Board 8 > Percussion Mafia Topic 2

(+) Yeah! (+)

5tarscream posted...

I am willing to one time vote every single player on this game if you think there is a possibility of multiple bombs on scum team

I am obviously not serious there. I was more thinking that maybe town has a bomb of their own, and only as a slim possibility.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Yes

Then I retract my criticism of not saying it earlier assuming youre telling the truth. I still dont like you writing off the topic and I dont really like you just town clearing everybody that posts something you like. That being said neither of those are as outright damning. Ill move you back to lean scum instead of absolute scum.
Congratulations.

##unvote


---

##unvote: Panthera
##vote: 5tar

I think you may have been granted a wish on an evil monkey's paw, 5tar.

So here's my problem that I have with you right now, your vote doesn't make a lot of sense from any angle here.

Like you don't like that I am being a bit lazy and uncaring - okay I mean sure, but then you have people who are being way less involved than i am and you seem so far to be giving them all a pass.

But also now you are just tacking on things to try to make your vote look better. You didn't post before the bomb or anything, so as someone catching up not directly involved in the topic at the time it should have been easy to register that bomb went off super early and I claimed bombproof literally page 2 of the first topic.

I think you got caught trying to look town by going after me and you messed up.

---

I didnt expect an unvote there
Wait so you are entirely okay with Chris' claim now, 5tar?

Because your first reason for disliking it was not the same as the one Chris corrected you on.

He has already claimed a role that is useless to town

I also didnt like the timing of your claim because you could have claimed it much earlier than you did and it makes town more cautious.

---

Chris explained it better. It reads like you only took back the latest reason for voting Chris when the previous ones were already enough to tip the edge.
---

Hey look Death, I am more engaged in the topic now! Just what 5tar wanted.


---

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PEpm8PVCeAo

(Note: not my flavor, but I wish it was)
---

That Mzero question is peculiar...

---

Hey 5tar, say Chris was lynched and flipped Town. What does that tell you about Corrik?

---

Corrik role swapping IGCD and Ben on the fly like that makes me think he is town. That's not impossible to pull as scum but it would be pretty dang sneaky

Chris are you really sticking with bombproof? I took it for a joke but if it's a joke I think it's run its course in terms of amusement v. utility

I am probably dead night 1 we don't really need to overkill my role here. I earnestly dont see the big deal of me being bombproof.

---

Being bomproof itself isn't a big deal. I just wanted a firm confirmation that you weren't (or were) deliberately playing with your food, as you put it

Ah. Bombproof is my role pm :p

---

Just got an email that there's a confirmed case of covid in my apartment complex. Happy Monday.

I will pray for you. Thoughts on 5tar as you await your doom?

---

Yeah uh, stay strong Puns.
---

Chris checks out not interested in lynching him tbh

---

Mzero is helping save chris what a kind soul.

Mzero thoughts on the villains on me?

---

Corrik7 posted...

That Mzero question is peculiar...

Trust me buddy I have my reasons!

---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Mzero is helping save chris what a kind soul.

Mzero thoughts on the villains on me?

Corrik I believe is misguided town. Sultan I think is scummy but best to let the tracker claim resolve. 5tar unvote looks awful imo

---

Actually I'm going to bed so take my sword chris

##Vote: 5tar

Enjoy Persona 5 Royal it's freakin incredible

---

5tar reads as just posture-y and overly confident to me. Could just be personality though. I don't see much apparent scuminess at the moment

Chris why were you bothered by sultan

He sounded insincere to me so I decided to poke him. He has since sincered up

---

Heh, Lea's vote on Chris didnt even register.
(Thats not a slight against Puns, I forgot Lea voted Chris too)

Also did 5tar just up and run away?
---

I believe 5tar is a weird timezone person

---

Yeah, it should be just after midnight for 5tar.
---

Ok so I dont have to the assume the worst of his courage at least.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

He sounded insincere to me so I decided to poke him. He has since sincered up

Any thoughts on the weirdness of the claim?
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Any thoughts on the weirdness of the claim?

