Current Events > Curing cancer would be an insult to those who died from it

Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3
Questionmarktarius
10/19/22 10:19:09 AM
#51:


bigblu89 posted...
This sounds like a miserable way to live.
....yet post 45 is likely going to be hosed for this.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sad_Face
10/19/22 10:21:59 AM
#52:


RchHomieQuanChi posted...
I mean, that's what the conservative mindset is. "I had to suffer and struggle (in my mind), so everyone else needs to too"


Nah, OP's pic is "If I can bust my ass to make it, you can do it and not need the rest of us to help you too". I've seen this sentiment of "If I can do it, you can do it too so pull yourself up by your own bootstraps" with guys who've left "The hood" or (surprisingly) with this one guy who beat an opioid addiction ragging on people getting stuck with some addiction.

The conservative mindset is basically "Why go to college in the first place to go into crippling debt and not have a decent job? It's a bad deal! Stop going to college!".

---
https://i.imgur.com/WmIB016.jpg https://i.imgur.com/53FGj6K.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
OudeGeuze
10/19/22 10:28:14 AM
#53:


Solid_Sonic posted...
That's how I live. If I can't be happy no one else fucking will.

People smiling at me when all I can think about is the piles of work that need to get done get the middle finger from me. This world is fucking shit and if you try to gloss over it by being cheerful and positive then you're delusional and making life harder for all of us living with our eyes open because now we have to take time out of our lousy day to explain to you what a terrible state society is in so you actually come off your high horse.
The cringe and edge is insane
... Copied to Clipboard!
Shadow_Don
10/19/22 10:31:17 AM
#54:


Pepys_Monster posted...
Except it literally is. And then theres joining the military and getting the GI Bill, which is another choice.

lmfao surely you're joking right?

I mean you could just be a prostitute and pay for college as well. What's the big deal guys?!

---
"The soul in the darkness sins, but the real sinner is he who caused the darkness." - Victor Hugo
... Copied to Clipboard!
LotsOfHorror
10/19/22 10:40:33 AM
#55:


Pepys_Monster posted...
Except it literally is. And then theres joining the military and getting the GI Bill, which is another choice.
Again

"No good choices" is equivalent to "no choice".

You're just throwing out options for how people should let themselves be taken advantage of and act like they should be ok with it.
... Copied to Clipboard!
cuttin_in_farm
10/19/22 10:44:45 AM
#56:


[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


This is true.

But this is also why I think forgiveness is the wrong solution. Its like getting a cure for cancer but the cure only exists for month. People are just gonna get cancer again.

---
A show of kindness may not do much help, but a show of cruelty may do much harm.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sad_Face
10/19/22 10:55:40 AM
#57:


LotsOfHorror posted...
Again

"No good choices" is equivalent to "no choice".

You're just throwing out options for how people should let themselves be taken advantage of and act like they should be ok with it.


This is why this is such a hot topic. Not all states share the same culture. In Wisconsin, there are towns where the amount people who hold at least a bachelor's degree doesn't even hit double digits and people are still able to live their lives comfortably. There towns and cities over the country with these kinds of cultures where it's not expected to go to college. To them, it was always a choice on whether to go to college or not and in their eyes, it's a waste a time for most people. As a result, they're up in arms over the prospect them having to pay for what they see as other people's flub ups.

In contrast, in other cities, especially liberal areas, college is presented to kids as if going to college is THE path to go if you don't want to be a secondary citizen so kids feel pressured to go despite not knowing what to do with their lives, be exploited by the government and academic institutions over constant tuition costs, and too many end in horrible debt with no proper career path as a result.

This isn't a straightforward conversation because it's a clash of lifestyles and culture. About what beliefs work and what doesn't work and is unsustainable across generations. But this causes further implications and discussions of what to do when certain cultural practices have been proven to be unsustainable and detrimental to society as a whole.

---
https://i.imgur.com/WmIB016.jpg https://i.imgur.com/53FGj6K.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
Pepys_Monster
10/19/22 10:57:10 AM
#58:


Shadow_Don posted...
lmfao surely you're joking right?

I mean you could just be a prostitute and pay for college as well. What's the big deal guys?!
Thats illegal.

