Board 8 > Eff 2019 Mafia: Topic 1 - 30 to 50 Feral Hogs

(+) Yeah! (+)

##NL

NO

LYNCH

KRU

amirite

---

This means we b8 special Scare confirmed

---

Let's talk about Ben, because I legit feel relatively confident he is scum and I haven't seen many people really talking about him.

---

confident why? because he hasn't contributed anything with merit?

TotallyNotMI posted...

Let's talk about Ben, because I legit feel relatively confident he is scum and I haven't seen many people really talking about him.

Has he really gave us anything to go on though he posted like 4 times half oh what where joking about him and scare being mason buddys for the upteenth time

---

Meow1000 posted...

This is the first post concerning me that I have flat out disagreed with, so let's have some fun.

Han calls me (and Red) scum, completely out of the blue. Han gives no reasons for any of this.

I call him out on this, he makes up some mason thing and calls even more people scum.

I call him out on making up the mason thing, and he retracts it, but doesn't change his supposed reads at all.

I push him again, and he calls me angry (Han knows what I look like when I'm angry, so again, he's making it up), but still doesn't give any specific reason for calling anyone scum, not even Red.

And you say I'm the one not contributing in the interaction?

This is almost certainly scum if Han is scum.

Literally everything Blade has said here is a lie.

TotallyNotMI posted...

When catching up I thought the blade votes were dumb. I thought blade would be more likely to just lose interest and AFK out and make all those votes just uselessly sit there.

Instead he went after 5tar.

This actually... feels like scum to me? Town Blade would be more likely to get annoyed and leave, scum blade stuck around to contribute? People who know blade better, talk to me about this.

This is basically my entire read from the get-go. Blade is a self-admitted player who doesn't care. He signs up for games so he can dick around on Day 1, make random reads later, and basically do nothing. Him as Town is the equivalent of having a text bot in the game.

After poking him, Blade turned on. But this vote is the absolute kicker.

Town Blade 100% accuses me of being Scum in this scenario, because he would know I was wrong. That's the limit of the effort Town Blade puts into games. He went after someone else here?

Ergo, Blade thinks I'm Town.

But Town Blade would think I'm Scum, here.

So Blade has to be Scum.

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Literally everything Blade has said here is a lie.

This is basically my entire read from the get-go. Blade is a self-admitted player who doesn't care. He signs up for games so he can dick around on Day 1, make random reads later, and basically do nothing. Him as Town is the equivalent of having a text bot in the game.

After poking him, Blade turned on. But this vote is the absolute kicker.

Town Blade 100% accuses me of being Scum in this scenario, because he would know I was wrong. That's the limit of the effort Town Blade puts into games. He went after someone else here?

Ergo, Blade thinks I'm Town.

But Town Blade would think I'm Scum, here.

So Blade has to be Scum.

Last game part of the reason he called me scum was for tunneling him all day

This game he calls me scum for learning from last game and not tunneling him all day its kind of funny

And I welcome anyone to read back on those pages. Han never gave a single reason for putting a vote on me outside of a completely separate game.

Anyways the only thing I can remember out of Ben was questioning me after I reinforced the Mason thing made me think the two of them were scum.

Not that Scare has done anything either.

---

It's more than just Ben didn't do anything and more the way he hasn't done anything.

Like, he was the only one who raised his hand at puns 'raise you hand if your town'. Nothing wrong with that, but he made a couple other posts first and then did it. In a way that was like 'oh man I can't not do this or it will look suspicious'. It just felt weird.

And then his fake 'oh man formatting is different' fake claim (Posts 91/92).

Then he seemed to be questioning a post I made, ignoring me when I asked what he meant by that, then when I prodded again said his first question was just a joke.

I guess long story short, everything Ben has posted has felt manufactured instead of natural to me.

---

The most curious thing about all this is Han seems deadset on making this day me vs. him and seems... Annoyed? That I'm not focusing all my attention on him.

We've never actually used a Lyncher here right

---

TotallyNotMI posted...

It's more than just Ben didn't do anything and more the way he hasn't done anything.

Like, he was the only one who raised his hand at puns 'raise you hand if your town'. Nothing wrong with that, but he made a couple other posts first and then did it. In a way that was like 'oh man I can't not do this or it will look suspicious'. It just felt weird.

And then his fake 'oh man formatting is different' fake claim (Posts 91/92).

Then he seemed to be questioning a post I made, ignoring me when I asked what he meant by that, then when I prodded again said his first question was just a joke.

I guess long story short, everything Ben has posted has felt manufactured instead of natural to me.

I don't even have a mental record of him doing that much


---

Which is fair, because nothing that Ben has done really warrants retaining that it was done.

---

Which is the problem.

Scare hasn't done anything of substance either, but Ben's done more without doing anything of substance.

---

Meow1000 posted...

The most curious thing about all this is Han seems deadset on making this day me vs. him and seems... Annoyed? That I'm not focusing all my attention on him.

We've never actually used a Lyncher here right

to be fair, you not being banned is annoying in and of itself. But you've put enough attention on me that you've convinced me of the read after poking.

