Board 8 > In your view, are all Links and Zeldas reincarnated, or different people?

Topic List	Page List: 1
creativename 05/10/17 6:33:04 PM #1:	I like to think of Link and Zelda as ever reincarnated versions of the same people. I know the Zelda story, of the sleeping princess that all other Zeldas are named after - which means she's sleeping while presumably other Zeldas live. So that makes my belief kind of tricky. How do you view Link and Zelda? Are they all different? Or do all Links and all Zeldas share the same "soul"? <cite>creativename posted [p:878852776] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>I like to think of Link and Zelda as ever reincarnated versions of the same people. I know the Zelda story, of the sleeping princess that all other Zeldas are named after - which means she's sleeping while presumably other Zeldas live. So that makes my belief kind of tricky. How do you view Link and Zelda? Are they all different? Or do all Links and all Zeldas share the same "soul"?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Skyridge87 05/10/17 6:33:51 PM #2:	creativename posted... I like to think of Link and Zelda as ever reincarnated versions of the same people Considering this is canon, it's not really open to interpretation. <cite>Skyridge87 posted [p:878852816] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>creativename posted...</cite> <quote>I like to think of Link and Zelda as ever reincarnated versions of the same people</quote> Considering this is canon, it's not really open to interpretation.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
creativename 05/10/17 7:02:58 PM #3:	Skyridge87 posted... creativename posted... I like to think of Link and Zelda as ever reincarnated versions of the same people Considering this is canon, it's not really open to interpretation. Oh? Where is this stated as canon? I googled "Zelda reincarnation" and I only found topics here and elsewhere with a myriad of opinions. <cite>creativename posted [p:878854489] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>Skyridge87 posted...</cite> <quote><cite>creativename posted...</cite> <quote>I like to think of Link and Zelda as ever reincarnated versions of the same people</quote> Considering this is canon, it's not really open to interpretation.</quote> Oh? Where is this stated as canon? I googled "Zelda reincarnation" and I only found topics here and elsewhere with a myriad of opinions.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
DeepsPraw 05/10/17 7:05:31 PM #4:	I thought that skeleton in TP was supposed to be the Hero of Time How does that work with reincarnation? --- pepsi for tv-game <cite>DeepsPraw posted [p:878854630] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>I thought that skeleton in TP was supposed to be the Hero of Time How does that work with reincarnation?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
BlackMageJawa 05/10/17 7:08:08 PM #5:	What about the Hero's Shade from TP? ~~It's very heavily implied, if not outright confirmed, to be OoT Link, which means his soul is still in the afterlife while TP Link goes on his adventure~~ --- The shattered stage is set and there's a role you must fulfil <cite>BlackMageJawa posted [p:878854766] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>What about the Hero's Shade from TP? It's very heavily implied, if not outright confirmed, to be OoT Link, which means his soul is still in the afterlife while TP Link goes on his adventure</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Heroic Bigpun 05/10/17 7:09:41 PM #6:	They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm --- pUnny at his phone. Expect tYpos <cite>Heroic Bigpun posted [p:878854860] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
creativename 05/10/17 8:22:19 PM #7:	Heroic Bigpun posted... They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm Who is they and when did they say it? Was it in the game WW? <cite>creativename posted [p:878859164] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>Heroic Bigpun posted...</cite> <quote>They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm</quote> Who is they and when did they say it? Was it in the game WW?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Anagram 05/10/17 8:25:34 PM #8:	Heroic Bigpun posted... They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm I could have sworn WW Ganon mentions that you're the reincarnation of the Link who defeated him. --- Not changing this sig until I decide to change this sig. Started: July 6, 2005 <cite>Anagram posted [p:878859353] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>Heroic Bigpun posted...</cite> <quote>They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm</quote> I could have sworn WW Ganon mentions that you're the reincarnation of the Link who defeated him.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