Sultan's a weird guy. That about sums it up. He could be lying but no real benefit hammering it home

---

I like 5star. His POV comes from town solving perspective

---

Please expand on that

---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Please expand on that

The way he tackled my situation with tange comes from town solving

I don't give scum star the credit to fake that from what I saw of him so far

---

5tarscream posted...

I think Scare looked bad but not scum. I think he looks bad to everyone outside of his mind space because Im assuming he had a very specific response he expected from Tange and he got something very different. To me it looked like Range didnt want to do Scares work for him which by itself isnt alignment indicative.
The problem is to everyone else that wasnt that big a deal and Scare could easily have done it himself, but to Scare it ticked a box in his head that nobody else saw.
I think hes probably town.

I think Balla is attempting to look busy.

I think Chris is either scum or not bothered, Corrik could be using this as an opportunity to eliminate Chris early without wasting a kill or he could just think Chris is scum. Chris has town cleared a lot of people so far.

##vote: Chris

This post. The box tick stuff. That is town trying to solve my slot

---

Hmm. Sure, we will assume perhaps 5tar was simply overeager with me

##UNVOTE: 5tar
##vote: panthera


---

What is your issue with panth?

I think there was something I didnt like from him early on, what is it you are voting him for currently

---

Weak vote on sultan and what puns pointed out about how ben handled him rung true

---

I went back to see what it was

In the time ben was alive he made 3 posts, all 3 had a vote for a different person.

One was red, but he never talked about the counter
One was lea about Ben's claim, but only in response to it

He had reasons to interact with Ben but never actually did, and ben even voted him at one point

---

Oh shit ben didny vote him just called him scum

That was probably what bothered me to begin with

---

##unvote

##vote: panth

---

Im in Europe at the moment by the way guys.
Chris what do you think about Balla.
Damion itd tell me Corrik was wrong. Thats all. Town vote town all the time.


---

I dont have a baseline for balla. Not lighting the world on fire though.

---

I have my own (probably not unique) thoughts about the Panthera business, not so much questions yet. So I will refrain from writing them until Panthera responds.
5tar, can you answer my questions?
---

MZero11 posted...

Actually I'm going to bed so take my sword chris

##Vote: 5tar

Enjoy Persona 5 Royal it's freakin incredible

I hate votes like this almost as much as I hate votes for absent players, I hate it even more when people do it as they leave so you cant question them on it.
MZero has looked very town so far though.

Can somebody fill me in on Lolo? Like when he plays is he some kind of S tier player? I just dont understand why he signs up then doesnt play.


---

I guess Mzero's question kinda asserts he is town or that he is scum who knows scums shots are bombs I guess. But, I can't see scum revealing that so I err to town. Which makes Chris... Likelier town? Bombproof could be a scum role.

Then again Bombproof could just be Bulletproof in nature and bombs replace shots. Idk. That's interesting.

Either way Mzero is pretty much town. Chris more likely to be town than he was before.


---

##vote: HB

Back to HB, Lea, Puns.

---

What question?

htaeD posted...

Also did 5tar just up and run away?

If this one then no I didnt. I was doing other things.

---

htaeD posted...

I didnt expect an unvote there
Wait so you are entirely okay with Chris' claim now, 5tar?

Because your first reason for disliking it was not the same as the one Chris corrected you on.

This one I guess?
Define entirely ok with it, I think there is a chance he is bombproof and I said I didnt like the claim and I didnt like the timing. It was two part. When Chris claimed he didnt see the topic until after the bomb exploded I gave him the benefit of the doubt.

So to make this clearer for you.
If I accept Chris timing claim then the claim makes more sense assuming hes telling the truth about not seeing the topic before the explosion.
Hes also been more active which was my other issue.

What do you think of Chriss claim?

---

Corrik7 posted...

Back to HB, Lea, Puns.

What dont you like about potential best friend puns?

---