Board 8 > Ace Attorney Music: Which generic witness theme is your favorite? (Part 2)

(+) Yeah! (+)

Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-_wBlS-0pb0&t=776s

Winners:
Courtroom Lobby ~ The First Prelude (PW1)
Ace Attorney 3 ~ Court Begins (Trials & Tribulations)
Logic and Trick (PW1)
Won the Lawsuit! ~ First Victory (PW1)

Personal ranking: Naive > Lively DD > Cheerful > Lively GAA > Strange > Elegant > Suspicious GAA > Enter > Suspicious DD > Stakes > Citizens > Difficult > Wind

Good grief, why does GAA have six of these? That being said, I think this is the first situation where the newer games solidly improved over what the older games put out. Some of these are pretty catchy without actually getting annoying.

Question: Should we do a final winners poll between these two polls, or just let there be two winners overall for this set? I do plan on doing some overall winners polls at the end, so it'd balance out in the end. I'm fine either way, but it just means an extra day with this category that most people don't seem to be crazy about.

---

For some reason 'Strange people' from AA6 is so memorable that it's hard for me to believe it was new to AA6

Anyway suspicious people from AA5 has that bassline so that's my answer

Strange SoJ>Difficult>Cheerful>Stake>Russia>Enter>Suspicious DD>Elegant>Suspicious GAA>Capital>Naive>Lively GAA>Lively DD

i cannot be fair to duel destinies lively due to association with the scenes it plays in sorry

don't feel like checking on gaa2's ones this time after the overload of gaa1 here

also this set is way weaker than the first one and i'd pick aai2 strange over soj strange in a heartbeat

Ugh, these suck. Some of the GAA tracks are okay though. Write-in vote for A Wind Across Russia if that's a thing I can do, probably my favorite of both days.

I'd say just have two winners for these, no need for a third day IMO.

---

Up

---

More

---

Nobody cares when it's not the OT huh

---

yeah how can anyone really care about these

happy people from aa6 is probably my fav here. emeer's theme is also pretty fun.
---

Well, what should we do next?

---

Last bump

---

specific area themes

---

Leonhart4 posted...

Well, what should we do next?

hotlines of fate?

investigations could be cool too
---

Difficult > Strange > Suspicious G > Cheerful > Elegant > Farce Naive > Farce Lively > Citizens > Suspicious DD > Stake > Russia > Court > Lively

Generally a pretty worse set than the first day. I'm not sure if its nostalgia or what. I can tell that I'm generally not a fan of the GAA soundtrack, but maybe that will change when I play the game!

Difficult People is a really cool theme. I wouldn't be opposed to making a more "serious" or low-key people theme in every game in addition to a more lively version.

I'll give Farce Lively credit. It's probably the only song in both days that feels genuinely like a character's theme. Perfect song for Some Guy.

Lively DD is trying too hard. It feels like I'm in some cartoon. Suspicious DD also feels like it's trying too hard, but it feels more like a detective novel. Which...I guess that's appropriate enough. I also just like the instruments in Suspicious DD way more.

Again, maybe it's because I listen to SOJ's OST a lot, but SOJ's songs are both pretty good! Cheerful People feels like the next appropriate step to Happy People and Strange People kinda fits that more "low-key" people theme. Unlike Difficult People, it doesn't feel like it's telling the player in "hey, this guy is probably the culprit, right?". That said, I just like the tune of Difficult People too much.

---

SSBM_Guy posted...

I can tell that I'm generally not a fan of the GAA soundtrack, but maybe that will change when I play the game!

I think it's a middle of the road OST for the series overall, but it has a handful of songs I really love.

None of these are among that handful though!

---