Board 8 > MAD Mafia Topic 2 - Anger leads to Votes

(+) Yeah! (+)

Peeved to have to change topics

1. Death
2. Lea
3. SBell
4. Wall
5. Ctes
6. Peaf
7. Cody
8. Ulti
9. Crescent
10. Scare
11. Dumey
12. Red
13. Kanz
14. Abacus
15. Ben

Died with an unspent vig shot...
KD1 - Kirby - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - JC - TOWN MAD Day Vig

Votals
[1] SBell: Dumey
[1] Ben: Ulti
[0] Red: (Ben)
[0] Kirby: (Scare)

Note: any Kirby related votals have been reset

It takes 8 votes to reach majority. If majority is not reached, day will end at 8pm EST tomorrow, in approximately 29 hours.

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


And to think Red besmirched Crescent's good name. Tsk. Tsk.

EDumey posted...

I said likely, not must.
And I think the Kirby shot was bad because it seemed clear that Kirby was being genuine about their claim, and there was no reason to doubt them at that time. Not that Kirby was obvious town, but that he was very likely a Vig as claimed through that whole situation. Hence I think it was a bad shot to make at that time.

Okay, likely, but still. You're pointing out a reason to think someone should have been obvious town but are admitting in the same post scum likely has the info so why would that matter

I can't wait for Ben's picture for ctes.

But for now.

ctes = town

Ulti, the part where JC was joking about his BP claim is where it would go wrong.

Kirby321 posted...
Cody, why do you think JC knows that everyone else in this game is a day vig? Could you explain that?

Cody11533 posted...
He said so himself.

Chaeix posted...
wait are people taking me seriously

Obellisk posted...
are we already taking things seriously?

ctesjbuvf posted...

EDumey posted...

I said likely, not must.
And I think the Kirby shot was bad because it seemed clear that Kirby was being genuine about their claim, and there was no reason to doubt them at that time. Not that Kirby was obvious town, but that he was very likely a Vig as claimed through that whole situation. Hence I think it was a bad shot to make at that time.

Okay, likely, but still. You're pointing out a reason to think someone should have been obvious town but are admitting in the same post scum likely has the info so why would that matter

You keep sneaking in words like obvious Ctes, and I'm not sure why you're trying to paint me in that light. Only Sith deal in absolutes, you know.

Here's how I recall the situation going down.

Kirby makes specific hint to Ulti about being a vig.
Several people respond about the 10 minute thing, including Ben posting a picture about it.
SBell is confused about how to interpret Ben's picture laughing at Kirby for ostensibly not knowing about the 10 minute restriction.
Kirby is annoyed that SBell is not picking up information that everyone else seems to understand.
Kirby asks if he can shoot SBell for not getting it.
SBell shoots Kirby for asking for permission to shoot.

It feels to me like the shot had more to do with the authenticity of Kirby's hint to Ulti. Otherwise SBell is making a pure retaliation shot.
So I'm saying that it was a bad shot overall, for either reason.

Just to be clear, if SBell's reason for shooting Kirby is solely only because of the fact that Kirby asked for permission to shoot him, then I still think that's a bad shot and doesn't change my argument for why I'm voting.

EDumey posted...

And to think Red besmirched Crescent's good name. Tsk. Tsk.

I considered poking at Crescent and goading a shot but I kept my teeth in.

Obellisk posted...

I can't wait for Ben's picture for ctes.

But for now.

ctes = town

Just because he is questioning my vote on you? Is your loyalty bought so cheaply, SBell!?!?

Also would like to bring this up again:
Kirby321 posted...

Ben is implying that he has the same restriction and that he's also a Day Vig of some sort
... Which is really setting off alarm bells because why is he the only one with this ridiculous "image posting only" restriction

Granted if someone pointed a gun at me, I could see myself fire back too.
But I dont think it would be my first response.

EDumey posted...

