Board 8 > A very important Jackbox poll

(+) Yeah! (+)

I have an inkling of which way this will go but I'm not sure
---

we reguarly play 3/4/1 for quiplash 2, survive the internet and Word Spud.

The other games are kind of trash.
---

You left out the best Jackbox game

But in terms of overall quality, PROBABLY 3 because Trivia Murder Party and Tee KO are a super strong double
---

that is a weird trio of games to be actively in favor of
---

Tokoyami posted...

You left out the best Jackbox game

But in terms of overall quality, PROBABLY 3 because Trivia Murder Party and Tee KO are a super strong double

what i miss
---

Gotta be 3 - it has Quiplash and only one bad for streaming game. You can pull up 4 whenever there's a Fibbage craving.
---

Monster Seeking Monster!
---

CherryCokes posted...

that is a weird trio of games to be actively in favor of

We like games where most of the content is made up by us.

Murder Trivia is ok but 90% of the time we all gather around and play while drinking and its just more fun to make up ridiculous questions and answer them or do ridiculous internet headlines. Word spud is one of those 'try to fuck the others' over type of game which can lead to hilarity.
---

oh i sure did

not sure it would have fit anyway though
---

That's ok. that game takes way too long to play sometimes anyway.
---

Man fuck a Word Spud
---

i've never played word spud. only ever played fibbage and drawful from 1
---

yeah, probably 3. Trivia Murder Party and Fakin' It are great, Tee KO is decent (though Drawful is much better)
---

1 is a solid game.
YDKJ is underrated.
---

It annoys me a bit that they made Drawful 2 a standalone
---

3 because it has some form of Quiplash (even if it's slightly inferior) and TMP and even an interesting unconventional one

But 4 is very close behind with Enough About You closely rivaling Quiplash (might be even better, I haven't played it that much), a solid drawing and jokey game, and even a mafiaesque
---

Word Spud is by far the most underrated jackbox game
---

With 3 and 4 around, I see no point ever going back to the second. The first at least has YDKJ. I definitely give the edge to 3; I like all five games there.
---

I didn't pick 3 because Trivia Murder Party is actual ass. Half of the questions require you to be American. Sure I'm not the best at trivia, but come on.
---

I adore Fibbage in general, plus MSM and Bracketeering are great. Survive the Internet is pretty good, and Civic Doodle isnt terrible (though it is pretty weak).

Havent played TMP yet sadly. I have soured on Quiplash but thats mostly because my group always goes for the meme answer instead of something genuinely funny. And I say this as someone who usually does the meme answer because Im bad at Quiplash and dont deserve to win.
---

Tee KO is awful wtf
---

Guesspionage is great though.
---

Zigzagoon posted...

I didn't pick 3 because Trivia Murder Party is actual ass. Half of the questions require you to be American. Sure I'm not the best at trivia, but come on.

y u mad bro
---

Zigzagoon posted...

I didn't pick 3 because Trivia Murder Party is actual ass. Half of the questions require you to be American. Sure I'm not the best at trivia, but come on.

It's designed so you get most questions wrong and still have fun. Only in the finale does trivia knowledge really matter a lot. I haven't really noticed the balance on those questions though.
---

so far the results largely reflect what I expected

though 4 is not doing as well as I thought it would
---

Eddv posted...

Tee KO is awful wtf

this
---

tee KO is by far the best jackbox game
---

Tee KO might be awful to me just because of my group.

Draw a penis and you win.

So then like 75% of the drawings are various dicks. My husband and I ironically are the only ones who get tired of it.
---

I'm also not a fan of MSM.
---

I feel like I've played about 10 games of Tee KO and seen a penis like, 2 times
---

it was an ironic penis
---

Tee KO's quality lives and dies on the players. It's either one of the best easily disappointing depending on how people play.
---

Yeah Tee KO is kinda fun. My friends aren't creatively bankrupt dickmongers though.
---

fishmongers
---

Fishmen come and go

Dicks are forever
---

Dicks come and go too
---

Oh grow up
---

Lopen posted...

Fishmen come and go

Dicks are forever

and when you combine the two

you win Best Picture
---

TRUST ME l KNOW.
---

3 and 4 are great. Voted 4 but it's really a toss-up

Also I just bought 4, so next time I host I'll have all games available
---

I feel like the people voting for 2 are the least vocal in this topic
---

My Immortal posted...

Tee KO might be awful to me just because of my group.

Draw a penis and you win.

So then like 75% of the drawings are various dicks. My husband and I ironically are the only ones who get tired of it.

This is a your group problem, not a Tee KO problem. Board 8 is just a better group.

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/87835278454050816/343612796891693057/unknown.png
---

Tee KO is bad for many other reasons, even if b8 is a good group that can make it fun
---

I originally voted 3. After looking at this it's hard to say. 2 has both the best 2 games Fibbage and Quiplash, but 3 has a lot of great games too. Might have to change vote to 2 based on overall quality of game. But 2 loses its luster since like like every pack has at least 1 of quiplash or fibbage. BUT I think I shouldve voted 2 instead of 3 because it has no duds and like I said both Fib/Quip. So.... objectively, yes.

Always want to play a round of one of these:
Fibbage 1/XL/3 (1/2/4)
Quiplash XL/2 (2/3)

These are really great also, maybe with some drawbacks:
YDKJ (1)
Drawful (1)
Tee KO (3)
Trivia Murder Party (3)
Bracketeering (4)
Earwax (2) [Underrated game]

These are still mostly fun but need the right crowd:
Monster Seeking Monster (4) <- This one could change the most on any given night I think.
Bomb Corp (3)
Fakin' It (3)
Fibbage: Enough About You (4)

The Bidiots Tier:
Bidiots (2)

I don't really get excited about these but I'll play them:
Guesspionage (3)
Survive the Internet (3)
Civic Doodle (4)

A Waste of Space:
Lie Swatter (1)
Word Spud (1)
---

no one ever talks about earwax or wants to play it.
I get way more enjoyment out of that game than anyone else i know
---

2 is great, I love all the games in it. Bidiots might be my favorite drawing game. Bomb Corp is surprisingly fun as well and tons of fun.
---

Bomb Corp is great with the right group of people

But terrible otherwise
---

Guesspionage is my underrated game. I love that one but nobody is ever interested in it.

Survive the Internet is always underrated and I don't know why.
---

Paratroopa1 posted...

Guesspionage is my underrated game. I love that one but nobody is ever interested in it.

Its probably my favorite jackbox game!
---