Poll of the Day > One thing that bugs me about Infinity war....(spoilers)

Topic List	Page List: 1, 2
hypnox 03/03/20 10:24:09 AM #1:	The fact it stated that ~~all life, including plants and everything was effected. So why didn't we see ANY of the trees turn to dust?~~ --- http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m0ajm6lGqf1qekkfi.gif <cite>hypnox posted [p:935164484] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>The fact it stated that all life, including plants and everything was effected. So why didn't we see ANY of the trees turn to dust? </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Krazy_Kirby 03/03/20 10:48:10 AM #2:	groot --- Kill From The Shadows. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiot <cite>Krazy_Kirby posted [p:935165397] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>groot</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
FrozenBananas 03/03/20 10:50:31 AM #3:	That is curious. Especially since the reason Thanos did the snap was to preserve resources. the planet hes resting at in Endgame is full of plant life --- I could do this all day. Yeah yeah, I know... <cite>FrozenBananas posted [p:935165480] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>That is curious. Especially since the reason Thanos did the snap was to preserve resources. the planet hes resting at in Endgame is full of plant life </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Mead 03/03/20 10:56:48 AM #4:	The subtext is that he meant all life with butts --- Lemonheads <cite>Mead posted [p:935165713] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>The subtext is that he meant all life with butts </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyuubi4269 03/03/20 11:22:10 AM #5:	Because he killed a disproportionate amount of sealife. It wasn't just a random 50% of people, it was a random 50% of all life. --- Doctor Foxx posted... The demonizing of soy has a lot to do with xenophobic ideas. <cite>Kyuubi4269 posted [p:935166714] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Because he killed a disproportionate amount of sealife. It wasn't just a random 50% of people, it was a random 50% of all life.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
WastelandCowboy 03/03/20 11:54:17 AM #6:	Kyuubi4269 posted... Because he killed a disproportionate amount of sealife. It wasn't just a random 50% of people, it was a random 50% of all life. Thats a lot of dead dogs, cats, horses, sheep, cows, fish, etc. Fucked up a ton of food chains. <cite>WastelandCowboy posted [p:935168112] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Kyuubi4269 posted... </cite> <quote>Because he killed a disproportionate amount of sealife. It wasn't just a random 50% of people, it was a random 50% of all life.</quote>Thats a lot of dead dogs, cats, horses, sheep, cows, fish, etc. Fucked up a ton of food chains. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyuubi4269 03/03/20 12:07:52 PM #7:	WastelandCowboy posted... Thats a lot of dead dogs, cats, horses, sheep, cows, fish, etc. Fucked up a ton of food chains. He clearly primarily killed single celled organisms so the amount of biomass reduction was significantly less. --- Doctor Foxx posted... The demonizing of soy has a lot to do with xenophobic ideas. <cite>Kyuubi4269 posted [p:935168789] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>WastelandCowboy posted...</cite> <quote> Thats a lot of dead dogs, cats, horses, sheep, cows, fish, etc. Fucked up a ton of food chains. </quote> He clearly primarily killed single celled organisms so the amount of biomass reduction was significantly less.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
hypnox 03/03/20 3:54:33 PM #8:	All I am saying is, let's say it was 50% of all life, the fact that many heros dusted and NOT A SINGLE BLADE OF GRASS OR TREE on screen did was stupid. --- http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m0ajm6lGqf1qekkfi.gif <cite>hypnox posted [p:935178654] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>All I am saying is, let's say it was 50% of all life, the fact that many heros dusted and NOT A SINGLE BLADE OF GRASS OR TREE on screen did was stupid. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
rjsilverthorn 03/03/20 4:52:40 PM #9:	hypnox posted... All I am saying is, let's say it was 50% of all life, the fact that many heros dusted and NOT A SINGLE BLADE OF GRASS OR TREE on screen did was stupid. If it was 50% of all life then even a single human getting dusted is statistically unlikely. <cite>rjsilverthorn posted [p:935181101] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>hypnox posted... </cite> <quote>All I am saying is, let's say it was 50% of all life, the fact that many heros dusted and NOT A SINGLE BLADE OF GRASS OR TREE on screen did was stupid.</quote>If it was 50% of all life then even a single human getting dusted is statistically unlikely. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Mead 03/03/20 4:55:34 PM #10:	rjsilverthorn posted... If it was 50% of all life then even a single human getting dusted is statistically unlikely. thats not how that works --- Lemonheads <cite>Mead posted [p:935181216] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>rjsilverthorn posted... </cite> <quote>If it was 50% of all life then even a single human getting dusted is statistically unlikely.</quote> thats not how that works </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
rjsilverthorn 03/03/20 5:15:32 PM #11:	Mead posted... thats not how that works Since the whole process is rather undefined it is hard to say exactly how it would work, but since it is an undefined 50% reduction in life on the planet and not each life form on the planet has a 50% chance of dying or each species is reduced by 50%, then yes it would be improbably for a large number of humans to get dusted given the fraction of a percent of all life on the plane they represent. <cite>rjsilverthorn posted [p:935182088] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Mead posted... </cite> <quote>thats not how that works</quote> Since the whole process is rather undefined it is hard to say exactly how it would work, but since it is an undefined 50% reduction in life on the planet and not each life form on the planet has a 50% chance of dying or each species is reduced by 50%, then yes it would be improbably for a large number of humans to get dusted given the fraction of a percent of all life on the plane they represent. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