creativename 05/10/17 8:59:22 PM #9:	Anagram posted... Heroic Bigpun posted... They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm I could have sworn WW Ganon mentions that you're the reincarnation of the Link who defeated him. When googling, I found many references to Ganon saying that. People weren't sure if Ganon meant it literally, or figuratively. <cite>creativename posted [p:878861343] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>Anagram posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Heroic Bigpun posted...</cite> <quote>They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm</quote> I could have sworn WW Ganon mentions that you're the reincarnation of the Link who defeated him.</quote> When googling, I found many references to Ganon saying that. People weren't sure if Ganon meant it literally, or figuratively.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Anagram 05/10/17 9:09:43 PM #10:	Why would it be figurative? You look exactly like Link, wear his clothes, have the triforce piece, and are chosen by the master sword. --- Not changing this sig until I decide to change this sig. Started: July 6, 2005 <cite>Anagram posted [p:878861986] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>Why would it be figurative? You look exactly like Link, wear his clothes, have the triforce piece, and are chosen by the master sword.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
creativename 05/10/17 10:16:03 PM #11:	Anagram posted... Why would it be figurative? You look exactly like Link, wear his clothes, have the triforce piece, and are chosen by the master sword. Lots of people think WW Link is just a random kid. I never played WW so I can't comment. <cite>creativename posted [p:878866480] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>Anagram posted...</cite> <quote>Why would it be figurative? You look exactly like Link, wear his clothes, have the triforce piece, and are chosen by the master sword.</quote> Lots of people think WW Link is just a random kid. I never played WW so I can't comment.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
GuessMyUserName 05/10/17 10:29:37 PM #12:	Something about WW Timeline being the branch of Link defeating Ganon which Link then leaves to return to his childhood and form the TP branch, so Link's spirit would have "left" the WW branch. --- I request affiliated many pipes. Been a bad girl, I know I am. And I'm so hot, I need a fan. I don't want a boy, I need a man. <cite>GuessMyUserName posted [p:878867285] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>Something about WW Timeline being the branch of Link defeating Ganon which Link then leaves to return to his childhood and form the TP branch, so Link's spirit would have "left" the WW branch.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
creativename 05/11/17 12:06:15 AM #13:	GuessMyUserName posted... Something about WW Timeline being the branch of Link defeating Ganon which Link then leaves to return to his childhood and form the TP branch, so Link's spirit would have "left" the WW branch. Well if he's reincarnated, that could be a return of his spirit. <cite>creativename posted [p:878872579] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>GuessMyUserName posted...</cite> <quote>Something about WW Timeline being the branch of Link defeating Ganon which Link then leaves to return to his childhood and form the TP branch, so Link's spirit would have "left" the WW branch.</quote> Well if he's reincarnated, that could be a return of his spirit.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Paratroopa1 05/11/17 12:08:27 AM #14:	All of the stories are different stories told in different places with similar but different characters <cite>Paratroopa1 posted [p:878872700] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>All of the stories are different stories told in different places with similar but different characters</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Anagram 05/11/17 1:58:39 AM #15:	GuessMyUserName posted... Something about WW Timeline being the branch of Link defeating Ganon which Link then leaves to return to his childhood and form the TP branch, so Link's spirit would have "left" the WW branch. creativename posted... Lots of people think WW Link is just a random kid. I never played WW so I can't comment. But Link is also reincarnated in ST, isn't he? And if his spirit 'leaves' the WW branch then surely Zelda's would also, and she's there. --- Not changing this sig until I decide to change this sig. Started: July 6, 2005 <cite>Anagram posted [p:878877224] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>GuessMyUserName posted...</cite> <quote>Something about WW Timeline being the branch of Link defeating Ganon which Link then leaves to return to his childhood and form the TP branch, so Link's spirit would have "left" the WW branch.</quote> <cite>creativename posted...</cite> <quote> Lots of people think WW Link is just a random kid. I never played WW so I can't comment. </quote> But Link is also reincarnated in ST, isn't he? And if his spirit 'leaves' the WW branch then surely Zelda's would also, and she's there.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
