Board 8 > Sir Chris Music Mafia 7: Something Music Related

(+) Yeah! (+)

I did need to read that.

If I were to pick a Scumteam right now:

Sultan
Red
Tange
Ben

Alternates:
Panth/IGCD together
ColZach
---

I would be willing to bet at least ONE of those 7 people is Scum. Maybe more!
---

Red I need to hear something from you dude

Give me a case
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I did need to read that.

If I were to pick a Scumteam right now:

Sultan
Red
Tange
Ben

Alternates:
Panth/IGCD together
ColZach

Tange but not PJ/Sheep?
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I would be willing to bet at least ONE of those 7 people is Scum. Maybe more!

I mean, I'm definitely a bit of a gambling man but I'd probably bet a small house on it.

Also reminder that Tange can't be scum unless he's Godfather
---

I'll be honest, I forgot about the cop claim.

But yeah, let's say he's the godfather candidate.
---

EDumey posted...

i didnt need to read that

What was that

ScareChan posted...

Red I need to hear something from you dude

Give me a case

sorry dealing with some family stuff real quick. Need like 20 minutes to sort some stuff out before I can get back to the game(The stuff actively needs my PC).
---

Han you've literally been wrong on every single one of your reads so far.

Why does zach keep saying this?
---

htaeD posted...

Han you've literally been wrong on every single one of your reads so far.

Why does zach keep saying this?

He keeps railing on him out of spite for suspecting him, would be my guess

Of course its quiet now.
Well, in event of Red VS Sultan. I am inclined to pick Red.
---

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Sheep007 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Btw, even more supporting evidence of my theory is that 4 Red votes and the serious talk of lynching him happened directly after Sultan left.

Out of those 4 votes from my point of view only IGCD and Han are potentially suspicious. Puns is firmly Town to me and I would wager most of the game, so does this indicate you think I, Han and/or God are likely Scum too?

I think nobody objecting means scum is ok with it, which worries me.

Not a single one of us defended Red in the recent game where I was scum with him. We kind of avoided talking about him instead. And that's what this game feels like. Everyone quickly mentions him being likely scum and moves on.
---

Plenty of people tried to soft defend red tho. Or avoid him like sultan here.
---

htaeD posted...

Plenty of people tried to soft defend red tho. Or avoid him like sultan here.

Can you point out a post that was calling Red towny, or even soft defending? I don't count avoidance as a defense of the slot. Not a legitimate one at least. If Scum Sultan was trying to avoid scum Red then it's not something he meant for the public to catch on to.
---

Thats what I mean with soft defense.
And stuff like 'scum may want red dead because they're quiet'
---

benjamin3740 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Sheep007 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Btw, even more supporting evidence of my theory is that 4 Red votes and the serious talk of lynching him happened directly after Sultan left.

Out of those 4 votes from my point of view only IGCD and Han are potentially suspicious. Puns is firmly Town to me and I would wager most of the game, so does this indicate you think I, Han and/or God are likely Scum too?

I think nobody objecting means scum is ok with it, which worries me.

Not a single one of us defended Red in the recent game where I was scum with him. We kind of avoided talking about him instead. And that's what this game feels like. Everyone quickly mentions him being likely scum and moves on.

You played with Scum Red recently, how was he in that game?
---

htaeD posted...

Thats what I mean with soft defense.
And stuff like 'scum may want red dead because they're quiet'

Scum absolutely wants me dead. The opposite is literally an impossibility at this point.
---

htaeD posted...

Thats what I mean with soft defense.
And stuff like 'scum may want red dead because they're quiet'

Oh. Well that's the very paranoia that I'm addressing. So I don't count that either.
---

Also ben if I recall correctly town was cannibalizing themselves in that game.

Thats obviously not happening in this game. If I were scum there would be a plan. And it sure as hell wouldn't be sit and watch as town confirms like 60% of the game by day 3.
---

Its a way to defend red without 'defending him' tho. I do count that.

Also hey red. Claimtime?
---

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Sheep007 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Btw, even more supporting evidence of my theory is that 4 Red votes and the serious talk of lynching him happened directly after Sultan left.

