Poll of the Day > What gmes are 10/10 in your opinion?

(+) Yeah! (+)

Note: This doesn't have to be your favorite game, just what games are perfect or close to perfect?

edit: mother fucking typo in the topic title. "games" obviously
---

Portal 2 and INSIDE, ok?
---

Witcher 3 is best at what it is. FPS is either halo 2 or CoD modern warfare(first one). Racing changes depending on my mood.
---

Aculo posted...

Portal 2 and INSIDE, ok?

I can actually totally agree with portal. Such a great game.

I've never heard of INSIDE, but it looks like limbo? is that basically what it's like?
---

green dragon posted...

Aculo posted...

Portal 2 and INSIDE, ok?

I can actually totally agree with portal. Such a great game.

I've never heard of INSIDE, but it looks like limbo? is that basically what it's like?

It's from the same developer, and it shares a lot of similar control and design, for sure. INSIDE, however, blew my mind in ways I didn't think a game could any more, ok?

You should play, ok?
---

Superman on the Nintendo 64.

Celeste, BotW
---

Diablo 2, enter the gungeon, symphony of the night, link to the past, grand theft auto 5 (though I hate it)
---

Im sure if I really though about it, I could come up with more but lets start with

The Last of Us
Super Mario Bros. 3
Super Mario World
Street Fighter 2
Mass Effect 2
---

Dark Souls.

Earth Defense Force (any)
Forza Horizon (any)
Monster Hunter: MHFU, MHP3rd, MH3U, MH Generations
Hot Shots Golf (any)
---

Super Metroid
Bloodborne
RDR II
Link to the Past
Silent Hill 2
What Remains of Edith Finch
Super Mario World
SMB 3
Odyssey comes close for me
Driver: San Francisco
Rayman Legends

Probably some of the others mentioned and some that will be mentioned

---

The Last of Us
Uncharted 2 & 4
BotW

---

Super Mario Bros 3
Ocarina of Time
Metal Gear Solid 3
Skyrim
Breath of the Wild
Stardew Valley
Super Smash Bros Ultimate

Some very honourable mentions that are 9.8+/10 would include:

A Link to the Past
Super Mario World
Super Smash Bros Melee
Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door
Pokemon Firered
Pokemon Heartgold
A Link Between Worlds
Metal Gear Solid V
---

Dota 2
Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars
---

hypnox posted...

Witcher 3 is best at what it is. FPS is either halo 2 or CoD modern warfare(first one).

Withcer 3 is indeed a great role playing game, but the combat isn't the greatest (better than what most people say though).

Halo 2 is a good choice, but I think 3 was the better game. Halo 2 was "fresher", though (meaning it improved upon halo so much while 3 didn't really improve on 2 all that much imo).

MW is crazy good. Can't really disagree with you.

Aculo posted...

You should play

Ok!

-Komaiko54- posted...

Celeste, BotW

I haven't played celeste, but I've been meaning to. Botw is pretty close to perfect. It's crazy because Botw didn't really revolutionize anything (like how a lot of big nintendo games do), and just did a lot of things extremely well. I really wish there were more cities and a bit more life everywhere. Kinda wish you could dive as well.

DragonShumway posted...

Diablo 2, enter the gungeon, symphony of the night, link to the past, grand theft auto 5 (though I hate it)

I agree with all of these.
Gungeon is amazing. It really shows how much love and care the devs put into the game. the constant free updates were great. I wasn't a super big fan of the game, and mainly just bought it on sale to support the devs. Putting that much love into a game should be rewarded.

GTA5 is perfect. So much to do.

kangolcone posted...

Im sure if I really though about it, I could come up with more but lets start with

The Last of Us
Super Mario Bros. 3
Super Mario World
Street Fighter 2
Mass Effect 2

I've never played last of us or ME2. SMW is my favorite game of all time, and smb3 is right behind it. sf2 is fun, but the sequels improve upon it in every way imo
---

I wanna had a few of my own:

Persona 5- everything is just amazing. story is great, the presentation is great, music, characters, just everything

The world ends with you- one of my favorite ds games. Love the gameplay, extremely unique. Nothing like it. music is groovy
---

I've been on the fence with Persona 5. Hear great things about it, but the last entry I played was 2 on the PS1 I think... Have no desire to play 3 or 4 but 5 looks interesting

---

Oh Suikoden II is a definite 10 for me as well

And SotC remake. Love the original but the remake is bar none a better game

---

Mad_Max posted...

I've been on the fence with Persona 5. Hear great things about it, but the last entry I played was 2 on the PS1 I think... Have no desire to play 3 or 4 but 5 looks interesting

I like it more than 3, I haven't really played much of 4 so it isn't fair for me to say. I also haven't played the persona 1, 2 eternal punishment

It's more like the mainline SMT games in that you have to negotiate with demons to get them on your side. Honestly, you should try it out. It's cheap right now, or you can wait until the enhanced version comes out.
---

DirtBasedSoap posted...

The Last of Us
Uncharted 2 & 4
BotW

add halo 3 to this.

halo 3 is almost unplayable in the MCC though. seriously the worst hit detection in any shooter Ive ever played. 343i is such a pile of shit dev lol

---

LttP
Pokemon FRLG

And maybe Skyrim, although its glitches make it a bit hard to view as a 10/10
---

did you just take this from reddit lol

---

Castlevania SOTN
Final Fantasy 6
Metal Gear Solid 1-5
Morrowind
Skyrim
Fallout NV
The Last of Us
The Witcher 3
Kingdom Hearts
Tales From the Borderlands
Diablo 2
Final Fantasy Tactics

---

green dragon posted...

