Board 8 > Eff 2019 Mafia: Topic 8 - And I Oop

(+) Yeah! (+)

easy Corrik, I'm not challenging your claim lol

was just trying to understand what went through your head. no biggie

Damn i was wrong about HB... but dude only tunneled Han and it was bad logic... oh well....

---

Actually yeah I guess I can claim now

The Houston Astros, TOWN Thief. We got busted for stealing signs in 2019

N1 Chris - Stole a Presidential Medal of Freedom. I thought he was scum for not saving red, and I thought it meant he got the Medal last year so I was sure I got him. But the character he claimed got a medal years ago and died last year, so I instantly bought his claim.

N2 Corrik - Stole purple drank. Seems to check out with his flavor claim at least

N3 Sultan - I'm holding this result until Sultan shows up

N4 Death - Stole Dr. Boom, which is a Hearthstone card so his claim checks out with his flavor as well. In hindsight, this was kind of pointless because he could have easily fake claimed miller with his real flavor >_>

---

oh hey Sultan, want to same time claim with my result?

---

MZero11 posted...

N3 Sultan - I'm holding this result until Sultan shows up

Im here mother fucka what you steal from me?

---

Alright Sultan let's claim at xx:45:00?

---

Scum thief, kill it.


---

MZero11 posted...

Alright Sultan let's claim at xx:45:00?

Lets go!

---

Psychic
Hans scumdar
Thief
Cop
Extra kill via congress.
Quad voter
Miller

Thats a pretty stacked team.


---

What were your reasons for checking those specific people?

---

I assume you stole some cat nip beacuse im

Grumpy cat Town Vanilla


---

Friskies cat food

---

If he is scum, you literally told him what to say. Lol so the same time was kinda pointless.

---

Okay so he checks out as theif atleast

---

benjamin3740 posted... What were your reasons for checking those specific people?

Corrik was suspiciously inactive the first two days and I usually have trouble reading him anyway. Sultan is also a tough nut to crack for me because he's all over the place. Death I thought was flying under the radar a bit with the miller claim, not that he wasn't participating but in that no one was looking at him

---

1) Ben - Psychic
2) Corrik - Doctor
3) Death - Miller
4) Han - Kid Pimp
5) MI - Quad Voter
6) MZero - Thief
7) Puns - Vanilla
8) Sbell - Vanilla
9) SultanOfSlam - Vanilla

How many players would need to be on the scum team for MI to be scum? Is 4 low enough? Because that's the big twist I can see existing in this game. One of Han or Mzero is scum, because four scanner type roles is just too much. Sultan is a sweet town boy and I would never consider lynching him. I only hope you all would do the same. Puns I still read towny. And I think back to the Suprak game with scum lawyer FD. Suprak's not afraid of scum roles that defy the meta we take for granted. MI has put all his votes on town lynches every day so far right? And he would feel comfortable doing it since his role confirms him.

We can prove though that MI IS town if he was targeted night 3 and Corrik saved him. And right now that is sounding likely, but then why was there no kill tonight with Corrik being roleblocked?


---

benjamin3740 posted...

1) Ben - Psychic
2) Corrik - Doctor
3) Death - Miller
4) Han - Kid Pimp
5) MI - Quad Voter
6) MZero - Thief
7) Puns - Vanilla
8) Sbell - Vanilla
9) SultanOfSlam - Vanilla

How many players would need to be on the scum team for MI to be scum? Is 4 low enough? Because that's the big twist I can see existing in this game. One of Han or Mzero is scum, because four scanner type roles is just too much. Sultan is a sweet town boy and I would never consider lynching him. I only hope you all would do the same. Puns I still read towny. And I think back to the Suprak game with scum lawyer FD. Suprak's not afraid of scum roles that defy the meta we take for granted. MI has put all his votes on town lynches every day so far right? And he would feel comfortable doing it since his role confirms him.

We can prove though that MI IS town if he was targeted night 3 and Corrik saved him. And right now that is sounding likely, but then why was there no kill tonight with Corrik being roleblocked?

Someone is lying.

---

Or MI is bulletproof 3rd party.

---

benjamin3740 posted...

Or MI is bulletproof 3rd party.

He could be 3rd party and would have to be bulletproof if so due to how much his role basically lends himself having to be town and being a scum target.

---

But 1 protection in 17 seems not right either. So, I assume someone is lying.

