Board 8 > Paper Mario Mafia Topic 3 - Hey Mario! I'm Goombario. I'm your biggest fan!

(+) Yeah! (+)

Kirby also how did you think Lea was daycop?

He's not here to defend himself so i am not advocating for us to special death, but:

Last game when he was town (days 1 and 2) he was very actively AVOIDING placing any votes. He didn't vote for his own scan target as cop because he doubted the results! And he didn't vote at all on day 1! And yet he felt compelled to leave a vote on me before he left for the day just now.

Death should be a top suspect tomorrow, please and thank you.

Death does avoid voting in general though.

Peaf, who could you and I agree upon lynching?

##unvote

well people are clearly not going for han so... do we go for the lea special or just let peaf go

my read on peaf isn't strong enough to want to necessarily force another claim given that we're just risking a vanilla

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Death does avoid voting in general though.

Peaf, who could you and I agree upon lynching?

how do you feel about dumey?

PunishedBen posted...

Updated.

Peaf [4] - (Han), Ben, Han, Plum, Death
Han [3] - Isquen, JC, Sultan
Lea [2] Kirby, Sbell
Isquen [1] (Sultan), EDumey, (Han), (Lea)
Sultan [1] - (Plum), Hb, (Isquen)
Dumey [1] - (Peaf), Lea
Plum [1] - Peaf
Ben [0] - (Peaf), (Lea), (Death)
Red [0] (JC)
Kirby [0] - (Han), (Lea), (Sultan), (Peaf)
Hb [0] - (Sultan)
Sbell [0] - (Plum)

Plum, sbell, and dumey are the ones i have any confidence in right now. I think dumey said he wouldn't be here at deadline, so I'm not going to do that to him.

No one has joined me on plum.
Sbell??

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


Me;IRL

Chaeix posted...

##unvote

well people are clearly not going for han so... do we go for the lea special or just let peaf go

my read on peaf isn't strong enough to want to necessarily force another claim given that we're just risking a vanilla

Kinda feels like votals are very close to be saying that

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Death does avoid voting in general though.

Peaf, who could you and I agree upon lynching?

He avoids voting in general.
And he voted for me before leaving.
That doesn't strike you at all?

Furthermore, why negotiate with me? Your vote is on me, and I've expressed that i think you're scum. I don't see why you think we should work together here.

Chaeix posted...

##unvote

well people are clearly not going for han so... do we go for the lea special or just let peaf go

my read on peaf isn't strong enough to want to necessarily force another claim given that we're just risking a vanilla

I hate this unvote

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]

that doesn't mean i feel better about you than the other people at the top!

you will notice i am not pushing for your claim

Peace___Frog posted...

He avoids voting in general.
And he voted for me before leaving.
That doesn't strike you at all?

Furthermore, why negotiate with me? Your vote is on me, and I've expressed that i think you're scum. I don't see why you think we should work together here.

It is particularly strange for Han to go 'hey who should we vote' to his top scumspect

are we sure we don't want to vote han

Peace___Frog posted...

I think you're really on the ball today, jc. But despite my inclinations against Han, i still ultimately agree with Sbell to give him a night and see if scum will kill him.

If not, then absolutely pressure him day 2, and especially day 3 (assuming i won't be here for them).

For the sake of time, I'm just a vanilla. I tried being clever and hinting at power earlier to try to draw a kill in a similar way to last game, but that's obviously dead in the water. Kill me if you wish, i think there's good material here for town tomorrow.

Where was your hint?

I never got a chance to reread Peaf. I thought he was scum last game on D1, so that's why I'm a little hesitant to lynch him because I think I just naturally think Peaf is scum for some reason or another. I don't think I ever felt particularly great about Peaf this game, but I also want to give him a fair chance before saying we should lynch him.

Isquen, though, I'm okay with lynching if he's just going to peace out. I know he does this every game, and I know it's lazy, but it's frustrating to deal with. Only problem is that his lynch doesn't tell us much if he flips scum, but a dead scum is still a victory regardless. Though I'm not sure what else we get out of an Isquen lynch if he flips town.

Peaf might be the smarter call for an information lynch, but I personally don't have a strong argument for his alignment off the top of my head.

I think I'm happy with either of these two candidates. Possibly Lea, but she's moved up on my list from "likely scum" to "keep an eye on her".

Still, I'd take Peaf or Isquen or Lea at this moment. No specials on this D1!

##Unvote
##Vote: Isquen

Peace___Frog posted...

He avoids voting in general.
And he voted for me before leaving.
That doesn't strike you at all?

Well, if Death avoids voting as town and scum yet voted for you; that doesn't necessarily make it a scummy move. It suggests he has a special reason.

PunishedBen posted...

Where was your hint?

When i said i wouldn't give my life to protect you, and when han pushed me originally way early on that i was different from last game or something like that i said "oh maybe a reason for that" or something like that. Again, just tried to be cute about it but i was talking about myself when i said subtlety here is lacking.

Hbthebattle posted...

Well, if Death avoids voting as town and scum yet voted for you; that doesn't necessarily make it a scummy move. It suggests he has a special reason.

I find it scummy because i think he wanted to ensure i got lynched over the other candidates being discussed. And there can only be one reason for that.

I won't lynch SBell at all.

I would rather lynch Plum than Dumey.

I think JC would be a good lynch too. He's not playing anything like he did last game :)

Kirby321 posted...

I also want to give him a fair chance before saying we should lynch him

Kirby wtf does this even mean.

I've had 48 hours. Why do you think i need "a fair chance"?

Peace___Frog posted...

And there can only be one reason for that.

