Board 8 > Mega Man Music Mania: Nominations! [mmmm]

Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
andylt
09/10/23 8:00:00 AM
#201:


9 HOURS REMAIN!

As a reminder here's the links you may find useful. The current standings are on the spreadsheet, as are your current noms if you want to check how many you have left. And remember we're going for a 64 track bracket!

Nominations playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLFj0gJtesYY8CGYDIOmO9arJPGW7lh-ex
Spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1viuS_a8XnAOaqEm4X7obUJ3DQY0JPoXnZD7NVgcBHys/edit?usp=sharing

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Place
09/10/23 9:08:16 AM
#202:


SUPPORT:
Prologue-Awakening Road ~OPENING:HIGHWAY STAGE~ (ROCKMAN X ALPH-LYLA with TOSHIAKI OHTSUBO)
Ground Man Stage (Unlimited Overdub Mix) (Chiptuned Rockman)
Primrose (Mega Man X8)
Gravity Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Network is Spreading (Mega Man Battle Network 3)

Still working out the rest.

---
Hi. I wanna play you something.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Place
09/10/23 9:41:11 AM
#203:


Ok fine let's see where this goes
NEW (DOUBLE):
Final Slot-In (Rockman.EXE N1 Battle) | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0o67IoZiV8&list=PL05AE7E37084680FD

---
Hi. I wanna play you something.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Prince46
09/10/23 10:44:01 AM
#204:


Haste_2 posted...
ADDITION: I wanted to send a thought about the cutoff point for qualifying for the tournament (the bubble): it would be great if doubles were treated exactly the same as two unique noms. The reason for this is that we each only have one double, so I feel it really needs to count. It could be disappointing for many otherwise. Granted, this may not matter if we just do play-in matches.

I support this, and if there is a sizeable number of doubles + 1, consider giving some spots to them
... Copied to Clipboard!
Isquen
09/10/23 12:06:14 PM
#205:


Meh, I have to work at ending cutoff, so signal boost using my double on my own nomination.

Double
Plague Man stage (Mega Man Rock Force)

Will browse to use my others if I get an opportunity, but given a festival is in town I sorta doubt it.


---
[Rock and Stone] <o/
... Copied to Clipboard!
Leonhart4
09/10/23 12:25:58 PM
#206:


so how many fangame songs are getting in

---
https://imgur.com/WqDcNNq
https://imgur.com/89Z5jrB
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 12:40:43 PM
#207:


Actually, all non-fangame songs will be disqualified and replaced with the OST of Viewtiful Joe. Did I forget to mention that in the rules?

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Leonhart4
09/10/23 12:46:48 PM
#208:


well I was assured fangame music wouldn't take over the contest so I wanted to confirm this was the case

---
https://imgur.com/WqDcNNq
https://imgur.com/89Z5jrB
... Copied to Clipboard!
pjbasis
09/10/23 12:54:10 PM
#209:


Now Viewtiful Joe music is gonna take over the contest.

Which I'm fine with let's do that with all of these

---
http://i498.photobucket.com/albums/rr345/Rakaputra/B8%20Girls%202012/pjbas.png
... Copied to Clipboard!
azuarc
09/10/23 1:01:59 PM
#210:


Randomly supporting things I see in the sheet because eh why not.

Armored Armadillo (Mega Man X)
Vs. Lumine 2nd Form (Mega Man X8)
Quick Man Stage (Mega Man 2)
Infinity Mijinion Stage (Mega Man X6)
Storm Eagle stage (Mega Man X)
Metal Man Stage (Mega Man 2)
Sigma Stage 1 (Mega Man X)
Dark Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Air Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. for 3DS & Wii U)

---
Only the exceptions can be exceptional.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Natalie
09/10/23 1:52:20 PM
#211:


Support:
Final Slot-In (Rockman.EXE N1 Battle)
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 3:00:17 PM
#212:


2 hours left!