FrozenBananas 03/03/20 5:29:09 PM #12:	Lets all remember that the person who does the snap can choose who to take and who to bring back. Hulk chooses to bring everyone back who was lost, and Tony Stark chooses to kill off just Thanos army. Maybe Thanos chose to save things like plant life on purpose. the movies are filled with loopholes so its not that bad --- I could do this all day. Yeah yeah, I know... <cite>FrozenBananas posted [p:935182671] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Lets all remember that the person who does the snap can choose who to take and who to bring back. Hulk chooses to bring everyone back who was lost, and Tony Stark chooses to kill off just Thanos army. Maybe Thanos chose to save things like plant life on purpose. the movies are filled with loopholes so its not that bad </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
hypnox 03/03/20 5:36:52 PM #13:	FrozenBananas posted... Lets all remember that the person who does the snap can choose who to take and who to bring back. Hulk chooses to bring everyone back who was lost, and Tony Stark chooses to kill off just Thanos army. Maybe Thanos chose to save things like plant life on purpose. the movies are filled with loopholes so its not that bad The creators said in an interview that it was 50% of all life in the universe. --- http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m0ajm6lGqf1qekkfi.gif <cite>hypnox posted [p:935182983] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>FrozenBananas posted... </cite> <quote>Lets all remember that the person who does the snap can choose who to take and who to bring back. Hulk chooses to bring everyone back who was lost, and Tony Stark chooses to kill off just Thanos army. Maybe Thanos chose to save things like plant life on purpose. the movies are filled with loopholes so its not that bad</quote> The creators said in an interview that it was 50% of all life in the universe. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
LinkPizza 03/03/20 5:41:47 PM #14:	Couldnt he have made the choice that it was 50% of each type of life? Like 50% of humans, 50% of dogs, 50% of each alien race, etc... --- Official King of Kings Switch FC: 7216-4417-4511 Add Me because I'll probably add you. I'm probably the LinkPizza you'll see around. <cite>LinkPizza posted [p:935183210] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Couldnt he have made the choice that it was 50% of each type of life? Like 50% of humans, 50% of dogs, 50% of each alien race, etc...</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Mead 03/03/20 5:44:39 PM #15:	rjsilverthorn posted... Since the whole process is rather undefined it is hard to say exactly how it would work, but since it is an undefined 50% reduction in life on the planet and not each life form on the planet has a 50% chance of dying or each species is reduced by 50%, then yes it would be improbably for a large number of humans to get dusted given the fraction of a percent of all life on the plane they represent. Mead posted... thats not how that works --- Lemonheads <cite>Mead posted [p:935183339] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>rjsilverthorn posted... </cite> <quote>Since the whole process is rather undefined it is hard to say exactly how it would work, but since it is an undefined 50% reduction in life on the planet and not each life form on the planet has a 50% chance of dying or each species is reduced by 50%, then yes it would be improbably for a large number of humans to get dusted given the fraction of a percent of all life on the plane they represent.</quote> Mead posted... </cite> <quote>thats not how that works</quote> </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
hypnox 03/03/20 6:09:28 PM #16:	LinkPizza posted... Couldnt he have made the choice that it was 50% of each type of life? Like 50% of humans, 50% of dogs, 50% of each alien race, etc... Then there would be grass and trees on screen that would have dusted. --- http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m0ajm6lGqf1qekkfi.gif <cite>hypnox posted [p:935184525] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>LinkPizza posted... </cite> <quote>Couldnt he have made the choice that it was 50% of each type of life? Like 50% of humans, 50% of dogs, 50% of each alien race, etc...</quote> Then there would be grass and trees on screen that would have dusted. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
LinkPizza 03/03/20 6:21:36 PM #17:	hypnox posted... Then there would be grass and trees on screen that would have dusted. But does it have to be evenly spread? Like, some places are more dense with plant life & foliage & stuff. So, maybe some places got hit more than others. Also, it may have been hard to see grass being dusted. Also, who says the trees didnt get dusted? Just because you didnt see it doesnt mean it didnt happen... --- Official King of Kings Switch FC: 7216-4417-4511 Add Me because I'll probably add you. I'm probably the LinkPizza you'll see around. <cite>LinkPizza posted [p:935185067] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>hypnox posted...</cite> <quote>Then there would be grass and trees on screen that would have dusted. </quote> But does it have to be evenly spread? Like, some places are more dense with plant life & foliage & stuff. So, maybe some places got hit more than others. Also, it may have been hard to see grass being dusted. Also, who says the trees didnt get dusted? Just because you didnt see it doesnt mean it didnt happen...</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