Out of those 4 votes from my point of view only IGCD and Han are potentially suspicious. Puns is firmly Town to me and I would wager most of the game, so does this indicate you think I, Han and/or God are likely Scum too?

I think nobody objecting means scum is ok with it, which worries me.

Not a single one of us defended Red in the recent game where I was scum with him. We kind of avoided talking about him instead. And that's what this game feels like. Everyone quickly mentions him being likely scum and moves on.

You played with Scum Red recently, how was he in that game?

Like this. He was suspected for the same reasons basically and he was treated the same (Every person including me saying he's probably scum), only in that game he survived a long time because there were others who looked even worse. I wanna ask ask Death if he thinks the same - he was also scum with us.
---

Id stop railing on Han if hed stop being wrong.

Yall are right that me shooting at Corrik N1 was wild. Fantastic, a pipe dream, but it happened. Now we can use it to our benefit. If you dont want to believe me about it, thats fine (Tony) but I didnt have to claim with Sheep and I didnt have to try and confirm eaed.

Just saying.

htaeD posted...

Its a way to defend red without 'defending him' tho. I do count that.

Also hey red. Claimtime?

Not really, because literally everyone left to claim is vanilla and if they said otherwise it'd be insta-lynch on the spot.

Wait For It Hamilton
Town Vanilla

Honestly pointless claim, but also entirely pointless to hold onto.
---

So much wasted townpower. Its sad.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Sheep007 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Btw, even more supporting evidence of my theory is that 4 Red votes and the serious talk of lynching him happened directly after Sultan left.

Out of those 4 votes from my point of view only IGCD and Han are potentially suspicious. Puns is firmly Town to me and I would wager most of the game, so does this indicate you think I, Han and/or God are likely Scum too?

I think nobody objecting means scum is ok with it, which worries me.

Not a single one of us defended Red in the recent game where I was scum with him. We kind of avoided talking about him instead. And that's what this game feels like. Everyone quickly mentions him being likely scum and moves on.

You played with Scum Red recently, how was he in that game?

Like this. He was suspected for the same reasons basically and he was treated the same (Every person including me saying he's probably scum), only in that game he survived a long time because there were others who looked even worse. I wanna ask ask Death if he thinks the same - he was also scum with us.

Thats what I was getting at yeah.
---

htaeD posted...

So much wasted townpower. Its sad.

It is kind of depressing... An apparent N1 vig shot on Corrik of all people... Vig is such a fun role too. As little as PJ may have done (I'm pretty sure I've posted more already), I really can't complain about his scan choices.
---

Also ben if I recall correctly town was cannibalizing themselves in that game.

Thats obviously not happening in this game. If I were scum there would be a plan. And it sure as hell wouldn't be sit and watch as town confirms like 60% of the game by day 3.

reposting because this literally applies to two posts following and got ignored.
---

Sheep could have gotten away with more scans. But I cant blame him for getting tense about what he already was sitting on.
---

red13n posted...

Also ben if I recall correctly town was cannibalizing themselves in that game.

Thats obviously not happening in this game. If I were scum there would be a plan. And it sure as hell wouldn't be sit and watch as town confirms like 60% of the game by day 3.

reposting because this literally applies to two posts following and got ignored.

What part applies specifically?
---

htaeD posted...

Sheep could have gotten away with more scans. But I cant blame him for getting tense about what he already was sitting on.

Theres a watcher and a JK, he might just end up getting more still.
---

htaeD posted...

red13n posted...

Also ben if I recall correctly town was cannibalizing themselves in that game.

Thats obviously not happening in this game. If I were scum there would be a plan. And it sure as hell wouldn't be sit and watch as town confirms like 60% of the game by day 3.

reposting because this literally applies to two posts following and got ignored.

What part applies specifically?

All of it? Hell we knew we had the hide behind death as town does nothing plan going in full force that game. It was the plan. Theres always a plan. Were I scum this game, like hell is anything that goes on in this game part of some plan.
---

htaeD posted...

Sheep could have gotten away with more scans. But I cant blame him for getting tense about what he already was sitting on.