---

Plus that assumes they would shoot MI two nights in a row also for some reason

---

Puns and Han scum together would be so nice. Plus a thief claim makes basically 4 scanner claims. Tho why Mzero wouldn't have gone to Ben is like absolutely beyond my understanding.

---

Like mzero should have doubted them cuz too many scanning roles. And Ben could have confirmed it and he confirmed if Ben was lying too.

---

Mzeros claimed actions don't make sense. They are even worse than Hans.

---

So out of Mzero, Han and me, we all are proven to actually have the abilities we claim. It's just that 2 or more are scum with that ability.

It makes sense now why Mzero was saying yesterday that me and Han cannot both be town. He either believes it or had to say it so he could stick with his claim.

.... Mzero I need your help to take down Han >_>

---

I'm convinced ben is scum Psychic and I didn't want to reveal myself as town power. I mean, why do you think I ISO'd both of them yesterday and was on ben all day lol

---

1) Ben - Psychic fucked up his own claim
2) Corrik - Doctor makes sense but if role blocked how is MI alive today?,
3) Death - Miller.... well with the cop dead...
4) Han - Kid Pimp could have been faked
5) MI - Quad Voter -confirmed role but os it town?
6) MZero - Thief checks out.
7) Puns - Vanilla claimed mayor originally then changed to vanilla? (Faked 1 time faked a second time?)
8) Sbell - Vanilla idk maybe?


---

Psst Han we need to form an uneasy alliance to destroy Mzero

---

MZero11 posted...

I'm convinced ben is scum Psychic and I didn't want to reveal myself as town power. I mean, why do you think I ISO'd both of them yesterday and was on ben all day lol

You were convinced as early as the day I claimed it??

---

MZero11 posted...

I'm convinced ben is scum Psychic and I didn't want to reveal myself as town power. I mean, why do you think I ISO'd both of them yesterday and was on ben all day lol

If he is scum psychic, you reveal him as scum... You kill scum and confirm yourself town. Or your wrong and he confirms your power and you confirm his flavor is legit.

---

We could have had like a three way of town confirms man.

Actually we couldnt have because someone is scum.

How fun

---

benjamin3740 posted...

So out of Mzero, Han and me, we all are proven to actually have the abilities we claim. It's just that 2 or more are scum with that ability.

It makes sense now why Mzero was saying yesterday that me and Han cannot both be town. He either believes it or had to say it so he could stick with his claim.

.... Mzero I need your help to take down Han >_>

If sultan is scum, he isn't proven.

---

Honestly, if Mzero is scum and thief they likely didn't scan me til night 3 to roleblock me tonight. The results sound too vague to be real though. And he should have been all over blade's claim if he is Astros and didn't have 2019 in front and Blade did. Was he?

---

Mzero, on night 2 you chose to not go to me because you were so sure that I was scum that you thought visiting me would only out you as a moving town power and not get you any information you didnt already know?

---

Corrik7 posted...

Honestly, if Mzero is scum and thief they likely didn't scan me til night 3 to roleblock me tonight. The results sound too vague to be real though. And he should have been all over blade's claim if he is Astros and didn't have 2019 in front and Blade did. Was he?

Great point

---

But on the other side, why claim Astros after ur buddy alrdy claimed Tampa with scum year if u didn't do that also.

---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/78345391?page=1

He was around during and after it but didnt say anything about it.

And then you have another good point.

Guess Mzero should answer the question

---

Suprak the Stud posted...

VOTALS:
[6] Blade - (Scare), Chris, Ben, Puns, Han, Lea, Scare
[5] Scare - Blade, Sbell, MZero, (Lea), (Chris), (Ben), (Hb), Sultan, Hb
[2] Ben - (MI1), (MI2), (Scare), (Scare), (Chris), MI1, MI2, (puns), (Scare), (Scare)
[1] Han - (Chris), (Hb), (Ben), (Lea), Corrik
[0] Lea - (IGCD), (Han), (Death)
[0] Chris - (MI1), (MI2), (Corrik), (MZero), (Puns), (Sultan), (MI1), (MI2), (Scare)
[0] IGCD - (Chris), (Sultan), (Hb), (Ben), (Death)
[0] Han - (Hb)

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch! Day ends at 9 PM CST (5 minutes from now)!

Just realized this was a scum-scum lynch.

---

Even on the days MI doesn't lead the town lynch he ends on town wtf man

---

There isn't 4 investigative roles and if Han and Mzero both visit Ben night 1. It could town clear a 3. If doctor did also town clears 4 people. Logic dictates that Ben and Han cannot be town together. But, Mzeros actions just don't make sense either.

