Board 8 > Best classic "only good" opinion

(+) Yeah! (+)

Which
---

That Final Fantasy opinion feels kinda dated now in light of FF6's meteoric internet limelight
---

these are all wrong

Pokemon was never good
---

Sonic is the closest to being accurate even though I love SA2

so that
---

LeonhartFour posted...

these are all wrong

Pokemon was never good

Why do you always have such a shit taste
---

sounds like I'm on the right track if Nanis disagrees with me
---

MZero11 posted...

Sonic is the closest to being accurate even though I love SA2

so that

---

MZero11 posted...

Sonic is the closest to being accurate especially since I hate SA2

so that

(Never gave the 3d stuff past that a chance, so I don't know if that statement is true or not, but it's at least the closest.)
---

Generations is good and Mania is great
---

Jeff Zero posted...

Generations is good and Mania is great

Colors is also really good, but yeah.
---

Oh whoops, I forgot the obvious great Sonic game that came out post-Genesis.

Sonic & All-Stars Racing transformed is what disproves that statement, naturally.
---

Star Wars mostly. But even the original trilogy is overrated.
---

Also all of those are wrong

Gaming was only good in the 16/32/64-bit era - Just plain wrong
Sonic was only good in the Genesis days - Uh no it was just overrated. SA2 is still the best Sonic game. Generations was good too
Star Wars was only good in the Original Trilogy - Only the first two, third sucked. Also Episode VII is the best
Pokemon was only good in Red/Blue (Yellow) or the original 151 - Pokemon got better ever since Gen 1
The only good anime (dubs) are the ones that aired on old Toonami/Adult Swim - I don't know about that one honestly
Final Fantasy was only good in the PS1 era (+ maybe FF6 and 10) - No because adding 6 and 10 is cheating. It's like..third of the Final Fantasy games. Also it's wrong because 5 is awesome
The only good Mega Man games are 2, 3 and X1 - This is so wrong on so many ways I don't know where to start
The only good Metroid games are Super and Prime1 - Every Metroid game that I played was good. Even Hunters
The only good Smash Bros is Melee. - All Smash games are good. Even Brawl
JFK was the only good American President - I don't know and I don't care
---

Metroid was better in the good old days.

When the series was just Metroid, Metroid II, and Super Metroid.

Get that Metroid Prime nonsense out of here, and get off my damn lawn. Kids these days.
---

(The irony is that when I was getting into speed running Super Metroid, I met people on GameFAQs who felt that the original Metroid was still the best, and these new fangled Metroids like Super Metroid were not nearly as good).
---

The golden age of gaming from 1992-1998.
---

Metroid 1 kicks ass

that final fantasy opinion is straight fact
---

Steiner posted...

that final fantasy opinion is straight fact

I would have agreed with the final fantasy option, if it weren't for XIV which is actually genuinely quite good these days.
---

XIII and XV both good
---

LeonhartFour posted...

XIII and XV both good

Ah, yeah, I keep meaning to play XIII.
---

Nanis23 posted...

Sonic was only good in the Genesis days - Uh no it was just overrated. SA2 is still the best Sonic game.

Good Nanis post sighting, well just a part.
---

you'll have to point out what part of that post was good because I'm not seeing it
---

That was pretty much it.
---

pretty sure everything he said was wrong

but maybe that qualifies as a "good" Nanis post because that's what you expect from him nowadays
---

Gaming has been shit since 2007
---

metroid composite posted...

(The irony is that when I was getting into speed running Super Metroid, I met people on GameFAQs who felt that the original Metroid was still the best, and these new fangled Metroids like Super Metroid were not nearly as good).

Now that's edgy!
---

Voted anime dubs since it's like...

I feel like the presidents one should be wrong since it'd probably be the Rushmore guys.

And then most others I either don't like, or just wouldn't play the things that are "only good." So dubs is like, yeah, I basically argued that only YYH has a good dub, which is Toonami. It's still not the only good dub, but at least I don't disagree/don't have experience in the "good" side of something.
---

WickIebee posted...

I feel like the presidents one should be wrong since it'd probably be the Rushmore guys.

I mean, the Rushmore presidents literally included one of its presidential choices cause the dude was friends with that president.

(Teddy Roosevelt was a pretty cool president and all that, but he probably wouldn't be in my list of "name four historical presidents").
---

WickIebee posted...

I basically argued that only YYH has a good dub

as someone who is currently watching YYH for the first time

LOL
---

I don't think YYH is some actually good bar of dub voice acting.

I just really like Yusuke.
---

All of these are wrong
---

Yeah, if you're going to choose a Toonami dub as the standard, it'd probably be Cowboy Bebop.
---

YYH dub was painful enough for me to drop. adore the DBZ one though.

i don't really have enough experience to talk about the others. specifically i never had interest in post-16-bit sonic, and i haven't played post-x ff.

might agree with the pokemon one if it said rby was the best, but gen 2 was also really good, and i thought gen 5 was decent (if played out)
---

LeonhartFour posted...

Yeah, if you're going to choose a Toonami dub as the standard, it'd probably be Cowboy Bebop.

Or Trigun.
---

SeabassDebeste posted...

YYH dub was painful enough for me to drop. adore the DBZ one though.

Same company you even got sabat in the main cast lmao
---

metaIslug posted...

Ys was only good until VI

@ninkendo ?
---

Seven is my favorite and general opinion seems to be VIII is the best one besides the translation
---

Most of these opinions are pretty terrible. Sonic seems like it might be close to true but I haven't actually played any since the Genesis days except Colours (which I did not like), so I'll willingly accept this one might be totally wrong too.

metroid composite posted...

Steiner posted...

that final fantasy opinion is straight fact

I would have agreed with the final fantasy option, if it weren't for XIV which is actually genuinely quite good these days.

Leon already mentioned XIII but V is good too! Not sure if it'd be the type of thing that would interest you as much these days but it's certainly a good game and anyone who enjoys FFT as much as you would probably acknowledge it as such too, given that it basically laid the groundwork for the non-SRPG elements of FFT.
---

These are among the dumbest ten opinions that exist

JFK was the only good American President

Whichever one is the best opinion, this one is definitely the worst.
---

Final Fantasy one can't be fact because every game in the series is better than IX
---

All wrong.
---

Some aren't worth complaining too much about but I can't agree with any of them.
---

Sonic had Adventure and Adventure 2, so no.

Gotta be star wars, since TLJ and TFA suck, Prequels are bad [except Podracing in TPM]
---

closest thing for me is the Metroid one, but it's not so much that i'd claim those are the only two "good" games, but that those two are miles above the others i've played. i still liked Prime 2/3 and haven't played any others.
---

The only ones I agree are Star Wars and Metroid.
---

NeoElfboy posted...

Leon already mentioned XIII but V is good too! Not sure if it'd be the type of thing that would interest you as much these days but it's certainly a good game and anyone who enjoys FFT as much as you would probably acknowledge it as such too, given that it basically laid the groundwork for the non-SRPG elements of FFT.

Ohh, misread the FF one--I thought it said "PS1 era and earlier, plus FFX" instead of "PS1 era only"

Yeah, ok, not including SNES FFs in a "this was only good back in the day when" topic is...zuh?

I probably know some people who think FF was only good in the SNES era or earlier and was all downhill after 6 so....
---