Board 8 > A Feast for Crows Mafia 12: Words are Wind

(+) Yeah! (+)

Euron is hella magic
---

Damphair knows cpr
---

Leafeon13N posted...

Leo3L posted...

My Immortal posted...

Leo3L posted...

The thing about Nana is that I just strongly get the cube he's speaking earnestly, saying whatever is genuinely coming to mind regardless of whether it's an effective argument or not. Scum's bad arguments are manipulative, calculated. His are just...genuine and misguided feeling at this point.

Is that a today thought or an all game thought?

Both, I guess? Like you and Red are jumping on him for his logical leaps but I can't help but feel scum nana would make tamer, safer arguments more likely to succeed instead of throwing all these wild punches

I think its a CE thing tbh. They seem to play a much less logical game than here on b8.

As an aside, I've written four responses to this post but keep deleting them because they would get me modded and thus modkilled.

You don't know me, buddy. You don't know CE. You, Chris, and your "Nana is going to be such an easy ML" bullshit that I'm sure is going on in the scum board. Bite me bro.
---

Lowly mongrels should be prostrated on the ground. And yet you dare come up here, to my board? Such impertinence.
---

##vote: MI
---

Nanahara715 posted...

Leafeon13N posted...

Leo3L posted...

My Immortal posted...

Leo3L posted...

The thing about Nana is that I just strongly get the cube he's speaking earnestly, saying whatever is genuinely coming to mind regardless of whether it's an effective argument or not. Scum's bad arguments are manipulative, calculated. His are just...genuine and misguided feeling at this point.

Is that a today thought or an all game thought?

Both, I guess? Like you and Red are jumping on him for his logical leaps but I can't help but feel scum nana would make tamer, safer arguments more likely to succeed instead of throwing all these wild punches

I think its a CE thing tbh. They seem to play a much less logical game than here on b8.

As an aside, I've written four responses to this post but keep deleting them because they would get me modded and thus modkilled.

You don't know me, buddy. You don't know CE. You, Chris, and your "Nana is going to be such an easy ML" bullshit that I'm sure is going on in the scum board. Bite me bro.

Ive seen plenty of CE play here recently. You remember my frustration in CT mafia with all the conspiracy crap.

[1] red: Nana
[1] MI: (Leo), Leo

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch! Day ends on tonight at 9 PM!
---

Is this where we are ending leo?

I'd be lying if i said i wasn't mentally exhausted at this point.

Leafeon13N posted...

Is this where we are ending leo?

I'd be lying if i said i wasn't mentally exhausted at this point.

Leo

Come on

You're really going to let this win?
---

My Immortal posted...

Leafeon13N posted...

Is this where we are ending leo?

I'd be lying if i said i wasn't mentally exhausted at this point.

Leo

Come on

You're really going to let this win?

Your going to quote that one of all things?
I'm a couple hours from starting work, and i got to actually get there at some point.

Yeah I don't see any reason to quote flavor meta so
---

Mayhaps
---

Like leos whole case against me is

Flavor meta (dumb first off, even dumber because suprak writes fake flavor)
Role meta (dumb as suprak has ran bigger games with only 4 Vanilla's)
And that I didn't buff my power the way he would've (and I still argue I played my role correctly)

No offense Leo but I feel like you're being complacent and going for meta over anything else
---

You left out the part where you've been a complete non-factor, play wise, all game. What exactly about your play am I supposed to read as Town?
---

Nothing about this Nana is town Nana. He's wildly swinging at whatever seems to be sticking at the time because that's what scum Nana does, reacts to what's in front of hin
---

That's Nana. What about you?
---

Leo3L posted...

That's Nana. What about you?

The obvious answer, cutting the weaker of the two(yes im aware this works both ways).

Should have been a trying to in there somewhere im sure.

Leo3L posted...

You left out the part where you've been a complete non-factor, play wise, all game. What exactly about your play am I supposed to read as Town?

I don't think that's remotely true or fair.

I've been here, I've been open and helpful and I've been trying to figure the game out. I've been wrong and that sucks, bit that doesn't make me scum. That is not true for the other two.

Hell when I asked red the same questions a couple days ago he just said it should be ibvious he isn't scum

What kind of answer is that
---

My Immortal posted...

Leo3L posted...

You left out the part where you've been a complete non-factor, play wise, all game. What exactly about your play am I supposed to read as Town?

I don't think that's remotely true or fair.

I've been here, I've been open and helpful and I've been trying to figure the game out. I've been wrong and that sucks, bit that doesn't make me scum. That is not true for the other two.

Hell when I asked red the same questions a couple days ago he just said it should be ibvious he isn't scum

What kind of answer is that

I gave a much deeper answer to that after. But feel free to continue with the lies snd half truths.

How much has MI leveled up

When did he become elite, town or scum. It's been a while since ME2
---

I'm really bad with time frames, but he went from rookie of the year right to elite pretty quickly as far as I recall.
---

What is a hall of fame MI scum game then
---

VeryInsane posted...

How much has MI leveled up

When did he become elite, town or scum. It's been a while since ME2

Hes been a top level player in more recent times, forgive me for not being able to put a time on it. He hasn't been living long enough to show it in even more recent games.

Didn't he win ME2 with you as scum pretty handily? With a minor assist from an unkillable over powered independent who ate the opposing scum team
---

Leo3L posted...

