Board 8 > Eff 2019 Mafia: Topic 2 - Very Artistic Bananas

(+) Yeah! (+)

red13n posted...

chris used to being lynched since when? he pretty much gets a free pass unless hes scum and i'm trying very hard as town.

I think we had one game where we lynched him day 1 like 3 years ago but that's all I can think of

---

Work is starting. Ill be back later

Meow1000 posted...

I think we had one game where we lynched him day 1 like 3 years ago but that's all I can think of

That was lawyered to boot. I am immortal.

Also Ill but probably better than any replacement still.

---

benjamin3740 posted...

I've got a scum read on IGCD.

My 100% read-rate on IGCD says he's Town.

Hbthebattle posted...

I can verify that it is possible for Han and Blade to go at it in a petty way while both are town, and anyone who played RDR2 mafia can verify this. However, Han isn't acting the same way as he did in that argument (where he came off as the more logical of the two), which makes me suspicious of him.

I'm sorry Hb. I'm trying really hard to use the past four days of this game to put together my case on Blade, but... I don't know! Something's just not clicking!

---

Hello Chris.

---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

That was lawyered to boot. I am immortal.

Also Ill but probably better than any replacement still.

Not three years ago. And you're welcome.

---

SBell are you caught up yet?

---

Fun fact: Ben's one scum read is someone he already called scum in his first or second post.

Meaning he has no new thoughts as the game has developed and is just sticking with what he's already said

---

I haven't actually been lynched here as town since 2011!

Also hi. I am bad ridden but feeling feisty.

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

SBell are you caught up yet?

Negative. been parenting and game is on.

---

Rude.


---

Feisty sounds like a spicy meatball

---

---

We're going nowhere real fast.

Blade, who do you think was more opportunistic with me pushing on you, Red or Hb?

---

My opinion on it is HB.

---

Thank you confirmed Town IGCD.

---

TotallyNotMI posted...

Fun fact: Ben's one scum read is someone he already called scum in his first or second post.

Meaning he has no new thoughts as the game has developed and is just sticking with what he's already said

First and second posts were jokes. NOW IT'S REAL.

---

I feel like scum Ben puts in effort to do his book thing.

---

I've seen it both ways. Ben has bragged about switching up how he treats his book thing as both town and scum so it is NAI

---

Okay so... has nothing really happened since ive left?? Come in guys.. ugh alright well ill go and reread some stuff to find somethings more closely or to see if anything stands out


---

The lyncher argument is really odd.. if han was really that role do you really think he would go after it this hard on day 1? Idk that whole argument seems to be grasping at straws

---

Yeah lyncher thing was questionable. Who said that first?

undefined posted... God....

I honestly feel like if Han was a lyncher or executioner he'd be more subtle.

undefined posted... HB....

Frankly the idea that Han is a Lyncher/Executioner is looking honestly pretty likely to me. This is not normal play by Han, not this early on.

---

Think it was god who mentioned it first

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

We're going nowhere real fast.

Blade, who do you think was more opportunistic with me pushing on you, Red or Hb?

Red has kept almost completely out of it. I get the impression he doesn't really care.

Hb's been more involved in it than anyone. There is an argument Hb has gotten too involved.

So it boils down to passive like half the game towards it or more active than anyone else in the game towards it.

So basically Hb was more likely to be opportunistic than Red.

---

I kinda agree but at the same point I feel like Hb's defense makes more sense.

---

turbopuns3 posted...

Yeah lyncher thing was questionable. Who said that first?

I brought it up as a joke
Hb brought it up later in a serious context
IGCD shot it down immediately

---

Leanansidhe posted...

Maybe we should just make IGCD disappear

Didn't you say this exact same line with Death instead of IGCD a few hours ago

---

5tarscream posted...

@Corrik7 do you plan on being a pushover for the entire game in the interest of being friendly?
Who is your top scum candidate so far?

Why are you concerned with my playstyle so much?

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I kinda agree but at the same point I feel like Hb's defense makes more sense.

Hb was not hyper focused on the issue, he was still paying attention to other things as well.

So why are you suddenly seeming more mellow you were acting like I murdered your family and defecated on their corpses

---

Meow1000 posted...

Hb was not hyper focused on the issue, he was still paying attention to other things as well.

So why are you suddenly seeming more mellow you were acting like I murdered your family and defecated on their corpses

I'm always pretty aggressive in this game. But nobody was doing anything so I thought I'd probe you on some of my thoughts.

---

Normally around this time you put vote pressure on someone who you feel is more likely to be scum and get them to claim in order to spur the game further with momentum and get some information in a day 1 to make a slightly more informed lynch. Just my two cents.

---

Fastbreak posted...

Did not care for Miz posts they seemed very fluffy to me

ummm like all my posts are explaining why red is scum how is that fluff

---

That is incorrect, Corrik. I don't particularly care for claims.

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

That is incorrect, Corrik. I don't particularly care for claims.

Okay.

---

1) Ben
3) Chris
5) Death
7) Hbthebattle
8) IGCD
12) Panthera
16) Starscream

Players I might support lynching today

*SBell

To clarify, I could keep bashing my head into Blade, but that's not going anywhere and nobody else is creating content off of it anymore. I still think Blade is leaning on the Scummy side and doesn't provide anything pro-Town as a player but the primary goal was to push him to do something and create some content. It was going to be either him or Red and Blade lost out because I expected Red to actually do something.

---

Decided I should read my pm to see what I was and I have no idea what it is referring to. Lol

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

To clarify, I could keep bashing my head into Blade, but that's not going anywhere and nobody else is creating content off of it anymore. I still think Blade is leaning on the Scummy side and doesn't provide anything pro-Town as a player but the primary goal was to push him to do something and create some content. It was going to be either him or Red and Blade lost out because I expected Red to actually do something.

It stopped creating content a long time ago.

---

Corrik7 posted...

Normally around this time you put vote pressure on someone who you feel is more likely to be scum and get them to claim in order to spur the game further with momentum and get some information in a day 1 to make a slightly more informed lynch. Just my two cents.

You should vote red imo

---

turbopuns3 posted...

1) Ben
3) Chris
5) Death
7) Hbthebattle
8) IGCD
12) Panthera
16) Starscream

Players I might support lynching today

how does panth get on this list out of curiosity? My memory of panth is this game is pretty blank tbh.

---

red13n posted...

how does panth get on this list out of curiosity? My memory of panth is this game is pretty blank tbh.

Both you realize Sbell replaced in for panth???

---

i dont recall anything from sbell either. and no i didnt.

---

Corrik7 posted...

Why are you concerned with my playstyle so much?

because thats how the game works? You look at peoples interactions and play style and try to see if its town or scum. When somebody plays the game totally differently to what they would usually do it draws my attention. Why would I not be interested in your play?

Leanansidhe posted...

I'm surprised no one wants to lynch me.

Suspiciously surprised

Do you want us to lynch you? Because you havent been super pro town or even really scum just super unhelpful.

---

turbopuns3 posted...

1) Ben
3) Chris
5) Death
7) Hbthebattle
8) IGCD
12) Panthera
16) Starscream

Players I might support lynching today

Igcd or hb or ben i could possibly get behind


---