Current Events > Just played the entire Dark Souls trilogy... time for some BOSS RANKINGS!

(+) Yeah! (+)

DavidZ2844 posted...

Yo whenever you get the chance, if you're still doing it, can I get a copy of that Google Drive for the reviews? I'd love to go back and read all the DS3 ones after I get around to finishing it myself.

Absolutely. Doing it a bit at a time but should have it soonish

---

no purge pls

---

Blackstar110 posted...

Absolutely. Doing it a bit at a time but should have it soonish

Thanks, much appreciated

anti-purge bump

Amazing.

---

Is there any way we can archive this topic? I want to read it all some day, but it will likely purge before that happens.

tc is saving his stuff but the thread itself is condemned to die and fade like the flame

---

This isn't related to bosses, but I figured it was the best place to mention it. I'm sitting around after Pontiff's bonfire invading, and it amuses me how many people there are with the Fallen Knight set and an Irithyll SS. Even years later, it's still the go-to casul kit.

---

Bump for eventual google doc archive

DavidZ2844 posted...

Bump for eventual google doc archive

That'll get done this week, thanks for your patience. Been busy lately but I'm dressing it up a little bit more than just a sloppy copy-paste. Trying to make it look half-decent, haha.

---

Never played any Dark Souls game, but I watched my buddy fight a few of these bosses on stream so this was an interesting read. Good job, TC.

---

Blackstar110 posted...

That'll get done this week, thanks for your patience. Been busy lately but I'm dressing it up a little bit more than just a sloppy copy-paste. Trying to make it look half-decent, haha.

No worries man, I totally understand, take all the time you need. Just wanted to make sure the topic didnt purge.

How this topic actually went down:
https://youtu.be/sT3CmU7X3eM

Anti purge bump

Should get this done today I hope

---

Bump
---

i believe

---

Xeon_Is_Back posted...

ANYWAY Bloodborne boss list when.

This is the only thing I know so let's see it shreddo

Edit: i saw you did it

---

I know I'm George RR Martin-ing this doc compilation, but the good news is I'm not 72 years old and 600 pounds so I won't die before I finish it

---

Blackstar110 posted...

I know I'm George RR Martin-ing this doc compilation, but the good news is I'm not 72 years old and 600 pounds so I won't die before I finish it

lol

---

Blackstar110 posted...

I know I'm George RR Martin-ing this doc compilation, but the good news is I'm not 72 years old and 600 pounds so I won't die before I finish it

This is what actually happened with Robert Jordan and the Wheel of Time series. Guys wife had to hire someone to finish the series using his notes.

---

meralonne posted...

This is what actually happened with Robert Jordan and the Wheel of Time series. Guys wife had to hire someone to finish the series using his notes.

Woah woah woah, back the fuck up.

Robert Jordan died from a blood disease with protein malformations.

Hardly the same thing.

---

You cannot look at a picture of Robert Jordan and tell me that he was in peak health or anywhere near it when he died.

---

Blackstar110 posted...

I know I'm George RR Martin-ing this doc compilation, but the good news is I'm not 72 years old and 600 pounds so I won't die before I finish it

mad props for the honesty lol

I decided to do another playthrough of DS3 since I never got around to doing any of its DLC.

However, after playing DS1 and its DLC and DS2 and its DLCs, I remain unchanged as to DS2 being the better of the 2.

DS2 has better bosses, better stages and better gameplay.

DS1 has a few standout stages but overall doesn't match tbe overall art style of DS2. The locations in DS2 felt more believable as actual destroyed ancient structures etc. In DS1, the attempt to achieve the same effect was only achieved in those few standout stages.

Also, DS2 just feels way more climatic and epic.

So for me, its a duel between DS2 and DS3 for the best of the trilogy.

DS3 is already more fun to play.

---

There are some very cheesy and cheap mechanics in DS3 that wasn't there in the first 2 games.

Weird hit boxes and wonky enemy animations.

---

KINDERFELD posted...

DS2 has better bosses,

Whaaat?

---

Stalolin posted...

Whaaat?

Yes the bosses themselves are more challenging and fun to fight than in DS1. The designs of the bosses, however, is a different argument.

DS1 Bosses
Design: 3/3
Challenge: 1/3
Fun to fight: 2/3
Total: 6/9

DS2 Bosses
Design: 2/3
Challenge: 2/3
Fun to fight: 3/3
Total: 7/9

---

KINDERFELD posted...

Yes the bosses themselves are more challenging and fun to fight than in DS1. The designs of the bosses, however, is a different argument.

DS1 Bosses
Design: 3/3
Challenge: 1/3
Fun to fight: 2/3
Total: 6/9

DS2 Bosses
Design: 2/3
Challenge: 2/3
Fun to fight: 3/3
Total: 7/9

Boy you ain't right I tell you hwhat.

---

DS2 bosses were lame. Half of them were some variation on a big knight with a 3-swing combo as it's primary attack.
---

Personally, I found very, very few of the dark souls 2 bosses to be fun.

---

meralonne posted...

Personally, I found very, very few of the dark souls 2 bosses to be fun.

Same. Very forgettable crew, hence their rather low placements on this list.

---

The only really hard boss of base DS3 to me was Prince Lothric tbh

---

Bump for GRRM and The Winds of Winter

le bump

---

a meteorite crashed on TC while he was out for a jog, rip.

---

Appreciate everyone keeping it alive. I do wanna get around to finishing this.

---

Time is running out

Kureejii Lea posted...

Time is running out

I have 54 posts!

---

Bump, 53 posts now :)

DavidZ2844 posted...

Bump, 53 posts now :)

52

---