obviously lying

Corrik7 posted...

Two trackers. You don't touch power claims day 1. Especially when so many unclaimed are on the board. 21 people. Two tracker is fine. Scum wouldn't have fake claimed it because counter risk is astronomical.

Both are town. Carry on.

Sheep isn't stupid.

Sheep realized he played like shit and his only play was to get tracker to counter claim him.

I do wish HB had given a little more time just to see who would buy the sheep tracker claim willingly and who didnt believe it.

Though yes I went too easy on it too I know

lmao

##vote: sheep

you may also consider my vote on sheep for now

Arti posted...

Sadly, I can't do that. Lopen was obviously lying

When did you realize he made that claim?

I can't be sure Ben is scum. I was 100% sure Sheep was after that. I decided to go for the ultimately safer play.

I think it is a bit nuanced tbh. Not lynching power day one is fair and also seeing the claim was bad is also fair. I am not going to be reading too broadly into the reactions but rather stick with what we know. If you look back at how sheep answered my questions about Ben oh boy. Also how he hopped the hell off of plum when I came after him.

Hbthebattle posted...

I can't be sure Ben is scum. I was 100% sure Sheep was after that. I decided to go for the ultimately safer play.

You are fine tbh. Scum got what they wanted but we have plenty of power

Yeah I am glad I saved my Sheep ISO up until now

htaeD posted...

When did you realize he made that claim?

You and others were talking about it in the previous topic!

Ben never answered my question: https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80023425/965101542

So I'm tempted to vote him. But... yeah if there's only one Tracker in the game, I would believe HB over Sheep.
... But at the same time, I could see two Trackers in a game this large being a thing.

Bleh, I'm a little uneasy about this, but I think we get more information out of Sheep's lynch than Ben's. So I'm keeping my vote on Sheep, even if it means possibly killing a Town Tracker.

Also can we get some praying emojis that sheep is mafia strongman/assassin?

Management left, freedom! Gonna catch up a bit more

I could buy multiple trackers, though. Didn't FFXIV have multiple, despute being smaller, or am I confusing that with motion detector? Are they the same?

I think that sheep is actually a Wooloo and a member of the League of Villainous Pokemon aka the Dark Side

Did I... nail scum d1 two games in a row?

I don't know what to do with this power

Mafia is fun when I try my best. Great job everyone. I am proud of you. Keep the claims low, carefully examine interactions, use powers on newer players as scum usually doesn't kill them. Keys to success if I die tonight. Just be chill.

Oh. Alright then Sheep is scum. That's not good for my optics

masterplum posted...

Did I... nail scum d1 two games in a row?

I don't know what to do with this power

think you're missing in a game in between there, buddy

masterplum posted...

Did I... nail scum d1 two games in a row?

I don't know what to do with this power

pssst, you were scum last game.

masterplum posted...

Did I... nail scum d1 two games in a row?

I don't know what to do with this power

There is a reason I left you in charge. I told you that you were underrated.

changmas posted...

think you're missing in a game in between there, buddy

If we are counting that, then 3 games in a row! I was hard on Lopen!

masterplum posted...

Did I... nail scum d1 two games in a row?

I don't know what to do with this power

Well I would hope you could find the scum in the last game!

Hold up with a game this size is having 2 trackers really that unreasonable?

Damnit, so late to joke about Plum

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Hold up with a game this size is having 2 trackers really that unreasonable?

No. But on top of the unlikely hood sheep's behavior really makes it a no doubter

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Hold up with a game this size is having 2 trackers really that unreasonable?

Its unreasonable for a lot of games really

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Hold up with a game this size is having 2 trackers really that unreasonable?

no, in fact, this is a Han game. and I wouldn't be surprised by two trackers at all.

especially after Hans backup claim as scum last game... Hans just here for the lulz.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

No. But on top of the unlikely hood sheep's behavior really makes it a no doubter

Hmm alright on Face value i didnt see much on sheep at first glance that made me think he was much different for the day he was alive last game. What are some keys to look for on the reread Sheep iso?

##Vote: Ben

I'm leaning towards not lynching power with the thinking that anything that anything that could fake a tracker (going on Scare's post) wouldn't be the worst thing keeping around when we don't know what Ben is.

However, that could change if Chris explains/points me in the right direction on where Sheep backs off of plum. There are two full topics, and not sure when or where it happened right now.

Also, if Sheep flips scum I will give my most heartfelt apology to Plum.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Hmm alright on Face value i didnt see much on sheep at first glance that made me think he was much different for the day he was alive last game. What are some keys to look for on the reread Sheep iso?

His plum vote was an alarm bell for me. He was very quick to jump on plum and not consider what I had at all that plumes view on Kirby could change from scum to town perspective and that's why he feared Kirby walls before. A rush to judgment. Also read how he talked about Ben when I asked. Very evasive. I called it measured at the time.

Kirby321 posted...

Ben never answered my question: https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80023425/965101542

So I'm tempted to vote him. But... yeah if there's only one Tracker in the game, I would believe HB over Sheep.
... But at the same time, I could see two Trackers in a game this large being a thing.

Bleh, I'm a little uneasy about this, but I think we get more information out of Sheep's lynch than Ben's. So I'm keeping my vote on Sheep, even if it means possibly killing a Town Tracker.

Scroll back like one page from that question. I didn't answer because it's right there. It was in the post where he first voted me I think

Kirby certainly looks a lot cooler now

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Hold up with a game this size is having 2 trackers really that unreasonable?

It's not impossible but the circumstances around sheep were already extremely suspicious

If this were a mass claim and two random players I had no opinion of both claimed tracker I would possibly consider it, but its not like sheep is a random player here.

htaeD posted...

Its unreasonable for a lot of games really

I mean not really tracker is both useful to find scum but also a way to out town power as well. And a game this size i imagine alot of people moving around