keyblader1985 03/03/20 6:23:12 PM #18:	Plants are resources though. If Thanos intended to preserve resources, it stands to reason that he would preserve plants as well. Has it been explicitly stated that "50 percent of all life" includes plants? If not, it's safe to say Thanos intentionally spared them. --- Official King of PotD You only need one T-Rex to make the point, though. ~ Samus Sedai <cite>keyblader1985 posted [p:935185130] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Plants are resources though. If Thanos intended to preserve resources, it stands to reason that he would preserve plants as well. Has it been explicitly stated that "50 percent of all life" includes plants? If not, it's safe to say Thanos intentionally spared them. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Blighboy 03/03/20 6:24:29 PM #19:	He obviously meant intelligent life. It's not even clear if animals were affected. You're just being overly pedantic and assuming a meaning that obviously wasn't intended. --- I have no idea whether or not he's a racist, but apparently there are recordings of him using racial slurs so it's a distinct possibility. <cite>Blighboy posted [p:935185196] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>He obviously meant intelligent life. It's not even clear if animals were affected. You're just being overly pedantic and assuming a meaning that obviously wasn't intended. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
WhiskeyDisk 03/03/20 6:26:44 PM #20:	The Infinity Saga was great, but the last 2 movies get really, really stupid if you start thinking about them too hard. Ignore the fridge logic of the Snap itself, and the implications of the snapped being unsnapped 5 years after people have moved on, or being unsnapped into empty sky at 30,000 ft because they were on a flight at the time of the Snap. There are plenty of scenarios where you just have to turn your brain off for the sake of the story. But can we take a moment to just reflect on the fact that the fate of the entire universe relied not upon the Avengers, or the Guardians, or Captain Marvel, etc, but on a rat? If that Rat hadn't been crawling around on the dashboard of Scott's van in storage and just randomly happened to hit the switch that pulled Scott out of the Quantum Realm, nothing would have changed in the post-Snap world. --- The SBA has closed for business, we thank you for your patronage Assassins. ~there's always free cheese in a mousetrap. <cite>WhiskeyDisk posted [p:935185302] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>The Infinity Saga was great, but the last 2 movies get really, really stupid if you start thinking about them too hard. Ignore the fridge logic of the Snap itself, and the implications of the snapped being unsnapped 5 years after people have moved on, or being unsnapped into empty sky at 30,000 ft because they were on a flight at the time of the Snap. There are plenty of scenarios where you just have to turn your brain off for the sake of the story. But can we take a moment to just reflect on the fact that the fate of the entire universe relied not upon the Avengers, or the Guardians, or Captain Marvel, etc, but on a rat? If that Rat hadn't been crawling around on the dashboard of Scott's van in storage and just randomly happened to hit the switch that pulled Scott out of the Quantum Realm, nothing would have changed in the post-Snap world. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
hypnox 03/03/20 6:31:24 PM #21:	keyblader1985 posted... Plants are resources though. If Thanos intended to preserve resources, it stands to reason that he would preserve plants as well. Has it been explicitly stated that "50 percent of all life" includes plants? If not, it's safe to say Thanos intentionally spared them. Blighboy posted... He obviously meant intelligent life. It's not even clear if animals were affected. You're just being overly pedantic and assuming a meaning that obviously wasn't intended. Interview stated all life, plants, animals, everything. --- http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m0ajm6lGqf1qekkfi.gif <cite>hypnox posted [p:935185520] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>keyblader1985 posted... </cite> <quote>Plants are resources though. If Thanos intended to preserve resources, it stands to reason that he would preserve plants as well. Has it been explicitly stated that "50 percent of all life" includes plants? If not, it's safe to say Thanos intentionally spared them.</quote> Blighboy posted... </cite> <quote>He obviously meant intelligent life. It's not even clear if animals were affected. You're just being overly pedantic and assuming a meaning that obviously wasn't intended.</quote> Interview stated all life, plants, animals, everything. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Blighboy 03/03/20 6:33:01 PM #22:	hypnox posted... Interview stated all life, plants, animals, everything. Can you provide a source on that? Cause that's a pretty dumb statement if true, a kin to them stating that Cap wears Red White and Green. --- I have no idea whether or not he's a racist, but apparently there are recordings of him using racial slurs so it's a distinct possibility. <cite>Blighboy posted [p:935185601] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>hypnox posted... </cite> <quote>Interview stated all life, plants, animals, everything.</quote>Can you provide a source on that? Cause that's a pretty dumb statement if true, a kin to them stating that Cap wears Red White and Green. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
hypnox 03/03/20 6:38:08 PM #23:	Blighboy posted... Can you provide a source on that? Cause that's a pretty dumb statement if true, a kin to them stating that Cap wears Red White and Green. It was an interview with Kevin Feige. I remember that much, tried looking for it for this topic but too many interviews to find it. --- http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m0ajm6lGqf1qekkfi.gif <cite>hypnox posted [p:935185802] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Blighboy posted... </cite> <quote>Can you provide a source on that? Cause that's a pretty dumb statement if true, a kin to them stating that Cap wears Red White and Green.</quote>It was an interview with Kevin Feige. I remember that much, tried looking for it for this topic but too many interviews to find it. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SpeedDemon20 03/03/20 6:44:00 PM #24:	I think we talked about this before. I asked if a pregnant women and the baby were considered separate lives, or could one of them be snapped and the other not (i.e.: she'd just have a belly of dust or the baby would just plop to the ground and the umbilical cord would magically be severed at some arbitrary point)? I was told that it's all dependent on and defined by the snapper (so if Thanos were pro-life, the baby and mother would dust separately). --- http://orig14.deviantart.net/59f8/f/2009/047/4/9/rylai_crestfall_by_eyue.jpg Crystal Maiden... gal could break your heart in a thousand pieces. -Rucks <cite>SpeedDemon20 posted [p:935186069] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>I think we talked about this before. I asked if a pregnant women and the baby were considered separate lives, or could one of them be snapped and the other not (i.e.: she'd just have a belly of dust or the baby would just plop to the ground and the umbilical cord would magically be severed at some arbitrary point)? I was told that it's all dependent on and defined by the snapper (so if Thanos were pro-life, the baby and mother would dust separately). </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
rjsilverthorn 03/03/20 6:50:30 PM #25:	hypnox posted... It was an interview with Kevin Feige. I remember that much, tried looking for it for this topic but too many interviews to find it. I do need to confirm something about the outcome of Infinity War, and apologies if youve addressed this the end of Ant-Man and the Wasp led to conversations. Are half the animals dead? Are half of the horses gone? Half of the ants? Yes! Yes. All life. https://birthmoviesdeath.com/2018/07/08/kevin-feige-still-wont-tell-us-all-marvels-future-plans So he confirms animals and insects, but never explicitly confirms plants. <cite>rjsilverthorn posted [p:935186342] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>hypnox posted... </cite> <quote>It was an interview with Kevin Feige. I remember that much, tried looking for it for this topic but too many interviews to find it.</quote> I do need to confirm something about the outcome of Infinity War, and apologies if youve addressed this the end of Ant-Man and the Wasp led to conversations. Are half the animals dead? Are half of the horses gone? Half of the ants? Yes! Yes. All life. https://birthmoviesdeath.com/2018/07/08/kevin-feige-still-wont-tell-us-all-marvels-future-plans So he confirms animals and insects, but never explicitly confirms plants. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Mead 03/03/20 7:12:49 PM #26:	~~we know at least one tree got dusted~~ --- Lemonheads <cite>Mead posted [p:935187351] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>we know at least one tree got dusted </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
FrozenBananas 03/03/20 7:17:19 PM #27:	Mead posted... ~~we know at least one tree got dusted~~ ~~hes more capable than most trees though~~ --- I could do this all day. Yeah yeah, I know... <cite>FrozenBananas posted [p:935187544] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Mead posted... </cite> <quote>we know at least one tree got dusted</quote> hes more capable than most trees though </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
JOExHIGASHI 03/03/20 8:23:42 PM #28:	In endgame why did he need the stones if he could time travel? you have infinite resources if you can go forward and back in time --- Next Xbox will be named Xbox1 2 <cite>JOExHIGASHI posted [p:935190852] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>In endgame why did he need the stones if he could time travel? you have infinite resources if you can go forward and back in time </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
FrozenBananas 03/03/20 9:01:38 PM #29:	JOExHIGASHI posted... In endgame why did he need the stones if he could time travel? you have infinite resources if you can go forward and back in time In endgame, he was relying on Nebula to return back and open the portal for Thanos entire army to enter. She only had one device to travel back, and she fooled everyone and then secretly let Thanos and his group through --- I could do this all day. Yeah yeah, I know... <cite>FrozenBananas posted [p:935192796] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>JOExHIGASHI posted... </cite> <quote>In endgame why did he need the stones if he could time travel? you have infinite resources if you can go forward and back in time</quote> In endgame, he was relying on Nebula to return back and open the portal for Thanos entire army to enter. She only had one device to travel back, and she fooled everyone and then secretly let Thanos and his group through </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
WastelandCowboy 03/03/20 11:44:55 PM #30:	WhiskeyDisk posted... The Infinity Saga was great, but the last 2 movies get really, really stupid if you start thinking about them too hard. Ignore the fridge logic of the Snap itself, and the implications of the snapped being unsnapped 5 years after people have moved on, or being unsnapped into empty sky at 30,000 ft because they were on a flight at the time of the Snap. There are plenty of scenarios where you just have to turn your brain off for the sake of the story. But can we take a moment to just reflect on the fact that the fate of the entire universe relied not upon the Avengers, or the Guardians, or Captain Marvel, etc, but on a rat? If that Rat hadn't been crawling around on the dashboard of Scott's van in storage and just randomly happened to hit the switch that pulled Scott out of the Quantum Realm, nothing would have changed in the post-Snap world. This was actually addressed: https://www.cinemablend.com/news/2471944/yes-the-hulks-snap-in-avengers-endgame-had-a-smart-bonus Reddit user dwallace3099: People have expressed views that, in Endgame, those brought back by the snap could have died in accidents (like someone being brought back 100 ft in the air where a plane used to be). Is it possible that Hulk, when doing the snap, not only brought everyone back, but also brought them back in a safe place? Kevin Feige: We refer to the version of Hulk in Endgame as Smart Hulk. So, yes. <cite>WastelandCowboy posted [p:935200283] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>WhiskeyDisk posted... </cite> <quote>The Infinity Saga was great, but the last 2 movies get really, really stupid if you start thinking about them too hard. Ignore the fridge logic of the Snap itself, and the implications of the snapped being unsnapped 5 years after people have moved on, or being unsnapped into empty sky at 30,000 ft because they were on a flight at the time of the Snap. There are plenty of scenarios where you just have to turn your brain off for the sake of the story. But can we take a moment to just reflect on the fact that the fate of the entire universe relied not upon the Avengers, or the Guardians, or Captain Marvel, etc, but on a rat? If that Rat hadn't been crawling around on the dashboard of Scott's van in storage and just randomly happened to hit the switch that pulled Scott out of the Quantum Realm, nothing would have changed in the post-Snap world.