Board 8 > YGO Master Duel Mafia Topic 1 - Ah yes the worst element: Rookie.

(+) Yeah! (+)

I just caught someone throwing out random names not realizing who is on the player list. Someone who only knows who his scum buddies are and doesn't care who the lynch is.

On another note, Poppy, Corrik, would you two mind explaining your votes?

You said you won't be here but I want more thoughts in your plum vote since he is your top read.

I'll admit i was poking fun at BCT at first but even this counter vote isn't sitting well with me

SBell: I got information all of a sudden. Intel that proved a prior theory of mine wrong.

What is this in response to?

I thought we were talking about Ctes. You said you presume ctes is town

"Scum hunting"

BCT, you didn't respond to my thoughts in post 160.

Not sure what information you received that changed a theory of yours considering you said you don't have enough info to scum hunt

Don't recall saying that. Ctes was "presumably" trying to pressure Sultan, to out Sultan as town. That's what I meant. I don't know what to make of Ctes yet. But Sultan slipped and now I no longer think that.

Can you explain Han's train of thought on BCT and what you do and don't agree with?

I think it's because that game is blurred from my memory, given the mental state I was in at the time. My bad.

The "typo" was the info. Was it really a typo, though? Probably given Sultan's reaction to me pushing him around tbh

##Unvote

I just caught someone throwing out random names not realizing who is on the player list. Someone who only knows who his scum buddies are and doesn't care who the lynch is.

Bro you typoed. No Leads makes me think something entirely different from No Reads. But once you explained that I get it.

You're probably town for this level of paranoia and PTSD at least

Can we not spoiler block things?

SBell, do YOU think BCT is Scum right now?

No... as someone who was on the receiving end of this argument not too long ago, this is a stretch. Though in my case, it was a joke instead of a misunderstanding, but it's still not a solid argument.

I know you have a tendency to suspect the people who vote you, BCT, but this ain't it.

Not really a typo but poor wording, really

Why do I get the feeling you're only calling me town to get me off of your back? I don't think you're being genuine, Ben.

can i put people in your book

Han, are you just avoiding the question I asked?

HB I gave you such an incredible power. Why didn't you make use of it?

Don't like this at all

I wasn't, but now I am, just to spite you.

it's a running theme so far this game. You are allowed to join the fun.

???

That sentence doesn't mean anything

I was your number one defender in the game you got replaced by Plum. If you're being honest right now, then why aren't you recalling that? Saying I suspect you just for breathing? That's literal fantasy. You're making stuff up.

That being said, I think you're rather quick to jump to conclusions. I don't necessarily agree with Han's train of thought on BCT, but it's worth pursuing just to see what happens.

I can't recall enough games with BCT to remember whether his defensive behavior like this is the norm for his playstyle or not. I definitely remember this defensiveness from Nickelodeon Mafia, where he was scum. I don't quite remember his Baseball Musical Mafia behavior, though, if anyone has any data on that. Either way, it's worth testing the consistency of this pattern just to see if it holds up.

On another note, Poppy, Corrik, would you two mind explaining your votes?

You know what

It just occurred to me that Ben tried pulling this crap of completely misinterpreting one of my posts back in Simple Mafia and trying to accuse me of contradicting myself. It brushed me the wrong way at the time, but I didn't do anything about it because I thought it was a genuine mistake. And then he ended up flipping scum to my surprise.

Now, I'm getting deja vu from Ben's attempt to make me look bad this game. Feels very much like a repeat tactic from Simple Mafia, but unlike back then, I'm not letting you go that easily this time around!

##Vote: Ben

anyway after catching up I actually like BCT this game, his anger feels pretty genuine. Ben, permission to inscribe him in the book?

Ok, hold on a minute. Most of your defense of BCT was well after he replaced out. This feels emotional-manipulation-esque to me.

• His initial wall felt far more like summary than any thoughts on the game, which even for Kirby's walls is not usually true when he's town.
• I don't liked the way he was pushing BCT and then jumped off when put to a little bit of scrutiny, feels somewhat ingenuine
• He hasn't been scum yet iirc so he has to be scum now (this is how probability works)

It is incorrect, yes. Red is referring to me saying he's always a good lynch, which, since mafia picked back up with Chris's experimental mafia where we were scum together, has been true in every single game except for 1.

Me thinking Red is always a good lynch is not directly related to whether I think he's scum or not.

But right now he strikes me more Townish.

If I'm overreacting, then it's too an overreaction. I got called scum outright. That's an overreaction in and off itself. But... maybe I'm reading into that differently? IDK... but I'd never jump to such a conclusion that quickly. Big difference between pressure and accusation.

I don't like how you're working him, but I can't say for sure that it makes you Scum. I put you in the position of having to put your chips down, and frankly, I don't like your conclusion. That's said, I'd have to reread you to really be sure how I feel about you.

Sultan, BCTs first post was garbage for so many reasons. If scum or town, it's just a bad way to walk into a game. He's still green.

Your post, highlighting his "jokiness" inside and outside of Mafia is fine, except then you chastise him for doing it as a first post. Why did you acknowledge that this is the type of person he is, in your opinion, and then attack him for being that person? Did you feel like making that joke post was indicative of Scumplay from BCT? If not, then what purpose did it serve?

There is a lot of "I'll say whatever I have to say to answer this post", this is a very defensive and afraid way of posting and I've yet to actually see an ounce of this "anger" you refer to.

But, I will see you all on Day 2, seeing as every time I open my mouth day 1, it gets me in trouble for reasons that absolutely BAFFLE me (breathing, perhaps?), so I'm just going to learn my lesson and shut up.

he asked you about one thing that was seemingly contradictory in your posts, he wasn't even pushing you over it

this actually does feel needlessly defensive

does this seem like it lacks "anger", considering BCT's history here, Sbell?

He's more concerned with how he'll look if he says things.