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Isquen
09/10/23 3:13:17 PM
#213:


Support:
Solar Inferno (Solar Mans Stage) (Mega Man 10)

---
[Rock and Stone] <o/
... Copied to Clipboard!
illuminatusbubu
09/10/23 3:27:36 PM
#214:


Apple Market (Mega Man Legends)

Anata no Kaze ga Fuku Kara (Rockman DASH)
Storm Eagle stage (Mega Man X)
Central Highway (Opening Stage) (Mega Man X)
Flutter vs. Gesellschaft (We are ROCK-MEN!)
Shadow Man Stage (Mega Man 3)
Frozen Island (Blizzard Mans Stage) (Mega Man 6)
Pharaoh Man Stage (Mega Man 4)
Dr. Wily Stage 1 (Mega Man 2)
... Copied to Clipboard!
MacArrowny
09/10/23 4:02:04 PM
#215:


Gravity Beetle Stage (Mega Man X3) this is a double
Armored Armadillo (Mega Man X)

---
All the stars in the sky are waiting for you.
... Copied to Clipboard!
NFUN
09/10/23 4:03:55 PM
#216:


double free mode

---
What can the harvest hope for if not for the care of the Reaper Man?
... Copied to Clipboard!
th3l3fty
09/10/23 4:12:28 PM
#217:


support Zero Stage 2 (X5)
support Farewell to Ballade (10)
double Opening, Snakeman (Chiptuned Rockman)

---
thelefty for analysis crew 2008 imo -transience
I have a third degree burn in flame-o-nomics -Sir Chris
... Copied to Clipboard!
Disillusion
09/10/23 4:30:22 PM
#218:


So I completely forgot this was happening, not that I could've contributed much since Mega Man is a weak spot of mine for VGM.

Shame that the original Gravity Man never got that much traction, that would've been the one nomination I would've gone all the way with.

Instead, here's my two cents for this whole thing:

Supporting:
Tundra Man Stage - Instrumental (Mega Man 11)
Gravity Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
GIVE IT A SHOT (Mega Man X Legacy Collection)
Internet World (Mega Man Battle Network 2)
Electrical Communication (Full Size) (Mega Man 8)
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 4:45:07 PM
#219:


15 minutes remain!

Supports:
Dr. Wily Stage 1 (Mega Man 2)
Bubble Crab Stage (Mega Man X2)
Wily Stage 1 (Mega Man 7)
X vs. Zero (Mega Man X5)
Thunder Tornado (Tornado Mans Stage) (Mega Man 9) (upgrading to double)


---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
DireKrow
09/10/23 4:46:44 PM
#220:


If there isn't a clean cutoff, will the rest be selected randomly?
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 4:48:17 PM
#221:


The TB process will depend on how many tracks are in play for how many slots. I was planning on a play-in, but if we have 50+ songs competing for 10 slots, then... we'll see >_>

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 4:50:44 PM
#222:


And my last support goes to:

Enigma of Aqua (Mega Man Unlimited)

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Dels
09/10/23 4:51:14 PM
#223:


so basically, if someone wanted to, they could go through the list of tracks with only 3 noms and pick 15 of them to boost them to 4 and guarantee they get in?
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 4:52:11 PM
#224:


In theory. Though there's only 13 slots left below 4 noms now!

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Dels
09/10/23 4:54:02 PM
#225:


well i won't do that. but if i did, it'd be funny that one person had the power to singlehandedly decide which 3-noms make it in instead of them having to go to whatever the play-in/tiebreak stage would be, which would be much more democratic
... Copied to Clipboard!
sergiocornaga
09/10/23 4:54:52 PM
#226:


