Board 8 > Dead by Daylight Mafia Topic 6 - Scanners

(+) Yeah! (+)

Chaeix posted...

like seriously why are we all just letting red off the hook here

Did you respond to my paragraph about Red? What exactly are we "letting him off the hook" from?

I know this is a thing that we struggle with every single mafia game, but wanting to dive off of the people we might actually have information and can make some informed reads on, and onto a player you think is inactive, just isn't appealing at all. Like yeah, we have to have a way of dealing with lower activity players at some point. But I gotta have an argument to vote someone, personally.

I have a question. Are we sure FD is actually dead?

It doesn't say FD died. There is a ? Not a K. What if he is still in the box and remains there as long as JC lives and he continues to lie to us regarding it. What if FD actually can come back to us still?

Corrik7 posted...

It doesn't say FD died. There is a ? Not a K. What if he is still in the box and remains there as long as JC lives and he continues to lie to us regarding it. What if FD actually can come back to us still?

Thought FD somewhere during the day said he killed FD which I guess he wouldn't have to say if he was scum just leave the ??? Right?

""""Isquen (Topic Creator)11/3/2023 8:00:11 PM
#309
The Chain Hunt continues, and votes are still locked in place. In the distance, a small light in the shape of a cube shimmers and becomes visible for all players. Looks like it's the source of the chains.

At any time before the start of Day 3, a player may now pick up the box and solve it by posting:
"##Solve: The Box"

Doing so will have the player run to The Box and attempt to solve it. This will end the Chain Hunt for all other players but the solver.

Votals:
Sbell [1]: Wallz
Ashe [1]: Corrik

With 15 players alive, there are 8 votes required to condemn a player.

If The Box is solved, Day Actions may be submitted until one hour before the end of day, which is currently scheduled for Nov. 4, 2023 at 9:00 pm Eastern.""""

nothing here really says he is dead. Why is anyone believing JC regarding this?

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Thought FD somewhere during the day said he killed FD which I guess he wouldn't have to say if he was scum just leave the ??? Right?

If he can revive if his Box ruler dies, why would he tell us this. He would want us to believe he is dead for good already.

Nothing here says he ever had an option to even spare. This could be made up as well. He is just trapped.

EDumey posted...

Did you respond to my paragraph about Red? What exactly are we "letting him off the hook" from?

I know this is a thing that we struggle with every single mafia game, but wanting to dive off of the people we might actually have information and can make some informed reads on, and onto a player you think is inactive, just isn't appealing at all. Like yeah, we have to have a way of dealing with lower activity players at some point. But I gotta have an argument to vote someone, personally.

red has not engaged with the last two days of game. it's not that he's been inactive, it's that he's been active but has demonstrated absolutely no mental flexibility or willingness to entertain possibilities about my role. you believe i'm scum, but you've discussed it with me. red has just come in and said 'jc's role is scum'.

Like, why bother even asking me to clarify the order of events if the answer isn't going to change your view? Clearly it wasn't, because he asked the question and then stopped caring about the answer. red's mind was not open to being changed, so why was he asking questions?

say that you're alive d4 with red, what has he given you today to work from? he just goes 'oh well i guess i was wrong about jc' and you have absolutely nothing. he is deliberately hiding in the background coasting on my lynch because it's easy.

as far as i am aware FD has just been completely removed from the game, including all chats he may have been a part of. if he comes back it's a surprise to me.

also it would be dumb for him to come back given my role caused him to win

like how can he win and come back

Corrik7 posted...

If he can revive if his Box ruler dies, why would he tell us this. He would want us to believe he is dead for good already.

Nothing here says he ever had an option to even spare. This could be made up as well. He is just trapped.

Do respect the fight though if he is indeed scum or 3p

Chaeix posted...

also it would be dumb for him to come back given my role caused him to win

like how can he win and come back

Nothing you say here means anything. You would be saying this regardless if I am completely right or not.

Corrik7 posted...

Nothing you say here means anything. You would be saying this regardless if I am completely right or not.

don't pretend i don't have to still say it to address your conjecture which means even less

@hosts can we have votals

if i get lynched as town because half the people on me think i'm independent and half the people on me think i'm scum i will literally lol

save_us.changmas

Chaeix posted...

don't pretend i don't have to still say it to address your conjecture which means even less

Actually I'm talking around you to others. You just keep trying to butt in.

Corrik7 posted...

Nothing here says he ever had an option to even spare. This could be made up as well. He is just trapped.

This is the part where Sultan's info that Pinehead cheats comes into play.

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80613325

At work, migrate at 450.

EDumey posted...

This is the part where Sultan's info that Pinehead cheats comes into play.

Yeah he is third party. I'm positive.

Honestly JC when I have questions about things that may have gone over my head at a time its easier to just ask than go digging.

Leafeon13N posted...

Honestly JC when I have questions about things that may have gone over my head at a time its easier to just ask than go digging.

i mean yes it's easier to ask than to dig but what is that an excuse for? you asked me a question, i told you where the answer was, and you clearly didn't care about the answer since you formed your entire opinion without feeling like you had to follow up and get that answer.

