Board 8 > Elden Ring Mafia Topic 7: Consecratered Snowfield

(+) Yeah! (+)

No, it's end of day if I participated in the scum lynching.

Chris has the soul read rights on red. If you think Chris is town, you have to accept red is town too

Further breakdown: I got a really bad feeling about lynching Ben and followed you onto Scare, ninjaing Chris's vote onto Scare by moments.

Chang saw the three of us there, thought the train was very strong, and joined.

Marth and Ben both commented, but hesitated. Neither of them joined for a fair amount after.

IGCD kind of just came in and voted him.

Which reminds me, when IGCD voted for Ben, I asked him why, but I don't think I ever got a direct answer and I don't remember if he's given one since.

So I'll ask again, why the Ben vote?

That means you should be ending the day on whoever gets lynched for the benefit of town and yourself

Crescent-Moon posted...

Further breakdown: I got a really bad feeling about lynching Ben and followed you onto Scare, ninjaing Chris's vote onto Scare by moments.

Chang saw the three of us there, thought the train was very strong, and joined.

Marth and Ben both commented, but hesitated. Neither of them joined for a fair amount after.

IGCD kind of just came in and voted him.

Which reminds me, when IGCD voted for Ben, I asked him why, but I don't think I ever got a direct answer and I don't remember if he's given one since.

So I'll ask again, why the Ben vote?

I did answer but ill answer again. Day 1 sheep Chris. That's been my play style for awhile now.

PunishedBen posted...

I'm sure I can get better things if more people rate the message. Or at least the ability to select my target myself.

Isquen I don't think never gave a clear answer as to how he gets powered up and it's bothering me. You would think it's end the day on a scum list. But his own comments contradict that

I've actually been wondering something for a while

He claimed a power, but did he ever actually.. Claim the role itself?

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I did answer but ill answer again. Day 1 sheep Chris. That's been my play style for awhile now.

Oh wait you did answer that today.

PunishedBen posted...

Chris has the soul read rights on red. If you think Chris is town, you have to accept red is town too

Chris is not the only one who thinks Red is way outside of his scumrange.

Corrik7 posted...

I still believe a scum was on the lookout for indy day 1 so if it is not chang, it has to be Sultan.

Ulti is latching onto who he perceives is the strongest town player to try and get good will from them and keep him alive. He kinda does it as town also though. But, he was openly more assertive this game than past town games.

Sultan could be the third party himself for bringing it up then. If you're confident in that theory.

I don't think he is on a team

But I an the prettiest princess

PunishedBen posted...

That means you should be ending the day on whoever gets lynched for the benefit of town and yourself

Yep. Isquen's claim requires him to be a frontrunner with his votes, which goes against how he's played this game so far.

red was outside of his scumrange the moment he got poisoned?

DoomTheGyarados posted...

But I an the prettiest princess

No, I'm the princess.

An adorable kitten princess.

(Seriously princess is my favorite pet name)

UnderUrMattress posted...

red was outside of his scumrange the moment he got poisoned?

Before

UnderUrMattress posted...

red was outside of his scumrange the moment he got poisoned?

Red was already outside of what I'd expect from him as scum Red who hasn't been scum in years the moment he claimed miller, which is why I spent day 1 with him on my town list nagging him to provide more content that would make me more comfortable keeping him there

Isquen posted...

I like this take/can get behind it, but that's a lot of conditionals.

Too pure to be scum btw

Crescent-Moon posted...

Yep. Isquen's claim requires him to be a frontrunner with his votes, which goes against how he's played this game so far.

And there we go again.

Isquen what is your role name please

Isquen posted...

And there we go again.

..Ben said it first!

so scum has

freezer
poisoner
probably just a vanilla mafia
and maybe a roleblocker or a strongman? possibly a joat

UnderUrMattress posted...

so scum has

freezer
poisoner
probably just a vanilla mafia
and maybe a roleblocker or a strongman? possibly a joat

I said this last game I played: I haven't seen a game without a scum RB in so long I couldn't even name one.

Guessing godfather

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Isquen what is your role name please

I'd rather not say the name of it proper, but it's flavored as Consumable.

To sum this up:

Ben says something bad about Isquen

I echo it and ask for a full claim from Isquen because I've never been sure we actually got one

Isquen attacks me.

Like, I'm not sure what else I can do here?

Isquen posted...

I'd rather not say the name of it proper, but it's flavored as Consumable.

............

Crescent-Moon posted...

I said this last game I played: I haven't seen a game without a scum RB in so long I couldn't even name one.

yeah i could really see a RB of some kind possibly in JOAT form

what about a vanilla mafia though? are plum's maf teams loaded with prs?

or the poison could be from a joat hm

Isquen didn't really attack. Anyway go to your neutral corners neither of you is up for death.