He thinks you are scum? It's not that hard
remember that last game also had endings in a timezone he could actually play, so he could make a decision last minute if he so chose. he doesn't have that luxury here.

Chaeix posted...

It is particularly strange for Han to go 'hey who should we vote' to his top scumspect

are we sure we don't want to vote han

I find his acceptance of dying to be persuading me into giving something else a try.

I too would rather Plum than Dumey. Plum has been like "anti-everything" this game, like he's intentionally trying to be contrary.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I won't lynch SBell at all.

I would rather lynch Plum than Dumey.

I think JC would be a good lynch too. He's not playing anything like he did last game :)

Then join me on plum.

Perhaps jc finally has a role that isn't TOWN CUT OFF YOUR OWN FOOT AND LAUGH ABOUT IT

Peace___Frog posted...

Kirby wtf does this even mean.

I've had 48 hours. Why do you think i need "a fair chance"?

More like I need to reevaluate your posts and actually analyze them to see if I'm just biased in thinking you're scum or if you've actually been scummy. Pretty sure I said this to someone else... last night? I forget.

I just didn't expect the practice thesis defenses I attended this afternoon to not only start late but also go way over time, so I never got a chance to reread.

Hbthebattle posted...

He thinks you are scum? It's not that hard
remember that last game also had endings in a timezone he could actually play, so he could make a decision last minute if he so chose. he doesn't have that luxury here.

You put that much faith into a death vote, when - again - he didn't vote for his own scan target as cop last game.

crap sorry had some family adding on to my spring training trip that complicated bookings then that ran into D&D. Can someone throw me a quicknotes version of the last bit of time?

Kirby321 posted...

More like I need to reevaluate your posts and actually analyze them to see if I'm just biased in thinking you're scum or if you've actually been scummy. Pretty sure I said this to someone else... last night? I forget.

I just didn't expect the practice thesis defenses I attended this afternoon to not only start late but also go way over time, so I never got a chance to reread.

Ok, so you're saying that you need a fair chance to read me, not that i need a fair chance in the game?

HanOfTheNekos posted...

##Unvote: Peaf
##Vote: Plum

Before anyone jumps on Han for this, last time he tried to start a separate train at the last minute on D1, he was Town Doctor.

Please let's not make the same mistake again.

red13n posted...

crap sorry had some family adding on to my spring training trip that complicated bookings then that ran into D&D. Can someone throw me a quicknotes version of the last bit of time?

nobody agrees on anything, peaf has claimed vanilla and it's impossible to quicknote because there is no 'main plotline'

that's the quicknote

Votals as of 381

Peaf [3] - (Han), Ben, (Han), Plum, Death
Han [2] - Isquen, (JC), Sultan
Lea [2] Kirby, Sbell
Isquen [2] (Sultan), EDumey, (Han), (Lea), Kirby
Plum [2] Peaf, Han
Sultan [1] - (Plum), Hb, (Isquen)
Dumey [1] - (Peaf), Lea
Ben [0] - (Peaf), (Lea), (Death)
Red [0] (JC)
Kirby [0] - (Han), (Lea), (Sultan), (Peaf)
Hb [0] - (Sultan)
Sbell [0] - (Plum)

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch. Day ends at 9:00 P.M. Eastern. (or approximately 5 minutes from now).

Honestly with 5 minutes left I'd almost prefer you lynch me just to avoid the special lol

Peace___Frog posted...

Ok, so you're saying that you need a fair chance to read me, not that i need a fair chance in the game?

Yes. Sorry, with the deadline approaching, I might not have properly expressed my words in haste.

Kirby321 posted...

Before anyone jumps on Han for this, last time he tried to start a separate train at the last minute on D1, he was Town Doctor.

Please let's not make the same mistake again.

quick before day ends. Han is probably important town role, scum.

Peace___Frog posted...

Honestly with 5 minutes left I'd almost prefer you lynch me just to avoid the special lol

Yeah but you saying this makes me not want to lynch you

I would lynch Kirby too, though

Chaeix posted...

nobody agrees on anything, peaf has claimed vanilla and it's impossible to quicknote because there is no 'main plotline'

that's the quicknote

I agree with you on many things, i think.

Quicknotes for you folks tomorrow. Go get them, I have faith in you :)

1. Ben - town
2. Cody - likely new scum but will give him some time
3. Ctes - town
4. Death - def scum
5. Dumey - doesn't feel like town dumey, but also hasn't really been particularly scummy in any way. Unsure.
6. Han - lean scum
7. Hb - town
8. Isquen - town
9. JC - town
10. Kirby - town
11. Lea - ???
12. Peaf - itsa me
13. Plum - scum
14. Red - afk, null
15. Sbell - scum
16. Sultan - town
17. Ulti - sick, null

I'd still rather Peaf than Plum >_> Plum hasn't even claimed

we can try rigging a tie to get extra time

PunishedBen posted...

I too would rather Plum than Dumey. Plum has been like "anti-everything" this game, like he's intentionally trying to be contrary.

so he's scum running around saying 'no, town, don't do that'? that doesn't seem particularly scummy

Obellisk posted...

quick before day ends. Han is probably important town role, scum.

You are riding Han so hard lately. Are there cowboys in Paper Mario?

Peace___Frog posted...

You are riding Han so hard lately. Are there cowboys in Paper Mario?

I'm really not. not sure why you see it that way.

Hbthebattle posted...

we can try rigging a tie to get extra time

I do not have any faith in our ability to do this.

Vote where your heart tells you to.

Plum has behaved in a way that makes me think he could be Scumbuddies with Sultan. Not that I think Sultan is Scum.