##Vote: JC

For FD.

HOST ERROR WARNING

"FD has been dragged off to hell."

END HOST ERROR WARNING.
(In short this should've been information when it happened at the end of day 2. Apologies for influencing votes by neglecting to do so.)

so uh

does the above change anything >.>

I don't even think it was necessary to say that, but appreciated anyway? Lmao. I thought the possibility of FD coming back was 0.000000000000001% in my books.

Leafeon13N posted...

Honestly JC when I have questions about things that may have gone over my head at a time its easier to just ask than go digging.

I think JC is referring to this:

Chaeix posted...

My intuitive trait said that I would get some clue to some grand mystery (paraphrased) at the start of the night, and gave me the ability to use my Elliott action contingent on surviving until morning.

What were you looking for exactly?

I could answer for Red because I think I was looking at the same thing when that happened, but I'll let him respond for himself.

I don't even know what is going on?

What's the votals

EDumey posted...

I could answer for Red because I think I was looking at the same thing when that happened, but I'll let him respond for himself.

honestly i read back i'm not sure what hes referring to in the old topic. He didn't make it clear when he was Pinhead. He claimed knowledge of the switch which at least to me was way the fuck out of left field. And then he was claiming to use an ability he shouldn't have had access to until the switch with night actions confirmed host locked at 24 hours, before the switch. And we don't have a game reason to not just hide this ability til the switch(Or make it wait an extra day for use).

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I don't even know what is going on?

Are you here to burn Sultan or are we just going to stay vague.

Gosh, I honestly don't know who to kill. I see arguments for, in alphabetical order, Brohan, Death, Ethan, JC, Red, and Sultan.

Also I think FD is definitely dead, based on that clarification. Based on how the role works and how JC played it, it doesn't make much sense to be a town role. He could just have played it badly.

But if someone is definitely suspicious, it's Brohan. At the same time, what does lynching him tell us? Not much. The goal is to win the game, though, so maybe...

##vote: Brohan

Claim please.

BCT don't mean to ruin your thunder here but it feels too late for tangents.

red13n posted...

honestly i read back i'm not sure what hes referring to in the old topic. He didn't make it clear when he was Pinhead. He claimed knowledge of the switch which at least to me was way the fuck out of left field. And then he was claiming to use an ability he shouldn't have had access to until the switch with night actions confirmed host locked at 24 hours, before the switch. And we don't have a game reason to not just hide this ability til the switch(Or make it wait an extra day for use).

my intuitive trait gave me access to the post-switch ability before the switch, that was the whole point of the trait. pretty straightforward. I knew I was going to switch when I got the PM at the start of N1.

unless you think Im making up that part because ???

red13n posted...

BCT don't mean to ruin your thunder here but it feels too late for tangents.

like sorry how is stop scum hunting a town post

Chaeix posted...

like sorry how is stop scum hunting a town post

That wasn't stop scum hunting. Thats "we arent lynching out of left field an hour left in the day".

BCT is town.

red13n posted...

That wasn't stop scum hunting. Thats "we arent lynching out of left field an hour left in the day".

There is hardly a consensus on me. You guys cant even agree if Im scum or Indy. get off your high horse

Chaeix posted...

There is hardly a consensus on me. You guys cant even agree if Im scum or Indy. get off your high horse

You aren't even the consensus. We have options Brohan just isn't really one of them right now. If we wanted that route we had 47 hours to talk about it.

Chaeix posted...

You guys cant even agree if Im scum or Indy.

Doesn't matter. And this is the second time you like tongue in cheeked you are 3p now.

red13n posted...

Are you here to burn Sultan or are we just going to stay vague.

I'm going to vote for whoever death is on, he's hounding me and he can't be upset if I end where he ends.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I'm going to vote for whoever death is on, he's hounding me and he can't be upset if I end where he ends.

You are a puzzle IGCD.

red13n posted...

You are a puzzle IGCD.

A puzzle box you say?

Just got back and need to catch up, but only a few pages.

Corrik7 posted...

Doesn't matter. And this is the second time you like tongue in cheeked you are 3p now.

why would I include town on that list when you arent entertaining it, dont pretend that was a slip.

general apologies for my irritability this game everyone, I am cutting nicotine out at the moment. Not an excuse, just context

So is ashs lie the main reason people are on him generally?

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I'm going to vote for whoever death is on, he's hounding me and he can't be upset if I end where he ends.

Is death even here?

Death is not here and left his vote on ash

Chaeix posted...

So is ashs lie the main reason people are on him generally?

I think so. I'll let everyone speak for themselves though.

People can definitely yell at me when the game is over about it.

hello everyone i am in fact back in time for the deadline woohoo

and a brohan lynch may still be viable. let me make my case

Chaeix posted...

Death is not here and left his vote on ash

So then I'm going to vote Ash.

I do find it odd though that death gave me three different players to vote instead of the person he is on.