Board 8 > Best track on Weezer (Blue Album)

(+) Yeah! (+)

The Blue Album is widely considered a great album front to back with no weak songs. But which song is the best?

---

I expect say it ain't so runs away with this but the answer is no one else

Interesting. If forced to rank them 1-10, No One Else would more than likely slot at 10, maaaaybe 9. However, there are only two tiers on this album for me:

Tier 1
My Name Is Jonas
Buddy Holly
Undone
Surf Wax America
Say It Ain't So
Only in Dreams

Tier 2
No One Else
The World Has Turned and Left Me Here
In the Garage
Holiday

Depending on the day, The World Has Turned goes into Tier 1. It's remarkable how consistent in quality this album is, hence why I was inspired to make this poll.

---

Only in Dreams

---

Tier 1
Buddy Holly
Undone
In the Garage
Holiday

Tier 2
My Name is Jonas
The World Has Turned and Left Me Here
Say It Ain't So
Only in Dreams

Tier 3 (aka the only two songs I don't still listen to on a fairly regular basis)
No One Else
Surf Wax America

---

Phenomenal album, but In the Garage and The World Has Turned are my clear favs. Voted Garage.

---

I think Say It Ain't So and Only in Dreams are the top two for me, but there would be a lot of close calls if I tried to rank this.

---

Undone

---

TheKnightOfNee posted...

I think Say It Ain't So and Only in Dreams are the top two for me, but there would be a lot of close calls if I tried to rank this.

this is exactly how I feel

I voted Only in Dreams, but I could go either way on those two. After that, gut instinct:

Holiday
The World Has Turned
Undone
My name is Jonas
Buddy Holly
Surf Wax America
In the Garage
No one else

back in 2014 I saw them play the album all the way through for the 20th anniversary and it was pretty dang great, probably my favorite concert Ive ever been to
---

Only In Dreams (range: 1-2)
Say It Ain't So (range: 1-3)
My Name Is Jonas (range: 1-4)
Undone (range: 2-5)
Buddy Holly (range: 3-5)
Surf Wax America (range: 6-7)
The World Has Turned (range: 6-7)
In the Garage (range: 8-9)
Holiday (range: 8-10)
No One Else (range: 9-10)

I guess ranking them like this yields three tiers with Surf Wax and The World Has Turned being a middle tier.

---

quick pop-in to say if you haven't listened to rock and roll part 3 by ozma yet you should get on that

Wow, surprised at the mixture of opinions! Good topic I guess then. Here's my ranking, although after hearing the album like 500 times I got sick of lots of it:

Tier 1 - Awesome, still want to listen anytime
My Name Is Jonas (best for sure) (I thought this was everyone's favorite)
No One Else
In the Garage
The World Has Turned and Left Me Here

Tier 2 - Still good, not that excited to hear 'em though
Only in Dreams
Holiday
Undone (mostly the last couple minutes)
Surf Wax America (ehhh maybe I'm getting sick of this too)

Tier 3 - Sick of these and would rather not hear them ever again
Buddy Holly
Say It Ain't So


---

Tough choice, could be any one of five options on a given day.


---