</quote> This was actually addressed: https://www.cinemablend.com/news/2471944/yes-the-hulks-snap-in-avengers-endgame-had-a-smart-bonus Reddit user dwallace3099: People have expressed views that, in Endgame, those brought back by the snap could have died in accidents (like someone being brought back 100 ft in the air where a plane used to be). Is it possible that Hulk, when doing the snap, not only brought everyone back, but also brought them back in a safe place? Kevin Feige: We refer to the version of Hulk in Endgame as Smart Hulk. So, yes. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Mead 03/03/20 11:48:12 PM #31:	Some people are so hilariously bad at suspending disbelief why even watch movies if that is how youre gonna be --- Lemonheads <cite>Mead posted [p:935200408] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Some people are so hilariously bad at suspending disbelief why even watch movies if that is how youre gonna be </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
WhiskeyDisk 03/03/20 11:51:10 PM #32:	WastelandCowboy posted... This was actually addressed: https://www.cinemablend.com/news/2471944/yes-the-hulks-snap-in-avengers-endgame-had-a-smart-bonus Reddit user dwallace3099: People have expressed views that, in Endgame, those brought back by the snap could have died in accidents (like someone being brought back 100 ft in the air where a plane used to be). Is it possible that Hulk, when doing the snap, not only brought everyone back, but also brought them back in a safe place? Kevin Feige: We refer to the version of Hulk in Endgame as Smart Hulk. So, yes. Sigh ok, we're going there then I guess. So I survived the snap. So did my 2 kids. My wife did not. In the intervening 5 years, I moved on, my kids moved on and I met a wonderful woman that my kids love and I had another kid with her after our marriage. Now my ex wife is unsnapped in our kitchen. Go ahead "Smart Hulk". Let's see how you untangled this knot on the fly, in the middle of a fight in the seconds you had to contemplate ALL THE THINGS... --- The SBA has closed for business, we thank you for your patronage Assassins. ~there's always free cheese in a mousetrap. <cite>WhiskeyDisk posted [p:935200517] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>WastelandCowboy posted... </cite> <quote>This was actually addressed: https://www.cinemablend.com/news/2471944/yes-the-hulks-snap-in-avengers-endgame-had-a-smart-bonus Reddit user dwallace3099: People have expressed views that, in Endgame, those brought back by the snap could have died in accidents (like someone being brought back 100 ft in the air where a plane used to be). Is it possible that Hulk, when doing the snap, not only brought everyone back, but also brought them back in a safe place? Kevin Feige: We refer to the version of Hulk in Endgame as Smart Hulk. So, yes.</quote> Sigh ok, we're going there then I guess. So I survived the snap. So did my 2 kids. My wife did not. In the intervening 5 years, I moved on, my kids moved on and I met a wonderful woman that my kids love and I had another kid with her after our marriage. Now my ex wife is unsnapped in our kitchen. Go ahead "Smart Hulk". Let's see how you untangled this knot on the fly, in the middle of a fight in the seconds you had to contemplate ALL THE THINGS... </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Mead 03/03/20 11:53:12 PM #33:	WhiskeyDisk posted... Sigh ok, we're going there then I guess. So I survived the snap. So did my 2 kids. My wife did not. In the intervening 5 years, I moved on, my kids moved on and I met a wonderful woman that my kids love and I had another kid with her after our marriage. Now my ex wife is unsnapped in our kitchen. Go ahead "Smart Hulk". Let's see how you untangled this knot on the fly, in the middle of a fight in the seconds you had to contemplate ALL THE THINGS... you have two wives now youre welcome --- Lemonheads <cite>Mead posted [p:935200585] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>WhiskeyDisk posted... </cite> <quote>Sigh ok, we're going there then I guess. So I survived the snap. So did my 2 kids. My wife did not. In the intervening 5 years, I moved on, my kids moved on and I met a wonderful woman that my kids love and I had another kid with her after our marriage. Now my ex wife is unsnapped in our kitchen. Go ahead "Smart Hulk". Let's see how you untangled this knot on the fly, in the middle of a fight in the seconds you had to contemplate ALL THE THINGS...</quote> you have two wives now youre welcome </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
AllstarSniper32 03/03/20 11:54:54 PM #34:	Mead posted... Some people are so hilariously bad at suspending disbelief why even watch movies if that is how youre gonna be Because it's trendy to super analyze movies to the point where you can say every movie sucks. --- If the people only understood the rank injustice of our money and banking systems, there would be a revolution before morning - Andrew Jackson <cite>AllstarSniper32 posted [p:935200660] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Mead posted... </cite> <quote>Some people are so hilariously bad at suspending disbelief why even watch movies if that is how youre gonna be</quote>Because it's trendy to super analyze movies to the point where you can say every movie sucks. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
