Board 8 > Elden Ring Mafia Topic 9: Lake of Rot

(+) Yeah! (+)

Also red kind of flubbed his answer to me today. He said he trusts people who go after him but I did last game and he called me scum for it lol

Corrik7 posted...

For red, him being scum is possible simply for the fact he knew if he had at multiple use poisoner that there had to be a way to cure it or it was broken.

Now, in counter, they shot blindly into unclaimed which was dangerous there with that strategy employed which is a point in his favor.

Marth was painfully obvious and this is actually a point AGAINST Red, not for him.

I will say one thing has bugged me and it's how little Red offered day 2.

Marth was not painfully obvious that he was specifically a poison doctor, though. I think for that to have happened, Marth would need to have been scanned.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

So Ben or sheep today. Except no substitutes.

I think we are pretty far ahead. And I am confident enough on Sheep to vote for sheep today.

The other option is to confirm Crescent just because we are so far ahead, but my read of the game doesn't really make me feel it Iis necessary.

I doubt Crescent would play ball with Ulti as his scum partner, and the only way I think it possible is with stuff we were told not to discuss anymore day 1 to really provide the deception over the curtain. So, I'll toss that out as an option.

Yeah Crescent really doesn't need to be tested though you are right in a power gaming only setting testing her is valid

But... no way lol

Sheep007 posted...

Marth was not painfully obvious that he was specifically a poison doctor, though. I think for that to have happened, Marth would need to have been scanned.

I had a hard read that Marth was protection and if town had any role that reversed poison, it was him.

My punk ass didn't even think poison doctor was a thing lol

Crescent-Moon posted...

I will say one thing has bugged me and it's how little Red offered day 2.

I think Red is begging me to claim because he thinks he has a counter claim on me. He doesn't though. The fact there is no cop and no godfather also means he probably lied about being Miller, especially with no flavor attached. But, it doesn't make him scum. That should spell out what I think he is to you.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

My punk ass didn't even think poison doctor was a thing lol

I thought he was either doctor that could cure poison or poison doctor specifically. I wasn't sure which.

I don't think lynching Crescent is necessary either tbh. Her confidence in her own game in these recent posts gives me assurance she's just town anyway.

PunishedBen posted...

I don't think lynching Crescent is necessary either tbh. Her confidence in her own game in these recent posts gives me assurance she's just town anyway.

I think Supreme confidence is more a tell of her scum game than town, but I haven't played with her in a long time so that may have evolved.

Corrik7 posted...

think Red is begging me to claim because he thinks he has a counter claim on me. He doesn't though. The fact there is no cop and no godfather also means he probably lied about being Miller, especially with no flavor attached. But, it doesn't make him scum. That should spell out what I think he is to you.

Corrik what are you even...that would be suicide at this point in the game.

But also this is why I hesitated when Marth poked me late day 2 about what I thought about him.

I didn't want to suggest to anyone what I actually thought.

hi red

day 3, 3 scum dead

flavor

I also agree that Crescent is just town.

##Unvote

Corrik, please can we get your role? I genuinely do think that would help us solve the game, because if I am excluding you that sticks me with a Ben/IGCD choice today. Which would, for obvious reasons, be made much easier with that claim.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Also red kind of flubbed his answer to me today. He said he trusts people who go after him but I did last game and he called me scum for it lol

You dont apply in that space.

Corrik7 posted...

I think Supreme confidence is more a tell of her scum game than town, but I haven't played with her in a long time so that may have evolved.

Maybe only after she pulls it off, but if she was scum this would not be a game in which she pulled anything off or had a chance to make it to the end

Her claim day 1 would not have been made with the endgame goal of living till the end as the last scum

Corrik7 posted...

I think Supreme confidence is more a tell of her scum game than town, but I haven't played with her in a long time so that may have evolved.

My confidence level is generally not alignment indicative. Too many things factor into it.

..Though I would say I'm definitely projecting more confidence than the game I was just scum and received 0 votes all game in.

crescent hasnt been that confident this game btw. She says things to appear more right than she sometimes is, which is a sign of someone with anxiety who wants badly to be seen as being good.

its a psychological thing and imo for sure a town thing.

Leafeon13N posted...

Corrik what are you even...that would be suicide at this point in the game.

Nah. Let's be honest. Do we really think town only had an ability to cure extra kills that happened every other night, a bodyguard, and a supposed 1 shot BP?

Full disclosure, I believe you are doctor or even jail keeper (who saved Sultan last night?) or a Town roleblocker. And you are trying to look for a way to go aha! Corrik can't fit.

I get it as town. Completely. I also don't believe my claim matters to it regardless knowing that already.

Bodyguard doesn't save a kill. A 1 shot BP if Isquen is to be believed is hardly mattering, especially if he can be poisoned through it.

No scanning. Limited protection. It makes sense why Ulti was Vanilla now. But, Town has to have something to stop a night kill regular.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

crescent hasnt been that confident this game btw. She says things to appear more right than she sometimes is, which is a sign of someone with anxiety who wants badly to be seen as being good.

its a psychological thing and imo for sure a town thing.

I did just say "projecting"~

I really don't want it to be IGCD because I still want that day 1 town reads post I made to be correct in the end, but does anyone remember when IGCD claimed, and did he have ANY reason to claim the info when he did?

PunishedBen posted...

I really don't want it to be IGCD because I still want that day 1 town reads post I made to be correct in the end, but does anyone remember when IGCD claimed, and did he have ANY reason to claim the info when he did?

He claimed after I replaced in and voted him

Corrik7 posted...

Nah. Let's be honest. Do we really think town only had an ability to cure extra kills that happened every other night, a bodyguard, and a supposed 1 shot BP?

Full disclosure, I believe you are doctor or even jail keeper (who saved Sultan last night?) or a Town roleblocker. And you are trying to look for a way to go aha! Corrik can't fit.

I get it as town. Completely. I also don't believe my claim matters to it regardless knowing that already.

Bodyguard doesn't save a kill. A 1 shot BP if Isquen is to be believed is hardly mattering, especially if he can be poisoned through it.

No scanning. Limited protection. It makes sense why Ulti was Vanilla now. But, Town has to have something to stop a night kill regular.

I've actually had a bit of a power suspicion on Red for, well, most of the game.

PunishedBen posted...

I really don't want it to be IGCD because I still want that day 1 town reads post I made to be correct in the end, but does anyone remember when IGCD claimed, and did he have ANY reason to claim the info when he did?

If IGCD is scum, he is claiming not to move as last scum, he is literally guessing to how many actions every night which could kill him outright when he basically has to be a scum power of some note. I mean, he basically would have to be his claimed power as scum, but this being his power as scum honestly doesn't fit the game I see in front of me.

red if I target you and you move it will be too late to claim not miller btw

New topic

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/79962382

Did he ever explain the flavor reason for why space deer is an observer. Because it's just a random boss in the game and I'd be surprised if Plum knew anything about the lore of the bosses if he revealed in a scum role that he thinks the game has no story