Current Events > 35,000 Jews travel to Ukraine to celebrate the new year despite Russian attacks.

(+) Yeah! (+)

80/80

Unfazed by the bombs, undeterred by the warnings, and in the face of the raging conflict, more than 35,000 ultra-Orthodox Jews from across the world have journeyed to Uman, Ukraine, to celebrate Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish new year.

Going to celebrate in a war zone en masse is crazy, said Azoulay Ruben, a 22-year-old trainee dentist from Paris. But at the same time, its a beautiful thing.

Rosh Hashanah is a two-day holiday that falls in September or October, marking the beginning of the high holy days. In Israel, it is usually celebrated with family visits and food: traditionally, apples dipped in honey are eaten to symbolise hopes for a sweet year ahead.
For followers of the rabbi Nachman of Breslov, however, Rosh Hashanah is a chance to party. Nachman, a great-grandson of the founder of what is today broadly known as Hassidic Judaism, a branch of ultra-Orthodoxy, spent the final months of his life in the Ukrainian city of Uman, 125 miles (200km) south of Kyiv, and died in 1810.

In 1941, the Germans deported the entire Jewish community in Uman, murdering 17,000 Jews and destroying the local Jewish cemetery, including the burial place of Nachman, which was eventually recovered and relocated. About 1 million Ukrainian Jews were killed in the Holocaust.

More than 200 years after Breslovs death, the sect still makes pilgrimages to his tomb on Rosh Hashanah, when it is believed those who pray over it will be atoned for their sins. Today the celebrations often involve loud music, trance-like dancing and heavy use of alcohol and drugs. Ukrainian police on Friday arrested four Israeli nationals suspected of drug possession at a crossing point outside the western Ukrainian city of Vinnytsia, Ynet reported.

Many come here to pray, says Natan Ben Noon, the chief rabbi of Uman. But I assure you that 80% of the visitors are not religious. They come here just to have fun.

Each year it is as if an ultra-Orthodox slice of Jerusalem had been transported to the quiet city of Uman, with its population of 80,000. The streets are filled with shops that gladly accept payments in shekels, men are dressed in long black coats or white prayer robes, and advertisements and street signs are written in Hebrew. However, before turning on the techno music, at midday it is time to gather in prayer on the street for the Tikkun HaKlali (the general remedy), with thousands of worshippers reciting in unison a set of 10 verses from the Psalms.

Israeli and Ukrainian officials pleaded for worshippers to stay away this year. Israels prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, and the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelenskiy, who is also Jewish, spoke last week in a conversation in which the Ukrainian leader made it clear that there were not enough shelters in Uman for local residents, let alone foreign tourists.
The city was last hit by Russian missiles in June, while in April 23 civilians were killed, including three children, after more than 20 long-range Russian missiles struck a residential neighbourhood.

Israeli citizens who are travelling to Ukraine need to act responsibly regarding their trips at this time, Netanyahu said in a statement. God hasnt always shielded us, especially in Europe It must be understood that in Israel, when missiles fall on us, citizens enter shelters and there is protection. There, there are no shelters and no protection.

Despite the warnings, as of Wednesday more than 35,000 foreign visitors had arrived in Uman, the majority from Israel, and others from France and the US.

In Israel, we are used to situations like these, said Rabbi Ben Noon, who moved to Uman from Israel in 1988. And I think this is also an opportunity for Ukraine. Its important for them to show the world they are in control of the situation and that the show must go on.

I come from a city near Ashdod do you think we dont know what it means to live in a war zone? said one of the pilgrims, Ohad Ginzburg, 31. We have air raid alarms too. I dont take sides in this war. Ukraine says lies about Putin, and Putin says lies about Ukraine. Its none of my business.

The vast majority of pilgrims are men, often accompanied by their children, some as young as three years old. Chaya Sadon, 29, from a town near Tel Aviv, was one of the very few women.