WhiskeyDisk 03/03/20 11:56:15 PM #35:	Mead posted... you have two wives now youre welcome Have you ever met a flesh and blood woman before in your life Mead? I'm in the middle of making pancakes for my 3 kids with my new wife when my dusted ex-wife spontaneously appears as if the snap never happened 5 years ago. --- The SBA has closed for business, we thank you for your patronage Assassins. ~there's always free cheese in a mousetrap. <cite>WhiskeyDisk posted [p:935200715] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Mead posted... </cite> <quote>you have two wives now youre welcome</quote> Have you ever met a flesh and blood woman before in your life Mead? I'm in the middle of making pancakes for my 3 kids with my new wife when my dusted ex-wife spontaneously appears as if the snap never happened 5 years ago. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Revelation34 03/04/20 1:01:16 AM #37:	WhiskeyDisk posted... The Infinity Saga was great, but the last 2 movies get really, really stupid if you start thinking about them too hard. Ignore the fridge logic of the Snap itself, and the implications of the snapped being unsnapped 5 years after people have moved on, or being unsnapped into empty sky at 30,000 ft because they were on a flight at the time of the Snap. There are plenty of scenarios where you just have to turn your brain off for the sake of the story. But can we take a moment to just reflect on the fact that the fate of the entire universe relied not upon the Avengers, or the Guardians, or Captain Marvel, etc, but on a rat? If that Rat hadn't been crawling around on the dashboard of Scott's van in storage and just randomly happened to hit the switch that pulled Scott out of the Quantum Realm, nothing would have changed in the post-Snap world. That rat was ~~Master Splinter.~~ --- Gamertag: Kegfarms, BF code: 2033480226, Treasure Cruise code 318,374,355, Steam: Kegfarms <cite>Revelation34 posted [p:935203046] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>WhiskeyDisk posted...</cite> <quote>The Infinity Saga was great, but the last 2 movies get really, really stupid if you start thinking about them too hard. Ignore the fridge logic of the Snap itself, and the implications of the snapped being unsnapped 5 years after people have moved on, or being unsnapped into empty sky at 30,000 ft because they were on a flight at the time of the Snap. There are plenty of scenarios where you just have to turn your brain off for the sake of the story. But can we take a moment to just reflect on the fact that the fate of the entire universe relied not upon the Avengers, or the Guardians, or Captain Marvel, etc, but on a rat? If that Rat hadn't been crawling around on the dashboard of Scott's van in storage and just randomly happened to hit the switch that pulled Scott out of the Quantum Realm, nothing would have changed in the post-Snap world. </quote> That rat was Master Splinter.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
WhiskeyDisk 03/04/20 1:12:15 AM #38:	Revelation34 posted... That rat was ~~Master Splinter.~~ I've gotten many mixed messages on the entanglement of TMNT with Daredevil continuity...but I would have at least glossed over it if it were a Squirrel instead... --- The SBA has closed for business, we thank you for your patronage Assassins. ~there's always free cheese in a mousetrap. <cite>WhiskeyDisk posted [p:935203380] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Revelation34 posted... </cite> <quote>That rat was Master Splinter.</quote> I've gotten many mixed messages on the entanglement of TMNT with Daredevil continuity...but I would have at least glossed over it if it were a Squirrel instead... </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
LinkPizza 03/04/20 2:07:48 AM #39:	WastelandCowboy posted... Reddit user dwallace3099: People have expressed views that, in Endgame, those brought back by the snap could have died in accidents (like someone being brought back 100 ft in the air where a plane used to be). Is it possible that Hulk, when doing the snap, not only brought everyone back, but also brought them back in a safe place? I figured it would be something like that. People always assumed that they would be brought back to just a random place... WhiskeyDisk posted... Sigh ok, we're going there then I guess. So I survived the snap. So did my 2 kids. My wife did not. In the intervening 5 years, I moved on, my kids moved on and I met a wonderful woman that my kids love and I had another kid with her after our marriage. Now my ex wife is unsnapped in our kitchen. Go ahead "Smart Hulk". Let's see how you untangled this knot on the fly, in the middle of a fight in the seconds you had to contemplate ALL THE THINGS... WhiskeyDisk posted... Have you ever met a flesh and blood woman before in your life Mead? I'm in the middle of making pancakes for my 3 kids with my new wife when my dusted ex-wife spontaneously appears as if the snap never happened 5 years ago. And...SCENE...go! This happens in a lot of those tv shows where people go missing for years and stuff. Basically, you do what you think is best. Some people go back to their first SO. Which could work if the other person also lost an SO. And some stay with new one, and the other person will sometimes understand. And if the other person had an SO before, as well, maybe they could see if things work out between the two. Which could make sharing the kids a little easier, if they exist. Or they could become one big happy family. Like either two full couples, or two people sharing one person. Whatever. In the end, there's a discussion that probably needs to happen to address everything... --- Official King of Kings Switch FC: 7216-4417-4511 Add Me because I'll probably add you. I'm probably the LinkPizza you'll see around. <cite>LinkPizza posted [p:935204782] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>WastelandCowboy posted...</cite> <quote>Reddit user dwallace3099: People have expressed views that, in Endgame, those brought back by the snap could have died in accidents (like someone being brought back 100 ft in the air where a plane used to be). Is it possible that Hulk, when doing the snap, not only brought everyone back, but also brought them back in a safe place?