Mad_Max posted...

I've been on the fence with Persona 5. Hear great things about it, but the last entry I played was 2 on the PS1 I think... Have no desire to play 3 or 4 but 5 looks interesting

It's more like the mainline SMT games in that you have to negotiate with demons to get them on your side.

That's very appealing to me.
---

Aecioo posted...

did you just take this from reddit lol

People have been discussing "the perfect game" long before reddit existed
---

Xenobradu and Deuce Ex

ECW_Originals12 posted...

Xenobradu

wtf does this mean?
---

Aculo posted...

ECW_Originals12 posted...

Xenobradu

wtf does this mean?

I'm guessing he meant xenoburaido.
---

I think he means Faxanadu
---

Shin Megami Tensei Nocturne
Persona 3 Portable
Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver
Metroid Prime
---

Diablo 2
Morrowind
Don't Starve
Guild Wars
Dark Souls
---

Tales of Symphonia
Golden Sun + The Lost Age
Pokmon Crystal

All I can think of right now. I definitely liked some of the other games mentioned, but I would vehemently disagree with them being anywhere near 10/10 for some of them.
---

Pokemon Platinum (due to its immense postgame and underground areas)

pretty much any of the main series of pokemon games that are remakes of older games, but that feels like cheating.

wolfenstein enemy territory and diablo 2 probably come close to perfect. possibly mass effect and fallout new vegas.
---

Witcher 3
Gears 3
ME2
Saints Row 3
GTA San Andreas
Red Dead Redemption
Dragon Age Origins


---

Just because a game is perfect does not mean it is good/fun/interesting. That's the problem with using a rating scale to denote a game's proximity to perfection.

@Aecioo posted...

did you just take this from reddit lol

lmao, i actually did haha

@final_lap posted...

Just because a game is perfect does not mean it is good/fun/interesting. That's the problem with using a rating scale to denote a game's proximity to perfection.

I don't think anyone disagrees with you.

Nade Duck posted...

pretty much any of the main series of pokemon games that are remakes of older games, but that feels like cheating.

Emerald may be a 10/10 game for me. Not sure if ORAS were as good as it could've been, but they were still fun games.
---

Final Fantasy X
Forza Horizon 3
Grand Theft Auto V
Halo 3
Kingdom Hearts II
Portal 2
Super Mario Galaxy 2
---

IMO, the closest to perfection is Donkey Kong Country 2, and in recent times, DOOM (2016).
---

Pong
---

Utterly perfect, 10/10 games:

A Link to the Past
Xenoblade Chronicles 1
Suikoden II
Radiant Historia
Bayonetta 1

"Nearly perfect games, but not quite" Tier: A Link Between Worlds, Bayonetta 2, Final Fantasy Tactics, Suikoden I and V, Super Mario Bros. 3, Age of Empires II, Baten Kaitos Origins, Legend of Dragoon, Super Mario RPG, Command & Conquer Red Alert Retaliation, NieR Automata

Burnout 3: Takedown

---

La-Mulana 1 and 2, Crystalis, Faxanadu, Mario 3

...

That's about it
---

Essentially Perfect
Link to the Past
Baldur's Gate 1

Close to Perfect
Factorio
Death Road to Canada
Super Metroid

Flawed Masterpiece
Dark Souls 1-3

---

MGS, OoT. Two of the only games to ever get tens from EGM, a magazine that gave legitimate ratings in the 90s.

---

Battlefront 2 (og)
Battle for Middle-Earth 2
Sims 2
---

Off the top of my head, Baldur's Gate 1/2 and F-Zero GX
---

So many good ones but......my 10's.

Diablo II LOD, still fun to this day. I'm actually playing it again now, and have a friend playing it for the first time now, he likes it more then D3 (heh).

Final Fantasy 3 (6), still my favorite of the series. Have not played it in over 5 years now though.

Kingdom Hearts (the first one to me, is the best by far. Still have not finished 3).

World of Xeen (many of them are good but clouds/darkside combined is still the best for me. Love it).

Castlevania Symphony of the night (many like it, and tons of metroidvania games now, but still my fav).

Dungeons and Dragons Online (my favorite MMO of all time, not as good as it was, but still fun).

Super Mario 64 (Others are good fun, but this was new and awesome and is still fun today. Liked it better then Odyssey).

Waveracer 64 (Shrug, it was amazing for a racing game, I just played new similar games and just missed it so much).

Fallout 3/NV (I can't choose between them, but I love them both so much. I can't finish/play fallout 4 because I end up wanting to play 3/NV too much halfway through).

Borederlands 2 (I'm not a FPS guy, but love this game and played it a ton (and BL1 as well). I'm hoping 3 is even better (didn't like pre-sequel).

Some games, like the original phantasy star online, really should be on here considering how good they were originally, and how much I played them, but they don't hold up very well. Every one I mentioned is still a blast to play today.

Edit: I'm gonna add knights of the old republic 1 as well (II would beat it probably if you didn't need a mod to make it complete)
---

It's tough for me to call any game perfect.
Especially because you notice more flaws when you absolutely adore something.
Especially because most of my favorite games are lacking in certain aspects.