---
Ryzen 3700X | ASUS RTX 3070 8GB | 16GB DDR4 3200 | Crucial MX500 2TB
... Copied to Clipboard!
Questionmarktarius
10/19/22 10:59:13 AM
#59:


cuttin_in_farm posted...
But this is also why I think forgiveness is the wrong solution. Its like getting a cure for cancer but the cure only exists for month. People are just gonna get cancer again.
This.
Writing off a bunch of loans while the Direct Loans program remains unchanged, is just setting up to do this all over again. The only way it makes any sense to do that would be if it's an intentional Cloward-Piven.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Shadow_Don
10/19/22 11:04:37 AM
#60:


Sad_Face posted...
This is why this is such a hot topic. Not all states share the same culture. In Wisconsin, there are towns where the amount people who hold at least a bachelor's degree doesn't even hit double digits and people are still able to live their lives comfortably.

The government subsidizes farmers. I don't see them complaining about that.

Pepys_Monster posted...
Thats illegal.

Wait so if prostitution were legal you'd be ok with people doing that?

It would really help if your argument didn't amount to "coercion is a fake concept".

---
"The soul in the darkness sins, but the real sinner is he who caused the darkness." - Victor Hugo
... Copied to Clipboard!
LotsOfHorror
10/19/22 11:32:18 AM
#61:


Pepys_Monster posted...
Thats illegal.
Which doesn't matter, law isn't morality.
... Copied to Clipboard!
refmon
10/19/22 11:33:42 AM
#62:


[LFAQs-redacted-quote]



---
If you read this signature, then that meant that I had control of what you read for 5 SECONDS!!
... Copied to Clipboard!
ZevLoveDOOM
10/19/22 11:34:10 AM
#63:


so this could be translated to "i was drowning in debt when i was in college so you should too!"

this sounds petty af...
... Copied to Clipboard!
Questionmarktarius
10/19/22 11:34:42 AM
#64:


ZevLoveDOOM posted...
so this could be translated to "i was drowning in debt when i was in college so you should too!"
If you've paid it off, you're not.
... Copied to Clipboard!
LotsOfHorror
10/19/22 11:34:45 AM
#65:


LotsOfHorror posted...
No good choices is equivalent to no choice at all.
@refmon
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sad_Face
10/19/22 11:40:35 AM
#66:


Shadow_Don posted...
The government subsidizes farmers. I don't see them complaining about that.


@Shadow_Don do you sincerely want all your food imported in the name of lower prices through capitalism?

---
https://i.imgur.com/WmIB016.jpg https://i.imgur.com/53FGj6K.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
Shadow_Don
10/19/22 11:58:05 AM
#67:


Sad_Face posted...
@Shadow_Don do you sincerely want all your food imported in the name of lower prices through capitalism?

No. I'm perfectly fine with subsidies for farmers.

Do you want there to be teachers, lawyers, doctors, scientists, engineers, etc... ?

I'm sure the doctors probably don't need the student loan bailout but teachers do.

Point being that the government helps people who pick and choose different professions all the time. The only reason why this has become a big deal at all is because one political party in this country has decided that education is bad and has made that their platform and thats what they spew 24/7 on their propaganda outlets.

---
"The soul in the darkness sins, but the real sinner is he who caused the darkness." - Victor Hugo
... Copied to Clipboard!
LotsOfHorror
10/19/22 11:59:30 AM
#68:


Shadow_Don posted...
I'm sure the doctors probably don't need the student loan bailout but teachers do.
Depends on the kind of doctor, there are a LOT of people who go into medicine to do pro bono work.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Prestoff
10/19/22 12:00:51 PM
#69:


cuttin_in_farm posted...
This is true.

But this is also why I think forgiveness is the wrong solution. Its like getting a cure for cancer but the cure only exists for month. People are just gonna get cancer again.

Well obviously it's just a band aid to a larger problem, which is the predatory practices of student loans and college being fucking expensive and sometimes the investment is not enough to pay off the debt. It's however still a net positive to have loan forgiveness.

---
DI MOLTO!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Shadow_Don
10/19/22 12:01:43 PM
#70:


LotsOfHorror posted...
Depends on the kind of doctor, there are a LOT of people who go into medicine to do pro bono work.

Thats a good point, thanks!

I'm guessing one of them is going to explain to me how maybe we should have less of those people going into a medical career because the debt is too high.

---
"The soul in the darkness sins, but the real sinner is he who caused the darkness." - Victor Hugo
... Copied to Clipboard!
s0nicfan
10/19/22 12:04:31 PM
#71:


Wouldn't curing cancer in this case be addressing skyrocketing tuition costs? A partial debt payment to one group once is more like giving some cancer patients one dose of chemo once.