Adding support for:
+ Duff Mcwhale [Unused theme] (Mega Man X5)
+ We're the Robots (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
... Copied to Clipboard!
UF8
09/10/23 4:58:10 PM
#227:


last minute noms no i totally didn't sleep in too late
Rise The Curtain (Rockman 1 Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA) | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=juHSJAaR9GM
Exotic Somewhere (Rockman 6 Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA) | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJQ0uLwDn10
Show Your True Face (Rockman 8 Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA) | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KUrlqOUX6Ko
Tropical Airport (Rockman 5 Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA) | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v6rIDDPe3dU
Stepping Out Again (Rockman System BGM Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA) | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kDhUXf_sagw
... Copied to Clipboard!
Xuxon
09/10/23 4:58:37 PM
#228:


double Crystal Snail (Mega Man X2)

---
http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lxkdr0uNc91qlu5jao1_r1_400.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 4:59:09 PM
#229:


Dels posted...
well i won't do that. but if i did, it'd be funny that one person had the power to singlehandedly decide which 3-noms make it in instead of them having to go to whatever the play-in/tiebreak stage would be, which would be much more democratic
Yeah, I understand that but it is part of the game I guess. Also I would be a little relieved at not having to come up with a way to narrow down 50 songs to 10 without starting a whole pre-contest contest >_>

Less than a minute left!

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
sergiocornaga
09/10/23 4:59:15 PM
#230:


Doubling:
Primrose (Mega Man X8)
... Copied to Clipboard!
sergiocornaga
09/10/23 5:00:00 PM
#231:


Tropical Airport (Rockman 5 Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA)
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 5:00:15 PM
#232:


Nominations are closed!

Thank you very much for participating, I'll go over the results and then attempt to decide on a tiebreaker method for whatever's on the bubble that won't take up a month in itself.

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Dels
09/10/23 5:01:22 PM
#233:


andylt posted...
Yeah, I understand that but it is part of the game I guess. Also I would be a little relieved at not having to come up with a way to narrow down 50 songs to 10 without starting a whole pre-contest contest >_>

Less than a minute left!

the last time i brute forced nominations in a music contest, lefty held it against me for... literally until this very day.

so i wouldn't!

... Copied to Clipboard!
MacArrowny
09/10/23 5:04:16 PM
#234:


Did you decide on 128 entries or 64?

---
All the stars in the sky are waiting for you.
... Copied to Clipboard!
pjbasis
09/10/23 5:09:53 PM
#235:


oops didn't use a double but Snake man might make it in anyway

---
http://i498.photobucket.com/albums/rr345/Rakaputra/B8%20Girls%202012/pjbas.png
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 5:24:39 PM
#236:


It'll be a 64 bracket.

Here's the final nomination tally. Please let me know if you see any mistakes!

6 nominations
Dr. Wily Stage 1 (Mega Man 2)

5 nominations
Armored Armadillo (Mega Man X)
Boomer Kuwanger (Mega Man X)
FINAL TRANSMISSION (ROCKMAN.EXE 15th ARRANGE BEST TRACK)
Flutter vs. Gesellschaft (We are ROCK-MEN!)
Opening, Snakeman Stage (2A03+VRC7 mix) (Chiptuned Rockman)
Storm Eagle stage (Mega Man X)

