Board 8 > English Literature Mafia Topic 18: It Was the Best of Lynches

(+) Yeah! (+)

Nah Lopen is actually just scum

It's why I didn't scan him.

Let's take a look at my POE

- Lopen

And I only EVER put him on a town list because Chris told me to
---

benjamin3740 posted...

And are there any straight up evil characters in the Great Gatsby?

Objectively?

I dunno

I think they're all pretty awful characters

Camarija posted...

Lopen has been obviously Mafia sided all game

How so??

5tarscream posted...

Probably not the guy trying to clean the pool. Id say either Gatsby or the killer.
My lessons are starting

Did the flavor you receive confirm he cleans the pool? Because for example Pez claimed a character from 1984
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Nah Lopen is actually just scum

It's why I didn't scan him.

Let's take a look at my POE

- Lopen

And I only EVER put him on a town list because Chris told me to

I feel you

Independently, I think both 5tarscream and Death have good chances of being Mafia after going through my notes

turbopuns3 posted...

Camarija posted...

Lopen has been obviously Mafia sided all game

How so??

They've been supportive of mislynches and supported Red and Luis, and vice versa

Camarija posted...

They've been supportive of mislynches and supported Red and Luis, and vice versa

I'm not sure I understand.

turbopuns3 posted...

Cam, being good is multi-faceted

1) be accurate

2) get people to trust and agree with you

You're 1/2 =P

Maybe 7 more games here?

I'll admit I've been playing a bit trolly here so there's that

turbopuns3 posted...

Camarija posted...

They've been supportive of mislynches and supported Red and Luis, and vice versa

I'm not sure I understand.

ok

I was about to make a huge post but I don't want to make it seem like I want to lynch Lopen today

Because I don't

Obviously we are lynching death but I just want to understand the point you were making because I can't make sense of that sentence.

One could say trying to lynch the cop was incredibly scummy, but not in the way that integer overflows into being too scummy to be scum, but in reality Lopen is the only one not too cowardly to do what it takes

I wanted to lynch Ben but I wussed out on it

looks like that might be for the best

thass why you account for the possibility you might be wrong!
---

Not me, I'm never wrong

Lea3Lea posted...

but in reality Lopen is the only one not too cowardly to do what it takes

I'm offended

Wait

Is this sheepsaysmeep?

##unvote

I've made my point.

I'm feeling uneasy though. We start mislynching with people like Lopen and eyes must be turned towards the extensive power still alive.
---

@Sheep007 are you sheepsaysmeep?

I'm guessing no

turbopuns3 posted...

Obviously we are lynching death but I just want to understand the point you were making because I can't make sense of that sentence.

Right ok

Lopen had play that seemed to support Luis as someone to follow

Similarly Luis had play that seemed to support Lopen as someone to follow

They seemed to village read each other in a weird way

---------------------

It looked suspicious and I think Lopen is probably Town now

---------------------

Also, Lopen trying to lynch Benjamin over obvious Mafia was weird

And well, pushing those mislynches on Day 3 was weird too, but everyone is kind of guilty of that one

According to Luis, thank you Luis, we only have 3 Mafia to go now

So Death is one

then 2 more to go in this list:

1. UltimaterializerX
2. Lea3Lea
3. Benjamin*
4. SBell (Obellisk)
5. 5tarscream
6. Sheep (replaced Hbthebattle)*
7. Tom Bombadil
8. Lopen
9. turbopuns3*

*I believe Sheep should always be Town
*I believe Puns should always be Town
*I believe Benjamin should always be Town

That leaves 2 Mafia in this group of 6:

1. UltimaterializerX
2. Lea3Lea
3. SBell (Obellisk)
4. 5tarscream
5. Tom Bombadil
6. Lopen

I WANT Lea to be town so bad, but I can't help but feel they're nosediving a bit

I WANT Lopen to be Town, but they're playing just so bad

5tarscream's claim makes sense, especially since we saw Mafia have a bookreader already flip, hmmm
Probably ok, but, oof

I want to believe SBell is Town

Ulti? 5tar claimed to have Ulti cleared

I'm left with a whole lot of oof

UltimaterializerX posted...

##Vote: Death

Not even remotely up for debate. Especially after that nonsense yesterday where people actively tried lynching the cop. Just.... what.

Obviously mate

Don't end the day early

Anyway, if I can say I contributed anything this game, it was saving the Town Bodyguard

:pika:

Obellisk posted...

I know we have marked death waiting on the door step but.

##vote:5tar

Can someone other than 5tar reiterate exactly how he revealed his scans.

Keep in mind Lolo claimed to BG 5tar and Corrik claimed to use his ability on Lolo. Both confirmed town. Lolo would be an illogical scum kill yesterday, so 5tar is confirmed town.