---
"History Is Much Like An Endless Waltz. The Three Beats Of War, Peace And Revolution Continue On Forever." - Gundam Wing: Endless Waltz
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sad_Face
10/19/22 12:10:46 PM
#72:


Shadow_Don posted...
Do you want there to be teachers, lawyers, doctors, scientists, engineers, etc... ?


Most people are not getting their degrees in professional fields. On top of that, in the conversation of lawyers, last I checked the market (probably 5 years ago or so) was heavily oversaturated because so many people did well in college but didn't know what to do with their lives ended up going to law school.

This doesn't refute the counter point that not everyone needs to go to college.

Point being that the government helps people who pick and choose different professions all the time. The only reason why this has become a big deal at all is because one political party in this country has decided that education is bad and has made that their platform and thats what they spew 24/7 on their propaganda outlets.


You're ignoring the now almost 30 year plan where the government pushed for people to go to college and allowed and enabled academic institutions to drive up tuition exponentially to put the populace in this major debt crisis with federally backed loans, on top of passing a law to prevent people from defaulting on their school loans. You're being bamboozled if you're labeling the republican party as the sole culprit.

Saying the government helps pick and chooses different professions all the time is a horrible way to compare one crisis they're actively fostering versus a more important goal of ensuring the country isn't fully dependent on food from other countries.

---
https://i.imgur.com/WmIB016.jpg https://i.imgur.com/53FGj6K.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
Guide
10/19/22 12:11:02 PM
#73:


[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


Honestly, people choose cancer all the time. Smoking, poor diets, CE.

---
evening main 2.4356848e+91
https://youtu.be/Acn5IptKWQU
... Copied to Clipboard!
LotsOfHorror
10/19/22 12:11:10 PM
#74:


Shadow_Don posted...
Thats a good point, thanks!

I'm guessing one of them is going to explain to me how maybe we should have less of those people going into a medical career because the debt is too high.
While simultaneously saying we should have more programs to help treat addiction and homelessness
... Copied to Clipboard!
Prestoff
10/19/22 12:23:20 PM
#75:


Solid_Sonic posted...
That's how I live. If I can't be happy no one else fucking will.

People smiling at me when all I can think about is the piles of work that need to get done get the middle finger from me. This world is fucking shit and if you try to gloss over it by being cheerful and positive then you're delusional and making life harder for all of us living with our eyes open because now we have to take time out of our lousy day to explain to you what a terrible state society is in so you actually come off your high horse.

I really hope you're just telling a really bad joke here, because if this is how you really feel you should seek professional help. And I don't mean that in a demeaning way, it's a very terrible way to look at life.

---
DI MOLTO!
... Copied to Clipboard!
cuttin_in_farm
10/19/22 12:33:41 PM
#76:


Prestoff posted...
Well obviously it's just a band aid to a larger problem, which is the predatory practices of student loans and college being fucking expensive and sometimes the investment is not enough to pay off the debt. It's however still a net positive to have loan forgiveness.

Its not even related to the problem is the issue.

Its people who want to be bailed out taking advantage of a serious problem in the US. Which, to be clear, I have no issue with. Businesses get bailed out all the time.

But forgiving school loans does absolutely nothing to address the actual issue which, in your words, is predatory practices of student loans and college being fucking expensive. And everyone knows it but asks for it anyway.

---
A show of kindness may not do much help, but a show of cruelty may do much harm.
... Copied to Clipboard!
CanuckCowboy
10/19/22 12:35:16 PM
#77:


Solid_Sonic posted...
That's how I live. If I can't be happy no one else fucking will.

People smiling at me when all I can think about is the piles of work that need to get done get the middle finger from me. This world is fucking shit and if you try to gloss over it by being cheerful and positive then you're delusional and making life harder for all of us living with our eyes open because now we have to take time out of our lousy day to explain to you what a terrible state society is in so you actually come off your high horse.

What a fun well adjusted fella you are.

---
"I have a cat he's burly n buff but he just likes goin' for walks n stuff"
https://files.catbox.moe/gqwlkg.jpeg ~ by JimCarrysToe. Be amaze.
... Copied to Clipboard!
MajesticFerret
10/19/22 12:35:47 PM
#78:


Dumb analogy.

Cancer is an impartial disease that kills humans. It causes death and you have limited control over it.