Just because he is questioning my vote on you? Is your loyalty bought so cheaply, SBell!?!?

no, remove me from the equation. Its merely that he is prying into your words and splicing them apart and revealing hypocrisy. looks more townish than it does scumish my eyes. It paints ctes in a very town light. You too could be town, i'm not speaking against you here. Just speaking in favor of ctes's actions

EDumey posted...

Just to be clear, if SBell's reason for shooting Kirby is solely only because of the fact that Kirby asked for permission to shoot him, then I still think that's a bad shot and doesn't change my argument for why I'm voting.

are you throwing away my much earlier dislike of kirby when he went after cody and then very quickly backed off when cody waved a feather at him?

like ok Dumey, you want to attack me for my decision to shoot kirby thats fine but present all the evidence, not just what suits your narrative.

Ben would like to reiterate that Red is scum

Obellisk posted...

are you throwing away my much earlier dislike of kirby when he went after cody and then very quickly backed off when cody waved a feather at him?

That was something you added after I voted you. And thus wasn't really a part of my vote against you.

But in fairness I will consider it now.

.

.

.

Yep, still think it's a bad reason to shoot.

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


Are you in the room with us right now?

Some men just can't help but fire their guns immediately

Some have a different problem and see the town doctor when their gun stays fully loaded for four hours

EDumey posted...

You keep sneaking in words like obvious Ctes, and I'm not sure why you're trying to paint me in that light. Only Sith deal in absolutes, you know.

I know "obvious" was overstating given you said not obvious.

I follow your logic on thinking Kirby was town for what it's worth, and that it's a bad shot. I just thought that initial post was weird.

Why would you consider shooting me, Lea?

EDumey posted...

But in fairness I will consider it now.

.

.

.

Yep, still think it's a bad reason to shoot.

I cant ask for more than fairness. As long as we are clear that it wasn't just "oh he's asking if its ok to start shooting". I felt my reasons were justified enough to take a shot. I was wrong, doesn't make me feel great. Luckily it appears we've got at least 17-2-1-1 = 13... assume 4 or 5 for scum... so assuming that ulti's was also a town vig shot then we are looking at like 8 or 9 left? surely we'll hit scum eventually.

Sounds like we just gotta keep blastin' then. It's 5PM my time, where's the Kanz bullet?

I'm surprised and semi-suspecious someone is town clearing me this early. I feel like no one ever has a clear read of me before like day 3 unless I get scanned.

Man I havent seen Kanz in so long, I dont want him to get shot so soon

ctesjbuvf posted...

I'm surprised and semi-suspecious someone is town clearing me this early.

I think your probing of edumeys argument speaks highly of you and I suppose just watching you play helps the read? its enough to ask to not have your shot at least.

EDumey posted...

Sounds like we just gotta keep blastin' then. It's 5PM my time, where's the Kanz bullet?

but its not 5pm red time.

Tsg

I can never remember Disney world vs land locations

So this is quite the situation to come back to after a few work calls... really a shame on those shots, i like talking to both of those players.

Ulti and sbell are unfortunately mistaken town. Dumey is also town. My other town reads are dead.

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/4/7/9/AAVaiKAAET_v.jpg

how long has Ben been sitting on that one?

Based on me or on SBell's comments?

That looks delicious, but I also dont get it

That's a bit disappointing

I had frog legs in Florida once. I think Ben is saying that red is in Florida.

htaeD posted...

Man I havent seen Kanz in so long, I dont want him to get shot so soon

Hi death, miss you too buddy <3

Hello Kanz. I think I joined a CYOA of yours like 6 or 7 years ago. Time sure flies, huh?

Ben says we have a Peaf problem

Tick tock

Fastbreak posted...

Ben says we have a Peaf problem

are you only a mouth piece for Ben and not a "piece"

I only trust Ben's reads when he skims games, for the moment. Once he gets actively involved he loses the thread.

The astute reader would know the answer to that