By extension Tom is all but confirmed town.
---

It was the best of times

It was the blurst of times

Lopen posted...

Obellisk posted...

I know we have marked death waiting on the door step but.

##vote:5tar

Can someone other than 5tar reiterate exactly how he revealed his scans.

Keep in mind Lolo claimed to BG 5tar and Corrik claimed to use his ability on Lolo. Both confirmed town. Lolo would be an illogical scum kill yesterday, so 5tar is confirmed town.

By extension Tom is all but confirmed town.

No

Directly killing players is a thing

Camarija posted...

No

Directly killing players is a thing

What?
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

The explanation seems obvious. Corrik was telling the truth and his role delayed Lolos death.

That's what I said, yes.

Lopen posted...

Camarija posted...

No

Directly killing players is a thing

What?

You're clearing players based on who Lolo claimed he protected

However, Lolo could have just been directly attacked

UltimaterializerX posted...

If they scanned me as SK one of the claimed scum would have just outright said so on the way out, they wouldnt sit there and give my real flavor just because especially with how easy of a mislynch I could be given past behavior.

I wasn't saying you're SK I was saying 5tar could be on a mafia team who scanned you.

then you'd need an explanation for two kills tonight and no kills the previous night

and also why they'd wanna kill Lolo with two scanners on the board
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

One thing sticking out in my mind is I said to red during the part where he'd given up that if there really was an SK it would be ulti. Then the following day 5tar revealed a scan on Ulti.

"lol SK talk" but like I can't ignore this fact

If they scanned me as SK one of the claimed scum would have just outright said so on the way out, they wouldnt sit there and give my real flavor just because especially with how easy of a mislynch I could be given past behavior. And given were very ahead now (Death is pretty much 99.99% scum and I will not allow ANY other lynches), lol sk talk is no longer a valid criticism. Youre right to consider one. If we do have a third party though its not me.

Based on the night kills, I think us having a traditional serial killer is off the table. Theres no extra kills outside that second mafia kill on night 2, which is just way too many nights to hide at this point.

If I had to guess, *if* this game has a third party its probably Voldemort (Camarija) whose wincon is needing Harry Potter dead. Just a pure gut hunch. Cam is the clear lynch choice tomorrow unless a scanner says otherwise.

Dude, I don't want sheep lynched

I think they're always town

@htaeD If there is a 3P, who is it?

Tom Bombadil posted...

then you'd need an explanation for two kills tonight and no kills the previous night

and also why they'd wanna kill Lolo with two scanners on the board

(this in response to Cam saying they could've just shot Lolo)
---

Camarija posted...

You're clearing players based on who Lolo claimed he protected

However, Lolo could have just been directly attacked

Lolo being attacked directly night 3 is an illogical mafia kill
---

Tom Bombadil posted...

then you'd need an explanation for two kills tonight and no kills the previous night

and also why they'd wanna kill Lolo with two scanners on the board

OOOOHH

Yeah I understand now

Thank you

Sorry lol

ok, so 5tar is cleared Town now

UltimaterializerX posted...

Why wouldnt they just make something up then? Id be likely to flip out, or they might try to test it with a lie or something. At the very least, Im a very easy mislynch target. Scum removing me from their mislynch pile makes no sense.

Well to reirerate, I don't think this is likely. I was just doing due diligence considering things and then you started responding to my "unlikely" bits and I felt I should clarify the ways you were misinterpreting me.

And by extension, whoever 5tar claims they've scanned

Which includes... people?

[who has 5tar cleared so far?]

Wait, I think we can just close this game out today then?

@5tarscream

Who did you scan again?

Wait

Corrik said he was going to protect Lolo

Lolo said he would protect 5tar

Lolo's death got delayed, not 5tarscreams

There is no guarantee Mafia attacked 5tarscream and not Lolo

Ulti and Hb and me

Barring shenanigans it's pretty much down to the nilla squad (Death obv and you and lopen and puns and lea)

(sbell could be the godfather; ulti could be some sorta "flavor godfather" but that would be particularly silly)
---

Yeah, I'm not feeling the logic for how 5tarscream is cleared via corrik and lolo

Ugh, this game is going to be me and Puns in the final three with some third person isn't it

Mafia killing Lolo night 3 is absurd is what clears 5tar
---

Camarija posted...

There is no guarantee Mafia attacked 5tarscream and not Lolo

....Tom Bombadil posted...

then you'd need an explanation for two kills tonight and no kills the previous night

and also why they'd wanna kill Lolo with two scanners on the board

also 5tar is mostly cleared via me
also he is very unlikely to have bussed red in such a fashion
---

Lea3Lea posted...

Ugh, this game is going to be me and Puns in the final three with some third person isn't it

I don't think so

Game should be over in 3 game days

Just sheep me for victory