Student debt is something you absolutely have control over, is a privilege not a right (by legal definition as it is not something intrinsically granted to you by government powers in US), and you would be making blue collar workers pay more for your mistakes.

Crying about student debt also hurts any arguments for free college as you're proving first hand most college degrees are useless, or even good college degrees can be a waste of time and money without a good GPA or potentially some connections to get your foot through the door. Good paying jobs dintcneed debt relief because they are lucrative enough to be worth it and pay your debt in a reasonable manner.

Additionally, college for everyone just changes the playing field so having a degree becomes intrinsically less useful. Foreign countries where college is massively subsidized pay far shittier for degreed positions relative to the US, the ones that do pay well can be elitist as to where you went to school, and schools can still be picky over who they administer.

The end results is that most jobs that "require" a degree dont actually require a degree. A degree is nothing more than something a company uses as a form of elitism to weed out applicants. Free college for all just gives rise to extreme college elitism and oversatuaration of degrees so people with degrees get paid like shit due to oversupply and less demand and the few high paying jobs still go to people from universities that will filter riff raff out through pay walls or GPA/SAT requirements.

---
Sanity is a one trick pony, all you get with it is rational thought, but with crazy the sky's the limit.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Jerry_Hellyeah
10/19/22 12:39:40 PM
#79:


I just dont think the US government should be dropping millions from its budget to aid college graduates (generally) in particular. Theres more good to be done in the world with that money. We still don't provide adequate support for struggling veterans, but we'll shave 20 grand off the bill for the doctor who didn't care about staying on top of what he owed. I've still got 3 grand left of mine, and I'd love to have that paid off, but going to work and seeing so many elderly people struggling day to day. It's not that simple, no, and it's a shitty comparison for sure, but money is money. Its gotta to come from somewhere, and we know its not the military budget taking the hit.

It's only PR anyways. Without actual reform, more students are going to get fucked and hung up by collections, and now the guilty parties get to point at the thing they did that one time.

---
This is a cool sig
... Copied to Clipboard!
Prestoff
10/19/22 12:40:16 PM
#80:


cuttin_in_farm posted...
Its not even related to the problem is the issue.

Its people who want to be bailed out taking advantage of a serious problem in the US. Which, to be clear, I have no issue with. Businesses get bailed out all the time.

But forgiving school loans does absolutely nothing to address the actual issue which, in your words, is predatory practices of student loans and college being fucking expensive. And everyone knows it but asks for it anyway.

We all know it, but it's a very hard issue to address because the problem is systemic and it doesn't make for very good campaign promises. But still, having studen loan forgiveness is still a net positive and a lot of the people who are against it are against it for the wrong reasons imo.

---
DI MOLTO!
... Copied to Clipboard!
NoxObscuras
10/19/22 12:46:02 PM
#81:


Prestoff posted...
I really hope you're just telling a really bad joke here, because if this is how you really feel you should seek professional help. And I don't mean that in a demeaning way, it's a very terrible way to look at life.
I read that and immediately thought it was a joke post. It's just too on the nose to be serious. But a lot of people are replying to it very seriously...

---
PSN - NoxObscuras
Z490 | i9-10900K | EVGA 3080 FTW3 Ultra | 32GB DDR4 3600 | 4TB SSD
... Copied to Clipboard!
Shadow_Don
10/19/22 12:47:52 PM
#82:


Sad_Face posted...
You're being bamboozled if you're labeling the republican party as the sole culprit.

You're reading that wrong or I wasn't clear.

I'm not saying the republican party is responsible for the debt crisis, I'm saying that the reason for the backlash against student debt forgiveness is that Republicans are making it an issue.

Nobody here is complaining about farmers getting subsidies. Im just saying that those people out in Wisconsin or wherever can pipe the fuck down if they are getting mad about debt relief for students.

Saying the government helps pick and chooses different professions all the time is a horrible way to compare one crisis they're actively fostering versus a more important goal of ensuring the country isn't fully dependent on food from other countries.

I understand that farmers are the most essential of essential workers but that really doesn't matter. The point was that there are a lot of professions that require college degrees that are critically important to our society and its a bad idea to let those professions go into shortages because the debt crisis is too big.