4 nominations
Abnormal Gravity Area (Mega Man Network Transmission)
Air Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. for 3DS & Wii U)
Anata no Kaze ga Fuku Kara (Rockman DASH)
Armored Armadillo (We are ROCK-MEN!)
Bubble Crab Stage (Mega Man X2)
Central Highway (Opening Stage) (Mega Man X)
Crystal Snail (Mega Man X2)
Cybersheep Dream (Sheep Man Stage) (Mega Man 10)
Dark Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Departure (Remastered Tracks Rockman Zero Mythos)
Duff Mcwhale [Unused theme] (Mega Man X5)
Ending from ROCKMAN3 (25th Anniversary Rockman Rock Arrange Ver.)
Enigma of Aqua (Mega Man Unlimited)
Epilogue - The Transient Silence (ROCKMAN X ALPH-LYLA with TOSHIAKI OHTSUBO)
Falling Down (Mega Man Zero 4 (Remastered))
Farewell to Ballade (Special Stage 3) (Mega Man 10)
Galaxy Man Stage (Mega Man 9)
Gravity Beetle Stage (Mega Man X3)
Gravity Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Groundman Stage (Unlimited Overdub mix) (Chiptuned Rockman)
Infinity Mijinion Stage (Mega Man X6)
Metal Man Stage (Mega Man 2)
Navi Customizer ~Free Mode~ (Mega Man Battle Network 3)
Pharaoh Man Stage (Mega Man 4)
Pleasant Thief Marino (Mega Man X Command Mission)
Primrose (Mega Man X8)
Prologue-Awakening Road ~OPENING:HIGHWAY STAGE~ (ROCKMAN X ALPH-LYLA with TOSHIAKI OHTSUBO)
Revealing (Mega Man X7)
Rubber Man Stage (Arranged) (Mega Man 11)
Sigma Stage 1 (Mega Man X)
Sky High - Grand Nuage (Theme of Guardian) (Mega Man ZX)
Skyway (Hurricane Hoatzin Stage) (Mega Man X: Corrupted)
Solar Inferno (Solar Mans Stage) (Mega Man 10)
Spark Mandrill (Mega Man X)
Splash Blue (Splash Woman's Stage) (Mega Man 9 (Arranged))
Take Back The Tower ~TOWER STAGE~ (ROCKMAN X ALPH-LYLA with TOSHIAKI OHTSUBO)
Thunder Tornado (Tornado Mans Stage) (Mega Man 9)
Title (Mega Man 3)
Tornado Man Stage (Integer Spin Mix) (Chiptuned Rockman)
Tundra Man Stage - Instrumental (Mega Man 11)
We're the Robots (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Wily Field (Mega Man Soccer)
Wily Stage 1 (Mega Man 7)
Wonder Panorama (Area F) (Mega Man ZX)
X vs. Zero (Mega Man X5)
You'd Better Be Nippy (Water Stage Medley) (ROCKMAN DYSTOPIA)
Zero Gravity Area (StarMan's Stage) (Mega Man Network Transmission)
Zero Stage 2 (Mega Man X5)

3 nominations
Apple Market (MegaMan Legends)
BATTLE ARENA (Rockman Xover)
Blazing Internet - FireMan's Stage (Mega Man Network Transmission)
Boundless Network (Mega Man Battle Network)
Cannon Ball in Resonance (Rockman Zero Collection Soundtrack - resonnant vi)
Chill Penguin (Mega Man X)
Commander Yammark (Mega Man X6)
Cossack Fortress 2 (Mega Man 4)
Electrical Communication (Full Size) (Mega Man 8)
Esperanto CAP-JAMS ver. (ONE / CAP-JAMS)
Final Slot-In (Rockman.EXE N1 Battle)
Flash Man (Mega Man 2)
Frozen Island (Blizzard Mans Stage) (Mega Man 6)
Gigabolt Man-O-War stage -Dynasty- (Mega Man X8)
GIVE IT A SHOT (Mega Man X Legacy Collection)
Great Battlers -N1 / Ranked Battle Theme- (Mega Man Battle Network 3)
Hornet Man Stage (Mega Man 9)
Internet World (Mega Man Battle Network 2)
Jakob Space Elevator (Mega Man X8)
Mr. X's Fortress (Mega Man 6)
Night in the White -Chill Penguin stage- (ROCKMAN X ALPH-LYLA with TOSHIAKI OHTSUBO)
Opening Stage (Project X Zone 2)
Over the Top ~Theme of Mega Man~ (Mega Man: Battle & Chase)
Proto Man Theme (Mega Man 3)
Quick Man Stage (Mega Man 2)
Shadow Man Stage (Mega Man 3)
Shine in the Dark (Mega Man Battle Network 3)
Shop -Protoman- (Mega Man 10)
Sigma 2nd Battle (Mega Man X6)
Spark Man Stage (Mega Man 3)
Splash Woman (Mega Ran 9)
Squid Adler Stage -Volt Kraken- (Mega Man X5)
Staff Roll (Mega Man 8)
Sunstar Battle (Mega Man V)
Surge of Power! (Mega Man Battle Network 6)
The Last No. Zero (ROCKMAN Dystopia)
Theme of Roll - Kaze no Tsutaete (Tatsunoko VS Capcom)
Trap Phantasm (Mega Man ZX Advent Tunes)
Two of Braves (Mega Man Battle Network 6)
Vs. Lumine 2nd Form (Mega Man X8)
vs. Nebula Grey (Mega Man Battle Network 5)
Wave Man Stage (Mega Man 5)
We're the Robots (Mega Man 9)
X-Buster (ROCKMAN HOLIC)