Suprak didn't put a role in that allows the game to break. So ben or Han is lying.

---

Han is maybe the likelier liar there. Cuz even if Ben is scum psychic. He kills himself or still has to confirm to Town all the town clears also. And Ben if be was smart would have known that if he claimed after Han.

Plus, Han is still alive.

But, roleblock meta is in Hans behavior.

---

But that may be why Han was roleblocked every night if Ben is legit. But the no kill tonight remains unexplained.

---

I am gonna ponder that one some. But Ben or Han has to be scum gamebreaking then. If no one claims a way to block the kill, then MI is Indy.

---

Corrik7 posted...

Honestly, if Mzero is scum and thief they likely didn't scan me til night 3 to roleblock me tonight. The results sound too vague to be real though. And he should have been all over blade's claim if he is Astros and didn't have 2019 in front and Blade did. Was he?

It's not really the same thing. My flavor is the entire organization. The Astros got busted for stealing signs a few years ago, so it wasn't specifically last year's team. I think Blade's claim was referring to specifically last year's Lightning team. I never thought it was a slip to begin with because specific teams are often referred to that way, such as "The 2007 New England Patriots" or "The 2015 Golden State Warriors". Also no one slips like that and puts their alignment in their flavor, like "I'm scum Mario, Town Jack". That makes no sense

---

benjamin3740 posted...

Mzero, on night 2 you chose to not go to me because you were so sure that I was scum that you thought visiting me would only out you as a moving town power and not get you any information you didnt already know?

Considering I was reading you scum before you claim, and I didn't think you would claim Psychic as not-psychic, I didn't feel like it was worth targeting you and outing myself. All I could prove is that you really were psychic, which I didn't doubt anyway.

---

MZero11 posted...

It's not really the same thing. My flavor is the entire organization. The Astros got busted for stealing signs a few years ago, so it wasn't specifically last year's team. I think Blade's claim was referring to specifically last year's Lightning team. I never thought it was a slip to begin with because specific teams are often referred to that way, such as "The 2007 New England Patriots" or "The 2015 Golden State Warriors". Also no one slips like that and puts their alignment in their flavor, like "I'm scum Mario, Town Jack". That makes no sense

Well you can't rule out slipping just because no one should ever realistically be doing it. There was no reason that I should have typed up the wrong name entirely for my flavor, but I did.

---

I mean, yeah I could get a thief result but I thought I could get Ben lynched without outing myself, but alas

---

Suprak the Stud posted...

No one died last night!

Everyone:
1) Ben
2) Corrik
3) Death
4) Han
5) MI
6) MZero
7) Puns
8) Sbell
9) SultanOfSlam

No One:
LD1 - red: Storming Area 51 and not even finding a single alien (a.k.a. Storm Area 51), TOWN Cop
KN1 - 5tarscream: Being unable to tell if you were the person in blackface or the Klan outfit because come on man it really could be either Im going to need some more specific dates on that one Ralph Northam, TOWN Vanilla
LD2 - IGCD: Lori Loughlin, TOWN Vanilla
LD2 - Scare: Baby Yoda, 2019 Adorable Meme
KN2 - Chris: Toni Morrison, TOWN Vanilla
KN2 - Lea: Elijah Cummings, TOWN Politician
LD3 - Blade: Greta Thunberg, 2019 Person of the Year (Role Swapper)
LD4 - Hbthebattle: Dexit, TOWN Vanilla

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch! Day ends at 9 PM CST on Tuesday!

GO GO GO GO GOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Let's assume that scum is things from 2019 that were not negative connotations.

Like Lori got caught usc cheating scans. Elijah died. Morrison died. Juice WRLD died. Houston caught stealing. Northam, not finding aliens.

And scum is positive things. Baby Yoda, Greta Thunberg in supraks mind.

Why exactly is the most popular meme of 2019 not a positive thing and why would you assume sultan is town based on the result.

---

MZero11 posted...

Considering I was reading you scum before you claim, and I didn't think you would claim Psychic as not-psychic, I didn't feel like it was worth targeting you and outing myself. All I could prove is that you really were psychic, which I didn't doubt anyway.

Aren't you thief? You could have proved whether my claim was fake or not

---

MZero11 posted...

I mean, yeah I could get a thief result but I thought I could get Ben lynched without outing myself, but alas

-__-

Was that a slip. That was a slip wasn't it

---