Regarding the underlying problem of the expense of college, I just don't know where you think you are going to take this conversation. I'd wager like 99.9% of people that support student loan relief also support free college.

cuttin_in_farm posted...
But forgiving school loans does absolutely nothing to address the actual issue which, in your words, is predatory practices of student loans and college being fucking expensive. And everyone knows it but asks for it anyway.

Find me one person who supports debt relief and also doesn't support reducing the costs of college or free college.

---
"The soul in the darkness sins, but the real sinner is he who caused the darkness." - Victor Hugo
... Copied to Clipboard!
Prestoff
10/19/22 12:53:53 PM
#83:


NoxObscuras posted...
I read that and immediately thought it was a joke post. It's just too on the nose to be serious. But a lot of people are replying to it very seriously...

I always take hyperbolic posts like those as jokes, but then I remember on CE that there are people who really do actually have similar outlooks on life so sometimes it's very hard to find out who's being serious or not.

---
DI MOLTO!
... Copied to Clipboard!
famfam
10/19/22 12:57:22 PM
#84:


"ending slavery is an insult to people who were slaves their whole lives"
... Copied to Clipboard!
Oatcakes
10/19/22 1:02:02 PM
#85:


It works in that it attacks the idea of "I had to suffer so everyone else should too" way of thinking, but doesn't work as a direct example of a similar situation with one being a "choice" and the other not really being a choice at all.

---
F.C. Stokalona
http://i.imgur.com/CJ0dPBq.jpg
... Copied to Clipboard!
cuttin_in_farm
10/19/22 1:03:18 PM
#86:


Shadow_Don posted...
Find me one person who supports debt relief and also doesn't support reducing the costs of college or free college.

No shit folks want both.

If the issue is world hunger. And your solution is distribute clean water to everyone. Im fairly sure most would say yes to both fix world hunger and fix water shortages.

But giving everyone water has nothing to do with world hunger. So you cant cite food as why we should distribute water.

Same logic with forgiveness. People are complaining about predatory practices. But the solution has nothing to do with fixing what the complaints are. So its hiding behind a legitimate issue to get a bailout.

---
A show of kindness may not do much help, but a show of cruelty may do much harm.
... Copied to Clipboard!
dancing_cactuar
10/19/22 1:11:18 PM
#87:


As much as I'm against the crab in bucket mentality that the original OP was presenting, that rebuttal was a really, really bad analogy.

---
I don't need to see a movie to know how well the characters are handled- Danyarmy
The PS5 has liquid metal tech like the T-1000 Terminator- AceCombatX
... Copied to Clipboard!
Unsuprised_Pika
10/19/22 1:22:07 PM
#88:


Solid_Sonic posted...

Aaaand tagged.

There is a difference between realism and being maliciously nihilistic. Seek mental help please.

---
I post clips of my Cool, Stupid and glitchy MH Rise/Sunbreak hunts here just for fun.
https://youtube.com/user/linkachu1000
... Copied to Clipboard!
InfernalLurker
10/19/22 1:48:56 PM
#89:


What a lot of these people who have paid off their debts are failing to realize is that they are in all probabilities highly likely to be far more successful than the people who wait around to get government loan forgiveness.

---
If both the left and right don't like you, you are living the best life.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sad_Face
10/19/22 1:49:41 PM
#90:


Shadow_Don posted...
Nobody here is complaining about farmers getting subsidies. Im just saying that those people out in Wisconsin or wherever can pipe the f*** down if they are getting mad about debt relief for students.


Your logic for this doesn't hold up at all. Refer back to my previous posts on why (tl;dr food production is a national necessity, going to college is not necessary for the majority of the populace). In addition, you can't use the "we need scientists, doctors, and engineers" as an excuse because most people who go to college don't get degrees with in the intention of going into those fields. These are by and large the ones that academic institutions have exploited to inflate the tuition prices. And as I mentioned before, the market for lawyers is saturated due to so many people finishing a degree but not knowing what they wanted to do with their lives.

Shadow_Don posted...
I understand that farmers are the most essential of essential workers but that really doesn't matter. The point was that there are a lot of professions that require college degrees that are critically important to our society and its a bad idea to let those professions go into shortages because the debt crisis is too big.


How would this occur? Just because some of us are saying too many people are going to college doesn't mean we want no one to go to college.

Regarding the underlying problem of the expense of college, I just don't know where you think you are going to take this conversation.


Gonna echo cuttin's point here.

cuttin_in_farm posted...
Same logic with forgiveness. People are complaining about predatory practices. But the solution has nothing to do with fixing what the complaints are. So its hiding behind a legitimate issue to get a bailout.