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 5:25:52 PM
#237:


2 nominations
...if you (Pachislot Rockman Ability)
Aqua Man stage - Saturn ver. (Mega Man 8)
Blackheart Beat (Mega Man Zero 4 Remastered)
Blaze Heatnix Stage (Mega Man X6)
Boss Theme -Scrapped Beat - (Mega Man Zero 3)
Boss Theme- Navi Battle - (Mega Man Network Transmission)
Bubble Man (Mega Man 2)
Cinq Ville - C`est Notre Espoir (Mega Man ZX)
Crash Man (Mega Man 2)
Cyber Planet (Mega Man Battle Network Chrono X)
Dark Man Stage (SIDE-R) (We are ROCK-MEN!)
Dr. Wily Stage 1 (Dragalia Lost)
Get the Punk Out -Special Stage 2- (Mega Man 10)
Giant Dam (Toxic Seahorses Stage) (Mega Man X3)
Gravity Beetle stage - PSX Arrange (Mega Man X3)
Holy Land (Mega Man Zero 4)
I.D.E.A. -Boku wa Mainichi, Yume wo miru- ending theme (Mega Man X6)
Ice Brain in Resonance (Rockman Zero Collection Soundtrack - resonnant vi)
Izzy Glow Stage -Shining Firefly- (Mega Man X5)
Jet Stingray (Mega Man X4)
Magnet Man (Mega Man II)
Magnet Man Stage (Mega Man 3)
Melody of Isolation -Theme of Rogue- (Mega Man Star Force 2)
Metamorphosis (Mega Man Universe)
Museum Intro Stage (Megaman & Bass - SNES)
Network is Spreading (Mega Man Battle Network 3)
Opening -Code Crush- (Mega Man X7)
Opening; Buzy - Be Somewhere -Game Edit- (Mega Man Battle Network 5: Double Team DS)
peace again (Mega Man Battle Network 2)
Plague Man Stage (Mega Man Rock Force)
Rainy Turtloid (Mega Man X6)
Snake Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Spaceport stage (Mega Man X4)
Splash Blue (Splash Womans Stage) (Mega Man 9)
Stand by Zero (Mega Man X Command Mission)
Theme of Zero (ZERO&ZX Re-Creation) (Mega Man Zero/ZX Legacy Collection)
Title (Mega Man 2)
Top Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Tretista Kelverian's Stage -High-Speed Lift (Mega Man Zero 3)
Tropical Airport (Rockman 5 Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA)
Vanishing Gungaroo stage -Underground - Tunnel Base- (Mega Man X7)
Vile's Theme (Mega Man X8)
Wave Battle! Ride On!! -Boss Theme- (Mega Man Star Force 3)
Wily Stage 2 -Turtle's Realm- (Mega Man 7)
Wily Tower: Wily Stage 4 (Mega Man: The Wily Wars)
Yellow Devil theme (Mega Man 2: The Power Fighters)

