Board 8 > Rank the Captain America movies

(+) Yeah! (+)

Now this one I imagine will have some divergent opinions!

(3 > 2 > 1 imhotbqh)

---

Yeah, 3 > 2 > 1 for me, but 2 and 3 are both so good you can't go wrong switching them.

---

3 > 2 > 1

Buy I really think you could make a case for any of them.

---

The first debatable one. 2 >3 >1 for me

---

3 > 2 > 1

I ranked all of them side by side by side during the b8 MCU ranking. Very similar quality.

---

3 2 1

first pair are legits, I was never big on First Avenger though

---

I think the first Captain America is a little underrated and probably my second favorite of the phase 1 films.

But 2/3 I think are both better. Civil War gets a bit messy, but Winter Soldier is probably one of my top five or so Marvel films so I think 2 3 1 is the way I'd go.

---

Honestly surprised this many have 3 over 2. Civil War is great and all but come on it's Winter Soldier

---

Huh, every vote so far has 2 > 1!

(I do too, but it was a tougher call for me than both over 3!)

---

So far literally every voter has 2 > 1

2 and 3 are outstanding, 1 isn't (but fine)

2 is marginally better
---

This lineup really blows Iron Man and Thor's out of the water. Captain America's worst movie is equal to those groups' best.

---

2>3>1 for me, with a pretty significant margin between each

2 is one of the top MCU movies
1 and 3 both sucks and I have hard time choosing which is worse

---

3 >>>>>>> 2 > 1

KamikazePotato posted...

This lineup really blows Iron Man and Thor's out of the water. Captain America's worst movie is equal to those groups' best.

Iron Man 1 shits all over Captain America 1.

---

Easy 3>2>1, but lets be honest, theyre all great. The first two in the ranking are both still top five MCU films, and 1 is definitely the best phase 1 solo movie.

Captain America 1>>Iron Man 1.

---

KamikazePotato posted...

This lineup really blows Iron Man and Thor's out of the water. Captain America's worst movie is equal to those groups' best.

Nah, Ragnarok is better than First Avenger.

---

2 > 3 > 1 pretty easily

---

1>2>3

They were all equal in my opinion(great).

---

I went 2 > 3 >1. Civil War is fun and flawed, so WS is better. Both are great.

---

First Avenger is one of my favorites and damn near perfect for a WW2 Cap movie. I never thought we'd get one (I always figured if they did a Cap movie they would skip that and just go with the Man out of Time aspect) so I probably overrate it but fuck it I love it.

---

2 > 3 > 1

I enjoy all three, but Winter Soldier is on another level. I could easily watch it daily.
---

Town between 2 > 3 > 1 and 2 > 1 > 3.

The Winter Soldier is the best overall. And this is the case despite a fairly whatever main antagonist.

Civil War is great because of its introductions to T'Challa, Peter and Zemo -- the airport stuff is just a lot of sound and noise to me, unfortunately, and I've been told that that's the real tipping point in its favor for a lot of fans.

The First Avenger is... cute.

---

KamikazePotato posted...

This lineup really blows Iron Man and Thor's out of the water. Captain America's worst movie is equal to those groups' best.

This has two top tier movies as opposed to one but First Avenger doesn't really touch IM1 or Ragnarok

---

Lopen posted...

This has two top tier movies as opposed to one but First Avenger doesn't really touch IM1 or Ragnarok

---

This is about what I expected in terms of results. Civil War put up a good fight, but Winter Soldier's reputation is warranted.

---

Winter Soldier is just too good

---

i vote 3 over 2 but i mean yeah i definitely get 2 leading

i got my spidey shield theft tho

---