This is why I brought up the underlying problem of the expense of college. So you can understand how it came to be so it helps give perspective on why people are against the loan forgiveness. For some it's shallow "If I can do it, you can do it too", for another it maybe "Most people do not need to go to college to have a functioning society so why should we be paying for it", and for others "It doesn't solve the problem to begin with; forgive everyone's loans now, and in a decade we'll be back to the same problem of saturated markets where most can't find a job with their degrees and are heavily crunched by their debt".

---
https://i.imgur.com/WmIB016.jpg https://i.imgur.com/53FGj6K.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
MachineJaipur
10/19/22 1:54:24 PM
#91:


InfernalLurker posted...
What a lot of these people who have paid off their debts are failing to realize is that they are in all probabilities highly likely to be far more successful than the people who wait around to get government loan forgiveness.

Or they went to a smaller or cheaper school and they took on a mid level paying job, nothing fancy, and prioritized paying it off because inflation wasn't so rampant to the point where things have basically doubled in price.

But why let reality get in the way of an idealized view that if you just work hard enough, you'll pay off a loan with a predatory interest rate?
... Copied to Clipboard!
#92
Post #92 was unavailable or deleted.
Prestoff
10/19/22 3:26:26 PM
#93:


[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


Dark Brandon made sure the Republicans, who criticised the student loan forgiveness, remembered.

---
DI MOLTO!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Brolypotence
10/19/22 3:27:47 PM
#94:


Solid_Sonic posted...
That's how I live. If I can't be happy no one else fucking will.

People smiling at me when all I can think about is the piles of work that need to get done get the middle finger from me. This world is fucking shit and if you try to gloss over it by being cheerful and positive then you're delusional and making life harder for all of us living with our eyes open because now we have to take time out of our lousy day to explain to you what a terrible state society is in so you actually come off your high horse.
go wash your face or something lol


---
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/2000121-/79905217
LMAO
... Copied to Clipboard!
Shadow_Don
10/19/22 3:37:33 PM
#95:


Sad_Face posted...
Your logic for this doesn't hold up at all. Refer back to my previous posts on why (tl;dr food production is a national necessity, going to college is not necessary for the majority of the populace). In addition, you can't use the "we need scientists, doctors, and engineers" as an excuse because most people who go to college don't get degrees with in the intention of going into those fields. These are by and large the ones that academic institutions have exploited to inflate the tuition prices. And as I mentioned before, the market for lawyers is saturated due to so many people finishing a degree but not knowing what they wanted to do with their lives.

You're getting way too hung up on the farmers and food industry thing. It's not necessary for the point at all. I just used that as one example of an industry we subsidize that I imagine is common in the community/culture you said are upset about student debt relief. I can find more.

Just because some of us are saying too many people are going to college doesn't mean we want no one to go to college.

That's not what I said at all.

What I said was that letting the student debt and college expense crisis continue could have consequences such as shortages in jobs that are critically important.

And we should take measures to make sure that doesn't happen. Loan relief is one such measure albeit not the complete solution as we both seem to agree with. If one party is not going to help with this problem then executive action loan relief is a course that we should pursue, even if that comes with its own problems.

In my mind I don't see that as any different from the government subsidizing and bailing out other critical industry.

And quite frankly as a final point, I really don't give a fuck about peoples "feelings" relating to that matter. I don't care if they feel like its a slap to the face or they feel like they got spit on. Fuck your feelings. All I care about is what is best for the economy and society.


---
"The soul in the darkness sins, but the real sinner is he who caused the darkness." - Victor Hugo
... Copied to Clipboard!
bigblu89
10/19/22 3:38:56 PM
#96:


Sad_Face posted...
This is why this is such a hot topic. Not all states share the same culture. In Wisconsin, there are towns where the amount people who hold at least a bachelor's degree doesn't even hit double digits and people are still able to live their lives comfortably. There towns and cities over the country with these kinds of cultures where it's not expected to go to college. To them, it was always a choice on whether to go to college or not and in their eyes, it's a waste a time for most people. As a result, they're up in arms over the prospect them having to pay for what they see as other people's flub ups.

While true, catering to this base will just continue the divide.

I've always seen financial politics like this...