JonThePenguin 05/11/17 3:09:10 AM #16:	Anagram posted... GuessMyUserName posted... Something about WW Timeline being the branch of Link defeating Ganon which Link then leaves to return to his childhood and form the TP branch, so Link's spirit would have "left" the WW branch. creativename posted... Lots of people think WW Link is just a random kid. I never played WW so I can't comment. But Link is also reincarnated in ST, isn't he? And if his spirit 'leaves' the WW branch then surely Zelda's would also, and she's there. No, Zelda stays behind when she sends Link back in time at the end of OoT. In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation. --- JonThePenguin http://www.backloggery.com/main.php?user=erunion <cite>JonThePenguin posted [p:878879367] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>Anagram posted...</cite> <quote><cite>GuessMyUserName posted...</cite> <quote>Something about WW Timeline being the branch of Link defeating Ganon which Link then leaves to return to his childhood and form the TP branch, so Link's spirit would have "left" the WW branch.</quote> <cite>creativename posted...</cite> <quote> Lots of people think WW Link is just a random kid. I never played WW so I can't comment. </quote> But Link is also reincarnated in ST, isn't he? And if his spirit 'leaves' the WW branch then surely Zelda's would also, and she's there.</quote> No, Zelda stays behind when she sends Link back in time at the end of OoT. In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
bryans7 05/11/17 3:18:04 AM #17:	I never saw it as reincarnation. I always saw it as every so often a Zelda and Link are born, but they are different people every time. --- http://s9.postimg.org/52c0cmqtp/2nbu45s.jpg <cite>bryans7 posted [p:878879609] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>I never saw it as reincarnation. I always saw it as every so often a Zelda and Link are born, but they are different people every time.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
BowserCuffs 05/11/17 3:33:52 AM #18:	Why does it have to be an "or"? --- Everyone's best is different. You can't always be the best, but you can always do your best. <cite>BowserCuffs posted [p:878879984] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>Why does it have to be an "or"?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Wedge Antilles 05/11/17 7:41:34 AM #19:	There's a manga at the back of Hyrule Historia that deals with this. --- I used the knife. I saved a child. I won a war. God forgive me. <cite>Wedge Antilles posted [p:878885415] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>There's a manga at the back of Hyrule Historia that deals with this.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
tcaz2 05/11/17 7:52:42 AM #20:	JonThePenguin posted... In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation. I mean, it could very easily just be like Avatar where the Avatar is a reincarnation with the same soul but they're a different person each time and they can talk to their past lives. <cite>tcaz2 posted [p:878885719] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>JonThePenguin posted...</cite> <quote> In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation.</quote> I mean, it could very easily just be like Avatar where the Avatar is a reincarnation with the same soul but they're a different person each time and they can talk to their past lives.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Heroic Bigpun 05/11/17 10:12:02 AM #21:	creativename posted... Heroic Bigpun posted... They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm Who is they and when did they say it? Was it in the game WW? IIRC the boat fucker says it to not-jabu jabu It's when they're speaking the ancient tongue, so you can only read the convo on your second playthrough --- pUnny at his phone. Expect tYpos <cite>Heroic Bigpun posted [p:878890853] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>creativename posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Heroic Bigpun posted...</cite> <quote>They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm</quote> Who is they and when did they say it? Was it in the game WW?</quote> IIRC the boat fucker says it to not-jabu jabu It's when they're speaking the ancient tongue, so you can only read the convo on your second playthrough</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