1 nomination
A Serious Mission (Mega Man Battle Network 2)
Absolute Chill (Chill Man Stage) (Mega Man 10)
Acid Man Stage (Mega Man 11: Wily Numbers Instrumental Stage Tracks)
Battle Pressure -Tournament Battle Theme- (Mega Man Battle Network 4)
Battle Spirit (Mega Man Battle Network 2)
Block Man Stage (Mega Man 11)
Boss Battle (Megaman & Bass -SNES)
Boss Theme -Nothing Beats- (Mega Man Zero 4)
Buster Rod G Stage -Wily Tower- (Mega Man: The Wily Wars)
Cannon Ball -Vs. Omega Zero- (Mega Man Zero 3)
Chasers Future City Course (Mega Man Battle & Chase)
Conflict - Escape Stage (Mega Man X7)
Crash -boss theme- (Mega Man Zero)
Crimson Viper stage (Street Fighter x. Mega Man)
Digital Strider (Mega Man Battle Network 6)
Dr. Doppler Stage 1 (Mega Man X3 SNES)
Dr. Wily Stage 4 -Castle of Evil- (Mega Man 9)
Dr. Wily Stage Boss (Mega Man 10)
Dynamo (Mega Man X5)
E-Crystal For My Heart (Art Gallery) (Mega Man Zero/ZX Legacy Collection)
Ending (Mega Man X)
Endless Struggle (Endless Stage) (Mega Man 10)
Esperanto (Rockman no Constancy)
Exotic Somewhere (Rockman 6 Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA)
Fight! X (Megaman X: Command Mission)
Fighting Oneself (Mega Man Battle Network 4)
Gate's Laboratory stage (Mega Man X6)
Green Grass Gradation (Area A - Forest) (Mega Man ZX)
Hard Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Horror Fortress (Shade Mans Stage) (Mega Man 7)
Innocence (Mega Man ZX Tunes)
Internet Area (Mega Man Network Transmission)
Jewel Temptation (Jewel Mans Stage) (Mega Man 9)
Justice Of Dys World (Climax Battle Medley) (ROCKMAN Dystopia)
Maze of Death (Endless Stage) (Mega Man 9)
Mountain Rider (Area B - Mountain Pass) (Mega Man ZX)
Network Space (Mega Man Battle Network 5)
Opening -Kotono Shibuya - One More Time (Mega Man X3 PS1)
Opening Stage (Mega Man X) (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Opening Stage X (Mega Man X4)
Our Blood Boils -vs. Sigma 1st- (Mega Man X7)
Power Bomb (Mega Man Zero 2 (Remastered))
Power Supply (Mega Man Rock N Roll)
Pulse Man Stage (Mega Man Rock Force)
Quest in the Water (Mega Man Battle Network 5)
Rise The Curtain (Rockman 1 Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA)
Rockman 2 Dr WILY STAGE 1 -OMEGAMAN MIX- (We are ROCKMEN! 2)
Rubber Man Stage (Mega Man 11)
Running Through The Cyber World CAP-JAMS ver. (ONE / CAP-JAMS)
Shooting Star (Mega Man Star Force)
Show Your True Face (Rockman 8 Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA)
Snake Eyes (Last Area - Slither Inc.) (Mega Man ZX)
Spark Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Staff Roll (Mega Man II)
Stepping Out Again (Rockman System BGM Medley) (ROCKMAN UTOPIA)
Strike Battle (Mega Man X Corrupted)
Strong Opponent -Boss Theme- (Mega Man Battle Chip Challenge)
Title / Wily Station (Mega Man II)
Trail on Powdery Snow (Mega Man Zero 3)
Venus's Stage (Mega Man V)
Weapon Get (Mega Man 3)
Wily Battle (Mega Man 6)
Wily Battle (Mega Man)
Wily Fortress 1 (Mega Man 3)
Wily Fortress 2 (Mega Man 3)
Wily Stage 1 (Mega Man 8)
Wood Man (Mega Man 2)
Zero's Theme (Marvel vs. Capcom 3)
Zero's Theme (Mega Man X2)

