Current Events > Let's play a game: Is this Star Rail review Kotaku's or AI generated?

(+) Yeah! (+)

Honkai Star Rail - A Visually Stunning but Problematic Journey

Honkai Star Rail, developed by miHoYo, takes players on a visually mesmerizing journey through an enigmatic universe created by Hoyoverse. Despite its captivating graphics and intriguing storyline, the game falls short in its portrayal of the first major planet, Jarilo-VI. With clear similarities to Russia, including Ukrainian war implications, it raises concerns about cultural sensitivity in a game made by Chinese developers, Russia's allies. Additionally, the game's character design is marred by sexist and misogynistic elements that detract from an otherwise promising experience.

There's no denying that Honkai Star Rail excels in the graphics department. The visual design is stunning, and the landscapes of Jarilo-VI are intricately detailed, immersing players in a world filled with captivating beauty. However, it becomes problematic when the game seems to draw heavily from Russian aesthetics and history, particularly given the sensitive nature of the post-Ukraine war context.

The first major planet in Honkai Star Rail, Jarilo-VI, is unmistakably reminiscent of Russia. From the architectural style to the snowy landscapes and the presence of traditional Russian elements, the similarities are striking. While drawing inspiration from real-world cultures is not inherently wrong, the developers should approach this with cultural sensitivity, especially when touching upon historical events that may still evoke pain and suffering for affected communities.

The decision to depict a planet resembling Russia raises questions about cultural sensitivity and geopolitical implications. As Chinese developers, it becomes essential to handle such sensitive subjects with caution and respect. Games, as a form of media, can influence perceptions and understanding of real-world events, making it crucial for developers to approach such topics responsibly.

Another glaring issue in Honkai Star Rail is the portrayal of female characters. Many of the females in the game are depicted in sexualized outfits that cater to the male gaze, perpetuating harmful stereotypes. While it's not uncommon for video games to have characters with diverse designs, the overt sexualization of female characters detracts from their personalities and abilities, reinforcing harmful gender norms.

Honkai Star Rail offers players a visually stunning journey through the mesmerizing universe created by Hoyoverse. However, the game stumbles when it comes to cultural sensitivity and gender representation. The resemblance of Jarilo-VI to Russia in a post-Ukraine war world by Chinese developers raises concerns about how such sensitive subjects are portrayed in games.
Additionally, the sexist and misogynistic character designs detract from the otherwise promising experience, undermining the agency and depth of the female characters. In an industry where diversity and inclusivity are becoming increasingly crucial, it is vital for developers to be mindful of the impact their portrayals can have on players and broader societal attitudes.
As players, we should continue to engage in constructive conversations about these issues, encouraging game developers to be more responsible and sensitive in their approach to culture and gender representation. Honkai Star Rail's visuals may be stunning, but it is crucial to address the problematic aspects of the game to foster a more inclusive and respectful gaming landscape.

By the way, how much do reviewers actually get paid?

Kotaku. They're making too many overt, contemporary references to be AI