JonThePenguin 05/11/17 10:17:18 AM #22:	Heroic Bigpun posted... creativename posted... Heroic Bigpun posted... They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm Who is they and when did they say it? Was it in the game WW? IIRC the boat fucker says it to not-jabu jabu It's when they're speaking the ancient tongue, so you can only read the convo on your second playthrough Exact line is: "The one I have brought with me has no connection to the legendary one. And yet I sense great promise in the courage that this one possesses. " --- JonThePenguin http://www.backloggery.com/main.php?user=erunion <cite>JonThePenguin posted [p:878891082] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>Heroic Bigpun posted...</cite> <quote><cite>creativename posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Heroic Bigpun posted...</cite> <quote>They went out of their way to say Wind Waker Link is not a reincarnation. That makes me think that reincarnating is the norm</quote> Who is they and when did they say it? Was it in the game WW?</quote> IIRC the boat fucker says it to not-jabu jabu It's when they're speaking the ancient tongue, so you can only read the convo on your second playthrough</quote> Exact line is: "The one I have brought with me has no connection to the legendary one. And yet I sense great promise in the courage that this one possesses. "</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
KaijuKing97 05/11/17 10:22:12 AM #23:	I'd say both. Yes, after a certain point they regain their memories of past lives and battles, But does that make their current forms less real? To put it another way, ~~Tetra~~ had a life before turning into Zelda. Was she real? Or was she just Princess Zelda in disguise playing ~~pirate~~? --- If all else fails, there's always the sun. <cite>KaijuKing97 posted [p:878891312] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>I'd say both. Yes, after a certain point they regain their memories of past lives and battles, But does that make their current forms less real? To put it another way, Tetra had a life before turning into Zelda. Was she real? Or was she just Princess Zelda in disguise playing pirate?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Llarian 05/11/17 12:15:49 PM #24:	What if Zelda was a girl? --- essentially shizuo "eat your vitamins and say your prayers" heiwajima in an apron. <cite>Llarian posted [p:878897142] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>What if Zelda was a girl?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Anagram 05/11/17 1:19:51 PM #25:	JonThePenguin posted... In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation. Where is this confirmed? --- Not changing this sig until I decide to change this sig. Started: July 6, 2005 <cite>Anagram posted [p:878900873] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>JonThePenguin posted...</cite> <quote> In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation. </quote> Where is this confirmed?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
StartTheMachine 05/11/17 1:24:20 PM #26:	Anagram posted... JonThePenguin posted... In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation. Where is this confirmed? Hyrule Historia --- - Blur - My Mario Maker Levels: https://supermariomakerbookmark.nintendo.net/profile/Blaringblur <cite>StartTheMachine posted [p:878901142] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>Anagram posted...</cite> <quote><cite>JonThePenguin posted...</cite> <quote> In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation. </quote> Where is this confirmed?</quote> Hyrule Historia</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
JonThePenguin 05/11/17 1:28:26 PM #27:	Anagram posted... JonThePenguin posted... In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation. Where is this confirmed? Hyrule Historia, page 118 The spirit of Link's ancestor, the Hero of Time, teaches him his secrets. Ever since returning to the Child Era, the swordsman has lamented the fact that he was not remembered as a hero. This is the reason he passes down the proof of his courage and his secret techniques to the Link of this era, addressing him as "son." --- JonThePenguin http://www.backloggery.com/main.php?user=erunion <cite>JonThePenguin posted [p:878901418] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote><cite>Anagram posted...</cite> <quote><cite>JonThePenguin posted...</cite> <quote> In any event, Hero's Shade is confirmed to be OoT Link so TP Link can't be his reincarnation. </quote> Where is this confirmed?</quote> <cite>Hyrule Historia, page 118</cite> <quote>The spirit of Link's ancestor, the Hero of Time, teaches him his secrets. Ever since returning to the Child Era, the swordsman has lamented the fact that he was not remembered as a hero. This is the reason he passes down the proof of his courage and his secret techniques to the Link of this era, addressing him as "son."</quote></quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Anagram 05/11/17 1:29:22 PM #28:	Thanks. --- Not changing this sig until I decide to change this sig. Started: July 6, 2005 <cite>Anagram posted [p:878901483] in In your vi... [t:75332550]...</cite> <quote>Thanks.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1

Board 8 > In your view, are all Links and Zeldas reincarnated, or different people? (+) Yeah! (+)

Board 8 > In your view, are all Links and Zeldas reincarnated, or different people?