0 nominations :'(
Against The Pressure (Rockman 10 Image Soundtrack)
Astro Man Stage (Mega Man & Bass (SNES))
Blackheart Beat (Mega Man Zero 4)
Drake Man (Mega Man Rock N Roll)
Final Wily Stage (The Hatches) (Mega Man 7)
Flutter VS The Gesellschaft (Mega Man Legends)
Ghost Woman (Mega Man Rock N Roll)
Gravity Man Stage (Mega Man 5)
Ground Man's Stage (Mega Man & Bass - SNES)
Gyro Man (Mega Man: The Power Fighters)
In The Wind (Floating Ruins - Aeolus' Stage) (Mega Man ZX Advent Tunes OST)
Industrialism (Area E - Power Plant) (Mega Man ZX Tunes OST)
It's Okay to Cry (Rockman DASH 2)
Jet Man (Mega Man Unlimited)
Kaze Yo Tsutaete (Buster Core Meltdown mix) (Chiptuned Rockman)
Napalm Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Neo Ambience (Pachislot Rockman Ability)
One And Only (Rockman 10 Image Soundtrack)
Overloaded (Highway - Thetis' Stage) (Mega Man ZX Advent Gigamix OST)
Pirate Man Stage (Mega Man & Bass SNES)
Pluto stage (Mega Man V/Rockman World 5)
Polar Woman (Mega Man Rock N Roll)
Rockin' On (Mega Man ZX)
Rockman X2 OPENING STAGE (We are ROCKMEN!)
Shadow Man Stage (Super Smash Bros. Ultimate)
Special Stage (Handy remax) (Chiptuned Rockman)
Tornado Man Stage (Rockman 9 Arrange Soundtrack)
Trap Fanatics (Vs Prometheus & Pandora) (Mega Man ZX Gigamix OST)
VS. Cache (Rockman EXE: Phantom of the Network)

Before moving on, I'll allow time for anyone to notice my probable errors here. But if this is correct, then everything with 4 noms is in, and everything with 2 or below is out. And as it stands, 9 of the 54 tracks on exactly 3 nominations will make it in.

But how to decide which 9 make it? There's a few options I'm considering:
  • Run a 9 day play-in round with 6 of the 54 songs on each day, the one receiving the most votes each day gets a spot in the contest. Pro: it's democratic and all the songs get a chance to shine. Con: it's very long!!
  • Randomly allocate the slots. Pro: it's quick! Con: Is it fair?
  • Allocate first slots to nominators who got no tracks into the contest. Pro: More people will have a reason to be invested in the contest. Con: It may penalise early nominators who happened to get to widely popular tracks first.
  • Prioritise games/albums with fewer reps. Pro: A more varied field. Con: There may be a reason some games have more support than others!
  • Remove songs with a double first. Pro: Songs with more supporters get a better chance. Con: A couple of people have already expressed objections to this on the grounds that a double here is more meaningful than in VGMC.


While I wait for any errors to pop up, please chime in with your thoughts! And again, thanks so much for taking part.

---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
failgirlema
09/10/23 5:32:23 PM
#238:


personally i think 3 and 4 are the best options since it just seems nice to let people have nominations in or to let other games get the spotlight
4 seems especially good considering the top spots are VERY dominated by X, so more variety would be appreciated

---
she/her
woaaa
... Copied to Clipboard!
sergiocornaga
09/10/23 5:32:37 PM
#239:


andylt posted...
* Allocate first slots to nominators who got no tracks into the contest. Pro: More people will have a reason to be invested in the contest. Con: It may penalise early nominators who happened to get to widely popular tracks first.
This is my favourite suggestion.
... Copied to Clipboard!
UF8
09/10/23 5:35:16 PM
#240:


i think it doesn't matter since even if i do get to have 1 (one) song get in this way it'd get fed to one of the top seeds so lol

mostly bitter the ones i was most invested in aren't even in contention since they're all at 2 or less
... Copied to Clipboard!
Place
09/10/23 5:41:55 PM
#241:


Run a 9 day play-in round with 6 of the 54 songs on each day, the one receiving the most votes each day gets a spot in the contest. Pro: it's democratic and all the songs get a chance to shine. Con: it's very long!!

