Board 8 > Elden Ring Mafia Topic 11 - Ranni's Ruse

(+) Yeah! (+)

Chang night 2.

Possible they just whiffed night 1.

Mostly, because of him taking credit for being messenger, claiming to know the split, and backing off the claim when it started to look like being lynched would be a viable option.

Still not convinced the messenger isn't scum.

Still not convinced the messenger isn't scum.

if my memory serves me i believe sbell actually said something to the order of "i was around but i was reading too slow and chris got the #instill before me"

there's at least something to suggest maf might have known about it beforehand and just got beaten on the jump.

then ulti intentionally jumps on the second one.

but their goal should be to convince everyone the message writer is town and not 3p in that case

It doesnt seem like any of the people voting IGCD really think he's scum. Which would include me. But i still think Sheep is even less likely scum. The question is, does IGCD flipping town mean people will just turn around and lynch Sheep tomorrow? Because Sheep is who i am protecting here.

For the record i don't think igcd is ever scum here and I don't endorse the lynch due to that.

Still not convinced the messenger isn't scum.

I also don't think this is scum IGCD, but I wouldn't go so far as to say he is never scum. Literally the only thing he has going for him is the claim itself, which is a terrible one to make as scum. Everyone else I consider town based on their play, and he's essentially my top "scumread" right now through PoE. Everyone else has something else in gameplay or an interaction with scum that just looks really good for them.

...but I still don't think he's scum. It just feels really damn wrong. The confusion is kind of leading me back to Corrik, because I honestly think Corrik is the only player capable of creating a game state where he looks this good as scum. Probably along with Chris, but Chris just murdered Panth and has the benefit of being essentially cleared if IGCD is town. IGCD isn't a terrible lynch today, but him being scum feels off, and I have a feeling Chris is still gonna try and murder me tomorrow if I do vote IGCD and he flips town. Regardless of the power claim stuff, and regardless of the fact that IGCD being town all but confirms a bunch of us. Which probably means two dead town if IGCD is town. Maybe I'm overestimating Chris' power of persuasion and I should just try and confirm myself with the rest of the game, and ignore any future tunneling? But honestly, I'd rather try and catch scum.

##Vote: Corrik

I guess we're back here again huh

I will not stop voting sheep until game is over or he is dead

They didn't vote you either, Chris.

If this is the case why does Ulti commit suicide?

because I honestly think Corrik is the only player capable of creating a game state where he looks this good as scum.

Corrik is essentially confirmed not roleblocker unless he's a roleblocker ninja did you miss that

You had a cop scan Chris? Not a track?

I will let it slide since I am town

Ulti, sbell, panthera did not vote for each other at all day one. What are the odds they vote for their blocker?

You had a cop scan Chris? Not a track?

Taking an action but not moving is exactly the kind of power a scum would want to claim if they were ninja, since IGCD's role exists.

Corrik full claim when?

Yeah I got a cop scan not a BP. Of course I wouldn't claim BP if I got one lol

But do you think he actually believes that or he has to say it here to make his argument work.

Why does he seem to never go after you too?

I think Chris plays this completely differently if he is scum and just forces the game to swing another direction rather than murdering Panth. I think Chris is as good as scum but in a different way.

Also I'm not going after him too because he's essentially cleared if IGCD is town. Which I think is the case.