</quote> I figured it would be something like that. People always assumed that they would be brought back to just a random place... WhiskeyDisk posted...</cite> <quote>Sigh ok, we're going there then I guess. So I survived the snap. So did my 2 kids. My wife did not. In the intervening 5 years, I moved on, my kids moved on and I met a wonderful woman that my kids love and I had another kid with her after our marriage. Now my ex wife is unsnapped in our kitchen. Go ahead "Smart Hulk". Let's see how you untangled this knot on the fly, in the middle of a fight in the seconds you had to contemplate ALL THE THINGS...</quote> WhiskeyDisk posted...</cite> <quote>Have you ever met a flesh and blood woman before in your life Mead? I'm in the middle of making pancakes for my 3 kids with my new wife when my dusted ex-wife spontaneously appears as if the snap never happened 5 years ago. And...SCENE...go!</quote> This happens in a lot of those tv shows where people go missing for years and stuff. Basically, you do what you think is best. Some people go back to their first SO. Which could work if the other person also lost an SO. And some stay with new one, and the other person will sometimes understand. And if the other person had an SO before, as well, maybe they could see if things work out between the two. Which could make sharing the kids a little easier, if they exist. Or they could become one big happy family. Like either two full couples, or two people sharing one person. Whatever. In the end, there's a discussion that probably needs to happen to address everything...</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
keyblader1985 03/04/20 7:24:55 AM #40:	WhiskeyDisk posted... So I survived the snap. So did my 2 kids. My wife did not. In the intervening 5 years, I moved on, my kids moved on and I met a wonderful woman that my kids love and I had another kid with her after our marriage. Now my ex wife is unsnapped in our kitchen. Go ahead "Smart Hulk". Let's see how you untangled this knot on the fly, in the middle of a fight in the seconds you had to contemplate ALL THE THINGS... You haven't watched Far From Home, have you? Shit like this is commonly addressed. --- Official King of PotD You only need one T-Rex to make the point, though. ~ Samus Sedai <cite>keyblader1985 posted [p:935209916] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>WhiskeyDisk posted... </cite> <quote>So I survived the snap. So did my 2 kids. My wife did not. In the intervening 5 years, I moved on, my kids moved on and I met a wonderful woman that my kids love and I had another kid with her after our marriage. Now my ex wife is unsnapped in our kitchen. Go ahead "Smart Hulk". Let's see how you untangled this knot on the fly, in the middle of a fight in the seconds you had to contemplate ALL THE THINGS...</quote>You haven't watched Far From Home, have you? Shit like this is commonly addressed. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
mooreandrew58 03/04/20 7:41:25 AM #41:	LinkPizza posted... I figured it would be something like that. People always assumed that they would be brought back to just a random place If I had of assumed something it would be them being brought back where they got dusted. --- Cid- "looks like that overgrown lobster just got served!" Bartz-"with cheese biscuts AND mashed potatoes!" <cite>mooreandrew58 posted [p:935210207] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>LinkPizza posted... </cite> <quote>I figured it would be something like that. People always assumed that they would be brought back to just a random place</quote> If I had of assumed something it would be them being brought back where they got dusted. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Mead 03/04/20 7:41:59 AM #42:	WhiskeyDisk posted... Have you ever met a flesh and blood woman before in your life Mead? I'm in the middle of making pancakes for my 3 kids with my new wife when my dusted ex-wife spontaneously appears as if the snap never happened 5 years ago. And...SCENE...go! sell the kids to the military and go on a cruise with those bitches --- Lemonheads <cite>Mead posted [p:935210220] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>WhiskeyDisk posted... </cite> <quote>Have you ever met a flesh and blood woman before in your life Mead? I'm in the middle of making pancakes for my 3 kids with my new wife when my dusted ex-wife spontaneously appears as if the snap never happened 5 years ago. And...SCENE...go!</quote> sell the kids to the military and go on a cruise with those bitches </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SKARDAVNELNATE 03/04/20 7:45:03 PM #43:	Thanos: snaps fingers nothing happens Thanos: I have succeeded. Cap: Uh... nothing happened. Guys, did anything happen? Tony: Jarvis, did anything happen? Jarvis: Negative 98% of life in the universe is micro-organisms. --- No locked doors, no windows barred. No more things to make my brain seem SKARD. Look at Mr. Technical over here >.> -BTB <cite>SKARDAVNELNATE posted [p:935239144] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Thanos: snaps fingers nothing happens Thanos: I have succeeded. Cap: Uh... nothing happened. Guys, did anything happen? Tony: Jarvis, did anything happen? Jarvis: Negative 98% of life in the universe is micro-organisms. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Veedrock- 03/04/20 7:57:48 PM #44:	It annoys me more than it should that some people actually think it's half of all life distributed randomly. That is clearly not Thanos' intention, not to mention he says verbatim "when I'm done half of humanity will still be alive." --- My friends call me Vee. I'm not your friend, buddy. <cite>Veedrock- posted [p:935239655] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>It annoys me more than it should that some people actually think it's half of all life distributed randomly. That is clearly not Thanos' intention, not to mention he says verbatim "when I'm done half of humanity will still be alive." </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Lokarin 03/04/20 8:06:56 PM #45:	You're not thinking 4th dimensionally. Only in the one universe where victory is possible is the exact number of onscreen microbes preserved. --- "Salt cures Everything!" My YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/Nirakolov/videos <cite>Lokarin posted [p:935240037] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>You're not thinking 4th dimensionally. Only in the one universe where victory is possible is the exact number of onscreen microbes preserved. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