And don't pretend like you can learn and do better either :P

---

Mayor and Miller in the same game sounds already boring powerwise

---

Oh man Lea posted on the wrong board again

We've almost got her now!

Just need it to happen once more to be sure.

---

Lea, be more careful. If you mess up a third time after what I just posted I'll have to actually vote for you.

---

Fuck.

---

The hell have I done anywhere near recently that warrants banning

I did stuff that warranted it several years ago if anything

---

Also that smiley feels tonally off but that's probably just me being biased.
TotallyNotMI posted...

Oh man Lea posted on the wrong board again

We've almost got her now!

Just need it to happen once more to be sure.

Nail her to a tree but don't invite Scare

---

Yessssssss Ben votes.

---

Ben and scare have alarmingly done nothing of substance wich is surprising for them both. Considering i usually fine them to be the most active... also who hasnt posted yet?

---

Everyone has at least posted, I believe.

---

implying that I was not already confirmed town to Scum Lea

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Ben and scare have alarmingly done nothing of substance wich is surprising for them both. Considering i usually fine them to be the most active... also who hasnt posted yet?

Scare the most active what

---

Leanansidhe posted...

Ben is not in my TOWN BOOK, the worst crime of all.

The real question is is Lea in your TOWN BOOK obv

---

But if Lea is scum, how can I trust Lea's opinion that Lea should be lynched?

---

I wanna be part of the club

##unvote
##vote: ben

I'm offended I have to apply.

---

I have connections. If you let me in I can get you a key to the city

Meow1000 posted...

Scare the most active what

Not this game i mean usually when they play they are among the most active this game they arent however

---

Death in general feels a little too concerned about being put off and not quite concerned enough about solving

The way Han has been arguing is far, far more biased than in previous games. Yes, I get it, you dont like Blade, but in earlier games you were able to put that aside, at least early on, and the way he argued that Town Blade wouldnt vote after 5tar makes little sense to me.
---

Oh, and Puns, can you paraphrase a bit of your flavor?
---

Joke about not getting majority vote and having to win twice. That's basically it then just says I am a mayor with police connections

I am actually scum BP mayor cop with a heart of gold

That was a... Very random mayor claim(I'm referring to the one like 40 posts ago not the recent joke). .

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Not this game i mean usually when they play they are among the most active this game they arent however

"Scare the most active what"

---

Hbthebattle posted...

The way Han has been arguing is far, far more biased than in previous games. Yes, I get it, you dont like Blade, but in earlier games you were able to put that aside, at least early on, and the way he argued that Town Blade wouldnt vote after 5tar makes little sense to me.

I'm not sure it's much worse than DR but honestly I barely remember the game or who was even in it.

What I would like to hear is what he has to say about the other people he was naming earlier. They seem to have gone completely out of focus now and we have yet to see anything meaningful on them.

---

Meow1000 posted...

I'm not sure it's much worse than DR but honestly I barely remember the game or who was even in it.

What I would like to hear is what he has to say about the other people he was naming earlier. They seem to have gone completely out of focus now and we have yet to see anything meaningful on them.

Ok remember RDR2 mafia, where you two went at it with each other and it turned out it was town/town? This feels like that- except Han is blatantly using bias and illogical appeals, which he didnt do as much then. Its out of character for him.
---

TotallyNotMI posted...

It's more than just Ben didn't do anything and more the way he hasn't done anything.

Like, he was the only one who raised his hand at puns 'raise you hand if your town'. Nothing wrong with that, but he made a couple other posts first and then did it. In a way that was like 'oh man I can't not do this or it will look suspicious'. It just felt weird.

And then his fake 'oh man formatting is different' fake claim (Posts 91/92).

Then he seemed to be questioning a post I made, ignoring me when I asked what he meant by that, then when I prodded again said his first question was just a joke.

I guess long story short, everything Ben has posted has felt manufactured instead of natural to me.

Nah I realized that no one had raised their hand (AFTER fully reading up) and wanted to stand out. So kinda the opposite BUT STILL SUSPICIOUS.

That was a joke about scum hinting their roles.

And that one was also a joke. HB said scum doesnt push jokes too hard or something.

On a serious note, no one has stood out to me in any way whatsoever. So good job guys. Totally not my fault!

---

Hbthebattle posted...

Ok remember RDR2 mafia, where you two went at it with each other and it turned out it was town/town? This feels like that- except Han is blatantly using bias and illogical appeals, which he didnt do as much then. Its out of character for him.

My memory for mafia games is shot more than ever, especially in the past couple of years.

That aside, I feel like he used logic and emotion equally that game, but this game is definitely more slanted towards the latter.

Better question is how this led to 5 votes on me.

Sultan voted me for an actual reason and has been proactive. Right now I like him. "Sultan is intentionally playing dumb" is an argument that gets used every game. He has moments like that, and they're null.

Then we have:

Chris immediately voted Sultan for voting me, may as well have told Lea to join on, then changed to me like 10 minutes later.

Scare voted me out of nowhere.

Lea followed Chris onto me.

This is probably not an all town threepack.

---