Yeah, that was the gamble I had to take. Initial thought was to play through it before I changed my mind, now with the current activity levels I'm feeling it might have been better to get another off. MZero and Tange were never going to be big targets anyway and I think people may have drifted off me regardless of if I claimed. I also got less disbelief of me than I was hoping, which leads me to believe I either got Godfather or scum already lost motivation, because pretty nicely showing 3 players as town at once has to be a blow. The only person really doubting what I said was Dumey.
---

red13n posted...

Theres a watcher and a JK, he might just end up getting more still.

That's what I'm hoping to do tonight. I'll probably be killed and Tony blocked again, but it's definitely possible.
---

What do you want then, red?
---

I don't think I doubted your scans?

I just didn't like your pre-claim strategy.

If I'm honest I think you should have held the claim for tomorrow, but that info in twilight only would be basically devestating to you.
---

EDumey posted...

I don't think I doubted your scans?

I just didn't like your pre-claim strategy.

If I'm honest I think you should have held the claim for tomorrow, but that info in twilight only would be basically devestating to you.

You're right, I misinterpreted something from earlier. My bad.
---

I don't really understand why Sheep claimed when he did but I don't see a good reason to want him dead right now either, so it's kind of just "a thing that happened" right now.

htaeD posted...

What do you want then, red?

I don't want to lynch sultan and that is making this tough to convince people otherwise.

People should know I don't have a hell of a lot of fire when lynches are set so day 1/2 were honestly just hard to bring much to the game and right now I'm pretty disappointed people are coming after me.

Honestly, I'm kind of fighting it because I was wrong so much last game that I don't know exactly where to go. Gut is telling me IGCD peacing out was extremely convenient but I'm having a lot of trouble getting stuff out.
---

red13n posted...

I don't want to lynch sultan and that is making this tough to convince people otherwise

Whats your opinion on Panth?
---

Well, then I am sorry we had 2 scumlynches so far?
I didnt get much of a read on you, but that also means I just cant trust you. Less than Zach or Sultan at least.

##Vote: red

Goodnight all.
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Might as well lynch the scum bg.

Hell look he even said this.

We know no one in this game is scumbg. It doesn't take much thinking to tell you there is no scum bg(It could be scum doctor, but bg is lol).

And yeah, Scare said it first, but Scare has momentary memory lapses like that all the time. And people that come up with dumb ideas are honestly less likely to be scum than the idiot that follows the bad idea.

And I've preached it all day, lynching panth makes no sense whatsoever. Hes the easiest lynch in the world to just wait until tomorrow and we are so far from risking a loss with a mislynch that given him a day to prove himself is worth the potential reward. (And scum blocking or killing him if he were town leaves scanners free to go nuts).
---

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

red13n posted...

I don't want to lynch sultan and that is making this tough to convince people otherwise

Whats your opinion on Panth?

I spent all day 1/2 telling you zam/leo/panth were all scum. We have what, 2 hours left? Don't waste my time.

The only reason we aren't lynching panth is because his claim dictates him 1 day of survival that we can more than afford and we know he isn't roleblocker.
---

Hey I lapse but I usually get it together
---

Red, do you have anyone on radar besides IGCD and Panth?
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Red, do you have anyone on radar besides IGCD and Panth?

not with any sort of conviction right now.
---

Ok. Then musings, with less conviction?
---

ScareChan posted...

Hey I lapse but I usually get it together

I mean, not to state the obvious but, he literally backed your lapse, and it was a pretty stupid lapse.

I would remind everyone how desperate scum has to be right now.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Ok. Then musings, with less conviction?

my musings got thrown for a loop by sheeps claim.
---

htaeD posted...

Well, then I am sorry we had 2 scumlynches so far?
I didnt get much of a read on you, but that also means I just cant trust you. Less than Zach or Sultan at least.

##Vote: red

Goodnight all.

Um... This was a pretty weak stance on a "goodnight" vote.

And Sultan probably isn't coming back is he

red13n posted...

ScareChan posted...

Hey I lapse but I usually get it together

I mean, not to state the obvious but, he literally backed your lapse, and it was a pretty stupid lapse.

I would remind everyone how desperate scum has to be right now.

Fair, but I do think scum doctor is on the table
---