Board 8 > Magic: The Gathering: Mafia (Sign-ups)

(+) Yeah! (+)

Crescent-Moon posted...

With him it's less strategy and more "he's definitely going to lie for multiple topics in the game and act like an obnoxious dick as he runs the game over with his constant lies".

It sucks any tiny sense of enjoyment the game can even have.

You might be surprised to learn that mafia is about a group of people lying to the majority and trying to run the game over with their constant lies.

If I was an "obnoxious dick", I would have been modkilled. You instead don't like the way I sometimes play the game so you labeled me that out of spite. I am again sorry for how you feel, Crescent. I don't know why you are making a game about you that you are not even playing though.

I side with Corrik on this one.

Gambits are a core part of Mafia.

Lynch all liars is smooth brain thinking. And I say that as someone who pushed that for a while

That being said, you need to have a good exit plan before diving into one like that

(But really if I'm already this defensive imagine how I'd get in an actual game)

Imma just stop reading this topic and pull back.

FFDragon posted...

I side with Corrik on this one.

Gambits are a core part of Mafia.

Lynch all liars is smooth brain thinking. And I say that as someone who pushed that for a while

Lynch all liars made sense until Town learned to lie.

The meta evolves with the players.

Actually that makes a lot of sense. It worked to a point, then once town realized they could use mafia's best trick against them it stopped making sense.

2 points for Han

Jokes on you, I was lying

What is fun is subjective because I have some of the most fun with Corrik around. But he's not innocent as to why people don't want to play with him.

##vote: han

lynch all jokers

TidusOfTheX posted...

I would like it if you do not do things like that Corrik, I want this game to be fun for everyone. If you make it not fun, then you will have to be replaced, you have been warned(I would rather replace than modkill if possible).

Oof

About to say, I was lying about what my role was capable of before I had even known it was modkillable to copy-paste parts last game.

Corrik7 posted...

If I was an "obnoxious dick", I would have been modkilled.

If I was the host I would have modkilled you

also put in me as the replacement if corrik is replaced

that would be fun

You'll just make the same counterclaim that Corrik got replaced for!

Aecioo posted...

also put in me as the replacement if corrik is replaced

that would be fun

Wait are we making this a you vs Corrik option?

If there is no Corrik can I have you replace empty spot

Would get replaced for, and are y'all really meta'ing a game that hasn't even begun?

Oh you mean if he is replaced mid game. Haha

I say if we let Ulti play.
We can also let Corrik play.

masterplum posted...

Oh you mean if he is replaced mid game. Haha

yeah

HanOfTheNekos posted...

You'll just make the same counterclaim that Corrik got replaced for!

that's why it would be fun!

if he got replaced midgame, trying to dig out of whatever hole he's in sounds great

htaeD posted...

I say if we let Ulti play.
We can also let Corrik play.

I agree with this but probably not the direction they want to go!

Ulti was borderline abusive last game which makes me hesitant

Dude, this isn't a big deal. If you don't want me to play a mafia game, just cut me. I don't understand it, but it's whatever. I have done literally nothing here besides get attacked, a lot.

I went to the sign up page for a mafia game and a mafia game broke out

Lopen posted...

I went to the sign up page for a mafia game and a mafia game broke out

I think I just got mislynched. Town is sad. Haha.

I claim mayor. There will be no lynch.

Lopen posted...

I claim mayor. There will be no lynch.

Well, I guess that claim has to be real then. I am alive! Woohoo.

There has been a replacement. Han replaced Lopen.

##DayVig: Corrik

I just want to make the game fun for everyone

I would only moderate if it gets obnoxious though, so you can still lie about a claim

TidusOfTheX posted...

I just want to make the game fun for everyone

I would only moderate if it gets obnoxious though, so you can still lie about a claim

You have to declare pretty unilaterally that someone will only be moderated for breaking the rules. "Obnoxious" does not quite break the rules. "Being an actual dick" does, as does playing not to win.

for the record, my gamefaqs account has traditionally had a grand total of 3 users blocked/ignored:

vlado
ulti
corrik

ulti was indeed on good behavior for that last game

Uh...well I guess I'll probably sit this one out. Feel free to put me on the replacement list though!

Suprak the Stud posted...

Uh...well I guess I'll probably sit this one out. Feel free to put me on the replacement list though!

He cut off sign ups too quick. You and Lopen would have been great additions. Not a jab at you host. Just a compliment to them.

UltimaterializerX posted...

5 years ago sure, but these days I'm a teddy bear.

we've been here a long time, haven't we

Corrik7 posted...

He cut off sign ups too quick. You and Lopen would have been great additions. Not a jab at you host. Just a compliment to them.

I don't think sign ups are over? Does lopen even want to play?

My bad I thought he had 13 when he posted that.

This theme is good and it's been a while since I've played any mafia, but the vibe is real bad in here. I don't like the idea of trying to ban people because they don't play the way you like them to. Never seen Corrik be anything resembling "abusive" in mafia games (makes some VERY questionable plays at times, but not hostile) and while I'd believe Ulti was since he has his moments, you've got people saying he wasn't so I doubt he was either. Seems just like people wanting a controlled mafia environment not wanting rogue elements in the game, which sounds really boring.

Fwiw, it hasn't really been all that bad? Host made a reactionary comment, Crescent said her bit and bounced.

Aside from that, all the talk about people being banned or not allowed has been pulled out of nowhere.

Lopen posted...

This theme is good and it's been a while since I've played any mafia, but the vibe is real bad in here. I don't like the idea of trying to ban people because they don't play the way you like them to. Never seen Corrik be anything resembling "abusive" in mafia games (makes some VERY questionable plays at times, but not hostile) and while I'd believe Ulti was since he has his moments, you've got people saying he wasn't so I doubt he was either. Seems just like people wanting a controlled mafia environment not wanting rogue elements in the game, which sounds really boring.

Hence my 'oof' to that post

Sorry, this is only the first time I am hosting, and I have only played a single mafia game(which was without corrik). I have only heard about him from crescent and plum

I don't think final decisions have been made about anyone other than crescent is out if corrik is in

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Aside from that, all the talk about people being banned or not allowed has been pulled out of nowhere.

TidusOfTheX posted...

Sorry, this is only the first time I am hosting, and I have only played a single mafia game(which was without corrik). I have only heard about him from crescent and plum

Not saying it's your fault as the host but the talk is here

Lopen play with me. <3

Appreciate the ping, but I am way too distracted to have the mental energy to play mafia at this time.

this is more drama than i want to deal with, but mark me down as playing if crescent plays

i'm very excited about the flavor