Board 8 > A Feast For Crows Mafia: Topic 10 - Fire Consumes, But Cold Preserves

(+) Yeah! (+)

Leo3L posted...

Rule One: If Chris (or whoever good town player) is alive late into the game, they are probably scum. Chris got shot N1 an absurd amount of times, unless he rolled scum. MI is often shot because as town he's super active and skillful

Do you think he's been both this game?
---

what was Chris' defense again?
---

htaeD posted...

what was Chris' defense again?

I stepped in and said scum wouldn't shoot someone that was inactive the last part of the day. This was way back when i originally brought up r1 and MI because the kill of scare made no sense to me.

VeryInsane posted...

Leo3L posted...

Rule One: If Chris (or whoever good town player) is alive late into the game, they are probably scum. Chris got shot N1 an absurd amount of times, unless he rolled scum. MI is often shot because as town he's super active and skillful

Do you think he's been both this game?

Not especially

Maybe I'm just giving Nana too much benefit of the doubt, though
---

I'm just going to follow my guiding principle that I used for Shad and for Han.

I can think of a reason to call everyone else town, to varying degrees of flimsiness, but I got nothing for KBM
---

My Immortal posted...

While i can see yhe case against either of kbm or Nana in my mind

Between my gut and Chris defense of Nana d1
##Vote: Nana

I think kbms misinterpreted voting habjts and her defensiveness after are the kind of things that get her mislynched.

If I'm scum, who is my partner?
---

Leo3L posted...

I'm just going to follow my guiding principle that I used for Shad and for Han.

I can think of a reason to call everyone else town, to varying degrees of flimsiness, but I got nothing for KBM

in fact you said the same thing day4 I think
---

That sounds like me
---

My Immortal posted...

I mean they had nice town/town wagons days 1 and 2.
They had a pretty set scum lynch days 3 and 4

Where would they have abused this prior to today?

Also acting like I deserve to be r1 and not red is dumb

The day was almost entirely me and Han sitting at 2-2. i wouldn't call that "set". Wasn't really set until Jeff and Red jumped on later in the second half of the day.
---

New Topic

https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/75494298
---

Leo3L posted...

Nanahara715 posted...

htaeD posted...

btw do we think scum would get a 'Persistent' role if town didnt have anything it could 'persist' through?

To be fair, this would be a way for scum to definitively shoot a player without watcher fear.

Scum bus driver busses Cop/primary and reasonably scummy looking player (or even a scummate), persistent Strongman shoots through and doesn't need to worry about watcher seeing him AND if he gets tracked he has a built in excuse if someone else targeted the Cop/primary.

This doesn't really hold up I don't think. They did have a full time ninja if they were that worried about being seen.

Sure, but Ninja doesn't bypass protection.

We know (or are at least fairly confident) that Chris shot Stan directly. His first post about the bus driver was less than one minute after day was posted, which means he only had 14 minutes to fully formulate a fake vig claim on Puns. Speculation, but what's he going to do if there wasn't a bus drive?

Furthermore, Stan was the OBVIOUS watcher target. Is Chris so bold to straight up shoot claimed cop with a potential watcher on town?
---