This is probably an unpopular perspective but I love this haha. More music to enjoy, which can only be a good thing in my book

---
Hi. I wanna play you something.
... Copied to Clipboard!
failgirlema
09/10/23 5:43:57 PM
#242:


Honeslty I also kinda love the idea of the 9 day mini contest type thing but I don't think anyone would really agree and people who didn't want it would probably just only vote for what they knew...

---
she/her
woaaa
... Copied to Clipboard!
Prince46
09/10/23 5:45:51 PM
#243:


Majorly in favor of Option 3, and then Option 1. I don't think the others are really good. I feel well with giving spaces with people with no nominations considering the tight space, a very selfless act.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Natalie
09/10/23 5:51:51 PM
#244:


I'd be down for a play-in contest, but the other options are fine too.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Leonhart4
09/10/23 5:52:32 PM
#245:


Give the spots to the songs that have doubles

---
https://imgur.com/WqDcNNq
https://imgur.com/89Z5jrB
... Copied to Clipboard!
UF8
09/10/23 5:53:59 PM
#246:


Leonhart4 posted...
Give the spots to the songs that have doubles
almost a joke-tier suggestion but simultaneously the one i'd actually be happiest with
... Copied to Clipboard!
andylt
09/10/23 6:27:26 PM
#247:


I am always up for a mini-contest!

However, I've checked and I believe that of the 54 tracks on the bubble, exactly 9 of their nominators have 0 tracks currently in the field. This is perfect! It is too neat a solution not to go for, so unless there's a major objection (or I've made a counting error somewhere ;>_>) then the songs on 3 noms making the field will be:

Opening Stage (Project X Zone 2), nominated by UF8
Electrical Communication (Full Size) (Mega Man 8), nominated by kamakazikila
The Last No. Zero (ROCKMAN Dystopia), nominated by LKProd
Apple Market (MegaMan Legends), nominated by xenosaga
Proto Man Theme (Mega Man 3), nominated by Ashethan
Surge of Power! (Mega Man Battle Network 6), nominated by -Chaos-Zero-
Staff Roll (Mega Man 8), nominated by fluttershypony
Jakob Space Elevator (Mega Man X8), nominated by Chinballz,

...and one of either:
Great Battlers -N1 / Ranked Battle Theme- (Mega Man Battle Network 3), or
Night in the White -Chill Penguin stage- (ROCKMAN X ALPH-LYLA with TOSHIAKI OHTSUBO)
, both nominated by MXCM. It seems only fitting to have the user themselves pick which they'd rather have, so @MXCM the ball's in your court!

...I really hope there's no tally mistake now, or this will get awkward.


---
No longer becoming a Final Fantasy aficionado.
... Copied to Clipboard!
MacArrowny
09/10/23 6:42:46 PM
#248:


My suggestion: run a 1 or 2 day play-in round with all the songs. Everyone gets 5 votes.

Otherwise I'd definitely be for the regular play-in round.

Edit: ah I guess you already decided.

---
All the stars in the sky are waiting for you.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Fluttershy_Pony
09/10/23 6:50:27 PM
#249:


Considering MM8 Staff Roll is my current favorite Mega Man song, I fully support this plan for blatantly selfish reasons. <./<

...More seriously I'm fine with whatever you decide, but this is pretty blatantly the best result for *me*, so I feel like I need to at least say "yes, I would be happy about that".

---
Formerly known as Raetsel.
Currently listening to The Remedy by Abandoned Pools on repeat.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Hbthebattle
09/10/23 6:59:07 PM
#250:


Considering we already have chill penguin in the contest, Id strongly prefer Great Battlers

---
:)
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6