Its really exciting to be here, she said. Last year, there was still a war, yet nothing happened. We are not coming here with no purpose. We came here to stay in a holy place.
Ukraines Centre for Countering Disinformation this week used Telegram to expose what is said was false information being spread by Moscow that Ukraine was preparing a terrorist attack in Uman, for which it would then blame the Russians.

The arrival of thousands of Jewish pilgrims in Ukraine does not help the Kremlins propaganda, which has persistently claimed the need to denazify the country since it launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022.

However, Ukrainian authorities fear that Russian saboteurs could infiltrate the crowds and intentionally create problems to then blame Kyiv. Approximately 1,000 law enforcement officers have been deployed and an additional 24 bomb shelters set up to ensure the safety of the pilgrimage.

Its a problem, says Alexander Khmara, a 34-year-old Ukrainian Jew and member of the Magen Ukraine, a community group that coordinated with regional police to patrol the streets. Weve set up a checkpoint at the entrance of the main road. We are here to check every individual coming in and out. And to monitor that there are no individuals among the visitors with the intention of provoking the crowd and then saying: See, the Ukrainians are Nazis.

This years Rosh Hashanah celebrations in Uman come after a diplomatic spat last month in which Ukraines ambassador to Israel accused the Jewish state of deporting Ukrainian refugees and denying Ukrainian nationals entry.

Tens of thousands of Ukrainian and Russian nationals have sought shelter in Israel since the war began.

Full Article: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/sep/15/ultra-orthodox-jews-celebrate-rosh-hashanah-uman-ukraine-pilgrimage

https://youtu.be/hvUjua0S7D8?si=IozggzOKQ2emu7d3

https://i.imgur.com/sTuMfQI.jpg

I like how they even managed to slip a "Both Sides!"er in there

Erm isn't that kinda callous of them?

Religion makes all kinds of people do stupid stuff.

B-b-but Ukraine os full of Nazis, Putin said so! Why would the Jews celebrate the new year in a Nazi land?

/s just in case, this board is really dumb sometimes.

They are not normal Jews, they are ultra-Orthodox!

Lil_Bit83 posted...

Erm isn't that kinda callous of them?

I think the intent is solidarity. Like so many Jewish holidays are celebrations of survival, so in the face of Russian aggression, Jews are going to Ukraine to celebrate Rosh Hashanah in defiance of the terror and aggression of the Russian military.

Jewish people have faced annihilation so many times, including in Ukraine where - as the article states - over a million Ukranian Jews were murdered in the Holocaust. So to stand up and celebrate where a world leader is trying to forcibly eliminate an entire people is to flip Putin and Russia the bird and to say "eat shit, you're not getting rid of anyone you fascist cocksuckers".

Now whether it's a wise idea to venture into an active warzone, I don't necessarily agree with. But more power to them for showing up and making the statement.

BewmHedshot posted...

Religion makes all kinds of people do stupid stuff.

I think about this a lot lol. I work in the service industry right now, and every once in a while Ill get customers calling in who are like I need someone to come service my heat / air conditioning! and Ill be like ok, I can get someone there this afternoon and theyll be like oh I cant do that because of [holiday] and its like I cant do anything because were booked until then.

Like you cant have it both ways. It seems insane to me that people would let religion have that much control over their lives and have the nerve to give people a hard time over their choices like that.

Foppe posted...

They are not normal Jews, they are ultra-Orthodox!

....

You know that's a thing right?

I wonder if some of them will be conscripted and sent to fight for Ukraine.

RiKuToTheMiGhtY posted...

I wonder if some of them will be conscripted and sent to fight for Ukraine.

They won't be.

Props to them for being willing to face danger for what they believe in.

Like one poster said, Jews would not be heading to Ukraine if it was a Nazi hotbed. I think this should maybe receive a little more focus on account of that. I know the claims are and always have been bullshit, but this makes a good "What now?" retort against anyone still clinging to that false claim.