That's Nana. What about you?

I'm cooking and multitasking give me a break

I found a quote in the archives earlier today where you thanks me how how much I was digging in the archive and piecing things together. Red and Nana haven't done that.

You're letting the fact that I've been wrong cloud your judgement and and remember me not doing anything which is flat our not true
---

Leafeon13N posted...

My Immortal posted...

Leo3L posted...

You left out the part where you've been a complete non-factor, play wise, all game. What exactly about your play am I supposed to read as Town?

I don't think that's remotely true or fair.

I've been here, I've been open and helpful and I've been trying to figure the game out. I've been wrong and that sucks, bit that doesn't make me scum. That is not true for the other two.

Hell when I asked red the same questions a couple days ago he just said it should be ibvious he isn't scum

What kind of answer is that

I gave a much deeper answer to that after. But feel free to continue with the lies snd half truths.

After I had to explicitly ask you to
---

And even then it boiled down to WiFom of you wouldn't play this way as scum

That means nothing to me
---

VeryInsane posted...

What is a hall of fame MI scum game then

Here me2

On CE kotor
---

My Immortal posted...

Leo3L posted...

That's Nana. What about you?

I'm cooking and multitasking give me a break

I found a quote in the archives earlier today where you thanks me how how much I was digging in the archive and piecing things together. Red and Nana haven't done that.

You're letting the fact that I've been wrong cloud your judgement and and remember me not doing anything which is flat our not true

You always dig through the archives like that, town or scum. Hell theres been so many times you've called me scum over tjings in the archives (i was town a lot of these times and you were hunting tells that didn't exist).

I remember saying that, but I don't recall who it was you were researching. Did it ever amount to anything?
---

Did that happen in the previous GOT game
---

My Immortal posted...

And even then it boiled down to WiFom of you wouldn't play this way as scum

That means nothing to me

Every argument for being town is going to boil down to that unless a role or something dictates otherwise. Best i could ever hope to give is justification for everything I've done in tjis game.

Leo3L posted...

I remember saying that, but I don't recall who it was you were researching. Did it ever amount to anything?

I can't recall which time it was. I can look for it after dinner.

VeryInsane posted...

Did that happen in the previous GOT game

What is that
---

Scare admits he may be thinking too highly of MI, or succumbing to tunnel vision, but he does not feel like MI goes for the self pity angle here instead of logically dismantling the scum players with reasoning provided for why they should be lynched instead.
---

My Immortal posted...

Leo you are breaking my heart

if KBM was episode 2 Anakin does this make MI episode 3 Padme
---

I have listed so many reasons for both Nana and red and asked you.flat out what more you needed to see.leo

Unless I missed it you didn't respond

And any dismantling I do is just going to be seen as me going for who I have to

I don't have a hard gotcha on either red or Nana but I HAVE outlined why they are scum.
---

Found it. My archive reading you were referring to Leo was looking for Chris/Han interactions the day Han was lynched
---

My Immortal posted...

I have listed so many reasons for both Nana and red and asked you.flat out what more you needed to see.leo

Unless I missed it you didn't respond

And any dismantling I do is just going to be seen as me going for who I have to

I don't have a hard gotcha on either red or Nana but I HAVE outlined why they are scum.

Your argument on me above is just an appeal to authority "This is not town Nana because X", and there is an implied "I know Nana better than everyone else" attached.

But you aren't the only one who has played with me for multiple games, including as a scummate, but you're the only one making this argument.

Obviously you HAVE to make some sort of argument against me, but when it comes to my playstyle, it's you said/I said.
---

Technically speaking that's Scare's ultimatum.

Are you worried about being seen as just going for the win, or are you interested in finding the real scum? If you're town there must be something to take down Nana or Red.

As a show of good faith, I will continue to reread Crystal Chronicles mafia, the only known example of scum Nana posting more than three times.
---

I mean

They're both scum

So I have found real scum
---

My Immortal posted...

Found it. My archive reading you were referring to Leo was looking for Chris/Han interactions the day Han was lynched

And did you go after Han after that, or did you continue to flail at Nana?

Cuz when I did that archive read I throttled Han
---

My Immortal posted...

I mean

They're both scum

So I have found real scum

Wow MI pulling a snarky red response here.

Leo3L posted...

My Immortal posted...

Found it. My archive reading you were referring to Leo was looking for Chris/Han interactions the day Han was lynched

And did you go after Han after that, or did you continue to flail at Nana?

Cuz when I did that archive read I throttled Han

I believe ultimately I stayed on Nana because I have wanted and still want Nana lynched, but I gave the Han lynch my support.
---

FFD dislikes all three of you for various reasons and is very disappointed in the one who is actually town
---

MI, do you have a particular scum game of Nana's you've been thinking of all game?
---

Leo3L posted...

FFD dislikes all three of you for various reasons and is very disappointed in the one who is actually town

Going to again point out ffd lost the right to complain about anyones play after his day 1.

I ask because Crystal Chronicles is not an especially high comparison for this Nana
---

If I had to describe his play in FFCC, it would be bloodless as Roose Bolton
---

Leo3L posted...

If I had to describe his play in FFCC, it would be bloodless as Roose Bolton

I don't know what this means :(
---