Bed time. Make panth claim. Night.

UnderUrMattress posted...

yeah i could really see a RB of some kind possibly in JOAT form

what about a vanilla mafia though? are plum's maf teams loaded with prs?

I was referring to a full-time RB, not a part-time RB.

As for the second part? Who knows.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Isquen didn't really attack. Anyway go to your neutral corners neither of you is up for death.

Bed time. Make panth claim. Night.

Isquen just flat out refused to claim his role, and you're ok with that?

Just so its not taken the wrong way, my comment was meant to be advice from one town to another. Isquen you SHOULD end the day on the lynch leader going forward.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Isquen what is your role name please

Isquen posted...

I'd rather not say the name of it proper, but it's flavored as Consumable.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Isquen didn't really attack. Anyway go to your neutral corners neither of you is up for death.

Bed time. Make panth claim. Night.

Really, Chris? Since when are you one to ask people to claim, then accept it when they only pretend to?

I could be giving IGCD way too much of a townread but I do think he's just town here.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Isquen just flat out refused to claim his role, and you're ok with that?

My take is that when someone is either town or the worst scum you've ever seen, they're pretty much resolved and not something to worry too hard about ~

PunishedBen posted...

Just so its not taken the wrong way, my comment was meant to be advice from one town to another. Isquen you SHOULD end the day on the lynch leader going forward.

I'm aware, but I still would not have benefited in any way from Scare's lynch. And now someone is trying to get me to react the same way to guide another mislynch.

Does Corrik shield his scum buddies or is he a busser

UnderUrMattress posted...

Does Corrik shield his scum buddies or is he a busser

I would say he leans heavily toward bus on day 1

UnderUrMattress posted...

Does Corrik shield his scum buddies or is he a busser

Corrik does whatever the hell Corrik wants. He will bus his entire team or a whim, or try to keep them all alive.

PunishedBen posted...

My take is that when someone is either town or the worst scum you've ever seen, they're pretty much resolved and not something to worry too hard about ~

Chris asking for a claim, when he has no interest in actually hearing the claim is... A rather significant red flag to me.

Corrik definitely isn't as loud today

But then again if Corrik is scum why would he allow SBell to practically IC Chris when he was trying to sell Chris being scum

PunishedBen posted...

I would say he leans heavily toward bus on day 1

Well his one townread d1 was Sbell so keep that in mind.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Corrik does whatever the hell Corrik wants. He will bus his entire team or a whim, or try to keep them all alive.

Chris asking for a claim, when he has no interest in actually hearing the claim is... A rather significant red flag to me.

I don't think he had much interest and was just trying to appease you

But I do think that MZero spooked the scum team into thinking that he had some form of a guilty on Sbell and someone within [Chris, chang, Panth] got on the early bus. Right now it looks very bad for Panth.

UnderUrMattress posted...

Well his one townread d1 was Sbell so keep that in mind.

With the look of the game right now, Corrik's overall reads day 1 were not good at all.

Unless Chris is scum, Corrik made virtually no attempt to bus at all.

Yeah I've convinced myself that Panth is scum and want them to claim asap pronto.

Crescent-Moon posted...

With the look of the game right now, Corrik's overall reads day 1 were not good at all.

Unless Chris is scum, Corrik made virtually no attempt to bus at all.

He also buddied Panthera

And he discredited both my votes on Panthera and Sbell.

UnderUrMattress posted...

But I do think that MZero spooked the scum team into thinking that he had some form of a guilty on Sbell and someone within [Chris, chang, Panth] got on the early bus. Right now it looks very bad for Panth.

I would agree with this. I believe the scumteam thought it was a scum scan, considering just about everyone seemed to.

Most of the game seemed to assume that he scanned SBell. Maybe SBell didn't even bother claiming because scum thought he was that screwed.

The 4th person on SBell got on quite a bit later than the first 3. I'm looking through trying to figure out who it was.

I think Sbell tried to call MZero's bluff but got slapped with a royal flush

[0]Sbell(DEAD): (Mzero), (chang), (Chris), (Panthera)

Oh.

Panthera was the slightly delayed, 4th vote.

Silly me, I didn't notice that post wasn't including MZero.

UnderUrMattress posted...

I think Sbell tried to call MZero's bluff but got slapped with a royal flush

It was pointed out, and quickly, how MZero did this as a scanner with a damning as all hell scan on Scare on day 3 in FFXIV.

SBell had to have at least suspected.

Well, when I was catching up, I personally thought he was bluffing dayvig but was very pleasantly surprised.