Basically everyone was taught to share when they were younger. I'm talking 6 years old or younger. And it's an easy lesson to learn, because at that age, you're basically given everything you have, and don't have to really earn any of it. Parents give you food, clothes, toys, etc. So sharing something you didn't really have to sacrifice for wasn't that huge of a deal.

Most people hold on to that through their youth and into their teens. They'll put a dollar in the poor box. They'll give their friends half their sandwich if they forgot their lunch.

And then people start earning their own money and buying their own shit. They hit a crossroad where they can continue to think "Yes, I have all of this, but others have less, and we should do something about it", and then others think "Wait, this stuff is MINE, why should I have to share what I earned on my own?".


---
It takes zero effort to be a good person.
... Copied to Clipboard!
#97
Post #97 was unavailable or deleted.
MachineJaipur
10/19/22 3:51:46 PM
#98:


bigblu89 posted...
And then people start earning their own money and buying their own s***. They hit a crossroad where they can continue to think "Yes, I have all of this, but others have less, and we should do something about it", and then others think "Wait, this stuff is MINE, why should I have to share what I earned on my own?".
Because I'm not a sociopathic asshole that doesn't realize that the government taking a little bit extra out in taxes and using it to fund programs designed for social benefit and mobility is better than the extra Big Mac meal I could have afforded if they hadn't.

Becoming an adult did nothing to dissuade my beliefs that a government should foremost exist to protect and nurture its citizenry.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sad_Face
10/19/22 5:18:54 PM
#99:


Shadow_Don posted...
You're getting way too hung up on the farmers and food industry thing. It's not necessary for the point at all. I just used that as one example of an industry we subsidize that I imagine is common in the community/culture you said are upset about student debt relief. I can find more.


But that's the problem, you're being general in saying "governments subsidize X industries so it's okay", who is to say we approve of the government subsidize X specific industry? Most people did not support the bailouts in 2008.

If you want to bring up a relevant analogy it has to satisfy the criteria of an industry that most people not being needed to be a part of for society to function.

Shadow_Don posted...
What I said was that letting the student debt and college expense crisis continue could have consequences such as shortages in jobs that are critically important.


And here's where we're coming into conflict; letting the student debt continue; having so many people go to school and end up in debt is not causing shortages in jobs. If anything it's causing a saturation of the job market and giving companies even more leverage to raise the standards higher than need be for their job openings. Tuition prices constantly rising over the past decade is proof they have no shortage of applicants.

And quite frankly as a final point, I really don't give a f*** about peoples "feelings" relating to that matter. I don't care if they feel like its a slap to the face or they feel like they got spit on. f*** your feelings. All I care about is what is best for the economy and society.


I believe when it comes to decision making and law making, a certain level of indifference to feelings is needed. However that statement can flipped on you so easily. What is the benefit to someone going to college for a degree in humanities over going to trade school? Why should the country pay for someone saddled in debt for going to school for an Art degree?

I personally am open to debt forgiveness, but this is only because I believe my Milennial generation was duped in going to college. I still recognize that this conversation of debt forgiveness isn't as straightforward as you think it is.

bigblu89 posted...
And then people start earning their own money and buying their own s***. They hit a crossroad where they can continue to think "Yes, I have all of this, but others have less, and we should do something about it", and then others think "Wait, this stuff is MINE, why should I have to share what I earned on my own?".


Yeah, when you starting putting in effort to earning the things you have, you'll value them more and be less open to giving them away. However, people generally are gracious and understand the things they've earned, they didn't do it all by themselves and so they want to give back to give others the same opportunity they had.

I think the bigger conflict in how people perceive what "giving back to give others the same opportunity" means; because they would generally want others to put in the same amount of work as they did and anything less would be giving it away to them.

---
https://i.imgur.com/WmIB016.jpg https://i.imgur.com/53FGj6K.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
bigblu89
10/19/22 5:25:13 PM
#100:


MachineJaipur posted...
Because I'm not a sociopathic asshole that doesn't realize that the government taking a little bit extra out in taxes and using it to fund programs designed for social benefit and mobility is better than the extra Big Mac meal I could have afforded if they hadn't.

Becoming an adult did nothing to dissuade my beliefs that a government should foremost exist to protect and nurture its citizenry.
OK. That's YOU.

There's hundreds of thousands, possibly millions, of people out there that don't want their taxes going to anything other than "Pave the roads and pay the police/firemen".

There is a stupid amount of people that live the "I got mine" world.

---
It takes zero effort to be a good person.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3