zebatov 03/04/20 8:45:53 PM #46:	Why did they say you completely solved the case as Chris in Resident Evil after annihilating the entire mansion without ever searching for Barry? Like F that guy I guess. --- C was right. <cite>zebatov posted [p:935241682] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>Why did they say you completely solved the case as Chris in Resident Evil after annihilating the entire mansion without ever searching for Barry? Like F that guy I guess. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
WhiskeyDisk 03/04/20 8:51:04 PM #47:	keyblader1985 posted... You haven't watched Far From Home, have you? Shit like this is commonly addressed. It wasn't addressed at all, it was handwaved with a throwaway line. Granted delving into the minutae of the Snap would be a real buzzkill, but let's not pretend that Marvel wants us thinking too hard about the logistics of the Snappening in the first place. --- The SBA has closed for business, we thank you for your patronage Assassins. ~there's always free cheese in a mousetrap. <cite>WhiskeyDisk posted [p:935241912] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>keyblader1985 posted... </cite> <quote>You haven't watched Far From Home, have you? Shit like this is commonly addressed.</quote> It wasn't addressed at all, it was handwaved with a throwaway line. Granted delving into the minutae of the Snap would be a real buzzkill, but let's not pretend that Marvel wants us thinking too hard about the logistics of the Snappening in the first place. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SKARDAVNELNATE 03/05/20 12:19:06 AM #48:	If changing the past creates a new timeline how did the dusting occur at all after they got the infinity gems? --- No locked doors, no windows barred. No more things to make my brain seem SKARD. Look at Mr. Technical over here >.> -BTB <cite>SKARDAVNELNATE posted [p:935250980] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>If changing the past creates a new timeline how did the dusting occur at all after they got the infinity gems? </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
AllstarSniper32 03/05/20 12:24:28 AM #49:	SKARDAVNELNATE posted... If changing the past creates a new timeline how did the dusting occur at all after they got the infinity gems? Because Cap went back and put all the stones back in their place. And as explained in the movie, changing the past doesn't change the future. If you went back in time and changed something, that creates an alternate timeline, it doesn't affect the current timeline. --- If the people only understood the rank injustice of our money and banking systems, there would be a revolution before morning - Andrew Jackson <cite>AllstarSniper32 posted [p:935251159] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>SKARDAVNELNATE posted... </cite> <quote>If changing the past creates a new timeline how did the dusting occur at all after they got the infinity gems?</quote>Because Cap went back and put all the stones back in their place. And as explained in the movie, changing the past doesn't change the future. If you went back in time and changed something, that creates an alternate timeline, it doesn't affect the current timeline. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SKARDAVNELNATE 03/05/20 12:32:05 AM #50:	AllstarSniper32 posted... that creates an alternate timeline, it doesn't affect the current timeline. When they returned to the present was that along their original timeline or the timeline they created? Returning the stones would have just spun off more timelines. So in all the timelines created between taking the first stone and returning the last stone Thanos wouldn't have been in possession of them since they were displaced in time. --- No locked doors, no windows barred. No more things to make my brain seem SKARD. Look at Mr. Technical over here >.> -BTB <cite>SKARDAVNELNATE posted [p:935251455] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>AllstarSniper32 posted... </cite> <quote>that creates an alternate timeline, it doesn't affect the current timeline.</quote>When they returned to the present was that along their original timeline or the timeline they created? Returning the stones would have just spun off more timelines. So in all the timelines created between taking the first stone and returning the last stone Thanos wouldn't have been in possession of them since they were displaced in time. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
WhiskeyDisk 03/05/20 12:33:55 AM #51:	AllstarSniper32 posted... Because Cap went back and put all the stones back in their place. And as explained in the movie, changing the past doesn't change the future. If you went back in time and changed something, that creates an alternate timeline, it doesn't affect the current timeline. And we were robbed of the exchange between Cap and Red Skull when he went to return the Soul Stone... --- The SBA has closed for business, we thank you for your patronage Assassins. ~there's always free cheese in a mousetrap. <cite>WhiskeyDisk posted [p:935251543] in One thing ... [t:78446654]...</cite> <quote>AllstarSniper32 posted... </cite> <quote>Because Cap went back and put all the stones back in their place. And as explained in the movie, changing the past doesn't change the future. If you went back in time and changed something, that creates an alternate timeline, it doesn't affect the current timeline.</quote> And we were robbed of the exchange between Cap and Red Skull when he went to return the Soul Stone... </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1, 2

Poll of the Day > One thing that bugs me about Infinity war....(spoilers) (+) Yeah! (+)

Poll of the Day > One thing that bugs me about Infinity war....(spoilers)